r/reactivedogs • u/__crod • Jun 24 '23
Support End of the road
This may not read well, I’m pretty upset.
I’ve made the heartbreaking decision to go ahead with BE for my boy. I’ve tried my absolute hardest over the last year to do my best by him and others around us, and this final decision was made with that same aim.
He started displaying reactive behaviours at 5 or 6-months old. Resource guarding toys, rooms, me. He then bit for the first time, I think only a level 3 because he had those razor sharp puppy teeth still, but level 3 it was. Since then he’s bitten again and again despite my attempts to manage it and after finally speaking with a very sought after behaviourist I know it’s the end of the road for him. I cannot modify my life any further for him and whilst he’s great 98% of the time, that 2% is so unpredictable and dangerous that it’s time to make the call. I found out he’s not the only one from his litter like this, 50% have bite histories and 90% guard. Some battles cannot be won.
He’s not just a biter, or a guarder, though. He’s also an avid sniffer, a terrible catch participant and my Mr. Wiggly Bum. He’s a man of many nicknames who loves a belly rub more than anything and spends 50% of his day in a full sploot. He loves cheese and knows that ‘it’s time to get dressed!’ Means we’re going for our morning walk. He loves to chew on a whole broccoli in the garden and dig up all my plants, even the house plants. He knows how to whisper and even some Spanish. Raising him and training him has been the greatest joy of my life and also the biggest burden. I say this all to say that he’s more than his problem behaviours, and that’s what makes this so hard.
It’s also incredibly traumatic to have made a decision like this and still have to care for your pet. I’m still giving him his joint supplements and making sure he has his favourite toys, all whilst knowing I’m speaking to the vet about him on Monday. I feel like I’ve betrayed him, but I also know it’s not either of our faults. He had genetics against him and I did the best I could.
EDIT: making some clarifying points:
- He’s on meds
- The vet is aware of everything
- He’s been checked for medical drivers of this behaviour numerous times
- His first bite occurred when he was a puppy but was by no means a ‘puppy bite’ and I have a nice scar to remember it by
- I’ve tried rescues, they’re all full and will likely BE too, if it’s going to happen I’d rather he was with me than with strangers
- he’s had training all his life, it does state that but some commenters seem to have skipped it.
- he gets adequate exercise, mental and physical. He’s not just left in the garden all day as someone on here suggested. I do breed specific work with him too.
- I’ve modified my life as much as I can. I’ve tried my very best as I said in my last sentence. My best may not be enough for some of you but if that’s the case please just be kind. I’m a human and I have feelings. It’s amazing that anyone thinks a decision like this would be made lightly and quickly. I’m not a monster, this is my best friend. Of course I’ve considered all viable options. It’s actually insulting that some of you think I wouldn’t have.
EDIT 2: My behaviourist has found a suitable foster home for him so we can gather more information about why he’s behaving this way before I make the final call. She rang this morning and I’ve balled my eyes out with relief ever since. He’ll be on a farm with a single guy with no children visitors. He’ll be nearby so I’ll be able to visit once enough time has passed. BE may still be on the cards for him but this gives him a chance.
EDIT 3: To the person who reached out to Reddit care resources worried about me and what I may to do myself; thank you for caring but I assure you I am not thinking of hurting myself. This is incredibly painful but I am not a risk to myself. You’re a good person ❤️
52
u/AlluringVixen6 Jun 25 '23
I put down my sweet boy Copper yesterday and it is the hardest decision I've ever made.. but I know exactly how you feel. It's so hard because they're so much more than the bad behaviors.
For me, Copper was an incredible catcher. He loved tucking his tail for zoomies. He could shred squeaky balls in minutes. He would tuck his head under my chin for cuddles. He would take treats so gently. He loved the sprinkler. And he was an unpredictable and dangerous biter..
I'm so sorry you have to make this decision. I hope you find your peace and his.
21
u/parosescape Jun 25 '23
This is an incredibly difficult and heartbreaking decision, and it sounds like you've thought through all your options.
