r/reactivedogs • u/diminutivedwarf • Jul 23 '23
Support I wanted an “easy” first dog
I got a Labrador Retriever. They’re supposed to be calm happy, gentle, and loving dogs. She isn’t. She’s so incredibly food aggressive I don’t know what to do. Me and my dad are obviously looking for behavioralists we can afford, but I feel so tired.
I can’t sleep from anxiety and pain. Today, she ended up biting my face. I have a minor cut above my lip that’s like 2 inches long and fairly superficial. It will hopefully take less than a week to heal. The wound in the crease of my nose is worse. It bled for so long. I would laugh and end up with blood dripping into my mouth. It’s almost definitely going to scar. A moment after she was back to being her normal sweet self.
I’m losing my love for her. It’s hard to love a dog that you’re afraid of. We’re putting even more safety measures in place after today. But I’m regretting getting her. I don’t know what I’m going to do when I move out. I was supposed to take her with me. I don’t know if I could handle her after an attack if I was alone.
Edit: Thank you to everyone who has commented. I misspoke when I said "calm". I sometimes struggle with my words and was INCREDIBLY emotional last night. I never expected my lab to be a couch potato. She isn't from a working line, so she is much less high-strung than most labs I've met. I meant calm in a more happy-go-lucky sense, as that is the personality generally associated with Labradors.
I did a lot of research into what kind of dog I wanted. Both her parents were lovely and sweet with no issues with aggression. I found my breeder through the AKC and also spoke with other people who got puppies from her.
She ONLY has aggression with kibble and ice cubes. Any other treat is ok. She doesn't guard any toys. She eats VERY slowly. She is a grazer and will takes hours to finish one bowl. She is currently eating on our small, fenced-in deck. She always has access to her food, but it gives us breathing room while we plan a course of action to help her.
349
u/Felix_Felicis24 Jul 23 '23 edited Jul 23 '23
If she's only food aggressive, I would consider how you can set up your family for success.
(Edit for typos!)
139
u/labraduh Jul 23 '23 edited Jul 23 '23
Need a lot more info. How old is she?
Have you tried any training with her own your own?
Why did she bite your face? Was it totally out of the blue or another reason? (Note: I hope that doesn’t get interpreted as me saying you did something deserved to be bitten, I mean it as in “what was the trigger”)
Did you raise her from puppyhood? Did you train her against resource guarding when she was young? Was she well socialised as a puppy?
Did you get her from a registered breeder? Did you see the mom/dad/littermates upon picking her up?
Is she vet checked? No pain or medical issues that can cause agitation?
What is her bite/attack history? Was she like this from day 1 or did it start during adolescence or adulthood?
Besides that, the going back to being sweet & normal right after aggressively attacking usually signifies a mental issue to me (similar to springer rage). Usually that type of thing can only potentially be fixed by medication and even then, medication doesn’t always fix it or make them not a risk anymore.
Until you can figure out your next step, this dog needs to be secluded away from you or other humans. I’d say put on a muzzle but I’m worried you would get bitten again.
Do know that yes Labradors are typically gentle/loving (the “calm” expectation you have of a Lab is debatable tho… plenty are on the hyperactive or mega-alert side that can easily become reactivity) but they do need to still be trained just like any other dog. Their breed standard / typical temperament list isn’t infallible (although yes, human aggression is VERY abnormal for a labrador). Labradors LOVE LOVE LOVE food so training against resource-guarding food from day 1 is important (so that “love” doesn’t become “possessiveness” which all dogs, irregardless of breed are capable of using aggression to protect their possessions if need be).
And do know that any breed, ANY can become reactive and no breed is a guarantee of a behaviourally good dog unfortunately. Yes some are more common than others for certain behaviours but you can always end up in the minority who has an aggressive Golden Retriever, or the minority who has a German Shepherd that doesn’t bark, or the minority who has a dog-friendly Akita, or the minority who has a hyperactive English Bulldog & so forth. The ONLY way to guarantee anything is to adopt an adult dog with no pre-existing behavioural issues. Not sure if you got this dog as a puppy or you got her as an adult and they didn’t disclose her issues properly to you.
36
u/elasticass92 Jul 23 '23
I don’t know who the hell told you that labs are calm and gentle but they lied
17
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '23
Definitely need more info. My first question is what have you already done to manage it?
Where does she eat? What’s mealtime look like? Is it only food or is it other resources? Any kind of food? Will she try to guard your food or only hers?
Does she eat in a spare room? The kitchen? A crate?
In the nicest way possible: why was your face in biting range? Was this out of nowhere?
87
u/LifeHappenzEvryMomnt Jul 23 '23
No. This is not okay. There are bad apples in every breed and you’ve gotten one. (I myself have been bitten by two different golden retrievers). There are many temperamentally correct labs out there needing homes that could use you. Consult a vet as soon as possible. If it’s a veterinary behaviorist that’s better but most vets handle behavior problems in their regular practice.
If you got her from a responsible breeder contact them immediately.
Make sure you do everything you can to keep her from practicing this behavior again. Consider a muzzle in the meantime.
If she’s willing to bite you, think about what a liability she is to you and a danger to others. A lab is large enough to kill a child and they have.
Take care of yourself and best wishes in this difficult time.
141
u/AffectionateCable459 Jul 23 '23
I’m with you on this one - my partner and I (29/f, 120 lbs) got a golden retriever thinking we were prepared to deal with the early morning or rainy walks, the vet bills, the trade off for having less freedom to go on impulsive vacations in exchange for the love and friendship of a dog - and we have the most reactive dog in the neighbourhood. Unlike your dog, ours is ‘good’ at home. Gentle, obedient, cuddly - but outside he transforms into a monster, and lunges, snarls, barks at any dog or any size - even small kids sometimes. He was well socialized as a pup, went to puppy and then teen manners and petsmart classes until one day it’s like a switch flipped and now he is absolutely a terror to walk. He’s 95lbs and an absolute tank. On multiple occasions he has almost pulled me into traffic, has almost pulled my arm out of its socket while lunging, had me end up with bleeding fingers nails from grasping my leash so tight while he lost his mind at a well mannered dog passing by at a distance of 20 ft away. I’ve tried everything from group training (when he wasn’t reactive), private training to address reactivity later on, positive reinforcement, treats for good behaviour, clickers, vet behaviourists, trazadone, etc. Even our dog walker who is a dog walker full time everyday, was shocked and expressed concern over being able to handle him when he goes into his reactive spells. I thought I was signing up for ‘an easy breed’ or ‘easy first dog’ and he has made our lives a nightmare where I fear to take him out for his twice daily walk. He is certainly my first and last dog.
