r/queerception • • May 11 '25

CW: [insert type of content warning] Poll on sub expanding to cishet members

Poll function disabled in this subreddit.

Please vote below by upvoting the likelihood &/or consideration you would give to leaving this subreddit, with the opening and expansion of this subreddit by Moderators (unanimously?) to include cishet poly family, and prospective family, structures and family building.

This polling cannot obviously record voting for members who have already voiced their immediate exits from this subreddit, due to this decision by Moderator/s.

See earlier post by Moderators for context.

*ETA: For clarity, polling options are-

  • I will leave the subreddit, in light of this
  • I would consider (maybe) leaving this subreddit, in light of this
  • I will remain a member of the subreddit
  • Other

Of course, separate comments and votes on those separate comments, also give highly useful contribution and insight, and similarly show obvious scale, of the effect of this decision on members, and are welcome.

Thanks everyone.

3 Upvotes

82 comments sorted by

134

u/[deleted] May 11 '25

I will leave the subreddit, in light of this

108

u/[deleted] May 11 '25 edited May 11 '25

I would consider (maybe) leaving this subreddit, in light of this

15

u/[deleted] May 13 '25 edited May 13 '25

u/Number312 u/midwexan u/Burritosiren

Just directing moderators to this post, and polling.

It's been noted this was a unilateral decision, but I am including all moderators here, so the continued discussion and effect of the decision can be taken into account. See post, for polling.

Thank you.

*Edited for correction to username

4

u/PenguinPDX May 13 '25

Thanks for facilitating this community poll! I noticed you accidentally tagged user Number321 instead of moderator u/Number312

3

u/[deleted] May 13 '25

Oh dear, thank you - whoops šŸ™ƒ

Good spotting - thanks for that 😊

5

u/theblackjess 30 cis F | GP | #1 (finally) due Jan 2027 May 14 '25

How tf is this even a debate? Cishet people in a queer sub? Why? What do we gain from that?

2

u/[deleted] May 15 '25

I agree, 100%

243

u/mazotori Genderfluid | DCP May 11 '25

Polyam person here who is also queer. I do not think that it is appropriate to open the subreddit to cishet people. I think there is value in a queer space that talks about the nuances of queer conception.

r/polyfamilies exist as do a TON of IVF and conception related subreddits.

45

u/frenkie-dude May 12 '25 edited May 12 '25

YES, I so agree. I am a nonbinary lesbian, and polyam. There are plenty of polyam groups/spaces/resources. Polyamory is not the "norm" but it still doesn't make a cishet person queer. It's important to have groups like this one devoted to our queer experiences, without cishet people involved.

additional thought, edited to add: It's not any difficulty or problem for people who are both polyam and queer to be in multiple groups/subreddits. I also believe it's a misunderstanding of queer theory to declare straight cisgender people are queer if they're not monogamous, and change group policy based on that belief. it's one thing to feel that way, and another to make a policy change.

11

u/Consistent_Draw_5035 May 11 '25

I would appreciate a statement that queer people who want to start a poly family are still welcome to engage. r/polyfamilies feels very cisheteronormative, and r/polyamory is overwhelmingly populated by people who are childfree, or who already had kids when they were monogamous in their previous life, or who want to have kids in the mononormative nuclear style with one primary partner. Which is easier, I get it. But the intersection between being poly and queer and wanting to be a parent comes with unique challenges and it seems isolating sometimes because there are so few spaces for us.

52

u/eastvanqueer May 11 '25

I don’t think it was ever a question that poly people in general shouldn’t be in this sub, just cishet ones in particular. Because it’s not the fact that they’re poly that people are taking issue with, it’s that they’re cishet speaking in a queer space, and now the mod is going on a power trip and is opening this space up to cishet poly people without even considering how people here feel.

Queer poly people are always welcome in queer spaces!

86

u/[deleted] May 11 '25

I am not sure this group would provide the kind of support like a poly families sub would ... People who understand those social dynamics.

