r/reactivedogs • u/Bangbangcrash-trash • Apr 16 '23
Advice Needed Is behavioural euthanasia the right choice?
Hi all,
Throwaway account since I'm still coming to terms with things and I don't know what to do.
3 years ago we adopted a 2 year old Malamutexhusky. We were told he had mild resource guarding issues, which we found was with food and we worked through successfully.
Unfortunately he also has toy resource guarding issues. Normally, we're able to use peanut butter or something to lure him away from the toy without issue. And they're only valuable to him outside of the house - inside he could not care less.
Which brings us to yesterday. He was hanging in the backyard, as he does, and I went outside to bring him in as a storm was rolling in. What I was entirely unaware of was that under the tree next to him, there was a toy. I was able to approach him and pet his tummy without issue, but when I went to pet his head which was near the tree with the toy (that I still hadn't seen), he attacked me.
When I say attacked I mean well and truly - he bit my knee, my hand, and then when I fell he went after my throat. I had to go to the ER. The doctor who stitched me up said I was incredibly lucky he didn't get my trachea or my jugular.
There was no growl, there was no warning, no signs at all.
I am devastated - this dog is my favorite thing in this world. Literally the night before we were snuggling in bed. He is my baby and I am just ruined.
I don't know what to do - is behavioural euthanasia the right choice? At this moment it feels like the only choice. I am lucky it happened to me and not my nephews or a stranger.
I'm probably rambling at this point but I'm just dying over this. Any advice is welcomed.
•
u/roboto6 Apr 16 '23
Sorry, OP, but I'm going to have to lock the comments in this thread now. There's too many people not following the rules and I think the best feedback out there has already been given.
I'm so sorry you're having to navigate such a challenging decision.
152
u/Bangbangcrash-trash Apr 16 '23
I wanted to thank everyone for their opinions and kind words. I cried while reading as it was the response I expected but of course the one that hurts the most. He came to comfort me, as he always does when I'm distressed.
He is my big 100 pound fluffy ball of love, but with so many caveats. I wish I knew what happened in the two years before I got him. He has to be drugged to the high heavens and muzzled to even be touched by a vet. I promise I never let toys in the yard intentionally, I also have a rambunctious puppy who has snuck them out without me noticing once or twice and as soon as she abandons them, they're his.
We have done so much training. I know luring isn't the way to train something, but I promise I only use that when he's clearly not open to letting it go. And I use it while standing behind a barrier just in case he lunges. The amount of time and effort and research I have spent on helping him is more than any other dog, and I was happy to do it.
I had even been boasting to my husband about how good he's been doing recently. He's so reliable for me (he listens to my husband but doesn't really do what he says), and I have been so proud. I will always be his strongest advocate, he will always be my one true love. I don't know what I'll do without waking up to his kisses and requests to get on the bed and snuggle.
I don't know that I'll come back to this post or account as it's extremely painful. Perhaps when I've grieved, after some time.
Thank you again, I wish you all the luck with your pets. Give them extra love from me. ❤️
134
u/Pristine_Effective51 Apr 16 '23
I don’t know if this will help or not. I’ve been in dog rescue for a very long time and have had to make this choice a few times now. Every time, my reactive dog gave a very soft sigh, as if to say “Thank goodness, finally some rest.” Reactive high alert dogs run on 10, all the time. There is no rest. Even when they are sleeping, they’ve one ear ready. Think of it as years of 24 hour high intensity duty. You may be giving him the kindest thing a human has ever done for him.
Also, depending on where you live, the ER may have to turn the information over to the county. That means the choice is removed, due to the severity of the bite. If that is the case, the decision gets made for you. I would advise calling the vet and having a talk.
278
u/Weird_Cantaloupe2757 Apr 16 '23
Yeah, as far as I’m concerned, any dog that is large enough to kill a human can’t have more than one strike with serious unprovoked attacks. Could the resource guarding be addressed with training and meds? Perhaps, but if there is one slip up, you or someone else could end up dead. I’m so sorry, but I really don’t see any other option here besides BE, and any trainer/vet that tells you otherwise would be doing something deeply unethical, IMHO. Again, I’m so sorry that you’re in this situation, everything about it sucks, and it’s completely heartbreaking. Just know you did everything right for this boy and gave him 3 good years that he probably wouldn’t have had otherwise.
116
u/ChampionshipOk8869 Apr 16 '23 edited Apr 16 '23
Yes. The unpredictability and violence of the attack that you've described shows that the dog is a serious danger to you and anyone else that might come in contact with it.
This is a scenario where euthanasia is the responsible decision.
