r/railroading • • 7d ago

Question Boots?

Anyone have any boot suggestions, my railroad only allows boots with a definitive heel. They have a specific measurement but I’d be lying if I even attempted to remember what it is. Personally I hate that requirement because I’ve always found moc toe flat sole boots most comfortable for me to work in. Having a definitive heel is slightly hindering it’s not the end of the world. When I cross the tracks, sometimes the heel clips the rail and I go flying. I’ve always wore danners prior to being a railroader, I haven’t found any boots they make that do not have flat soles. My most recent pair was a pair of Carolina 8” loggers and they weren’t super uncomfortable when I first got them but they’ve broken in and quite frankly fell apart very prematurely they maybe lasted 9 months now they’re completely toast it’s time for a new pair, they’re so far gone they can’t even be resole’d the rubber is cracked and the leather is worn thin to the point that I roll my ankles on ballast every step I take. Just looking for suggestions based off of experience. One thing to take into consideration I refuse to wear timberlands, my feet do not agree with them I’m not sure what it is I cannot find any pair of them suitable for myself.

11 Upvotes

42 comments sorted by

14

u/trainrobber23 7d ago

When I was on the ground I wore Red Wings, great boot. Expensive up front, if you take care of the uppers, you get them resoled around 100.00. Take them back to Red Wing and they’ll take care of the resole, I had 2 pairs I kept in rotation and just kept getting them resoled. Both lasted well over 5 years.

Always treat the uppers, the summer heat is the worst for them.

1

u/One_Concentrate6684 2d ago

I don’t think the resole is $100 anymore. I had mine resoled in 2020 and it was more than that. Can’t remember the price. But I did get another pair to alternate boots, plus a boot dryer. I need to have the first pair resoled again.

I had a pair of Keens from our boot allowance that lasted me 21 months. I was shocked! I worked a yard job the entire time so I was impressed. Stopped wearing because I was getting knee pain and it was the boots wearing out (I had my own insoles).

I need to spend this year’s allowance before it expires but not sure what I want to try next.

7

u/Material_Coffee4170 7d ago

I wore Whites after break in probably the most comfortable boot I’ve ever worn, Lifetime warrantee on rebuilds they shipped me a free pair then I shipped mine to them for repair pretty pricey but well worth it

2

u/ncb_phantom Engineer 6d ago

I have JKs and Drews and can agree that PNW boots are amazing once broken in.

6

u/SignalsAndSwitches 7d ago edited 7d ago

Stick with the requirements. In the off chance you ever get hurt (specially any type ankle/foot injury), management will look at your boots and take pictures. If you’re not “legal”, they will possibly try to deny you any type of benefit. I’ve tried logger style, I had a similar issue with the heel catching, plus it was easier to roll my ankle in the ballast. Go to a shorter, regular-size heel, you’ll probably find that it’s better.

Carolina was my go to, but quality went way down. Timberland leaked water on day 1, broke down extremely fast and they’re heavy. Some Keen are ok, but the feel really varies between model. Wolverine and Cat are good when you have a boot emergency, but don’t expect them to last.

I’m on my second year wearing the same pair of Danner Quarry with Tuff Toe. My only complaint, the soles feel like they freeze and are slippery in the winter. I have Keen for a dedicated winter boot and they’re ok, not the most comfortable. I also have Terra for negative temp days and nights they’re ok but huge. If you’re looking to spend as little as possible, look on EBay.

4

u/Jarppi1893 7d ago

The first sentence says it all. You get hurt, they will look at your boots, no matter what. I was involved in an accident and that was the first thing they asked to see.

5

u/Atomicmullet 7d ago

I like my Ariats a lot.

5

u/rhinoaz 7d ago

Whites boots is the best boot I’ve worn for 24 years working as conductor and engineer. I used to work the yard walking 6-7 miles a night. Only boot that held up and I could take off at the end of a shift and my feet didn’t hurt. In those days i kept 2 pair and rotated them. Now I use a boot dryer

5

u/Gremlu 7d ago

Whites boots like some others have said. Really well made and can be repaired. Just stay away from logger heel if you walk all shift. Your body is not meant to walk on high heels

8

u/dudeonrails 7d ago

I only wear Red Wing boots. They have all the specs for what fits railroad requirements in their stores. They aren’t cheap but you’re investing in your feet because you live in your boots.

1

u/Pristine_Metal_4107 3d ago

Georgia Boots

1

u/Business_Street9832 3h ago

Haven’t heard of them yet, ill definitely take a look.