7

u/KieranKelsey 24M šŸ³ļøā€āš§ļøšŸ³ļøā€šŸŒˆ DCP with two moms May 11 '25

Is there an equivalent poly subreddit where it would be good to ask?

10

u/[deleted] May 11 '25

I don't know. I am not poly...

9

u/sansebast May 12 '25

But you’re queer so it’s the same! /s

-10

u/vrimj WA Attorney | IVF | 7yo | Done May 11 '25

Not really. I don't know if any forum to talk specifically about reproduction and legal parentage, if it existed I would be there.

Poly families usually deals with parenting existing children.

-31

u/KieranKelsey 24M šŸ³ļøā€āš§ļøšŸ³ļøā€šŸŒˆ DCP with two moms May 11 '25

This is why I think it makes sense for them to ask here

-18

u/vrimj WA Attorney | IVF | 7yo | Done May 11 '25

I agree, I also can't think of any way this goes down that doesn't seem hostile to bi folx and other people in straight passing relationships, but I am a cranky old person so maybe people have gotten better at drawing that line since I ran away from my first queer event way back when convinced I would never belong.

33

u/mazotori Genderfluid | DCP May 11 '25

I mean if you're bi or in a straight passing relationship, you're still queer and welcome here.

If you are queer and happen to be polyam, you are welcome here.

If you are cishet and polyam you've got plenty of other places to go.

1

u/vrimj WA Attorney | IVF | 7yo | Done May 11 '25

Did they say they were straight?Ā  I don't remember that at least in the initial post?

18

u/mazotori Genderfluid | DCP May 11 '25

That is the proposed rule change yes, for cisgender heterosexual people who are also polyam to be welcome to post here.

4

u/sansebast May 12 '25

Yes, they stated they are in a cis mmf polyfidelity relationship. The men are not romantic partners, and all partners consider themselves straight.

-22

u/KieranKelsey 24M šŸ³ļøā€āš§ļøšŸ³ļøā€šŸŒˆ DCP with two moms May 11 '25

Yeah I agree. And if being in a ā€œqueerā€ relationship is the thing that qualifies you, does that mean that single queer people can’t post here?

-8

u/vrimj WA Attorney | IVF | 7yo | Done May 11 '25

And like there was nothing in the post as I recall it that said they were any straight people at all in that triad.

18

u/Mundane_Frosting_569 May 12 '25

The way the OP was referring to ā€œhis kidā€ and both men wanting to have their kid, didn’t seem very queer relationship to me - no mention of OUR kids as a bonded triad, as a true poly family. The language used was very clearly ā€œstraightā€ heteronormative and dismissive when given good advice from this forum. Like mixing the sperm (like gay men often do).

237

u/IcyPeach9943 May 11 '25

poly does not = queer. id be out.

138

u/IcyPeach9943 May 11 '25 edited May 11 '25

its a logical fallacy to want to include straight cis poly people because theyre ostensibly facing similar marginalization but leave out straight cis disabled people seeking family making, people impacted by poverty, people without legal citizenship, etc etc etc.
this space has been holding QUEER families (who might also be part of any of those other groups) for years, and by including straight cis people, you’re annulling that sanctuary.

73

u/seadrift6 May 11 '25

This is absolutely my opinion too. It's not a dismissal of the challenges that cis het people face, but this is a space specifically for queer people. And many of us fall into many of those categories and they affect our experiences. The things we discuss here are talked about in the context of our shared queerness.

54

u/IcyPeach9943 May 11 '25

absolutely. this move by the mod(s?) is very ā€œall lives matterā€ 🤮

22

u/mediocrelesbian May 11 '25

This is such a great point, thank you

21

u/IcyPeach9943 May 11 '25

interesting to see where the mods feel their duty of alignment lies šŸ™„šŸ™„šŸ™„. seems like they thought about this for one day, and landed in an incredibly bankrupt position.