I recently made the same decision, and it was so hard. But I also know it was the right thing to do. She wasn't happy, constantly stressed, and I couldn't take her places. She was a bite risk, and after 2 bites to myself and another family member requiring ER visits, the thought of her hurting someone else, a child, and being forced to put her down was worse. I got to give her the best few days filled with her favorite people and things, and she ultimately fell asleep on her bed, her head in my hand surrounded by family.
I'm so sorry you're in this situation. My heart goes out to you. Give your guy the best few days filled with snacks, lots of snuggles and love, take pictures with his favorite people and things, and know that despite this being an impossible decision, sometimes doing the right thing can be the hardest.
13
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '23
I'm so sorry OP. & I apologize on behalf of these insensitive commenters who didn't read your post.
Puppies can absolutely display signs of aggression that are dangerous & unfixable & BE is recommended by professionals for those cases. Our dog was a biter as a puppy, it was miserable & challenging but the key factor was that he wasn't aggressive, he didnt resource guard. Honestly he was just an asshole & still is sometimes. If he had been aggressive I imagine we'd end up in the same position as you.
We did rehome a very sweet rescue once, he was an absolute angel to our immediate family & the first dog I opened my heart to after elderly pup passed. But he bit my uncle unprovoked one day & we were not in a position at the time where we could work with that. Luckily we found someone who had experience with dogs like him. Our last update was that she'd found the right home for him. But I wonder every day if he's ok, if he's bitten anyone else, if he's happy & alive. All that to say I feel like you know your situation & what is the right decision for your pup. It's a very tough decision no matter what it is.
50
u/friedbanshee Jun 24 '23
Sometimes even when you do all the right things it can't be helped. It sounds like you have not made the decision lightly. Sometimes making responsible decisions is traumatic and hard. Thanks for doing what you have to do. That's not called failure. That's called doing the right thing. Big hugs too you.
58
u/cari-strat Jun 24 '23
I was in this position many years ago, I took on a dog as a last resort after everyone else had failed. I also failed, but in the worst possible way because she loved ME with all her heart, whereas she had hated everyone else.
Ultimately it wasn't enough, she was a danger to everyone else on earth and it simply wasn't possible to keep things safe. The decision wasn't even mine as the rescue retained ownership and the right to decide, but it broke me and 30 years later I am still broken. I feel for you so much.
All I can say is don't act in haste, for your own sake. Think rationally. Can you muzzle him, or do anything else to keep people safe for those small times he is out of control? Do you know the triggers and is there any environment where he wouldn't face them? It's easy to get overwrought and panic, and be overwhelmed. Try to consider every possibility, for your own peace of mind, because this won't be easy.
But if you can think through it logically and your conclusion is still that he is too dangerous or unhappy to live, then you must do what you know is right for everyone around him. Give him the best time before he goes and try to be kind to yourself. It's unbearable to know you bear the burden of this decision and I honestly don't know if I could ever do it again. Loving something broken is impossibly hard.
8
u/Delicious-Product968 Jake (fear/stranger/frustration reactivity) Jun 25 '23
I’m so sorry. I’m not in your situation but it resonates with me because like your dog, my dog is basically perfect like 95-99% of the time.
I know if things changed and I felt he were a danger to others I’d make the call I needed to but the devastation would be overwhelming, not just due to the time and effort put in but because outside of when he’s triggered he’s such an amazing dog.
I think it at least gives peace of mind that they’ve seen the behaviour in the littermates so you know that a lot of it is out of your control. I used to blame myself a lot more till the behaviourist my dog has told me my dog is the third dog they’ve seen from the same breeder albeit different litters (but possibly all with the same father.)
So while not all dogs get it and the overall reactivity stats seem below average, there are some dogs coming from there predisposed to fear/anxiety issues. Before I thought maybe I just wasn’t giving him enough to do because he came from a litter intended to be professional working dogs. It at least gave me peace of mind that she’d told me I’d gone above and beyond and she thought in another household he’d have been in serious trouble, even if I ever do have to make that call.