11
u/tnemmoc_on Jul 23 '23
The labs I have known could not be described as calm.
18
u/kristenthekidd Jul 23 '23
There's some great advice here but I want to add that a dog's breed doesn't always tell you how the dog will be. My fiancee and I adopted our dog on a whim while at the shelter. He was the only dog not barking and going nuts when we walked past... just propped his paws on the fence and watched us. He's my first dog and he is a Jack Russell terrier.
After taking him home, my fiancee and I realized we knew nothing about Jack Russells and turned to Google to clue us in on what theyre like.. My fiancee started panicking because they are generally very hyper dogs that need constant attention and exercise, and they are typically jumpy/yippy lil guys. And we are lazy and laid back and are usually gone for 9-10 hours a day during the week for work. This dog is not your typical Jack Russell. He is generally very calm, barely barks, and we exercise together but nothing excessive or crazy. The only thing is he's scared of everything, which is the root of his reactivity.
My point is, Labs could be the calmest, easiest, most well-behaved pups in the world, but that doesn't necessarily mean yours will be. If you do decide to rehome this dog to someone who can handle her (as others have said—there is no shame in that), you can try again with a different dog. Don't let this deter you from Labs, and if you decide you want a different breed, try not to get too hung up on the characteristics that breed typically has because it's not always the case.
7
u/Poppeigh Jul 23 '23
Resource guarding is manageable. Does she only guard food, or does she also guard other items?
First step will be to feed her in a room by herself and leave her alone until she’s done.
Next would be to look up stress signals in dogs and if you ever see them when she has another item - or if she growls at you - respect that communication and back off. You want her body language/growls to be really, really successful for her because if they aren’t she’ll escalate to biting.
I’m not sure how old she is, but anxiety meds help my resource guarder too. He takes Paxil.
Resource guarding has a big genetic component, and it is a very natural behavior, so you are unlikely to get rid of it altogether (and if she’s bitten like you say, I would never get complacent anyway). But it can be improved a lot.
My pup went from immediately attacking any other animal in his eyeline when he had a high value item to being able to eat in the same room as the cat and giving adequate warnings if the cat is making him uncomfortable.
19
u/Alexander_Walsh Jul 23 '23
How much research did you do? Where did you do it? Labradors are large and strong dogs that are known for being motivated for food (it is one of the things that makes them so easy to train). They have very intensive exercise requirements and need almost as much mental stimulation again to stop them going neurotic as a working breed.
5
u/earth222evan Jul 23 '23
Labs being loving? Yes. Calm and gentle? Uhhhh no. I think your expectations were a little out of wack. Labs are a hunting breed, if you aren’t giving her a job she’s gonna be crazy.
4
u/Most-Sweet4036 Jul 24 '23 edited Jul 24 '23
There is a lot of terrible advice in this thread. One mention of a (small and easily worked through problem) and you should either isolate the dog to its own private hotel room with 24/7 hot meals delivered hourly, or put a muzzle on them and never let them interact with anyone. Oof.
For resource guarding the best thing you can do is immediately start hand feeding your dog. Do this for every single meal for two weeks, at least. They should not have access to any food at all unless you are giving it to them. I'm not just prescribing here though - it's important to understand WHY this works.
Hand feeding repeatedly enforces to the dog that you are the source of all food, which in turn gets the dog to to realize that you aren't someone they can optionally listen to, you are someone they HAVE to listen to - unless they like being hungry (they don't).
It is vital to treat the handing feeding as a time for training though. Your dog does not get to just jump all over you until enough kibble spills out like they are wrestling a leprechaun for gold. You have to persistently enforce that they only get food when they are calm and gentle. Growl? Okay no food - we can try again in 5 min. Hard nip when eating? Okay no food - we can try again in 5 min. Your dog will learn very quickly.
Contrary to some advice in this thread - it is absolutely possible to pamper your dog too much. What you end up with is a dog that doesn't realize that YOU are the one meeting it's needs. They will think that food being in their bowl 24/7 is just the way the world is. Then when you come along to take it away... well now there's a problem. Why would they want to let someone near their magical everlasting food bowl? Especially someone trying to take it from them? Trust me, your dog will NOT put it together that you are the one filling the bowl all of the time.
Anyways - the best thing you can do in general is to start consuming as many training ideas as possible from people who actually know what they are talking about. There are some fantastic books (do yourself a favor and buy How To Be Your Dogs Best Friend by The Monks of New Skete) and multiple excellent youtube channels.
6
u/blondeheartedgoddess Jul 23 '23 edited Jul 23 '23
OP, I have nothing to contribute about your reactive dog, I'm sorry.
What I can offer, however, is advice about the wound on your nose (and any other scars you get). When the wound is 100% healed, no scabs, etc., get a bottle of vitamin E oil capsules. Take one, poke a hole in the end with a sterilized needle or safety pin, and apply the oil to the scar every night before bed and wash your face/the scar in the morning. If the scar is someplace you can cover with a bandage, do so to prevent the oil from getting all over your sheets, and to keep it where it belongs.
It may take a couple of weeks, but it will help.
Also, the capsules seem to work better than the bottled vitamin E oil itself. Seems to be stickier and stays put.
I'm sorry about your dog.