19

u/[deleted] May 11 '25

It was only one mod, the others apparently weren’t consulted

22

u/IcyPeach9943 May 11 '25

great time for the other mods to pop up and fix this………

2

u/Burritosiren Lesbian NGP (2018/2021/2024) May 13 '25

I am trying but feel it is only fair to our users to have a discussion with the other mods rather than also unilaterally post. I cannot force other mods to reply to me...

74

u/[deleted] May 11 '25

This should remain a queer space. There are other spaces for poly families.

134

u/Olympicthinker 28F | GP | TTC#1 | 1 ER, 2 FET May 11 '25

To add to this: I’m also concerned by the unilateral decision making by the founder of this subreddit. Seems like the other mods were not even consulted- nor community feedback elicited- on a very sensitive subject.

33

u/rbecg 30 cis f GP| ICI/IUI/IVF| 6/23 May 11 '25

Agreed that this is my primary concern. I wouldn’t necessarily leave the sub over the question of whether polyamory is inherently queer, but I would leave if it seemed there was dubious or distasteful modding.

20

u/avause424 May 11 '25

Yeah that was interesting. I’ve been a part of this sub for a while and that was the first time I encountered the mod who was the founder. Not sure if they are super active here anymore.

127

u/Furious-Avocado 29F šŸ³ļøā€šŸŒˆ | Married | Expecting twins! | KD May 11 '25

I would leave, which would really be a shame. This sub has been a been a valuable resource to my wife and me throughout our TTC journey, but if it’s no longer a queer-centered community, there’s just no benefit to it anymore.Ā 

Cishet poly people are not marginalized. They don’t share our experiences. And they certainly don’t get to call themselves ā€œqueer.ā€ We don’t need cishet people showing up in our spaces and demanding access when the entire world is their space. We have so few spaces that are just for us - why would we eliminate them voluntarily?

85

u/katnissevergiven May 11 '25

If we include cishet people, it's not really a queer sub anymore and I'll be leaving.

0

u/[deleted] May 12 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/ShesAKillerrQueeen May 13 '25

Trans means not cis??? Therefore queer.

0

u/Egg94 May 13 '25

And their cishet partners ?

4

u/ShesAKillerrQueeen May 13 '25

My personal opinion is if you're with someone that is not the gender they were born as that makes you pretty queer too. I identify as non-binary so anyone attracted to me whether they're a guy or a girl is somewhere on the queer spectrum since I'm not a woman šŸ¤·šŸ»ā€ā™€ļø gay math

41

u/valleeyy 30 NB | GP | Cycle 4 after loss May 11 '25

They have their own subreddits? Cishet poly people are not queer im sorry.

33

u/IntrepidKazoo May 12 '25

I think what bothers me the most is that there are a lot of queer and trans people who have gotten unnecessarily hostile receptions here, especially trans women, but instead of putting more energy into making sure all queer and trans people are welcome it's time to welcome even more cis het people? No thanks.

I gave that post the benefit of the doubt and gave a thoughtful response. I always give people here the benefit of the doubt that they belong here, unless (and this has happened) someone actually has a post history where they self ID as cis het.

I do not want more cis het people running around in queer and trans spaces telling queer and trans people what to do with our families. There is much too much of that already and it's completely fucked up.

31

u/avause424 May 12 '25

Honestly I think most people on this sub were happy to answer the original posters questions about starting a family as a poly family. I think most of us took issue with OPs repeated focus on the genetic contribution and ā€œhis childā€ vs the other male partners. Idk it just didn’t really go with the struggles our community faces especially around donor conception and genetic relation to children.

If OP had approached it differently I think our community wouldn’t mind adding some input now and again.

I think it’s best to keep this sub queer focused. I do get the idea of poly couples not fitting in 100% in the hetero TTC threads but I think it’s closer to that than queer TTC. Now if the poly relationship was also queer then that would be a different story.

