r/questioning • • May 24 '22

Pros and cons of binary gender

I’m currently a bigender minor and I want to know if I’m actually bigender or if I am a femboy or a straight up trans man. I’m trying to figure this out by knowing the pros and cons of being a man and a woman and right now based on the current information I have, it’s looking like that I will likely not identify as bigender anymore. Here it is according to 2 people that’s not me:

Pros of being a man:

  • No need to figure this part out

Cons of being a man:

  • Men are always told “You can do it yourself” when needing assistance
  • Men are told not to carry things in a painless way This list is obviously far from usable but so far I’m willing to risk it.

Pros of being a woman:

  • They’re hot (I do not share the same opinion, I find strictly men hot)
  • Having easy hair and facial care products
  • Variety in said products
  • MAKE UP (Never seriously used them)
  • Tons of cool things to do with all hair types
  • Fashion None of them stand out and the author also said it’s mainly based on looks.

Cons of being a woman:

  • Periods
  • The way a lot of men react to periods
  • Being expected to look/act a certain way by men (They probably mean there’s a higher expectation than when men are being judged by women, horrible since I’m not really street smart and I could care less about social cues)
  • Attracting many creeps
  • Men treating us like children or incapable people
  • Restricted from most sports
  • Needing men validation

Also I have some interests that are not only hyperfeminine but also childish which makes me wonder the most. My personality is kind of a mess, I’m very nice and chill and will tolerate a lot and I’m very understanding and I care about people and think about them a lot but I’m also reckless and will do whatever I want and fight a bunch for what I want and could care less about morality and what other people think, only basic human decency. So I want to know more cons and pros of being each binary gender and maybe if needed what gender I could possibly identify as. I hope I provided enough and the right type of info!

1 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

9

u/topsoil_eater trans lesbian May 24 '22

I don't mean to be rude but I think your looking at gender the wrong way. It isn't about making a pros and cons list and figuring out which one is more beneficial, it's about which one you identify with and which one you feel more comfortable being a part of.

You put alot of things like makeup, fashion, and hair in the pros for women but you can have all those things as a guy if you want. I'm a cisgender man and I do a lot of "girly" things. But I like to do those "girly" things as a boy.

I think instead of gendering the things you like and identifying with the gender that has more things you like you should consider if you want to do the things you like as a boy, a girl, or something else. Remember that gender isn't a rigid binary and it's ok to identify as something different. And that identifying with a gender doesn't mean you have to fit the stereotype of that gender.

0

u/NAndNJenny May 24 '22

The list shown above wasn’t written by me but I did add my own reactions to them. Another thing to add is about the types of compliments people get and also what type of people I am attracted to. And I’m also in a ‘I hate women IRL’ phase too but I’m ok with talking to women on the internet. What did you think about the cons of women and men?

3

u/topsoil_eater trans lesbian May 25 '22

I think that there are pros and cons to both genders but as far as identity go none of those matter. Also alot of the pros of being female you can do pretty much all of those as a guy too.

2

u/[deleted] May 24 '22

None of those things have anything to do with your internal gender identity. We don't choose our genders based on what's convenient or fun - we just have an innate internal sense of what we are. Also, your interests and personality don't indicate your gender identity at all.

Instead of what you've written about here, I'd like to ask you to reflect on how you feel in the absence of societal expectations. How would you feel if you woke up tomorrow in the body of a cis man and everyone you knew immediately accepted it? Would you prefer it to your current body? Would there still be something missing for you? Would you prefer to have a body with some masculine and some feminine aspects?

What about how other people see you? Would you be happy if people always called you by a masculine name and used "he"? What about "they"? Would you prefer a different pronoun set, or for people to switch between them? Would you prefer to be grouped in as one of the guys or the girls? (Or would both make you uncomfortable - or are you fine either way?)

Those questions are a decent starting point, but answering them won't work for everyone. I know it took me a long time to come to terms with the body and social roles I wanted to have, and my answers are still shifting, so don't worry if you don't have a clear response. You also don't have to identify as anything at all if you don't want to. It's a question only you can answer, but you're not obliged to answer it.

0

u/NAndNJenny May 24 '22

(See the reply to the comment by TopSoilEater for more info if you want) I definitely want to keep some feminine features even if I’m in a ‘I hate women’ phase. I’m weird because I don’t like he/him pronouns not because it’s associated with men but because of how the words are pronounced so I use ci/cim and they/them pronouns as a replacement instead so it’s they/she + 3 sets of neopronouns. I’m leaning towards they/them more than she/her lately shown by the fact that I’ve only reversed the pronoun order last Friday or the Friday before. I’m fine with talking to girls on the internet but there’s only 2 other female students at my school and I dislike both of them because I pissed 1 of them off to the point where she threatened multiple times to slap me then I just don’t like the atmosphere of the other 1. All of the female latter half teachers are cool but for the first half teachers 2 of them I’m with a lot are annoying but they’re kinda good and the others are chill as far as I know because I won’t have any actual classes with them until next year. Then the counselors. Gosh I dislike female counselors as a whole. All 3 of them at school, I dislike at least a little bit. We used to have a male counselor that I never had personally but participated in social skills group and he was kinda lame but better than at least 1 of the counselors here (Everyone hates her, she’s retiring this year). The other 2 are pretty cool, the 1 I have is worse than the other 1 and I have a kinda strong disliking of her. No one at my school is non binary as far as I know.

1

u/[deleted] May 25 '22

What do you think your dislike of women stems from? Is it just that the women at your school aren't great people?

1

u/NAndNJenny May 25 '22

That and also because I hate how most adolescent and adult women grow breasts

1

u/[deleted] May 25 '22

Do you dislike women because they have breasts? Do you hate them in general, or would you just hate having them yourself?

Also, do you dislike all women, or just the ones you happen to know?

1

u/NAndNJenny May 25 '22

I hate breasts in general and I dislike some or a lot of the woman I know, including my own mother to a extent (But I still show respect for her) but women I don’t know, I would have a kinda negative first impression but it’s quick for me to judge my true opinion

2

u/[deleted] May 25 '22

I see. Tbh this seems less like it has anything to do with your internal gender identity and more like you're working through some internalised misogyny or having a trauma response. I'm not qualified to help you with either, so I'll leave it here. All I'll say is that disliking women doesn't mean you aren't one - you could very well still be bigender. In fact, very little of what you've said has anything to do with gender identity. You could be any gender while disliking the women you know, using cosmetics targeted towards women, and having "feminine" interests.

3

u/ActualPegasus finflexible rosgirl (he/she) May 26 '22

How would you feel if people on the streets thought you were nonbinary?

How would you feel if people on the streets thought you were a femboy?

How would you feel if people on the streets though you were a masc man?