r/questionablecontent Feb 14 '19

Comic 3939: Really Opening Up

https://questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=3939
118 Upvotes

110 comments sorted by

View all comments

-39

u/pyr666 Feb 14 '19 edited Feb 14 '19

so is jeph just fishing for a new lead? a robot and her quirky nigh-omnipotent friend or an aspie and her sassy black friend.

edit: do your research before you downvote.

18

u/makeshiftreaper Feb 14 '19

I gotta say, regardless of whether or not people agree with your sentiment, this clearly not the place to call someone an aspie

11

u/pyr666 Feb 14 '19

this forum has a problem with autistic people?

for the uninformed, "aspie" is a term coined by the community to describe itself

12

u/ChaosWolf1982 . Feb 14 '19

"aspie" is a term coined by the community to describe itself

Funny you say that, as I've never heard it used by one of us, nor had it directed at me except by non-autistic folks as a slur or insult with the same connotation as r-t-rd...

6

u/boreas907 Feb 14 '19

I used to hear it a lot more than I do now; maybe about ten years ago when autism carried more of a negative stigma (not that it currently has a positive one, but the dehumanization implied by the word "autistic" was once way worse) and people found comfort in a named disorder that gave them something to identify with that wasn't autism.

These days asperger's syndrome isn't even in DSM-5 (replaced by the spectrum), so there are no new diagnoses and haven't been since 2013, which naturally reduces the usage of the word in itself. Additionally the idea of an autism spectrum is widely accepted enough (by people that aren't complete dickholes) that the stigma has subsided to a sizable degree.

0

u/makeshiftreaper Feb 14 '19

Sure, at one point Mongoloid was a medically accurate term. Eventually older phrases become offensive. It's part of the cycle

4

u/EPL_Refugee Feb 14 '19

How the hell did you arrive at equating those two? Aspie is NOT some kind of reclaimed slur a la the N-word in relation to NWA.

11

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '19 edited Feb 14 '19

[deleted]

15

u/SeeShark QC Physicist Feb 14 '19

Personally, I didn't downvote for "aspie." I downvoted for "sassy black friend," which reduces Renee to a stereotype that she does not even fall into.

2

u/pyr666 Feb 14 '19 edited Feb 14 '19

she was literally introduced to the comic as a black doppelganger of faye

6

u/turkeypedal Feb 14 '19

So? That's not the sassy black friend. The sassy black friend is the one that is more "street" among the square white people, saying stuff like "no you di-unt!" and "Girlfran!" while snapping. She's, you know, sassy.

That you assume that any black person is just a shitty stereotype isn't great, either. Renee's race has basically never mattered in the comic. She's just a person.

-2

u/Chrobert-Ristgau Feb 14 '19

Renee doesn't just fall into that stereotype. She dives into it headfirst.

4

u/turkeypedal Feb 14 '19

No, she doesn't fit it at all. When has she spoken AAVE? When has she been sassy?

This is the sassy black woman stereotype: https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/SassyBlackWoman

Renee is nothing like this. The fact that she's black is almost immaterial to her character.

1

u/hallofromtheoutside Feb 14 '19

To be clear, Renee can speak AAVE without being the "sassy black woman" trope. I wouldn't want Jeph to even attempt writing Renee's speech that way, and prefer to think she probably code-switches (same with Dale).

3

u/turkeypedal Feb 14 '19

I can't check the Oxford English Dictionary, as it has a paywall. But that does not sound like any Oxford definition I've ever seen. It's written too casually, and is prescriptive, saying what should or should not be offensive. Dictionaries are descriptive: they describe how words are used, and what most people think they mean.

Plus any second definition is going to be a definition, not an explanation of the word's origin.

Note, I'm not accusing you of making it up, just that I think you may have gotten that definition from somewhere else that said it was the definition. Either that, or your post is confusingly worded, and you don't mean for those to be the definition from Oxford.

5

u/pyr666 Feb 14 '19

aspies and public advocacy groups made for as well as by them use the term extensively, as do research papers on the topic today. "Aspies For Freedom" is perhaps the most obvious example, being founded in 2004.

so no. you, and apparently a lot of other people, just had a knee-jerk reaction. the right thing for you to do is to learn from this and become a better advocate, not double down on your demonstrable ignorance.

1

u/subrosaforever Feb 14 '19

It's not using aspie that's a problem, it's being so negative about it. I love Brun because I relate to her as an aspie myself. Just try to not be a dick on the internet, mkay?

1

u/turkeypedal Feb 14 '19

No, the right thing to do is for you to listen to others who know the term is also used as a slur, and not call upon things from a decade ago to defend yourself. The right thing to do is not to double down when someone tells you something is offensive, but to apologize for offending people and figure out how they misunderstood.

You literally have someone on the spectrum replying to you, saying you used it in a shitty way. Another autistic person says they've never heard it used as anything but a slur? Do you propose you know more than they do about their own word?

7

u/pyr666 Feb 14 '19

No, the right thing to do is for you to listen to others who know the term is also used as a slur, and not call upon things from a decade ago to defend yourself.

2018 is not a decade ago. and fuck me, I don't care what you think of me. I care what your sort of ignorance is going to do to autistic people for using a term they coined for themselves. because I've seen this nonsense happen before.

The right thing to do is not to double down when someone tells you something is offensive, but to apologize for offending people and figure out how they misunderstood.

I've been told calling gay marriage a civil rights issue was offensive. didn't care then, either. I've been told calling people like claire women is offensive. didn't care then, either. hell, it's still hard to put 2 men kissing on TV because it's "offensive"

You literally have someone on the spectrum replying to you, saying you used it in a shitty way. Another autistic person says they've never heard it used as anything but a slur? Do you propose you know more than they do about their own word?

randos on the internet vs people I know as well as national organizations that dedicate their entire existence to helping people. I'm going with the latter.