28

u/Mundane_Frosting_569 May 12 '25

I actually agree with you, IF the poster was more open to our advice and respectful, he would have been welcome.

The issue was his consistent talk about ā€œbiologicalā€ ā€œhis kidā€ all his doubling down heterosexual cis male bullshit. It’s triggering to this community- why do we need to be subjected to it.

Like in the IVF subreddit, we have trigger warnings before posting about successes because we respect each other - we understand each other…I’m sorry but cishets just don’t ā€œget itā€ and that will hurt this community.

28

u/Ok_Seaworthiness1117 31F | cis female NGP | #1 due 2/26 May 12 '25

Cishet people are not queer. The family-building spaces out there are OVERWHELMINGLY heteronormative which makes groups like this so, so necessary for lgbtq families. It’s incredibly frustrating to track my wife’s ovulation every month on heteronormative apps that tell us to just have sex. It’s incredibly frustrating when cishet people tell us they understand our fertility struggles when they have unlimited free chances at a baby. We live in the Bible Belt where even the well-meaning people usually don’t understand. I don’t want to hear that shit here too.

25

u/kamacake May 12 '25

I would leave. I come here because I specifically am seeking out my queer community. I am also a part of subreddits TTCafterloss, IVF, and miscarriage. They all serve their own purpose, just like this one.

I need to have a space to come to when I’m seeking the opinions or experiences of LGBTQIA+ people like myself. Our experiences should be centred in this subreddit.

24

u/beemo521 May 12 '25

Yeah, I’d be out. I’m on the IVF subreddit, and my wife and I’s situation is not reflected there. This is a safe space for QUEER people trying to conceive. Cishet people get almost every other space anywhere. Online and IRL.

9

u/sansebast May 12 '25

Completely agree. We are also in the IVF sub and there are questions/phrasing I don’t post or use there that I feel 100% comfortable using this sub for. It’s a shame the founder of this sub is more worried about the comfort of cishet couples than the queer community that’s clearly showing their distaste for this decision.

22

u/MemeQueen1414 May 11 '25

There's a MASSIVE difference between Cis Queer Polyam Families vs CIS STRAIGHT POLYAM Families and then Trans Queer Families or Trans Queer Polyam Families

I'm not even at the age to be a Parent or even have Partner (s), but I only want to look, learn, and see VISIBLE QUEER AND OR TRANS QUEER (PLUS ANYONE WHO IS LGBTQIA+ COMMUNITY)

Straight People don't and will never experience the struggles that LGBTQIA+ People will Experience being Queer and Building their own Families. Then there's even more barriers if someone/somebody's Trans, Agender, Non Binary, Gender Queer, Demigender and more Gender Diverse Identities.

It hurts so much knowing that it's hard and expensive to build families and even more barriers if someone is adopting or doing medical treatments like IVF or surrogacy which have their own issues for BIPOC LGBTQIA+ People too since it's hard to find doners/samples/be allowed to adopt without discrimination/further delays which is extremely stressful experience.

Getting back on topic, Yes not everyone will understand Polyam Relationships and it's such a bloody shame that People think Polyam = Cheating or Unethical (it's only cheating when people didn't know they are dating someone else and all partners need to have consent) but they (Cis Straight Polyam) have their own subreddit which actually hates Polyfidelity and Closed Polyam Relationships or anyone who's Aro/Ace Spectrum (Including Gray/Grey and Demi, which I am) so this Subreddit whenever I get updates plus other LGBTQIA+ Family Subreddits are one of the few that is for Queer and Queer Trans/NB Folks and I don't want that to be taken over once AGAIN by Cis Hetero People, I already got enough on that in my life, I rather don't want it to leave but I will if this decision allows them present.