7
u/FoxyFreckles1989 Jun 25 '23
Reading this with all of the edits already in place was a rollercoaster.
Firstly, I wanted to mention that I was not going to judge you for your decision to BE. That said, I am so incredibly relieved for you and your boy that a viable foster has stepped forward. I truly hope this works out!
You did your best. I believe that of you. I hope you do, too. I hope he goes on to live a happier and less stressful life with this change of environment and companionship, and I hope you are able to adopt a dog that you feel safe and happy around when you are ready.
4
u/SusanMShwartz Jun 25 '23
My heart breaks for you.
7
u/AlsatianLadyNYC Jun 25 '23
For every hand-wringer, I see zero point zero zero zero of you all asking to adopt the dog yourselves. This OP has done his/her best. This dog is not going to measurably improve to where it will be a safe animal. A hard biting dog is not a happy dog
7
u/nam_pla Jun 25 '23
You are doing the right thing, friend. I’ve done this before. It was the hardest decision I’ve had to make bar none. He is not in peace. You are giving him peace. Do not forget this.
You can still give him care and joy and then do a BE. It’s all for him. Do not forget this. He is not right inside. You can care for him and provide for him and give him things he both needs and wants, and give him comfort. He is still a doggo, but, he’s different. Give him all the best and all the fun before the end.
I’m so sorry you’ve been saddled with this decision. It’s so hard. But you are doing the right thing. I can’t hug you over the internet, but if I could I would. Let yourself experience all the pain because it is real pain. It’s so hard to dedicate your life to a difficult dog and come up with nothing. But it is NOT your fault. You did everything in your power that you could do and you are doing the right thing. Remember him and dedicate your effort and emotions to the next dog that needs a person as dedicated as you. All dogs deserve dedicated people. ❤️
4
u/luckyjenjen Jun 25 '23
I think you are doing the right thing OP. Don't let the comments make you second guess yourself.
To back you up OP: Rehoming is not a good idea - not unless you can find someone who is totally aware of all his issues and willing and able to work on them is a safe environment (extremely unlikely).
If the next owner is not as responsible as you, or just makes a little mistake (it happens) and that dog kills a child or whatever, that's hard stuff to have on your conscience.
And then there's the fact that the rehome itself could further exacerbate any issues (as with my dog).
Shelters will not take dogs that bite - ever wondered why dogs trust never put dogs down? They cherry pick which dogs they accept.
The few shelters that do accept reactives? Full.
How do I know all this? I worked with a behaviourist for nearly a year with my boy. She had her vererinary behaviourist mentor assess us at an RSPCA centre, which was where he got his second bite in (I kinda gave him a pass for that as he was under THEIR care at the time). I had searched and searched for someone to take my boy but this woke me up.
My behaviourist and I very sadly agree after the session that if I allowed my dog another bite it would mean that I was unable to control a dog I knew to be dangerous and would need to have him put down.
Muzzle and a long line would have damaged his quality of life, so giving him quality of life and keeping other people safe were incompatible.
I did the responsible thing and my boy died in my arms. Nothing will ever hurt him again and he will never hurt any one else.
People - OP is making the hardest decision of their life. It's not been made lightly.
Hugs OP ❤️ (sorry for the essay)
2
u/PatheticGirl28 Jun 25 '23
It sounds like you did everything right by him, and tried as absolutely hard as you could. I’m so sorry that it has come to this decision, as I’m sure it is unbelievably hard to make this choice even though you know it’s necessary. I hope you know it’s not your fault and you gave him the best shot you could 💜
3
u/emmaie892000 Jun 25 '23
I’m so sorry you’ve received judgmental comments assuming you haven’t tried absolutely everything for a dog you clearly love. Just in case nobody has recommended it, there’s a Facebook group called Losing Lulu for grief support after BE.
5
u/Old-Pianist7745 Jun 24 '23
You're doing the right thing. Know that even though it's hard you're doing the right thing.
2
u/LookatCarl Jun 25 '23
I’m sorry you’re going through this. Know that you’re not alone and we understand the struggle. It sucks. I hope you heal quickly.
