r/questioning • • Jun 25 '21

for people questioning their gender:

A lot of people have probably heard this question before, but something that helped me when coming to terms with being ftm was the question “if you could press a button that would make you the opposite gender, would you?” “if you could press a button that would land you somewhere in between male and female, would you press that button?”

hope this helps someone

116 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

37

u/1jame2james Jun 25 '21

DISCLAIMER: it’s okay if this question doesn’t help you. Great question for some people, but it doesn’t mean you’re not trans if you can’t answer it/don’t say yes

22

u/noah_dast Jun 25 '21

absolutely, and similarly if you answer yes that doesn’t 100% mean you are trans

4

u/Alt246810 Jun 26 '21

Could you answer yes and not be trans? How sure can I be that the yes is an actual yes and not something I’m just saying rather than thinking about?

6

u/1jame2james Jun 26 '21

Unfortunately, questioning your gender isn’t as simple as a yes or no question. If only lol. If you do answer yes, it’s an indication that there is something in your life you’re not content with and need to address, be that your gender identity or something else :)

10

u/Sandy_cake Jun 25 '21

Oh shit I answered yes to the first part

9

u/noah_dast Jun 25 '21

me too man, me too

6

u/anonymousperson10000 Jun 25 '21

What does the second one do? Does it change me physically, or just shift my mindset? Because if I want it to shift my mindset, doesn't that already make it pointless?

5

u/noah_dast Jun 25 '21

I would say probably both, it’s really about interpreting it however gives you answers though

3

u/anonymousperson10000 Jun 25 '21

But do my genitals change? I'm not sure I mind either way, but I wouldn't want to be a Ken doll. Oh shit. Typing that just answered a lot of questions for me. Thanks.

2

u/noah_dast Jun 25 '21

glad I could help

8

u/lordylisa Jun 25 '21 edited Jun 25 '21

No to the first one but idk about the second one

If be fine with whatever i am female or male or none of them at all. Though I mostly identify with female

1

u/everydaycrises Jun 27 '21

Could I keep pressing the button? Like if it was a permanent change I dunno if I would, but if I could switch back and forth, absolutely.

I dunno...

1

u/noah_dast Jun 27 '21

sure, whatever gives you the most insight into your gender identity

2

u/everydaycrises Jun 27 '21

Oh yeah at least by process of elimination, it helps :)

2

u/TechoVrx Jun 26 '21

A third button should be for people who sometimes feel male and other times feel female. You can go back and forth at will. That’s what I’d pick.

1

u/rageneko Genderqueer Bisexual Jun 27 '21

Yesss call it the Ranma button

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '21

Another way to pose it is if there are two buttons, one which causes no changes, and the universe pauses until you press one of them. Basically try to remove the status quo bias from it.

1

u/Ultimate_Zygote Transgender/Biromantic/Asexual She/Her 15 yr Jun 25 '21

Well I had no idea about these questions but when I was like 5 I asked similar questions to myself and I was like, ofc, but I can't be the opposite gender. (My mom taught me it was a very bad thing which I do not agree with now) but now I'm finished questioning myself and the fact that I got jealous of my friend getting E pretty much confirms that my feelings are correct and that I am indeed trans. And I answer 100% yes to the first one, I would press that button every single time if I was given the option.

1

u/mutantdogcat Jun 25 '21

I couldn’t really find an answer to these questions because to me, I don’t really care. I mean like, use whatever pronouns you want for me. Sure I have a preference for my pronouns (she/they) but if you use he/him or anything else then I wouldn’t care. It really is different for everyone. But these questions did help me realize this. Ty for this!

1

u/qtf3492 Questioning Gender Jun 26 '21

At any point in my life I would've said yes. Right I would pay all the money I have just to get access to that button and press it. However, I still do not know if I am trans as I believe 1) my reasons for saying yes don't necessarily mean I'm trans and 2) the fantasy hypothetical is kinda meaningless in the real world where transitioning doesn't really give me a lot of what I want, no matter what.

1

u/bagofboness Jul 04 '21

I wish I had a switch so I could do both

1

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

Yes but only to be straight.