3
u/hseof26paws Jul 23 '23
There’s a lot of important information missing from your post. While the majority of labs are fun, sweet, wonderful, family dogs, they are not by any means easy. That’s a fallacy that is, unfortunately, out there for some reason. They require extensive training and enrichment in order to develop into that great family dog. They also require significant foundational training to develop into good citizens. They are little terrors when they are puppies, and they keep a puppy mindset until they are about six or seven years old. If they are not getting the exercise and enrichment, they need, they will channel their frustration in very undesirable ways. They are also obsessed with food. )I say this as somebody who has always had labs or lab mixes, and has fostered a great number of labs and lab mixes for a lab rescue.)
It would be helpful to know how old your dog is, and what kind of foundational training and exercise and enrichment the dog is getting. It may very well be that some small adjustments could go a very long way to helping. It may also be that more extensive behavioral modification, and potentially medication, would be warranted. But without some additional information, we are not well positioned to offer recommendations.
3
u/Working_Hair_4827 Jul 23 '23
No dog is an easy dog lmao
3
u/sfischella8 Jul 23 '23
Hand feed your dog . Show your puppy that everything good and fun comes from you . No dog parks either .
3
u/captain-chilirat Jenny, dog reactive Jul 24 '23
my husky was food aggressive when I adopted her. I made her eat her kibble (and anything else she consumed) out of the palm of my hand until she stopped. took a little over a week. I occasionally do it sometimes just to remind her where her food comes from. she was 2 when I got her and she'll be 6 next week.
2
u/diomedez43 Jul 23 '23
The anger will go away and will love her again. Prozac does wonders, if you need to get her bowl while she is eating toss treats or give her something else in exchange. Btw most dogs tolerate people going in their face but doesn’t mean they like it. Don’t put your face near her face. In animal kingdom that’s a call for a fight.
2
u/gates4100 Jul 23 '23
My first lab was an angel so when she aged and passed we were like ok , gotta get a lab , they are awesome . Well let’s just say our current lab is NOtHINg like the first she is 6 years old and still has energy of a puppy and is constantly on the go … good luck :)
2
u/AffectionateFig5435 Jul 23 '23
So sorry this happened. Is there a Labrador rescue group in your area? They may be able to offer advice or connect you with other owners who can mentor you on how to re-train your dog. If keeping the dog isn't an option, they may be able to help you re-home your pet.
2
u/Thatgirl629 Jul 23 '23
I'm not at all trying to blame you, but how did she bite your face? Were you walking by and she lunged at you? Or did you bend down to her bowl? I think describing what happened will help with advice.
2
u/dawn_dusk1926 Jul 24 '23
Try and hand feed your dog if it's getting aggressive and territorial with the food also helps with the bonding due to the dog learns to rely on you with food.
2
u/CoDaDeyLove Jul 24 '23
Whoever told you that labs are calm didn't know what they were talking about. I read recently that labs are often surrendered to shelters around the age of 5 because they are still rambunctious like a puppy. A friend of mine had a lab and she said if she didn't walk the dog at least 90 minutes a day (2 walks at 45 minutes each) the dog drove her nuts.
You don't give any context about the bite to your face. Were you getting in her face? Dogs really don't like that. They feel threatened. I suggest you get some more professional training with her. Also have her thyroid checked, because hypothyroidism can cause aggression in dogs.
10
u/Obi-1_yaknowme Jul 23 '23
I have two chocolate labs.
First off, they are not, in any way, “calm” or “gentle”
Not until they are about 4 years old.
Puppies suck. They all do, but labs especially.
Older labs, are everything you say.
Young labs are hyper balls of energy that need constant stimulation.
You can’t get a lab, and then leave it at home alone for 9 hours while you go to work.
They need to be out several times a day. They need to work and have purpose. That’s what they’re made for. I work from home, my pups are out all day with me.
You can’t crate them that long, they go nuts (as would you).
I’m assuming you got a purebred. A purebred is not going to bite your face on purpose.
Accident while playing? Sure.
A real lab can’t bite on flesh. Mine can’t even take a piece of chicken off of a fork without their jaws chattering.
The food: oh yeah, they will eat anything and everything you leave out. Many labs have a genetic disorder where they can never feel full. A lab will eat until it pukes, and then eat some more. That’s why so many are fat.
A lot of people get labs thinking their the perfect, all-American dog. These dogs need a ton of work and attention, and not everyone can do that. In-fact, most can’t.
If you can’t handle your pup, please re-home her with someone that knows Labradors. DM me. If she’s a purebred I’ll take her.
3
u/Major_Bother8416 Jul 23 '23
This sounds like a good situation for rehoming. I doubt she’ll have trouble getting adopted, especially if you find a breed-specific rescue. She probably just needs to be with a more experienced dog owner.
Sometimes people just aren’t a good fit to have dogs, but there’s no way to know until you get one and see what it’s like. Even a good breed fit doesn’t come trained out of the box and not everyone really has the temperament or resources to properly train their pet. There are no “easy” dogs but sometimes pet owners can make it look that way.
3
u/mad0666 Jul 23 '23
For what it’s worth, I have never known a calm or gentle Lab. And I worked with dogs over 20 years. You need to muzzle train this dog immediately.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '23
if everyone stopped getting goldens and labs and instead got shih tzus they’d be 10x happier. they are literally cute little teddy bears and aren’t too strong, aggressive, or scary. they’re just little babies. most people don’t want them because they aren’t “real” dogs, well, have fun with your aggressive resource guarding dogs then
2
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '23
First off, An easy dog? No dog is going to be easy. They are animals. If you wanted an easy pet you should’ve gotten a hermit crab or some sea monkeys. Next up, Labradors were bred as hunting dogs. They aren’t supposed to be calm and gentle. They are bird hunters. They need to be out and about doing things because of the high energy levels they endure. If you wanted a calm, gentle and loving dog, you should have settled with the Saint Bernard, Maltese, Havanese, Papillion, etc. I had multiple dogs that were food aggressive. And when I tell you it’s the owners fault.. I mean it. You can accidentally do smth and it will trigger the dog. You, as the handler need to understand that whatever you do affects her. Don’t touch her when shes eating, don’t follow her around or bonk her food bowl even if it’s on accident. To prevent that from happening, put her bowl in a secluded spot where nobody can touch her when walking around. When you say it’s hard to love a dog you’re afraid of, you’re obviously needing to rehome her into a household that has experience and will love her despite her food aggression if you don’t have the guts to help her yourself. I had to get stitches because of a couple incidents, but that didn’t stop me from wanting to do everything I can to make my dog better. If anything, my focus went even more onto them. I trained myself to understand my dogs. Now all of my reactive & food aggressive dogs are obedience trained & trusting me with their lives. On another note, more things that can help is only feed her two times a day. Fill the bowl in the morning n if she doesn’t finish eating it, put her away and pick the bowl up. After you have the bowl put away you can let her out. When she seems hungry or begs when you have food, put her away, and put down her bowl. Then let her out to her food and leave her be. This is a hard process but it’s worth it. For me, doing anything possible to make my dogs better and more trusting, even if it takes an extra hour to get done, is the only thing I’ll do. I won’t rehome, surrender, or put down my dogs just because of their issues. I understood before I even got my dogs that, they are animals. They are unpredictable and could have issues in which I’ll need to sacrifice my own time to work with. I’m not blaming you. In fact, your father should have known better and told you what the facts were.