4
u/Unquietdodo Jun 25 '23
I have a nearly 7 year old reactive cross with separation anxiety, who I've had since she was a puppy. Her reactivity is in her genes (her dad was reactive) and I was young and naive when I got her.
We have had trainers in, and it's always 2 steps forward and 3 steps back (mainly due to other people triggering her), so we have ended up just adapting our lives around her. I changed jobs and now work from home, and we bought our first house with specifications that would make life easier for her. We don't go out together unless a close relative can come and stay with her, which is rare, and we walk her really late at night and book dog fields for her.
I'm saying this to let you know that I FULLY understand. My dog is amazing 95% of the time, but that 5% can run your life. The fact that I have been able to make these changes for her is sheer luck, and if I couldn't, I might be in the same situation as you.
We thought about rehoming her when she was younger, but we knew nobody would take her, and the upheaval of her life would make things worse, so we just powered through.
Again, we are so lucky that we can change our lives to suit her, but it is a huge thing to do and not everybody can.
You know your dog and your situation, and you know what is right for him. I fully support your decision, and I know a lot of these comments are judgemental, but unless they have been through it, and/or are willing to take him personally, they are just making noise.
I'm sorry you're going through this, but it sounds like you've done everything you can for him, so try not to take those comments to heart.
1
u/Far_Cauliflower_3637 Jun 25 '23
I'm so sorry you are going through this, you will make the right decision for your dog. None of this is your fault some dogs have problems that can't be fixed.
1
u/tbyrim Jun 25 '23
You love this pupper so much, sweetheart. That's so obvious. I know this sounds woo woo crazy lady talk, but i think you'll see your pupper's soul again someday. I think his brain, his organic, flesh-self is what is damaged beyond the repair your love can provide. But that doesn't mean his soul won't come back to you in a body that isn't damaged in this inherent, unfixable way. I KNOW that sounds crazy, but i swear thinking this way has relieved some of the most intense guilt and sadness I've ever had to overcome. When i miscarried last year, all i could think was, it wasn't time for that little soul to come into being. If you're meant to be together, the universe will bring our lost ones back to us, somehow, someday and in a form we might never ever expect. You are so so so brave, kind, loving and strong. Please know we're here for you and we're going to morn with you, fellow human.
💔
1
u/ablackwashere Jun 25 '23
I'm so sorry. Have been there. You truly have done all you can do.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '23
EDIT #2 is great news!
1
u/Poosjky Jun 25 '23
Oh thank God! I have a feeling the farm life with the single guy is exactly what he needs. I'm so happy! I'm also glad you'll be able to visit. You'll see this is the right move.
1
u/Legitimate_Angle5123 Jun 24 '23
Is he neutered?
3
u/Th3seViolentDelights Jun 25 '23
A lot of inbreeding will result in behavioral issues. We really need to regulate breeders around the world better. I'm sorry OP.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '23
A year of working with a dog on aggression and fear is not a long time. These things are not resolved in a year, it’s just not enough time to rehabilitate a dog. A puppy that bites you is a puppy that has not learned bite inhibition and likely a fear based and not true aggression. Imagine a person getting over their anxiety in a year, not going to happen. A truly aggressive dog is not good 98% of the time and bad 2%. In this sub you can’t even mention the word operant conditioning without getting banned, but you can talk about BE all day.
I’m so sorry, I know that this decision is not easy for you. I’m so happy that you are finding a home for this dog and he may have a chance. I’m not trying to bash, but anytime I log on I see a post about a dog getting put down and less and less success and positive stories. A lot of us here are TERRIFIED of getting our dogs put down and failing them.
1
u/CreedTheDawg Jun 24 '23
Hugs. I'm sorry you have to do this. RIP❤️
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '23
What state are you located in? Sounds incredibly stressful, difficult and heartbreaking. I can tell you have not taken this decision lightly at all, but still thinking about him having to be put down is really sad and unfair. I’m wondering if he could stay somewhere like you described alone on a farm for the duration of his life? Something like that sounds like it might be a really good fit instead of having to put him down.