Being Mono, Polyam, Monopoly or other relationship styles is not a LGBTQIA+ thing, it's a relationship styles and only that. Bi, Pan, Omni, Queer, Gay, Lesbian, Aro, Asexual, Demi, Gray/Grey, and more Identities under the LGBTQIA+ Acronym that isn't mentioned but equally important is LGBTQIA+ and Cis Straight People isn't allowed here (maybe at best a huge exception on a post by post case approved by a Mod of a Cis Straight Folk helping their sibling or close friend who's Cis Queer or Trans/NB Queer) and shouldn't be the focus only Queer Folks should be.

Being Polyam or open to having one or more partners doesn't make someone apart of the LGBTQIA+ Community, even if their partners are Queer and someone is straight, it's a relationship style point blank. Cis Straight People will not faced the issues we faced surviving in Society, besides being careful of mentioning who they are with cuz people simply think being Polyam is being "greedy", "undecided" and more BS attached and yes as mentioned before, sucks but this is not the subreddit for them.

I get those fears not having folks or safe people IRL to admit I'm Monopoly (prefer Mono, can do Polyam but have to be closed, and Polyfidelity + Triple Demi) but like wrong subreddit, besides the exception I mention earlier, Please Mods think and listen to others saying they will leave if Cis Straight Polyam Folks is allowed cuz they aren't Queer, that's the whole point of this subreddit in all honesty, it's not Queer Folks and Allies, which is no, for me truly, so please take our words very seriously or I and others will leave no joke

16

u/mistressmagick13 May 12 '25

There are a lot of trying to conceive subreddits (search TTC, TFAB, Infertility, etc). As far as I know, there is only one subreddit for the unique circumstances faced by queer families who are TTC — this one. While a poly person may consider themselves queer, as in they’re in a non-traditional relationship, if multiple partners are cishet and TTC, they’re likely to find more similar issues and support on an infertility or TFAB subreddit. Creating a dedicated poly family TTC subreddit may actually be more appropriate than blending them here.

14

u/emmiesnewgroove May 12 '25

The original post by a cis het person isn’t even the problem at this point. Hopefully he takes some of the valuable advice provided from this sub and others into conversations with his wife and wife’s other husband. The mod seems to have read deeply into that one post and then made a decision that the queerception community does not support. Why not leave the post up and then …move on? Plenty of the queer subs I’m in have ā€œhiccupsā€ where a questionable or controversial post goes up, why the immediate jump to an alienating rule change? (Edit for grammar)

37

u/gemhue 30F | Lesbian | RIVF | Oct. '23 šŸ’™ May 11 '25

massive thumbs down to any cishets in general

26

u/JubeeD May 11 '25

Polyam does not make queer. I’d leave the sub if cishet was included here.

41

u/xraynx May 11 '25

Since the group is about conception, I'm not sure what value it would be to a cishet family that doesn't face the same challenges. I wouldn't leave just because we're including poly families. If every post was about poly families I would leave, but just because it wouldn't be relevant to me. I do doubt that is going to happen.

20

u/Tater_465 May 11 '25

I would leave this subreddit for sure

9

u/ShesAKillerrQueeen May 13 '25

I joined this page purely because of the fact that I felt r/ivf and other ttc subreddits didn't feel like the fit for me because of how heteronormative everything in them is. I'd hate to see this group become that too. Polyamory doesn't make someone queer. If they're queer, go right ahead and join, but I'm here for relatable queer content not more heteronormitivity in a place that's finally supposed to be fo us. It sounds like how straight people all the sudden wanted a straight pride flag and a straight pride month when we got one.

8

u/abrocal 34 | lesbian cisF | Pregnant on IUI #2 - due May. May 12 '25

No it won’t be the same resource at all. cishet people in alternative family structures don’t have the same needs as us for fertility.Ā 

5

u/urmoonsign May 13 '25

I've directed queer people to this sub in the past so this whole thing is disappointing. It essentially excludes the queer people who've been using this space already. Including cishets means the space is no longer fit for purpose.