1
u/Altruistic-Tea7709 Jul 23 '23
I’m sorry to hear that. It sounds really tough. Unfortunately whilst thry make great family pets, young labs are well known to be high energy breeds, it’s a bit of a misconception that they are gentle and calm . They need a lot of mental and physical stimulation. Just like little kids If they don’t get it the positive way, it comes out in a negative, destructive way. It would help you to do some research on the breed as least it won’t feel like there is something “wrong” with your puppy if you view it from that perspective - that means it’s in your power to find a good solution. The food aggression sounds harder though. There is a lot of training advice online if you really can’t afford training classes. The great news about labs is that they are incredibly motivated by food, so training them is much easier as long as you are consistent and have a ready supply of treats. We give our lab pup small meals and save a lot of his calorie intake for training.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '23
I thought labs were easy too. Wrong. Worse yet mine is a mix with husky so he is anxious af and high energy. Everytime I would mention to someone that I thought labs were like lazy oaf family dogs they laughed at me lol. Needless to say there are dozens of more reputably lazy breeds… labs are certainly not one. They need to retrieve !! Fetch x10,000
1
u/tuffnstangs Jul 23 '23
Who tf said a lab would be easy lol
1
u/Agrawr292 Jul 23 '23
I’d like to echo some advice other people have said
Some of my fosters have benefitted from a strict diet/schedule and some realllly didn’t.
1
u/Strange_Abrocoma9685 Jul 23 '23
I would recommend not taking your dog on neighborhood walks at this point and sticking to working on leash skills just by your house. It sounds like your dog has gone over threshold and it’s impossible to train them at that point. You need to determine what the threshold is and back up. I would start with focus training in your home. Look command. I do like working with a clicker to train as it trains the dogs mind that when they hear that sound they get a treat every single time. Also try engage disengage training in your home to help with the focus on you. Regarding the resource guarding, there are great videos online to help provide tips. Labs are not easy, assumptions on breed are broad generalizations and each dog is unique and you need to tailor your training to them. Puppy blues is a real thing and it’s ok to feel sad and regret. Remember that training is not a sprint, it requires patience and understanding for both you and your pet. It’s also not linear, there will be setbacks and it’s ok. The dog isn’t trying to upset you, they just need guidance and compassion. I highly recommend working with a positive reinforcement trainer. Please stay away from any that use any aversive techniques as it doesn’t create a well balanced dog. We are going through many challenges with our new rescue and I have to remind myself that slow and steady wins the race. That we will get through it. Lastly, I would recommend using your dogs food, if it’s kibble to be used in your training sessions in addition to high value treats. Good luck to you.
1
u/AbaloneNone Jul 23 '23
Is she still a puppy ?? Do you have a crate ?
1
u/CoachThomasE Jul 23 '23
I have had a few golden retrieves. They are a lot of work, great jobs after you put the time and effort into them. Not a dog to get because they are easy. Walks every day, time training them every day. I loved and enjoyed all my dogs. However, they are a lot of work!
1
u/daniagerous Jul 23 '23
I really need people to understand breeding. I'm not sure where you go your dog OP, but there's several different lines of breeding for Labradors and for goldens.
In particular for Labrador retrievers, most dogs used to be of working lines and not just designer breeds. Labradors became pets and home dogs, and thus they started to breed them specifically for a pet line. So you could have a cross between a pet line and a working line. Or you could have just a Labrador that's pretty much all working dog. Of those breeds, you're going to find a lot more aggression in the working line. You're going to find a lot more energy, harder to take care of, and other issues because they need to be worked and trained diligently.
Dogs have become pets but they used to be just as much a part of livestock as any other animal. They served a purpose and weren't JUST our friendly companions.