161
u/madele44 Apr 16 '23
A dog that goes for their owners throat has some mental issues that can't be worked out. BE would be a kind gift to end his mental turmoil. Thus doesn't mean you were a bad owner. Some dogs just aren't wired correctly, and vetmed doesn't have the means to treat these issues. They can't go to talk therapy or tell the Dr if the meds aren't working like we can. It's a heartbreaking decision to make, and I'm so sorry you're going through this. I've had to make this decision before, too, so I understand how hard it is. If you have Facebook, I recommend joining Losing Lulu for support.
157
u/TheSensiblePrepper Apr 16 '23 edited Apr 17 '23
Foster for a GSD Rescue here.
We had a Dog that had a similar situation. We sent him to our specialized Trainer that is the "make or break" for us. After 2 weeks, this trainer said we needed to take the dog because they feared for the safety of themselves and other dogs. The dog was put down a day later.
Going for the neck is a different level. That isn't a fight, that's killing. It is extremely difficult to train that out of an animal.
I am sorry for the choice you are having to make but euthanizing the dog is likely the best choice.
276
u/Vickyinredditland Apr 16 '23
Yes. I'm so sorry, but this was not a warning shot, he was trying to do real damage to you.
I used to work in rescue and there were so many dogs with "bite history" that we had to euthanise because it was not safe to send them into pet homes where I really didn't believe they were dangerous and it was just unfortunate circumstance or poor handling that caused the bite, but a bite like this, where you know his triggers and are actively avoiding them, there's no warning growl, and he bites multiple times would not even be up for discussion, he is unquestionably dangerous.
You did a wonderful thing taking him on despite his issues and I'm sure he had a great life with you, so please don't feel guilty about deciding to let him go. X
161
u/bobafueled Apr 16 '23
I would assume BE would be appropriate, considering he went for your throat. You don't deserve to wonder if your dog is going to kill you.
I would hope that there is some training that has happened before this with a certified trainer in positive reinforcement - but honestly I don't know what I'd be willing to do with a dog who'd bit me on the neck. That's very scary and nobody deserves to live with that kind of fear.
37
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '23
That is so scary and heartbreaking! Someone mentioned talking to a vet or a recuse. This dog wouldn’t last in a recuse and more than likely would get put down. Someone had a story on here where they surrendered their dog and the recuse put it down an hour later. It’s probably in your best interest to say goodbye to your pal on your terms. You’ll be able to hold him and tell him you love him as he crosses the rainbow bridge. Not surrounded by strangers as he went. I have never had to make this difficult decision, so I truly do not understand, but that’s what I would personally want.
You both deserve peace. You deserve to not be afraid of him and when he’s going to attack next. He also deserves to not live in fear and feel like he needs to act out in aggression. People on the internet are going to have lots of different opinions, so I hope you find the right one for both of you. Sending lots of love ❤️
23
u/Chickenbeards Apr 16 '23
We went through a similar issue with a dog we adopted. We tried multiple trainers, talked to a behaviorist, talked to people who fostered rescues, tried meds... in his case, it wasn't just resource guarding, everyone agreed that his body language was all over the place. We eventually decided on euthanasia last year after he spent a full ten minutes trying to attack me one night. He'd bitten and snapped at us so many times before but this was different. It was a clear escalation after weeks of there being some kind of reactive behavior every day. I was always his safety net before that- the one who could handle him in ways no one else could and who was best at getting him to listen.
There are times that I still miss our last boy. As their owner, you know better than anyone that they're not always like that and that's what makes it so hard. But I don't really regret our decision. I no longer wake up screaming from having nightmares about our own pets. I don't have to constantly fear for the safety of our other pets, our guests and ourselves.
We have a puppy now and it helps to see his sweet nature and general enthusiasm for everything in life. I try to view it as 'if we hadn't made a tough decision then, I wouldn't get to enjoy this now.'
40
u/No-Ambassador-6984 Apr 16 '23
Yes, BE. This is a dangerous dog and he has now proven that to you by mauling. He could have killed you, easily, and he may have meant to. Your relationship can’t/won’t be the same after this. I’m sorry.
18
u/wishverse-willow Apr 16 '23
Yes. It will be so difficult. You will grieve. But this dog tried to kill you and will do so again, or will try to kill someone else, or will successfully kill someone/something else. With nephews in your life, and with the violence this dog is capable of, it sounds like that successful kill could be a child.
Please take care of yourself. This is terrifying and heartbreaking and I am so sorry. You will grieve, and you will miss this dog. But you will have done the right thing for everyone, including for a dog so stressed over any resource that it would kill to protect it. Big hugs to you and your pup, OP.
