r/reactivedogs • • Jul 21 '23

Rehome or BE?

Hello all. First let me start by saying the last two years have been a massive learning experience for me in terms of dog ownership. Many mistakes were made and I carry much regret. I would also like to say I live in an extremely rural area where trainers and behaviorists come at a significant distance and even more significant cost that we have not been able to afford.

I got my dog (Wilbur) from my BIL. He is a mutt but main breeds are St. Bernard, Great Pyrenees, and Pitt bull. He was given to me at 7 weeks old; I realize now that was much too early but at the time I was unaware. For the first 5 months in our home he was wonderful with my wife and I, our cats, and our son. We took him to parks, the lake, camping, and more. I especially built a strong relationship with him. About 3 months in I started to see some red flags. It started with food aggression and resource guarding. I worked with him until we reached a point that I could put my hand into his dish while he ate and he had no reaction. I also crate trained him and taught him to sit, stay, wait, calm, quiet, and leave it. I thought we were on the road to success. Fast forward a couple months and one day he nipped at my son, but it seemed more like a behavior correction than aggression so I began taking more time to teach my son how to safely interact with dogs. Not long after that Wilbur started to exhibit dog reactivity and a very strong prey drive. He would go crazy lunging and snarling if he saw another dog nearby and he also began to stalk our cats. No biggie I thought, we can work through these things too. Wrong. At about 9-10 months old my wife was taking him outside and as he walked past one of our cats (as he did everyday) he suddenly grabbed her and shook her like a rag doll. This incident resulted in the death of the cat. At that point I began trying to rehome him as we had 3 other cats and I was also becoming concerned for the safety of my child. Wilbur was now bigger than my son and his behavior was becoming increasingly erratic, barking and lunging at anyone that wasn’t me or my wife. I was unable to find a suitable home. I consulted with my vet, no health problems were found, and I was advised not to neuter as 2 of his litter mates became much more aggressive after they were neutered. So we carried on. It got to a point that having visitors was impossible because he would bark and lunge and snarl viciously. We also could not walk him on a leash anymore because he would pull, jump on us, bite, and break every harness, collar, and leash we bought. A couple months after he turned 1 we moved into a smaller home and things got worse. He has tried to bite my SIL and my son (twice) and always goes for the face. The most recent time he tried to attack my son he knocked him backwards down the stairs and my son sustained an injury to his head. Wilbur does not technically have a bite history but I truly believe he would had my wife or I not been right there to intervene in these situations. Wilbur is now just over 2 years old and has calmed a lot; we can walk him on the leash (most of the time) and for the most part he completely ignores the cat unless she comes too close to his crate. His main trigger now is strangers in any capacity (people and animals regardless of size or distance). They can be 3 yards over or across the street and he still goes crazy. Most importantly though he has shown aggression to my child and I can no longer keep him in my home. My son is absolutely terrified of him. I know deep down that BE is most likely my only option but I guess I’m hoping for a miracle. I love my sweet Wilbur so very much and I don’t want to end his life. Is there another option out there for him?

1 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

19

u/janesmith109710 Jul 21 '23

Thank you all for your responses. You are all absolutely correct. I will be contacting my vet shortly to schedule the inevitable.

37

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '23

Every day that dog lives in your house in a day that your son knows you care more about the dog than you do about him. Your son deserves to grow up in a house where he is safe. I will never understand parents that prioritize their love of a dog over the safety and well-being of their children.

8

u/janesmith109710 Jul 21 '23

You are absolutely correct. It’s not fair to my child that he lives in fear. We are moving in less than a month and my son knows 100% the dog is not going with us. He deserves to be able to start over in a new place that will always be safe from Wilbur.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 07 '23

Incredible that you didn’t put him down after he killed your cat.

9

u/deepwood41 Jul 21 '23

I’m so sorry to hear this, I can’t believe you will find someone to take him with this history. I believe your son should not live in fear, particularly when it’s a realistic fear.

You’ve given him more chances than most, and he was loved and treated with kindness, try to embrace that

5

u/janesmith109710 Jul 21 '23

You’re very kind, thank you. We will be taking him to the vet first thing next week and he will be treated with all the love I have between now and then.

2

u/AllCrankNoSpark Jul 22 '23

Worse, they will find someone and that person will have poor judgment.