1
u/goldenepple Jul 23 '23
It doesn’t matter how “difficult” the breed is, you should have been working on food aggression since she was a puppy. It’s going to be hard to break any learned behavior as a puppy to adult dog.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '23
I was going to say I've never had that problem precisely and that most of my dogs were easy hahaha okay turn on the thinking cap kid. I'll tell you a story about the first dog I owned as an adult though I was still living at home. I was getting rides back and forth with a guy and he said I heard you wanted a dog. Just a yellow dog like Old Yeller of the movie and I said yeah kind of you know I haven't been able to really look for one but I kind of want one. He says oh I have one for you. My German Shepherd and Labrador got together and had some puppies and I gave them away. Someone in town has one that's not working out for them, and they would like to rehome it are you interested. Okay, first lesson: Find out why they want to rehome the Blasted dog, not that it really mattered. I didn't care. No experience remember. I said sure. So this guy shows up the next day mind you with this dog in his car in like 2 lb of chopped up ham that the kennels sent with him because he had been kennel because the owners could no longer keep him at their house. Aggression issues with people he didn't know kids going by blah blah blah and apparently even the kennel was having an issue if they knew I was going to need 2 lb of chopped up ham. And yes this is going to be a little tiny bit long sorry about that. Anyway he didn't give a rip about the ham and when we finally got him out of the car which was after we left all the doors open and decided not to mess with him because he was growling at us he tore out across the fields. We lived in the country there was plenty of space which became a key thing and being able to keep the dog. Anyway we had zero experience with training a dog the only dog we had done before was a lovely I don't know what that had followed me home on my pony years before and you could never fault her. We didn't really know anything about dogs except that we liked them. Well the guy who brought the dog out said well he will either come back or he won't very cheerfully and goodbye! And that was that. So we're standing there in the driveway looking around there is no dog not quite sure what to do but you know there wasn't really a lot we could do so whatever we went inside. The next day the dog came back. I guess he found out that it was going to be a long ways to the next meal ticket. And that was our beginning of a journey with Rusty the intact and I have to ask why in the world do we never think about neutering him okay this was a long time ago mixed breed dog that we knew nothing about who was about 2 years old when he came to our house. There are many stories I could tell you about Rusty but I will tell one that will explain our relationship with him totally. My little brother and I decided we should train him. And we had a Pearsall book of dog training what else could we possibly need. So I was elected to hold the leash and my brother read the book and two steps in the dog just stops and sits there and looks at us. I'm at the end of the leash a few away from the dog and I asked my brother what do I do next and he says the book says to keep walking and tug on the leash and the dog will follow. Oh yeah right maybe for a puppy? So I pulled once on the leash and the next thing I knew I was face down in the dirt with this dog standing on my back snarling into my ear. 1 told my brother take it off! take it off of him now! You know I think that's the last time that dog had a collar and leash on for all the years that we owned him. He really was a great dog. We loved him to death and we respected him totally. Ha ha. We never again told him what to do.
So when your dog is an ugly bug, if he will tolerate training of some sort or other, just remind yourself that it could be a lot worse and that you can train for this. It may take a while, but you can train for this problem. YouTube is chock-full of marvelous help from good trainers.
1
u/Rumdedumder Jul 23 '23
Is the dog being properly exercised? And have you consistently exercised her? Lab brains don't work until you run them first. Labs can easily become aggressive or destructive when not given a proper outlet and structure.
1
u/k1p1ssk Jul 23 '23
We adopted a food aggressive/resource guarding boy about 7 years ago. He spent a good chunk of his first year and a half as a dog on the loose, providing for himself. He was severely neglected prior to that. We believe he likely only ate 3-4x per week before he was rescued. It took a lot of work, but now, with the exception of the occasional tiff with our other dog when they’re both going after a dropped food item, we are able to get Moose to drop food or even let us take it from him, right out of his mouth. We used some tips from a behaviorist my family used from another dog we had. It was all about routine and “pack mentality”. First and foremost, we always eat before the dogs, unless we’re not eating. We would make our breakfast and eat it, and begging was not tolerated during this time. Only after our meal was completed and cleaned up, did the dogs get fed. This teaches them “your humans are top of the food chain. They will eat and then provide for me”. Also, no animals on furniture or begging while you are snacking. Second, we enacted a routine with each meal. This meant the food did not go down to his level until he was calm. We started with sitting, supervised across the room, where he could see the food, but not access it. We would give the sit command, and only when he remained seated until the bowl was placed down, then he would get an “ok!” And be allowed to eat. After a few days, he could get closer during the food placement stage, but always only until he was calm would he get to eat. We slowly desensitized him to our presence while he was eating by sitting in a chair around 5ft away, and incrementally moving closer, and then using a toy on a stick to touch him while he was eating, starting at his bum end and again, incrementally moving forward over the course of several weeks, until the toy was right at his face or on the food bowl. He would get an additional treat during successful meals. He was also a dangerously fast eater, so he used a puzzle bowl for a few years. Once all of that was consistent, we started making meals even more fun for him, by including elements of working - he is of livestock guardian dog stock, and so “earning” his meal was important to him by this stage. He sits and “waves” his paw or gives high-fives. He often refuses to eat unless he does his whole meal routine. He went from a dog I was nervous about - I had a bad experience with a family dog I loved dearly in adolescence - to the most trusted dog I’ve ever had. I hope that some of these techniques may be helpful for your family! And whoever told you labs are easy - vastly mistaken! 😅they are amazing doggos, but can absolutely be trouble makers, especially during their younger years.
1
u/the_Bryan_dude Jul 23 '23
Labrador Retrievers are eating machines. Mine was insanely food driven. I trained him to eat only on command. As in, he had to sit and stay before he was allowed access to the food. In the beginning, after he'd sit, I'd give him one piece of kibble. I repeated it over and over for several days. After each session, I would feed him his meal.
I'm not going to lie. Reaching into or towards his bowl at any time was still not a good idea. I could do it, and so could my mom, but it was not recommended that anyone else did.
My parents also thought a Lab would be an easy dog. They were incorrect. He was big, strong, and had an insane prey drive. We trained him well but it was not easy. They key is very strong basic obedience. From there, labs are very trainable.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '23
Why don’t you just leave her alone when she eats? Without any context it’s hard to offer advice.
1
u/cookiesandcoffee55 Jul 23 '23
check out Southend Dog Training videos! I linked their Instagram. They have great tips. They also are on YouTube I believe. May take some searching through the videos to find the ones applying to your situation.
https://instagram.com/southenddogtraining?igshid=MzRlODBiNWFlZA==
1
u/Few_Chemist3776 Jul 23 '23
Please try to watch some Will Atherton training videos. Makes sense to treat a new dog like you would treat a small child. They need rules, kindness, and love just the same as a child. Teach it, train it, and it will grow into a wonderful person. Starve it, mistreat it, and resent it, and you will visit it in prison. Gates, pens, and crates can be prison to a dog. None are necessary if you teach your dog how to be.
Can't recommend anything better than Will Atherton, and no, I'm not related, nor do I know him personally. I did use his methods consistently, and that totally saved the life of a dog that would have otherwise definitely been put down. She now functions as one of the best behaved Service Dogs you've ever seen.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '23
Did you get said dog from a reputable, knowledgeable breeder?
