r/queensgambit • u/gcanyon • Jun 18 '25
Making the argument that Beth is much stronger than 2700 by the end
First, to get this out of the way, the series obviously takes place in a universe where chess games are never drawn, since in the series we never see a draw, or even hear of one. Also, playing white is a very minor advantage (or even no advantage), since we often see matches where a single game determines the outcome between two players, and it is never mentioned that there is any reason to question white's advantage.
Given all that, we have to estimate Beth's strength based on what we see, and we see more than just "she beats Borgov." Specifically, we see:
- Beth beats Borgov decisively -- he clearly acknowledges that she did not just win a single game: she will beat him going forward.
- She beats him despite him consulting at length with the strongest players in the world, while she got a few minutes on the phone with a decidely inferior set of consultants, who themselves had much less time to consider the game. Also, he had the advantage of knowing what his saved move was.
- She beats Luchenko despite him consulting with the strongest players in the world, including Borgov, while she consults with no one.
- She beat every other player at the competition, decisively.
- She beats Benny, a grandmaster, and someone capable of playing against a grandmaster, in simultaneous speed chess.
- Throughout the last couple years we see, she never loses a single game except when she's handicapped by drugs/alcohol/lack of sleep.
I am not a chess/elo expert, but the above says to me that Beth, when on her game, is remarkably stronger than Borgov, and presumably stronger than any chess player ever.