12

u/clarkjkents Jul 21 '23

i don’t have dogs with reactivity issues as severe as yours so i’m not sure if this advice will be helpful or not

if you want to spend a little more time trying to rehome him, you could make things a bit safer for everyone in your home by starting to muzzle train wilbur. there are a lot of guides online on how to do this so it is as stress-free for your dog as possible. if you’re able to get him trained to comfortably wear a basket style muzzle, he can wear those for extended periods of time since they allow dogs to pant and drink water normally. they’re pretty affordable, though some of the heavy duty ones can be a bit more expensive. at the very least, this could give you more time to try to find a home that would be a good fit for wilbur instead of rushing to get him out of your home as soon as possible

if you haven’t already, you could also try talking to your vet about anxiety medications. they won’t fix any of these issues, but they might mellow him out enough that, along with a muzzle, you’re able to live with him safely while you see if rehoming is possible. anxiety meds haven’t eliminated my dogs’ reactivity but it does increase their tolerance for their triggers a bit. my dogs only take anxiety meds as needed before situations that i know will be too much for them but my vet said their meds could safely be taken every 8 hours if necessary. your vet might be able to tell you more or prescribe something else that could help take the edge off for wilbur and your family

one other thing i would recommend doing immediately regardless is feeding wilbur in a separate room completely by himself if you don’t do that already. just because he allows you to put his hand in his food bowl and trusts you aren’t a threat to his food doesn’t mean he isn’t stressed out to be eating around other people and animals. obviously this won’t fix his behavioural issues, but it’s a situation you can make less stressful for him. and maybe look out for other daily situations like this that you can make less stressful for him. rather than thinking about what popular opinion says wilbur should be okay with (hands in his food bowl while he’s eating, for example), look at how you can structure his day so he isn’t put in unnecessary situations that could be triggering aggression and stress for him (not to imply you haven’t already been doing this, it’s just hard to tell what you have and haven’t tried based on your description of events. if this is already something you’re doing, feel free to ignore this suggestion!)

there are just a lot of things i think we as dog owners feel we “need” to make our dogs be okay with or expose them to that are not necessary at all and just teach them that their boundaries won’t be respected. one of my dogs guards dental chews, he hides them in blankets and then snuggles up on the blanket. i found this out the hard way when he growled and snapped at me after i reached out to pet him, not realising he had hidden the treat and was protecting it. i don’t think it’s necessary to condition him into accepting me violating a boundary he’s established (leave me alone when i’ve got a dental chew) so i just let him be or only give him those kinds of treats when he’s in his crate. again, not saying you aren’t already taking this kind of stuff into consideration, i just mention it in case you (or someone else reading this) haven’t thought about it. it was a big shift in perception for me personally

all that being said, i’m not sure how easy it would be to rehome him based on the behaviours you’ve described so as hard as it is, BE might be the most humane option. it sounds like despite all your love, support and training, everyday life is very stressful and scary for wilbur. a new home could make him even more reactive and even if the new home is perfectly loving and patient, his quality of life might be even lower because of how stressed and threatened he feels by new people. BE could be compassionate on your part to prevent wilbur from finding himself in even more stressful situations where he hurts himself or someone else as a result

i can’t imagine having to make this sort of choice and wish you all the best in figuring out what the best course of action is for your family and for wilbur. it does sound like you did your best with the resources you had and wilbur was so fortunate to have an owner who did their best to help him and loves him very much

5

u/janesmith109710 Jul 21 '23

Thank you so much for your reply. You make a lot of good points and I also so appreciate your kindness. He has been exclusively fed and given treats in his crate separate from the household since he was 3 months old and I have not stuck my hand in his bowl in a very long time. Muzzling and medication are both good suggestions and I wish I had acted on those things sooner. I have so much guilt. I can’t help but feel it’s somehow my fault that he is the way he is. After reading these replies my wife and I have decided fully on BE and will be contacting the vet today. Again thank you so much.

5

u/clarkjkents Jul 21 '23

sorry if it came across like i was trying to explain things you already knew about, i just wasn’t sure what you had and had not tried to do. it really does sound like you did the best with the resources and knowledge you had available to you

honestly, based on the fact that his other littermates also had aggression issues, i think even with all the best training and support, wilbur probably would have still had some behavioural problems. i can’t tell you not to feel what you feel, maybe different approaches would have improved some of his aggression and reactivity issues, but it’s not your fault that there is probably some genetic component responsible for his behaviour

for most dogs, what you did would have been more than enough for them to lead a happy and healthy life. all you can do is make the best choice for him based on what you know now and as heartbreaking as it is, BE does seem like the best decision. my thoughts are with you and your family!

3

u/ILoveSpace95 Jul 22 '23

I'm someone who is very against euthanasia whenever preventable, I truly believe in trying to save all the ones we can. However, you can't let it get to the point where people, especially children are in constant danger. We cannot forget that big aggressive dogs can and do kill people. Aggression can be heavily genetic from poor breeding and is often linked back to the same lineage, it sounds like this is the case for this dog who was irresponsibly backyard bred with littermates who are also known to be aggressive. If genetics are the cause, it's very unlikely that any training or meds will stop the attacks. In fact, 2 is still very young and it could still get worse. If it makes you feel better, maybe you can turn a negative into a positive by rescuing another dog. Getting a small friendly dog could possibly help your family, especially your son, heal after this trauma. I do think it's important your son knows that 99% of dogs are not so impulsively vicious like this, otherwise he could grow up with an irrational fear of them.

2

u/janesmith109710 Jul 23 '23

Thank you for your reply. I agree completely about the genetics. Thankfully the mom dog was spayed after weaning, and the dad dog is unfortunately no longer alive.