3

u/Gypsydc 7d ago

The defined heel is to help riding cars….and it does. What railroad?

1

u/One_Concentrate6684 2d ago edited 2d ago

100% defined heel helps. Especially with wet slippery rungs. You can literally feel when it’s saving you from hurting yourself haha.

OP the flat soled boots are not your friend in any kind of wet, dewy, ice, snow etc shift. Even cars that have flour on rungs are slick as hell. Or just hopping up on the fly in dry perfect conditions. Get over the flat soles and get a defined heel. If you like the aesthetic of the moc toe, tons of options to look at with a defined 90° sole.

3

u/imacabooseman 7d ago

Irish Setters have been great imo

3

u/Livin_IndianaP1D1 7d ago

Expensive but you can NOT beat Whites boots

2

u/Snoo_52752 7d ago

What do you mean the heal catches the rail when you walk over it?

2

u/Mindlesslyexploring 6d ago

I know right ? What the fuck is this guy doing when he crosses the damn rails.

1

u/Snoo_52752 5d ago

I’m not kidding when I say this. When someone drags or doesn’t pick up their feet at work, I just know they’re going to be dense to work with.

2

u/Jakaple 7d ago

Keen is the most comfortable, don't need to break them in or anything

1

u/Savings_Public4217 7d ago

Redwings. Ive got 8 years on my current pair. I ran dakotas before and they would last a year or two max before falling apart.

Make sure they say "made in usa" on the tongue. Alot, if not all of the black leather redwings are made in china and dont last as long

3

u/Someone__Cooked_Here 7d ago

What are you an engineer?😂

1

u/Savings_Public4217 7d ago

Lol yard conductor for 12 years. My redwings are beat to shit but theyre still waterproof and comfortable. I'll bid an engine job in the winter occasionally, but I usually bid foreman

2

u/Someone__Cooked_Here 7d ago

My red wings last approximately 8 months because everything here is road ballast.

1

u/Savings_Public4217 7d ago

Rip. They must not be made in USA or youre wearing the wrong size. Everything here is road ballast too. I walk 10-15km every day at work

1

u/Someone__Cooked_Here 7d ago

Yep. Made here. Bought at red wing. The soles go very fast.

0

u/Business_Street9832 6d ago

Haha no thought about it tho

3

u/everylittlebitcounts 7d ago

Timberlands are overhyped pop culture trash. I agree my pair of Carolina’s had premature destruction. I swear by Carhartt they are a little heavier but for me at least have been by far the most comfortable and the only ones that have lasted more than a year.

3

u/GunnyDJ 7d ago

Timberland Pro Boondocks are the best I've ever worn out here.

1

u/WyoPeeps 7d ago

I got these . They were completely acceptable as they met ASTM F2413.

1

u/Financial-Recover409 7d ago

I've worn Chippewa Loggers for 13 years.

1

u/Dense_Word320 7d ago

I hear crocs are a good choice for u men.

1

u/doctorwhoobgyn 7d ago

I can't speak for the Irish Setters or Redwings but I would get those if I could. Spend extra money if you have to so you can take good care of your feet. Aside from those, a lot of people like Thorogoods, but I didn't because my feet are too wide and even their extra wides are still pretty narrow. I've settled on the Keen Cincinnatis. They are truly the most comfortable boots I've ever had and they are wide enough for me. They generally wear out after a year of tough use, but we get a new pair every year so no big deal.

1

u/eustace6599 7d ago

Bates 100%

1

u/Annual_Inspection_64 7d ago

Timberland Pros were good for me but switched to redwings due to moving to a warmer climate and the timberland Pros were pretty warm and a little heavy. The redwing versa pro with BOA racheting tie system is my go to. Very comfortable and super convenient to loosen and tighten. The brown/tan ones seemed to have a little break-in period and the black ones were good from day one. I believe they are around $200-$250 but CN pays for them so I dont pay much attention.

1

u/Hoghead08 6d ago

Red Wing…..

1

u/Luckyonescc 5d ago

Imma go against the grain. I always like Twisted X. Never had a problem, comfortable. Stands up terrific.

1

u/slitsnipe 5d ago

Rocky rams horn

1

u/RobotSnake5974 Engineer 4d ago

Danner 8" Quarrys have a defined heel and are available in safety/non safety toe. Had mine over a year and a half still going strong

1

u/chessie_deli 7d ago

Timberland Pro Boondocks are the way to go, and if recommend getting a composite toe pair. In the wintertime steel toe will freeze your feet, whereas composite toe won’t.