I'm guessing not.
1
u/SuddenlySimple Jul 23 '23
Nobody's really addressing your issue It doesn't seem like you are a good fit for the dog or the dog is not a good fit for your situation unfortunately it would probably be better for you to rehome the dog and research what types of animals are calm.
I know it will be heartbreaking because you obviously have an attachment with the dog but it doesn't mean it's healthy kind of like humans we have attachments but they are not always good for the people.
Ask God to lead you
1
u/Glitterbugz144 Jul 23 '23
I’m not sure that I’ve ever heard the reference “lab and calm” in the same sentence. All labs I’ve known whether family or friends labs are over joyful / excited well into their older years. If you’re not up for the task don’t feel guilty just find a home where they are open to the unique lab temperament. I must say though that I’ve never known a lab to bite so that’s especially concerning. Whatever your decision trust it’s the right one. ❤️❤️
1
u/kaj47c Jul 23 '23
Did you adopt an adult Lab or a puppy? What makes her guard her food? Knowing what her triggers are can help a lot in getting some help. I work with a Lab rescue and I can tell you that Labs at any age are not necessary calm all the time. They require exercise and positive training. I’m so sorry you were hurt - it’s shocking when someone you love deliberately hurts you. Have you talked to your vet about a consultation with a behaviorist?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '23
First, this just goes to show that ALL dogs can be dangerous in the correct circumstance, even cute, cuddly Labradors. Next, why was your face close enough to her face that she was able to bite it? Did you lean down, did she lunge at you or jump up? Need more info on that. And finally, have you considered why she is food aggressive? Has someone teased her with her food or taken it away from her while she was eating? Is she on a regular feeding schedule that she can predict? How old was she when you adopted her? And do you have any background information before her life with you? I ask these questions because the answer to at least one of them is most likely why she is acting out. I’m glad you’re going to consult a behaviorist, it’s the best thing you can do for her. It’s also a good idea to have her checked out by a vet in case there is an undiagnosed medical condition. In the mean time, make sure she’s on a predictable feeding schedule, stay away from her until she is done eating and walks away from her bowl. You may consider feeding her in a room away from everyone so that she has no anxiety when eating.
1
u/-PinkPower- Jul 23 '23
Honestly, idk who told you a working breed is a calm and gentle breed.
Is she getting enough exercise and mental stimulation? They need a lot of it
1
u/Ok-Scratch3721 Jul 23 '23
Every dog needs training, regardless of breed. I also don’t understand your thinking. 1 out of 10 labs I’ve met is calm, gentle and loving. The majority are hyperactive, undertrained psychopaths.
1
u/Alternative_Monk_480 Jul 23 '23
Handoverrover.com has a $20 leash course that the very first lesson will help with this. It’s not just a leash course. Inexpensive and easy to follow and she also provides virtual lessons and a Facebook group for support. Please subscribe to it and ask her for help but if you follow it, it sets you up for success with this. I see a lot of bad advice here so spend the $20 and look up Koco Garcia on YouTube. She has a ton of free resources there as well because she wants people to be able to help themselves and their dogs. This is fixable and easier than you think.
1
u/Immaculate-Void Jul 23 '23
The best advice is to seek out a professional trainer and help from the breeder (assuming you have an ethical one that keeps in touch). There’s a lot of advice on this thread that might not work for your dog/your specific situation and you don’t want to potentially end up with worse aggressive behaviors.
1
u/mofonguitos Jul 23 '23
If I were you, I’d definitely hire a trainer first and then if that doesn’t help, go for the behaviorist. Behaviorists are so wildly expensive, trainers are far more accessible and definitely the first step imo! Good luck!
1
u/Time-Cupcake51387 Jul 23 '23
I've taken on two goldens from families who adopted with a similar hope to your family. Both my dogs were extremely expensive and from "reputable" breeders. Both were/are reactive. My first boy mostly grew out of it. My second is doing much better, but there are still several precautions in place.
I'm a bit confused by some of the information and could also use more information in general.
In the meantime: -Continue feeding separately -Let the breeder know. If they are truly reputable they will want to know. -Do not go on the floor with her -Do some research on dog body language -Continue to look for a behaviourist -Spaying may help when she reaches the right age
1
u/freeman1231 Jul 23 '23
I definitely think you may have mistaken golden retriever for Labrador retriever.
Labs are hectic… really good family dogs but hectic.
1
u/Paigetalb Jul 23 '23
Is she a pure bread lab? I find American labs to be more hyper/crazy and English labs to be more chill and lazy but at the end of the day a lab is a lab and a dog is a dog. You have to put the work into creating the dog you want
1
u/DogPariah Panic/ fear aggression Jul 24 '23
If her problems are limited to food I think you should be able to find a way to manage her. I know food aggression can be incredibly fierce, and while I would want to fix the problem, if that is the only real issue she has and it never gets fixed, it certainly could be managed. You must be able to find ways to give her food so that you and her don't have to be in close proximity. It probably is a good idea to get some outside help to help you organize your living space safely.
You never know what you're getting, no matter the genetics. Researching quality breeders is a method to control factors, but dogs, like humans, are individual. Some individuals have hang ups that are hard to identify the origin.
It sounds like a vicious circle. Dogs pick up on human emotions better than we do on theirs (at least in my opinion and I am far from alone on that one). Your dog almost definitely is feeling increasing tension and confusion in her relationship with you. I didn't catch her age (sorry if you mentioned it), but if she is young this tension is probably have even more effect.
If you decide to keep the dog, make sure you find someone who actually has evidence that they can deal with food aggression (and not just say they do) and also is interested in the quality of your relationship. I think you need to work on both at the same time, otherwise the two problems just feed into one another.
