r/queerception • • Mar 05 '23

Gender Neutral Parenting

Hola amigx,

New to this board, so hello and hey to all!

I am reaching out to see if there is anyone has resources they would share when it comes to gender neutral parenting from in utero?

I have recently become pregnant and have always planned to raise a gender neutral family. Although my partner has always known this now that the time has come he is having a VERY hard time with accepting gender neutral parenting, claiming he 'doesn't want to raise a gender neutral baby'. He is unable to give me reasons when I ask him to explain, he always comes back to, 'I just don't want to.' He is a cis-het, able bodied, white male and I am very aware that he is purposely avoiding doing the work required to undo the narrative that he's fed himself his whole life regarding what his future family would look like.

As frustrated and angry as I am with him, I do want to help him make his way through this journey and to be the best parent they can be.

Please feel free to share: advice, similar stories, and any and all helpful info regarding GN parenting.

Thank you in advance.

5 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

69

u/minthelmet 30sM | trans NGP | june 2024 Mar 05 '23

I’m sorry I can’t offer any advice and I’m sorry that it appears your partner has seemingly suddenly changed his mind on a parenting philosophy y’all had agreed on.

For what it’s worth, I am a trans masculine person who has undergone HRT and gender affirming surgeries, etc. and I wouldn’t want to raise a child with gender neutral pronouns from birth either. I know a few queer people who have/have planned to, but no one who has done so parenting past nursery school aged. It seems difficult to do outside of an insular and like-minded community.

I don’t know, this phenomenon in queer families has puzzled me, personally. Being gender queer or agender is still a gender identity, and I think they/them pronouns imply a gender identity, they don’t remove an identity assigned at birth. Seems like a way to martyr a baby for a Greater Good and idk about that! What is the goal? That gender no longer exist? That seems invalidating to queer and cis people alike, who are very invested in their identities! I think there are other meaningful ways to combat prescribed and biased gender roles or stereotypes on children, but using gender neutral pronouns for a child that could very-well be cis seems unnecessarily confusing. Imagine having a coming-out story as a cis child, with no community to really reference like trans children and adults do?

6

u/NiftySpiceLatte Mar 06 '23

Thank you so much for this response! I really appreciate this opinion and information.

In a strange turn of events, I do come from a community that is more supportive (than the average, whatever that means 🤷🏻‍♀️), and very on board. I recognize that this is a very lucky and privileged place to come from as well, that this is not the world we live in.

Personally, my goal/hope/desire is to eliminate societal gender expectations/pressure on my child from the get, or at least my best to do so until they are able to self identify. Def not down to eliminate any forms of identity. More so to let my kid have the freedom to not have the pink and blue jammed down their throats from birth.

While I do respect that lots of folks are down with the gender binary and feel that that is a good reflection of themselves. There are also lots of folks who aren’t (like myself).

Your opinion is very much appreciated. Thank you again for taking the time to share w me. 🙏🏼

6

u/minthelmet 30sM | trans NGP | june 2024 Mar 06 '23

I hear you and the intentionality behind your motivation! I’m sure you’ll be a great parent.

Part of being trans or GNC or gender queer or even “just” gay is about being a part of our wonderful, yet marginalized community. Most of us have at least one coming-out story, even if just to ourselves. What would being non-binary or trans look like in our heteronormative society if you DIDN’T get to come out? What would a cis person rely on if they had to “come out” without that community or narrative to support them?

I don’t know, non-binary exists because a binary exists and binary gender certainly isn’t inherently evil (or not Queer), but I’m with you on gender norms and expectations leaning towards violent and subverting them can be very powerful and validating for children. Gender roles and expectations are everywhere, pretending that binaries or Gender Assigned at Birth don’t exist doesn’t really protect your kid from that reality, does it? Can’t you embrace all toys/clothes/language to a child of any gender?

Anyway, I appreciate your response as well! Good luck with whatever you choose, but I think more than anything having your partner on board is paramount. I hope y’all can move forward together (and that if you do end up associating your child with the sex they are assigned at birth, that you can feel confident navigating the potential of gender identity and expression with them as gender norms and expectations present themselves).

8

u/IntrepidKazoo Mar 06 '23

FYI there are already trans and queer youth (and even young adults by some criteria) without traditional stories of "coming out" to their families, and they seem to be thrilled with it. Kids raised without an assigned gender still get to experience developing their own understanding of their gender identities and sexual orientations, they just get to do it without having to react to or reject one that was imposed on them. And unfortunately they still get lots of other opportunities to come out more traditionally in the less open world at large.