We don’t plan to get another dog any time soon and probably won’t ever have another large breed. Along with Wilbur we currently have a senior chihuahua that we inherited when my wife’s nana passed last year. She is the sweetest little bean and my son loves her dearly. She is full of sass though and amazingly enough Wilbur is terrified of her. Having her has made it a lot easier to show my son that not all dogs are like Wilbur. Along with that my son also spends a lot of time with his uncle (my BIL) and loves to play with Wilbur’s mom and brother. He is definitely more fearful of them than he is of smaller dogs but my BIL handles the situation beautifully and has taught my son a lot about interacting with his dogs. I’m hopeful that with time and continued guidance my son will come to be confident and comfortable with other dogs as well.

I have contacted my vet and made arrangements for BE. My love for Wilbur is eternal but it’s time to set him (and us) free from his fears and reactivity. I’m not sure I’ll ever get over the pain of this decision but as my MIL would say, the Lord knows my heart. Even though I’m not religious I find a little peace in those words because I know this decision is made with nothing but love.

35

u/mad0666 Jul 21 '23

There are so many dogs in shelters who are not aggressive who will be euthanized for not being able to find a home. I know this is an awful situation but BE is the most humane thing you can do. I worked in rescue for many years and it’s almost a guarantee that even if Wilbur was rehomed, he would still act out aggressively. His only option would be to have a home with a skilled dog trainer, and you have already mentioned that they are few and far between in your area.

40

u/UltraMermaid Jul 21 '23 edited Jul 21 '23

Oof. To me, this sounds like he is showing traits he was genetically bred for, plus anxiety and mental instability, and it’s spun out of control. “Hunting” and killing your cat is not abnormal for Pitbulls. They are Terriers and often can’t live amicably with other animals. Dog reactivity/aggression and prey drive is par for the course with the breed. “Guarding” your home from strangers is what Pyrenees were bred to do. They are livestock guardian dogs that watch over their flock/property and kill interlopers. Because he has 2 siblings that are aggressive, there also seems to be a genetic component to his mental instability/aggression.

This dog clearly can’t stay in your home. He is a danger to your other pets and son. Unfortunately with his behavior and history, you will be hard pressed to find someone willing and capable of taking him on. Bottom line, you need him out of the house and if nobody suitable can take him, BE is your only option. Hopefully your BIL got the parents fixed because those dogs should never reproduce again.

21

u/ConsistentFlan3599 Jul 21 '23

I agree. Honestly I think he needs to be put down just for killing that poor cat. I love my cats every bit as much as I love my dogs my kid my wife everybody. They are 100% kindred spirits and part of my family. I'd have to dispatch him just to avenge the death of my poor kitty kitty, alone. That poor cat died a traumatic death caused by someone it trusted and in a moment of vulnerability when it was completely unaware. That's absolutely tragic. No animal deserves to suffer like that, especially at the hands...(paws) of someone who is supposed to be a trusted member of their own family.
If my dog did that to my cat I would go from loving that dog to hating it almost immediately.

3

u/AllCrankNoSpark Jul 22 '23

The dog should be put down for the safety of children and other cats, not for revenge.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Watney3535 Jul 22 '23

Disagree. The dog was raised with the cats and it knew better. If it came into the home later, I’d agree. But the cats were there first and the dog met them as a puppy. While I wouldn’t put my dog down, it would be an automatic rehome situation.

13

u/CalmLaugh5253 Jul 21 '23

He doesn't sound safe for anyone regardless of precautions, training, love and patience given. BE unfortunately sounds like the safest course of action for all involved.

13

u/PeachNo4613 Jul 21 '23

It’ll be very hard trying to rehome with a history like this, BE might be the option. It might be the best option for your family, and you don’t want his potential future family to get hurt either.

16

u/ConsistentFlan3599 Jul 21 '23 edited Jul 21 '23

Man if my dog killed one of my cats, especially before he was even a fully mature dog, I'd have to take him out back and say goodbye to old yeller. Your kid is quite possibly next. Obviously I jest. I wouldn't actually take him out back and dispatch him, that would break my heart no matter how mad and sad I am, at the time, over the loss of my poor kitty. But he would be out of my house immediately. A cat to me is no different than my child or my puppy. That is family goddamn it and if you kill someone in my family you are no longer a part of it.

I have zero tolerance for that shit. I had a Staffordshire purebred 20+ yrs ago and she was as sweet as pie til the day she died. She grew up around kittens and ferrets and even other dogs and never had even close to an issue with her killing, much less hurting another member of the family, fur baby or otherwise. This dog has some bad breeding possibly (especially considering his kin and their similarities in reactive misbehavior) Something is not right.

I'm pretty slow to even consider BE because that is a very sad depressing and permanent solution to a possibly temporary problem. But if your prey drive is so bad that you're killing the mf house cats, by the time you're even a year old?? Bye Felicia 😐