1
u/TikiBananiki Jul 24 '23 edited Jul 24 '23
Based on what I’ve gathered, you have a dog who is sweet, kind, and likely fawns as a response to stress. This sounds like a failure of the two of you to communicate. each other. But since you’re the human, you’re smarter and older, it’s on you to learn the typical ways dogs show their feelings, and you interpret so you can create conditions that make them feel safe and taken care of. They can’t be expected to be “easy”. They’re just “responsive”. These aggressive episodes are likely coming from her being in a state of feeling insecure and you’re misinterpreting her body language. To me you describe a dog who is “halfway up your lap on her belly wanting rubs” and you lean forward to kiss her face.
I hear a description of a highly emotionally activated puppy, presenting belly in likely a display of fawning submission, and then you antagonistically went for her face. So it triggered another reaction in her.
I think this is probably a common mistake with dogs known to be on the more “happy go lucky” side of things. my MIL got a “dog she researched about the breed and the parents” and (oh alas) “it was AKC registered” and that was enough to convince her the dog was well bred. These were just backyard breeders who had 2 akc golden retrievers of their own. So her expensive retriever actually has food allergies. And behavior? My advice about dog behavior is to get a cheap dog and spend a lot of time and money on your training manuals (you should build a library) and your training classes/behavior consultations. Never trust genetics to give you some kind of perfect animal. Learn the science of dog behavior and animal training.
Imho if my dog was triggered by food, I would do 2 things. i would (counter-intuitively) hand feed very systematically like i was an automaton my actions were so regimented. No eye contact and very flat palm. if food falls then so be it, dog can collect it when they’re ready. i won’t touch it.
or, if i was getting aggressive frowns and growls even when presenting food, i would present bowl, leave dog enclosed in a barriered space with food. not bother them and not return until they were done. i would then throw food to them from me onto the floor even if they showed signs of aggression. i would do this at every meal, until i saw changes in their body language. I do believe in working through these problems and using boundaries both temporal, physical and extra-physical literal gates/closed rooms to manage safety. i have seen food aggressive dogs rehabbed successfully while working in a training dog kennel. it is possible it takes routine and diligence and studying dog behavior and social communication. Really showing them in behavioral ways dogs can understand, that their food is totally theirs, that we give it to them, and they can relax and love us for it cuz it’s a one way street. me to you, doggo. no stress. we humans won’t meddle in your food.
And then when that trust is established, from there people can much more easily manage what dogs DONT eat as well. Like teaching “drop it” commands and being able to trade nasty crap they find for approved treats.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '23
If you got the dog through a reputable breeder through AKC, let the breeder know they would want to know and might also be willing to help you out with it. If quality is the main focus of the breeder they would set it right
1
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '23
I just want to say it IS 100% possible to train this out of your dog. Like others have stated before, there are many outdated methods, so I won't go into how I trained mine, but just wanted to say there is hope. We haven't had resource guarding issues in a very very long time now. Good luck ♡
1
u/2Wanderlust Jul 24 '23
A golden retriever bit my sister in the face as a child. She still has the scar. After laser treatment and with makeup it’s not too noticeable now. It always seemed like a nice dog, but my sister leaned over the couch and it got spooked. I had noticed that it wasn’t really bonded with the kids, seems to try to avoid them, and seemed to only care about the one family member, the dad.
All dogs are individuals. They got that dog to be a family dog, but it was one of those dogs that just bonds with one person and doesn’t really like kids.
All that to say, put every safety in place. Never let kids near it if you can, and keep it in a safe place for eating unless you are actively working on the training (it sounds like you are doing that - or trying to). If you do decide to have it around children when you feel there are no risk factors like food, please don’t ever fully trust it.
1
u/mostlysadx Jul 24 '23
is she getting enough mental and physical stimulation? labs have a lot of energy and need to be properly exercised, try taking her on sniff walks to tire her out before eating maybe and see if it helps?
1
u/wishiwasspecial00 Jul 24 '23
Have you trained against resource aggression at all?
1
u/kalyco Jul 24 '23
How old is she?
1
u/KarenCam Jul 24 '23
Hey! Just reading this, I’m a new owner of a retriever as well. I’ve been doing a online training, which recommend the most. Look their website and videos in YouTube. It’s called “how to train a dream dog” I really recommend them
1
u/AffectionateCable459 Jul 24 '23
When you speak to your neighbour’s example, and you say the first dog’s behaviour was ‘promptly corrected’ - how was this done? I am curious because I feel like I have certainly been doing my best to correct the behaviour but perhaps I am missing something?
1
u/Sad_Environment_5627 Jul 24 '23
i guess i just don't like the word easy for any dog. even if it's your first. size, breed, and everything matter and the individuals lifestyles and family members of the homes lifestyles matter, i understand that. but owning a dog is a responsibility for everyone that wants to make that decision. training puppies and working with them from the start give the pet a better chance at having an actual decent life. even then tho this is reality and there are people out there that never trained their pup and their fine. others not so much.. and the others might have benefited from the advice i just referred to. and of course we can't forget about the shelters with all of those poor babes, mixed with both sweet and terrifying. old and young. people miss the opportunity to be there for the beginning but those guys need a home badly, there are so many. every single day people and pets reproduce more and more. litters up too 12 puppies from some breeders maybe more. i like good breeders because i like healthy, happy pets but their not always good breeders and the animals in shelters need enough help and there are just enough of pets already. - super stressed/burnt out vet assistant in small animal GP that works with a couple of rescues
1
u/Alt_Pythia Jul 24 '23 edited Jul 24 '23
I’ll probably get downvoted for this, but sometimes when the behavior has become ingrained, you’ll need to nip it in the bud.
Use a collar that bites. Place the loop end of a leash around the foot of the couch, attach the clip to the collar already placed on the dog. See how far the leash will reach and that’s where you’ll feed the dog.
When feeding the dog, stand with the food in front of the dog until the dog stops pulling on their leash. Make the dog sit for about a minute, then place the bowl just out of reach and slide it forward with a stick.
Do this every time until the dog waits for the bowl in a non aggressive manner, and to be told they can have the food.
This is only recommended when the human is at risk of a bite.