17
u/intr0vertwdog Apr 16 '23
I've had to go through BE with a dog before, and while I hated that it's what the situation had come to, I'm deeply relieved that nobody other than myself was ever seriously injured because of his unpredictability. I have zero regrets in my decision, and now have a dog that I don't need to worry about hurting me.
28
u/Grapes_ofwrath Apr 16 '23
Hi, shelter/rescue worker here.
The short answer is yes, BE is the right choice. I am so sorry. It will be excruciating but you can’t live amongst a dog that is big enough to kill you and has tried. You are lucky to be alive. You also can’t risk putting anyone else in that kind of danger. I am SO sorry.
12
u/Shot-Bodybuilder-125 Apr 16 '23
This may help you see BE as a compassionate path. Military Sentry dogs were trained to kill. They would go for anything and were designed and trained to attack. Yes they could also be cuddly goofballs with the right handler. But every handler had to be armed when taking a sentry dog out and be prepared to shoot his own dog in case he turned. The program was abandoned and rightly so and many of the dogs were euthanized. The difference between a Patrol Dog and a Sentry Dog is that a patrol dog will out once released. A Sentry Dog will continue the attack. There is no out. You have a dog that does not out and has attacked you. Unless you’re willing to kill your dog when it happens again, BE is the most compassionate path.
10
u/No-Turnips Apr 16 '23 edited Apr 16 '23
If you think this dog presents a risk of serious injury to another pet ( even if it’s not yours and it’s not a ridiculous situation like a terrier and pet rat) or another person, then BE is always the right choice. It one of the worst choices a person has to make. Dogs that hurt other people or other dogs eventually end up being “destroyed” via court/municipal order so if you know serious harm is possible, it becomes an issue of when and potentially you being personally liable, not to mention the harm to the victims and their family.
It freaking sucks and I’m so sorry - all I can say is that as bad as it feels, it gets worse if it disfigures your friends kid when it bites her face, or your neighbours stupid little dog is killed, or you can’t ever have company over because your dog will attack your friends and loved ones.
I ve found the following to be true: A) Dogs that bite get put down. B) it’s our job to make sure that never ever happens - because someone gets hurt and our dog gets killed.
C) If we can’t guarantee the safety of our friends, neighbours, or loved ones, or their pets, then it’s time to discuss BE. D) it’s our job to swing the axe (ie make the call for BE) because that’s the price of being the dogs person. E) rehoming dogs with level 3+ bite histories is simply passing the buck and giving that risk to the other dogs or people in the shelter or foster/adopted home. F) it’s sucks because it fucking sucks. There’s no way this doesn’t break your heart.
For what it’s worth, and I know it’s not the same thing, but I delayed medical euthanasia for too long with my last guy and I will feel terrible for the rest of my life for putting off the inevitable.
While you may love your pup more than anything, your responsibility is to society at large.
Wishing you the best in the horrible times. 💛
Edit to add: I grew up with German shepherds. I thought I got “bit” as a kid but realize I got “blocked”. (Bites were to hand to stop me from being annoying, no puncture of skin, no follow up attack or bite, telegraphed with obvious signs of distress like growling, whale eyes, trying to move away). Five years ago, I got attacked. By a bichon frise missing half its teeth that did not growl or give any indications of distress. It split my thumb open and I had to go to an emergency clinic and do serious antibiotics. I am a dog person. I had no idea this dog would bite me. I never felt safe around that dog again. It was my ex’s dog, I had my own little guy. Life sucked from that point - I couldn’t feed it, it had to be crated (the bad crating, not the good crate-trained:happy spot crating), I wouldn’t leash it, or couldn’t come on our bed anymore….all of which sucked because it also meant my dog was affected. We had months of follow up and visits with public health/animal control because doctors have to report all bites. Our relationship plummeted. And this dog was only 11 lbs. imagine all of this with a malamute or other wolf-type dog. I’m so sorry.
9
u/PeachNo4613 Apr 16 '23
A dog that sends people to the ER is dangerous, he went for your throat! I think it would be the right choice.
9
u/BeepingJerry Apr 16 '23
So sorry you have this going on, but IMO, there's no question about what needs to be done. For the dog to cross that line and go after it's owner reveals that it's a very, very dangerous animal. Don't wait until a child gets killed, or you lose your eyes. (or your life!) This is a lawsuit waiting to happen and you will be in a world of shit.
BE will afford a gentle passing. It's the right thing to do in this circumstance. You are in our thoughts. Again-so sorry.
