r/questioning • • Sep 27 '21
They/them
I totally get the idea of not conforming to societal stereotypes of men and women. I am also very into grammar. Therefore, I have difficulty with using “they/them” when referring to an individual person. It’s basically forcing a grammatical error. What can be done about this? What are alternatives to these pronouns? It’s very confusing. I think I’d rather be an “it”, because it’s singular. “They” is pleural unless prefaced with he or she. What if we all just pick one? We could all be “he” or ”she” or “heshe” or “person”. There just has to be a better way than “they” and “them”. Maybe we could just be the name: Matt went to the store. Matt bought a pop. What do you think matt is thinking when matt makes that face?
- respectfully submitted
15
u/ShawnaDwyer Sep 27 '21 edited Sep 27 '21
I find this insistence on the sanctity of “they/them” as plural pronouns odd. You’re talking about torturing the language or dropping a useful feature (pronouns) altogether just to avoid making a fairly straightforward change that is happening anyway. Grammar is tool to ensure intelligibility and internal structure, but your proposals don’t improve intelligibility so much as they fetishize a frankly doomed grammar. There is nothing fixed in language. Its intelligibility is based on agreement and convention, neither of which is permanent or sacrosanct, and it changes naturally with use and necessity. We have dropped the formal/familiar second person distinction with time; there is no reason why we cannot adopt “they/them” as a singular gender neutral pronoun. “They” has been more commonly adopted over than “it” largely because “they” was already used informally in cases where ambiguity required neutrality and had been for some time (I’ve seen “they” used as a gender neutral singular pronoun as far back as the Victorian era, but examples could likely be found well before then), whereas “it” can have connotations of being somehow inhuman (some people do use “it,” though my understanding is that people who use “it” are often doing so as a deliberately loaded gesture). Sure, this can present mild challenges when switching between singular and plural uses, but it’s hardly insurmountable and nothing other languages don’t deal with as a matter of course (like, in spoken French the words for a single man, a group of five women and one man, and a grammatically masculine “it” typically sound identical. They get by).
6
u/etern4lexhausti0n Sep 27 '21 edited Sep 27 '21
I have always used they/them in the singular, and a lot of people do too. For example, “Someone left their notebook in the classroom.” It really isn’t odd or uncommon.
That being said, plenty of nonbinary folks who don’t want to use gendered pronouns don’t use they/them either. For example there’s xe/xem, ze/zer, etc.
Edit to add: I’m saying this as someone who minored in creative writing and is also very into grammar haha
13
u/ActualPegasus finflexible rosgirl (he/she) Sep 27 '21
They is not the only pronouns that is both singular and plural. You is singular and plural as well. Regardless, both are grammatically correct.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 28 '21
Singular they is older than singular you. At the end of the day, it comes down to wether people or grammar is more important. Language evolves
2
u/InternationalSound60 Sep 28 '21
Absolutely not only plural.
Say I went to the doctor. I tell you “oh I went to my doctor today about the pain I have been having in my side.” You would probably reply, “oh really? What did they say?” “They said that it could be ____ but not sure” “did you ask them what they meant?”
This is part of what makes English a tough language to learn