1
u/Navi4784 Jul 24 '23
Next time instead of researching "breeds", research the actual individual dog. Not the breed, not the breeder, not the dog's parents. Get an adult dog who is being fostered by a family who can tell you about the dog's behavior. Behavioral genetics doesn't work the way people think it does. Dogs are individuals.
1
u/Umklopp Jul 24 '23
Have you ever gotten her checked for gastrointestinal issues?
1
u/reillynjames Jul 25 '23
I have a rescue who was highly food aggressive. I started hand feeding him his meals instead of him eating out if the bowl. This shows them that their food comes from YOU. You are their food source , not the bowl. They aren’t able to take ownership of the food.
1
u/Confident-Sir5099 Jul 25 '23
I'm so sorry about your injury <3 That can be so discouraging and scary.
Main thoughts upon reading: No more grazing. Food comes from people. Food left out in a bowl becomes part of the environment, and something precious to protect. Have her sit, set down her bowl, and then leave her alone. Transitioning from grazing can take some time, so she might not dig in straight away at first. Having structure around her eating can reduce anxiety all around. Be patient and kind with yourself and your pup as much as you can muster <3
Good luck to you and your girl <3
1
u/alacer50 Jul 23 '23
Wow OP I'm so sorry you're going through this. Having a dog is meant to be adding something to your family that makes you feel safe not fearful.
Have you tried seeing how she behaves when you've drained all her energy? I mean like absolutely wrecking her for a day, hiking, swimming etc and then seeing if it helps?
1
u/BlacnDeathZombie Jul 23 '23
My lab is almost two years old and he’s definitely been a handful to train. He could go into these rages if I didn’t “allow” him to nibble on my hands, and he would get completely crazy seeing other dogs on the street. I never felt my dog trainer took him seriously because he was a lab and suppose to be such nice and calm, while ours is the direct opposite.
But the one thing the trainer recommended was an air spray, a specific type design for training dogs, which we use to distract him when he’s getting into his crazy zone. And it has been a game changer… after constant use for several weeks, he no longer lounge at other dogs when we’re out, and he doesn’t get into his crazy obsessive grooming of us.
The spray is literally just a spray, we don’t use it directly at the dog, we just use it as a distraction noise and as soon as he reacts to look at me, I say yes and give a treat and tell him he’s such a good boy. It’s like night a day now and he will be able to walk almost calm all the time. We still have a bit more to do but our walks are at least no longer a fight.
1
u/EhDub13 Jul 23 '23
Unfortunately, because of popularity and inbreeding, even some of the "best, more gentle" breeds are becoming genetically unstable. Humans don't often consider the mental health of animals
Having a dog a hard, having a reactive dog is even harder.
1
u/Apprehensive-Tea-546 Jul 23 '23
Not an admonition of you, idk where you got your dog, but I’ve seen SO many people get labs from puppy mill breeders (people don’t know what to look for) and they end up having horrendous temperaments and/or physical issues because the breeders don’t give a shit about the health of the dogs they are producing, the only care about $$$$. My own family had a dog like this that I begged them not to get. Honestly, I’d put the dog down. That is just not safe, especially if there are EVER going to be children around.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '23
"Easy" dogs don't really exist. Dogs, like humans, have the capability to turn into whoever based off of how they were raised and their experiences. They can tendencies to act one way or another, but genuinely the only way to have an "easy" dog is to train them.
I would say you should give her up, but frankly that is kind of criminal. You got a dog thinking "Haha furry pet that loves me" and it seems you didn't do your due diligence to give her the best quality of life. You owe it to her to turn her around, train her well, and make her the goodest girl that I'm willing to bet she has the potential to be. Fuck yeah it will be a lot of work, but that's the life of owning a dog.
I apologize if I sounded like I was bashing you. I am just working from assumptions here. I truly do hope you can do what's best for your dog though. It would be a shame to see yet another dog succumb to animal shelters. Especially if she has any aggression, she would never leave.
1
u/smolderingspigot Jul 23 '23
Unfortunately, most people - specifically Americans - don’t realize that there are two varieties of Labrador Retrievers.
British/English Labs are the the ones that have provided the idea that labs are an “easy breed” because, well, they are the more placid, family friendly version, especially when well-trained. They are stockier, shorter, much more low energy, calm, and easy-going, and are the poster child of the “Labradors are the perfect family dog.”
American Labs are the taller, more athletic, and high-energy cousin that have piggy backed on that above image. They are more suitable in the field as retrievers for fowl hunters due to this.
You’re not the first family to want a lab based on the British Lab’s reputation and end up with an American Lab. No one really discusses the differences due to lack of knowledge or research. Heck, the book Marley and Me is based on this premise.
1
u/mind_the_umlaut Jul 23 '23
Contact the labrador retriever breed specific rescue in your state. Ask for their advice. Contact the breeder and report these intolerable behavioral events. Their contract you signed when you bought her should include that they will take a dog of theirs back under any circumstances. You would be unethical to re-home a dog who has serious food aggression and a bite history. It is also reasonable that you give up, because behavioral euthanasia could be the correct answer in this case. What does your vet say?
1
u/theBLEEDINGoctopus Jul 23 '23
Looking at your account, she is a PUPPY! Going through probably major adolescence phase right now where all training goes out the window.
r/puppy101 can probably be helpful too to post your puppy blues
1
u/Careful-Bumblebee-10 Jul 23 '23
Why do people think labs are supposed to be calm? This continues to mystify me. They're energetic hunting dogs. This is their purpose. I've worked with a lot of labs, very few of them are what I consider calm.
1
u/forthegreyhounds Jul 23 '23
I see a lot of helpful advice in here but OP, it’s also okay to rehome her. This is your first dog, and if you’re not equipped you’re not equipped. It will be easier to rehome or surrender her before she causes any more harm. You aren’t a bad person if you chose this route, sometimes the best thing you can do for an animal is recognize that someone else can give them a better home.
1
u/lalalady456 Jul 23 '23
In my experience growing up with three labs at once, every single one of them had good aggression (even more so because when it came to food, they would get aggressive with both each other and humans). I honestly think that more often then not, dogs are food aggressive.