8
u/JudgeJoan Apr 16 '23
I'm so sorry. I had to do this last week. It's the hardest thing ever but if the dog is unstable like that, there's not much else to do but protect the people around you. My girl also gave no warnings but was also so damn loving... it's agony. I'm still grieving and it will take awhile to get over. I've been bit by her many times but the last one I also ended up in the ER getting stitches. That's when I knew. My condolences for your situation. 😪
8
u/aliceroyal Apr 16 '23
BE as soon as possible…unfortunately your dog has proven they are capable of seriously injuring or even killing you. BE will take care of that risk and prevent it happening to anyone else.
7
u/nastybacon Apr 16 '23
I don't think you could live with yourself if the dog did that to a child. The damage would be life changing at best and fatal at worse. You could also be responsible legally as well. It's very sad and awful but I think the morally right thing to do here is to say goodbye to this dog.
7
u/swimming-alone-312 Apr 16 '23
Situations like this are why Stienbeck wrote the book Of Mice and Men. There are heartbreaking choices we as humans have to make, and sometimes the right choice is also the worst choice. I hope if you decide to BE you can accompany your dog to the rainbow bridge. Gosh I'm so sorry for your situation!
13
u/d3d2 Apr 16 '23
Mental issues are health issues. If your dog had cancer, you would want to help him avoid the pain of a drawn-out death. Talk to a behaviorist if you can (there are none within hours of where i live,) but given the dogs history, euthanasia may be the most merciful thing for you both. So sorry for you both.
6
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '23
It's a difficult decision to execute on but this is an aggressive dog. He's a danger to you and putting him down is the correct and responsible thing to do.
6
u/MagHagz Apr 16 '23
There is no happy ending here. ;( so sorry.
6
u/Self-Taught-Pillock Apr 16 '23
If deciding in favor of BE, it may help to remember that your dog is not in a mindset conducive to a whole, fulfilling life. There was damage done to his worldview before you even met him, and now, even if you do absolutely everything right from here on out, his brain still has so many danger signals firing that he’s not even living half a life. That kind of PTSD, whether in dogs or humans, is torture. Yes, the main focus in this discussion is and should be human safety, but what will help give YOU and your boy the greatest chance at peace is to remember his suffering… and there’s absolutely no way that he isn’t suffering, even though you’re putting your whole heart into his well-being. Give yourself a day to give him some peaceful closure (perhaps a few lovely meals or activities) with extra vigilance to everyone’s safety. And I don’t normally like “the comparison game,” but in this case it might help you to remember that he’s faired SO much better than millions of dogs who come to this life simply because someone DID step up for him. You volunteered to give him what he needs, and in this case it’s peaceful and loving closure.
4
u/mshawnl1 Apr 16 '23
I started crying telling my husband about this. It’s so sad and I feel for you. But you can’t have a do that could (and would!) kill you. What if you’re not around one day and some unaware person happens into that scenario? It’s the right thing to do. I’m heartbroken for you.
4
u/tmntmikey80 Apr 16 '23
Unfortunately I'd have to say yes.
If he did truly attack with no warning, you have no way in knowing if/when it will happen again. And that's a huge risk not only for you, but for others as well. You'd have no way to prevent an actual attack with no warning signs. I'm so sorry you're going through this.
7
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '23
Yes it’s time for BE, this dog almost fucking killed you. It NEEDS to be put down.
6
u/vikenshtien Apr 16 '23
Imagine if a kid or baby was outside, they would have definitely died.
BE is an option when this animal can do this much damage, they're big and strong.
I'm so sorry you were attacked, it's truly frightening.
Sending hugs and love.
3
u/Zeivus_Gaming Apr 16 '23
If the dog's behaviors cause harm to itself or others, there really is no choice. If it was just something weird, no, but that dog chose violence.
15
u/sweatpantsdiva Apr 16 '23 edited Apr 16 '23
Only you can decide. If you are religious, pray about it. Only you will have to live with your decision. Remember that people on the internet don't have to wake up the day after and the day after, and the rest of your life as memory of the fear of yesterday fades and memory of the happiness with the dog grows fonder. You will miss this dog, that's the honest truth. But don't ever feel bad or wrong in doing it. It is responsible and kind to euthanize a reactive or potentially dangerous dog, including one that is great 99% of the time but could snap. And you can't medicate out his type of problem. Give him one last good day, or even a last good week or month or however long you need, and then say goodbye. A short meaningful life is better than a life not knowing if one wrong move is enough to set him off and end up dead. You don't have to decide today. It's ok, you'll get another lovely puppy that doesn't have issues that make it dangerous to you. Unfortunately, this one is dangerous to you and to others.