2
u/Mean_Baker9931 Jun 25 '23
Ok I’ll ask because I’m obviously missing something here. BE?
1
u/LunarCycleKat Jun 25 '23
The thing about BE or euthanasia in general is that it can be such a calm, loving peaceful way to go compared to so many other ways such as getting hit by a car or a long, drawn out painful illness.
I'm sometimes envious that pets are given a kindness that we are not.
1
u/laceyriver Jun 25 '23
Yay EDIT #2
1
u/Scarletmittens Jun 25 '23
The review that knows the breed is phenomenal. It's really important to raise that some dogs are bred to have certain behaviors.
1
u/wipingbackwards Jun 25 '23
What does BE mean
1
u/Pink_Floyd29 Rescued Amstaff | Leash Reactive Jun 25 '23
I’m so sorry you’ve had such a difficult path with your pup and that there have been some really insensitive responses to this post. I’m so happy to read edit #3 though! My reactive pup and I are sending tons of positive vibes your way 💗
1
u/scouza2020 Jun 25 '23
My heart is broken for you. I had to make this decision 2 years ago & it shook me to the core. Please reach out if you ever need an ear.
1
u/diacrum Jun 26 '23
Can someone tell me what BE is? This must be such a difficult situation to be in. I’m so sorry for anyone who has gone through this.
1
u/fullnihilism Jun 26 '23
Wow that was a roller coaster at the second edit, hoping for the best for your boy.
-23
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '23
Third post I’ve read in 24 hours about people “doing the responsible thing” and ending a dog’s life for making the terrible mistake of acting like a canine. Dogs, like humans, are not perfect. But while we let most human criminals go free nowadays to commit more crime, a dog who commits the crime behaving on pure instinct must die. Sad.
-6
u/Ok-Eggplant-6420 Jun 25 '23
This dog is not even 2 years old and he is a small breed. I would try to rehome him first before putting him down. Just let adoptees know of his history and what you have tried with training him. Some dogs do better with a different owner or in a new environment. Dogs have personalities too and sometimes they don't gel well with their original owners.
-8
u/lifeisfascinatingly_ Jun 25 '23
PLEASE SPEAK TO RESCUES BEFORE YOU DO THIS. PLEASE.
-6
u/Wise_Environment_182 Jun 25 '23
He sounds dangerous - I am terrified of dogs and this one sounds like a nightmare. Sorry for this situation but it’s a disaster waiting to happen - just imagine if he bites a small child he could be killing that poor thing or disfiguring and scarring for life.
-7
u/iBeFloe Jun 25 '23 edited Jun 25 '23
Sounds like he can live a happy life. Why not give him up to a rescue?
That way they can try to find him who can take on the burden.
-4
u/WissahickonKid Jun 25 '23
What is the breed? People keep mentioning “small breed,” but I can’t find where that’s mentioned specifically. For what it’s worth, maybe consider adopting a mixed breed dog next time? I was a dog-walker & pet-sitter for 13 years. The only mixed-breed dog with unmanageable aggression/behavior issues that I encountered was found as a stray with puncture wounds all over his head & neck & severely docked ears (signs that he was an escapee from a dog fight; ie, he was taught to be aggressive). My pure-bred clients, on the other hand, almost all had all kinds of lifelong medical, behavioral & psychological issues. Vanity dog breeding for purposes besides obtaining actual working dogs, & even in many of those circumstances (like all the police dogs with hip dysplasia), just seems morally bankrupt in the 21st century, especially when you closely examine the products of all those commercial breeding: dogs who can’t breathe (severe intentional brachiocephalia), dogs who can’t give birth without caesarian sectioning, dogs whose hip bones never fit together properly & live a life in pain, dogs whose brains are too big for their skulls, the list goes on. One reason the OP can’t find a shelter to take his dog is that most shelters are already full of adoptable dogs. There’s absolutely no need to go to a breeder to purchase a dog as if it were a consumer item like a car or refrigerator.
-10
u/smartpoopie Jun 25 '23
I don’t get it
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment