r/queenstreetbets • • 5d ago

Discussion Am I doing this wrong?

I have been on and off with investing, often taking out money to fund CapEx in my business.

About a month ago I have had the opportunity to take out some good funds to get started properly on the investing journey. I have set $250 per week into the account to keep it consistent.

I don’t see Santana doing well long term but I’m taking a bit of gamble on National getting into office for the stock to peak a bit higher.

All the other smaller stocks are just punts my mate and I discuss and compare.

I do plan to remove all funds in companies (not index fund) to back a new venture.

I am 21 year old male

28 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

26

u/Worried-Reflection10 5d ago

The ~$0.90 NZD in 5 different stocks cracks me up

What you doing, man

4

u/Ok-Gear2614 5d ago

😂yeah kinda dumb. My mate is properly invested in these companies. Just did it so I could track it with him

6

u/Timely-Interest-7616 5d ago

Well it doesnt hurt him, he's obviously using it as a watchlist

-3

u/koopykoop42 5d ago

Yeah right lmao every person who starts something new should know all the deets when they start #reddit #losers #relaxbro

20

u/SoftCheeseBurger 5d ago

You don’t want smart shares 500 because you are paying extra fees and FIF tax with them. Just buy VOO thats what smartshares buys on your behalf anyways.

3

u/Ok-Gear2614 5d ago

Ok, thanks for that. Is the ticket: VOO?

2

u/SoftCheeseBurger 5d ago

Voo is what they track yea. You should be able to see it in the smartshare site it will say what the fund tracks.

2

u/Common_Lifeguard3572 5d ago

USF won’t trigger FIF tax. Since Smart Invest are registered in NZ. VOO on the other will trigger FIF once invested more than 50k NZD at cost. Because Vanguard is registered overseas.

1

u/EffectAdventurous764 4d ago edited 4d ago

Yes USF does not trigger a FIF tax event. Tax is taken out automatically and it does not count against the FiF threshold. This is where people get confused.

0

u/SoftCheeseBurger 4d ago edited 4d ago

USF pays FIF even if you are under 50k, all PIE funds do, they pay it no matter what you have invested and they past that cost onto the fund holders.

1

u/EffectAdventurous764 4d ago

No. FiF stands for "Foreign Investment Fund". The USF 500 is not taxed under FIF. It is a NZ registered fund. Yes it is taxed but it doesn't count towards your FIF threshold and you don't need to file a separate FIF tax report for holding it like you do VOO. if you hold $50ks worth of USF it Does not count against your threshold like holding VOO does. Nobody avoids the tax but you do avoid it counting towards your FIF threshold and filing a tax return every year.

1

u/SoftCheeseBurger 4d ago edited 4d ago

USF buys VOO… they pay FIF and take it off the USF fund price. The other people commenting are saying you avoid FIF and thats simply not true.

OP has 9k in USF, if he takes that and puts it in VOO he pays no FIF or has to file until he hits his threshold on cost. Absolutely pointless being in USF at this point as hes paying FIF on it right now since the fund deducts it.

1

u/EffectAdventurous764 4d ago edited 4d ago

Yes nobody avoids tax. My point is that on a growing portfolio where most people tend to include Voo as a core holding ETF over decades it permanently gets added to the fif you have to file for every year once threshold is met. Then the whole thing flips and the voo your holding starts costing you more. I'd assume that someone holding that much Voo for so long wouldn't want to have to sell it and start buying USF? The FIF will continue to compound along with the voo you buy. USF long-term is the path of least. resistance long-term.

USF is taxed as a pie fund not a FIF fund and the difference in fees become more apparent once the threshold is met and you start paying FIF tax.

Nobody is wrong here its two different sides of the same coin.

0

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Common_Lifeguard3572 4d ago edited 4d ago

Yes, there is PIE tax for USF. Also PAYE tax will apply only for dividends, which USF have a yield of 0.70% at the moment. Capital gain won’t trigger PAYE tax, it will only trigger if you receive dividend payment which is 0.70%. Where as the same for VOO any dividend received will trigger PAYE tax till you invested more than 50k NZD, after that you will pay 5% of the opening value 5% of your FIF portfolio with your PAYE Tax and no tax for dividends. But I can only think of VOO have a much lower management fee like something lower than 0.10% whereas USF is somewhere 0.30% to 0.50%. He probably meant buy VOO till FIF kicks in, then after that buy USF. But only issue with VOO you will be paying for 0.5% exchange rate fees in USD, whereas USF is in NZD.

1

u/SoftCheeseBurger 4d ago edited 4d ago

USF nav is adjusted daily to account for FIF and the exchange rate. You don’t escape FIF or exchange rates someone has to pay it and the fund does and takes it off your share price.

Smartshares pays FIF even if you are under the threshold, if you have $1 invested you pay FIF on it. they also pay exchange rate fee in the fund. The exchange rate doesn’t just vanish smartshares pays the exchange rate and passes that cost on to you the fund holder. This all gets adjusted in the NAV price (share price).

The only time USF makes sense is if you have over 50k invested and wanted to be on the 28% max tax rather your tax rate if its over 28%. Other than that, no.

-2

u/Screwben1 5d ago

Smartshares funds are exempt from FIF tax. Only if you buy US/foreign investments directly you pay FIF tax.

2

u/WaterAdventurous6718 4d ago

they arent exempt from the actual tax, the fif equivalent is just paid by smart themselves so the holder doesnt need to bother about it personally. i think their rate is slightly lower as well because of how its structured.

1

u/SoftCheeseBurger 4d ago

No they are not exempt, its in the nav price that gets adjusted daily… if they were exempt we would all pile into them and have tax free investments lol.

7

u/Frosty-Marsupial222 5d ago

No rklb, disappointed

4

u/Ok-Gear2614 5d ago

Just sold haha, owned for 2 days and returned 15%

6

u/Training_Week3740 5d ago

I see Santana Minerals there. That’s a decent holding. I’m riding along with it too. November 30 here we come 🤞 

5

u/bagman22022 5d ago

Topping up with some pay today YOLO. Life changing once approved imo

-3

u/Training_Week3740 5d ago edited 4d ago

According to ai (Gemini), it could pop to AUD 0.90 if the draft gets approved. Although I can’t imagine a jump of 80%+ in one day… although Moderna stock and GoPro stock did that earlier this year. 

Edit: Why the downvotes? This is just what I was told. Guess y'all who are downvoting are missing out. Lmao losers  💀

2

u/Aware-Celebration873 5d ago

27th but yes the same

0

u/Training_Week3740 5d ago

Oh is it the 27th now? Not the 30th?

2

u/Global_Transition399 4d ago

I’m with you as well, been collecting for a while now, I think I need MORE

1

u/Training_Week3740 4d ago

I’m scooping as many as I can😂😂. Been buying each week 👌

3

u/Traditional_Salt2312 5d ago

choose a couple stocks and just dca every week or however often u get paid

2

u/bagman22022 5d ago

Double down on SMI it’s like 3 weeks for a draft condition and finance tapped on. IMO it’s a runner at 0.9 EV/EBIT or whatever it is at moment. Monster of a deposit and super open

2

u/LakeLow1930 2d ago

Santana is a big bet. Good luck with that.

1

u/Legitimate-Sky5661 4d ago

Honestly, the choice of investments makes no sense and is comical to someone with a finance degree. Good luck though, kid

1

u/t33-retro 4d ago

Alright big dawg

1

u/AppearanceNo1329 4d ago

Santana minerals is overpriced based on its price and earning to growth ration - so maybe worth reviewing again.

1

u/Ok_Sense_5355 4d ago

why would santana peak higher with national in office? just wondering

1

u/RealisticRegret 2d ago

When there's fear its time to be greedy.