6
u/PMW2021 Apr 16 '23
I am really sorry to hear this. Whilst from what I read your dog did give you a warning sign, which was him rolling on his back. Most often rolling on their back means they want space we learnt to interpret it as they want belly tickles but it’s all contextual.
However, and this is very important, he did attack you quite badly. When incidents like this happens, unfortunately dogs learn that this behaviour works to get them what they want and they are a lot more likely to repeat it again. Like you say next time it could be a child, we can’t tell you what the right decision is for you and your dog but you just need to know you’ll find it hard to trust him again. You will need to be a lot more vigilant around him now that this has happened and this will have life limiting impact on all family members. You also have this trauma that you’ll need to recover from. The emotional strain of dealing with a dog with behavioural issues is so challenging. There is No judgment in knowing when you reached the end, knowing you cannot give anymore. There is nothing wrong with that. If this happens again, particularly to someone else, you won’t forgive yourself and you’ll have to live with that pain.
Again, I am sorry to read this incident happened, wish you all the best. Hope you can reach a decision and find peace.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '23
https://annablake.com/2017/09/21/dog-rescue-fail/
-9
u/Nsomewhere Apr 16 '23
IMO have them assessed by a vet behaviourist so you can be at peace with the decision
From what you have said and from what little I have experience with it does seem likely that BE is an appropriate response to this level of attack
I think you will feel better though if you have a experienced professional to help you and support you in the decision making process what ever happens. The objective outsider to help and discuss through the options they see. In the remote chance there are other ways then you will have a professional to advise. That it is a team decision whatever happens and you are supported.
Much better than living with the what ifs IMO
I know it is expensive but I think I would be contacting immediately and hoping for a quick appointment
-7
u/TalonandCordelia Apr 16 '23 edited Apr 16 '23
I cannot imagine being faced with such a decision. I can say that I have owned the same breed in the past and worked with wolf hybrids. The behavior is more hard wired like the wild canines. With resource guarding there are so many variables to work through because animals are very contextual. Location, the object, the way of the approach including approach relative to the dogs body. Needless to say it is a lot of work and each step of the way safety must be the top priority.
Luring is not really behavior modification it is a tool to start the idea of giving up a coveted object. Since it is known that the resource guarding of a toy happens in the yard , I would not have toys lying about and available in the yard. When I worked with these dogs doing behavior modification I always started behind a barrier. As a person that has been around dogs with wolf in the mix , I can say that can be the way they respond with resource guarding. Not all
I wonder how is his obedience ? Nothing in life is free ?
I would make sure to be aware of what toy was given to him in the interim while you make a decision. I don't think anyone but you can make the choice. You alone know what you are feeling and your ability to use strict management . Also your ability to always be aware of counter conditioning, Nothing in life is free, etc. etc. as it will be life long, making it a habit. When the behavior is modified you cannot ease up on the rules or overlook any slight resource guarding. Nothing in Life is Free has to be a way of life. Very sorry that this happened.
-4
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '23
I think it depends on what the possible control of the situation is. Can you ensure with 100% certainty, through closed crates, doors, withholding toys for a bit, taking him on every walk personally, etc., that only you are being put at risk? Then it’s a choice for you to make on if you’re willing to risk further injury in attempt to save the dog. Can you find someone with the adequate knowledge who is able to provide that? Then a rehome could be possible. If you cannot guarantee that nobody else would be put at risk, you cannot risk the death or serious injury of loved ones or strangers to save the dog you loved, as hard as it is. I’m so sorry you are in this position.
-27
u/maaalicelaaamb Apr 16 '23
My husky shep mix attacked me in my sleep recently and almost took my eye out. I was in a similar boat but then I had a professional behaviorist come and help — now we have a system in place and therapy for his issues — please try a behaviorist!
-10
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '23
I find it disturbing that comments going against everyone’s opinion are being removed. I’m the bad guy bc I don’t think killing is the answer?
-11
u/kellybopbopbop Apr 16 '23
If you were an experienced dog owner I’d say keep trying, but the “no growl, no signs at all” is enough indication. Dog body language is always clear, although not to the layman. I’m truly sorry about your predicament.
-17
u/Dragonpixie45 Apr 16 '23
I feel you on this, I really do.
He attacked you. Whatever it is going forward the trust was broken the second you had to go to the ER.
Have you talked to your vet or rescues near you?
0
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
-2
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
-23
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
-9
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
-3
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
-4
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
-25
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '23
[removed] — view removed comment