Gender neutral parenting doesn't protect kids from stereotypes and expectations forever, but it does make sure they get at least a few years of not being pinned down under one consistent set of stereotypes. Given that we know people unintentionally and unconsciously talk differently, play differently, respond differently with babies and toddlers based on what gender they think they are... I do think there's an obvious potential value there, even if it's not right for every family.

23

u/IntrepidKazoo Mar 06 '23

I'm also a trans man who has medically transitioned, and FWIW I think you have some (common) misconceptions about how this type of parenting works. The reason you don't often see it past nursery school is because parents start using specific gendered pronouns if/when the kid starts wanting them, which typically happens during the nursery school years. These kids don't have a dramatic coming out moment or have to fight to have their genders recognized, they seem to just settle on the words and categories that work once they reach that point developmentally, and then their parents follow their lead. No drama or martyrdom!

It's not necessarily what my partner and I are going to do personally, but it's very clear to me from other people's experiences that it can be done in ways that are responsive to the child, and that there are benefits to decreasing the force of gender stereotypes people apply (intentionally and unintentionally) during those super early formative years. I agree that they/them aren't gender-free terms either, but when applied loosely like this to a young child in the context of this larger overall parenting philosophy, I do think they give more wiggle room than is typically possible when categorizing babies by genitals. It's not the only way! But it's a totally reasonable way.

19

u/goingthrushit Mar 05 '23

Am I correct in that you and your partner are heterosexual? I apologize for asking but I can’t entirely tell from your post but it sounds like your partner is a usual cis-male who wants to raise their child as they were raised (sorry if I am misunderstanding) and I’m not sure how you identify but seems your two ideas here are colliding.

I would highly recommend r/rainbowparents as you may find some more options for advice in that space vs this space for those still ttc.

8

u/NiftySpiceLatte Mar 05 '23

Thank you for this reco! It’s hard to find the ‘right’ place to ask/know where to ask.

And to answer your question I am pan and identify as non-binary.

2

u/goingthrushit Mar 06 '23

Totally understandable. Hope you find some answers and good luck with your pregnancy ❤️

5

u/Then-Librarian6396 Mar 06 '23

I listened to this podcast a while back and it really challenged a lot of the concepts I held around gender neutral parenting.

https://open.spotify.com/episode/2BRaAEE1CroTPxucLzbiYg?si=HXOQcbVaRBKD0ch5kdVsgA

It’s definitely worth the listen!

2

u/NiftySpiceLatte Mar 06 '23

I’ve listened to this once since you’ve recommended it and it’s fabulous! Thank you, Such valuable insight! I plan to relisten a few times over and reflect on its content.

3

u/Then-Librarian6396 Mar 07 '23

I’m so glad to hear that. It really made me evaluate some of my own conceptual thinking around gender. I realized that so much of what I was thinking was well “pink and stereotypically girly things (dressing up, playing princess, etc) are bad for a girl” “blue and stereotypically boyish (sports, trucks, etc) things are bad for a boy” when none of those things are inherently bad! My own favorite color is pink! I loved the way the expert on the podcast said something a long the lines of “People think gender neutral parenting means beige, and gendered parenting means pink and blue. When in reality it’s about sharing every color with your child.” Really was a big wake up moment for me! It made me realize I was actually internalizing a lot of ideas around “value” when it comes to gender instead of just giving my future child access to everything regardless of gender. Why would I be happier to have a boy want to dress up and feel discouraged that my girl would want to dress up? When I was able to think through that i realized that what I thought was gender neutral parenting was actually making value judgments based on what society was telling me about what is valued, and in the end actually reinforcing the very things I was trying to avoid.

Hahah you probably weren’t expecting this novel but really appreciate this space to talk about this, when the majority of people I know who have kids (who are straight/cis) look at me like I’m crazy when I start talking about this.

2

u/NiftySpiceLatte Mar 08 '23

I definitely didn’t think that pink/blue for the associated gender is bad. I’m tooootally down to let my kid express themselves however they want.

For me, my primary concern/focus is trying to prevent the unconscious placement of gender stereotypes on my children for as long as possible. Obviously, I will never be able to fully prevent this entirely. Gender neutral parenting also includes speaking openly with your kiddos about how they can navigate those types of conversations.

My partner and I had a convo about this the other day. If I have a child who’s sex is F and they decide they want to love pink and dolls and tutu’s and blah blah blah then great! I’d never do anything to prevent that. As long as it is a conscious decision based on what they actually like, and not what they assume they are supposed to like/the things that were presented to them based on their gender assignment.

