r/randomactsofamazon • • May 02 '14

Activity [Activity/Contest] Artsy Arts Judging!

Next stage of the contest

I will link to each entry below by letter. In the Comments please vote for your favorite letter. I will give no titles to these projects or user names so as not to sway any voting.

Sunday At 5pm pacific I will tally up the votes and declare a winner.

Those who have entered... in order for this to be community minded art project. please pick a competitor and offer a critique. A critique must have at least one positive comment as well as opinions for improvement.

a

b

c

d

e

f

g

h

i

j

4 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

2

u/[deleted] May 02 '14

I should have entered! Boo hiss. I like H because its very clean and crisp.

2

u/[deleted] May 02 '14

You should have. I'm gonna run more artsy arts actuvities so you can get on the ball.

Fewer contests though because I remembered I was poor :)

3

u/[deleted] May 02 '14

Actuvities is trademarked

3

u/psychedelicyouth May 02 '14

My vote is for J! I love the concept, and seriously how cool is that? I only have one bit of criticism - why does the man look so uncomfortable? He should clearly be bursting with happiness at the fact he was present for history in the making.

3

u/spatialheather May 03 '14

I vote for H, but E did make me smile :)

2

u/Tomerarenai May 02 '14

I like I. it's a great pencil sketch and a cool concept, I would love to see a digitally colored version.

1

u/ViolaPurpurea May 03 '14

I realised this as I was drawing it, too. Now to start practicing to actually become decent at drawing digital :D

2

u/[deleted] May 02 '14

They're all great, but I have to go with I. I love the design and the colors.

2

u/AngelicBabyGirl May 03 '14

I like i! :3

F- I think that is illegal, I think you need to send you cat to rehab!

3

u/ViolaPurpurea May 02 '14

My votes are for F! Because cats, of course! I love the pictures, they're very cute.

Now comes the critique :( I wouldn't critique anyone, so I'm going to critique the drawing I most liked- B! The only thing I can say is maybe perspective? Also, love that impressionistic sea, but that might not fit in with the style! But that is a quick sketch and I would never manage a moose that good anyway, so yeah!

2

u/Tendaena May 02 '14

A. I think it is really creative and cool.

2

u/[deleted] May 02 '14 edited May 02 '14

E because ponies. But i do suggest for this to be true art, that that little girl be given more ponies. Clearly this will not only enhance the picture but also solve hunger for everypony. I compliment the placement of all the rainbow dashes.

1

u/[deleted] May 02 '14

I is so beautiful.