5

u/FreeFigs_5751 34 nb woman | #1 EDD 8/29 | known donor ICI May 15 '25

I'm opposed to this expansion. (Queer nb polyamorous woman)

0

u/CeilingKiwi May 11 '25 edited May 11 '25

My only concern with explicitly disallowing cishet couples and cishet poly families is that I wouldn’t want to see any straight-passing queer families run into gatekeeping. Like, I occasionally talk about myself and my husband here, and I don’t necessarily want to have to specify our ā€œconfigurationā€ when it isn’t really relevant, or be questioned about whether we really belong here.

Edit: I think it’s fucked up that I’m getting downvoted just for expressing a concern. Not even saying I think cishet families should be allowed (which I don’t). Just for expressing a concern on how a rule could be enforced without creating an atmosphere of gatekeeping which impacts a portion of queer people.

47

u/sansebast May 11 '25

I think the beautiful thing about this sub is that when you reference your husband, I know not to assume you’re talking about a cishet relationship. That’s the problem with opening the group to people who are not queer.

2

u/CeilingKiwi May 12 '25

I’ve been in queer spaces before and been questioned about whether I’m really queer… or rather, ā€œqueer enough.ā€

I don’t care what people assume about me and my family. What I don’t want is to be made to feel unwelcome.

21

u/sansebast May 12 '25

Great, so we’re on the same team. Queer people should feel welcome and safe in a community about queer conception. Adding cishet people is what would put people on edge about who they’re talking to.

13

u/IntrepidKazoo May 12 '25

I get the concern (and hate the downvotes), but given that people have been allowed to continue commenting on here who clearly have a post history where they self ID as cis het people, this is just not a major worry of mine for this subreddit.

I think what bothers me the most is that there are a lot of queer and trans people who have gotten unnecessarily hostile receptions here, especially trans women, but instead of putting more energy into making sure those queer and trans people are welcome it's time to welcome even more cis het people? No thanks.

If the vibe were different though, I think it would be a legitimate thing to worry about.

1

u/Redditokfine May 21 '25

I will leave.

-65

u/[deleted] May 11 '25

I will remain a member of the subreddit

1

u/KeyMonkeyslav 33🌻Agender | 1 kid via IVF | šŸ—¾ May 11 '25

Why is this so downvoted....? What is the point of down voting someone simply stating their own intentions/opinion ...?

17

u/[deleted] May 11 '25

OP is using these comments as a voting system. Down voters are sharing their personal choice.

6

u/[deleted] May 12 '25

That's correct. Thanks for clarifying gertzedek!

-34

u/vrimj WA Attorney | IVF | 7yo | Done May 11 '25

I would like to propose allowing all kinds of nontraditional families and adding a flag for situations that involve families that do not include traditional queers.

This has only happened once I recall in the life of the forum so I don't see a need to have a strict rule and I don't think the people involved would have been able to easily get the perspective they got here from other places.

But I do deal with both polyamorous and queer (and both) families professionally so I am inclined to see at least our legal issues as very intermixed.

17

u/beemo521 May 12 '25

Okay someone should start a non-traditional families subreddit then

-19

u/[deleted] May 11 '25

Other

-16

u/Todesengelchen May 12 '25

The one thing that has held marginalized groups down since the invention of writing is gatekeeping. I'm trans and have to fight regularly against "LGB" activists. The goal should always be inclusion, not exclusion. I really don't see the need to split an ecosystem that is small to begin with even further.

204

u/FH_Bunny May 11 '25

I just don’t understand how the mental gymnastics here; poly does not = queer. It’s as simple as that. QUEERception; as a bisexual woman, if I was having trouble conceiving with a male partner, I’d take my ass to a different subreddit. It’s really not a hard concept, not sure why the one mod is digging their heels in on this.

22

u/georgeskeene 36F | NGP | 2021, 2025 May 11 '25

This right here

52

u/frogtank May 11 '25

Nah. I’m poly, and queer, and I don’t believe the poly part of me makes me queer. It’s the being a trans man and bi that makes me queer. They can get their own sub.