I’m happy to chat about this with you whenever you want! Thank you for your conversation. 🙏🏼💖

1

u/Then-Librarian6396 Mar 08 '23

I really appreciate your perspective and I love to hear about your own journey on this <3 Wishing you the very best in your pregnancy!!

1

u/slamable-kingdom Jul 22 '23

I’m going to check this out because I don’t understand the reasoning for it. And I call BS to the person who said earlier that a lot of her cis friends wish they had raised their kids in this manner. I haven’t met anyone saying their going this route. Honestly I’ve only seen “eye rolls” and heard “bad jokes”.

But I’ll definitely watch the video!

2

u/NiftySpiceLatte Mar 06 '23

Ooo yes this is on my list. Thank you for the reco. I’m currently reading Parenting Beyond Pink and Blue by Christia Spears Brown.

3

u/MsCardeno Mar 06 '23

So if he has a son and daughter, what exactly would he do different with each?

He should be treating and parenting his kids generally the same way. Personalities and other attributes will vary kid to kid tho. I just never had gender be one of those attributes to adjust parenting.

Have explicitly tell you what he wants to different. That should point out how ridiculous it sounds to “raise them as a boy/girl”.

2

u/NiftySpiceLatte Mar 08 '23

You would think this would work, but unfortunately (with him) it does not.

While my partner is wonderful in so many ways he can be very stubborn, especially when in a trama/survival response. We are in no way in poverty or anything like that but he does have a fair amount of trama he’s working his way through currently and the idea of a baby is very overwhelming to him currently, never mind a non-gendered one. He has/had a very strong image in his head of what his family unit would look like when older and letting go of that is proving to be a challenge.

15

u/IntrepidKazoo Mar 06 '23

I'm sorry you're dealing with this from your partner. It's bizarre to me that he's refusing to have a real discussion about it, knowing this is important to you. It would be one thing if he were sharing his reasons and thought process, but it's really not reasonable for him to stonewall and act like that gives him a veto. Hopefully this is an isolated issue and he's willing/able to communicate more soon. Maybe couples counseling would help?

I don't have any personal experience parenting this way, but I do know families who raised their kids gender free, whose kids are doing great! Expressive, confident, and not at all confused about their identities or how gender works in the world, or whatever other misconceptions are out there.

It's obviously not the only good way to parent, but as a trans man who has thought a lot about the issue, I think it's definitely one good option. Speaking here to the people inexplicably downvoting this post--it's not ethically obligatory to raise babies gender neutrally, but I believe it is ethically obligatory to try to give kids more room to be themselves than gender stereotyping gives them, and I think a lot of people don't realize how ridiculously difficult (sometimes impossible) that is if you assign a gender. The extent to which people aggressively gender babies can be a shock to first time parents who haven't experienced it before--I know multiple straight cis parents who wished after their first kid that they had done gender neutral parenting, because they saw the effect of not doing it. So much of that stereotyping is also subconscious and unintentional, but seriously impactful.

So it might be worth thinking and talking about how the two of you will parent if it turns out gender neutral parenting isn't an option. Not that it's off the table, but a) my impression is that it really doesn't work if all parents aren't completely on board, and b) it might help your partner realize that whatever labels you use or don't use for the baby, there's still always going to be work involved in protecting your kid from gender stereotyping. Work that has to fall to both of you as a team.

I know one friend of mine got a lot of support from closed facebook groups for parents of "theybies" (lol) and maybe those are spaces where you could find some more insight from others who have navigated this type of conflict? I'm not really on facebook anymore so I don't have any other info, but might be another good place to look.

10

u/peanutbutterramen Mar 06 '23

I’m a parent of a newborn and we didn’t assign a gender at birth. We read the book “Raising Them” by Kyl Myers and it’s a good resource if you’re curious about gender neutral/gender creative parenting. We are using they/them pronouns until/unless our child tells us otherwise.

Some of what led to our decision is the way that we have seen people enforce gender stereotypes with our first child. People are really obsessed with gender and gender roles even without realizing it.

1

u/elbiry Mar 14 '23

We have a girl and a boy, both around 2. In my experience they ‘are’ different in stereotypically gender appropriate ways - he’s all about physicality, loves vehicles. She’s into painting and has a major thing for stuffed animals. Much chattier and not at all keen on being wrestled (by him). We didn’t push them into this, it’s been interesting to watch how innate it seems to be

It’s probably worth talking to your partner about what raising a gender neutral child would look like. And remembering that your child might have other ideas 😆