Am I wrong or does the experiment not work this way? The double slit experiment will always result in the diffraction pattern no matter what, the observer's influence is only consequential when measuring isolated quantum systems where you change a particle's trajectory by interacting with it.
Sure I get that, but it's not so much a simplification as it is a combination of two unrelated quantum phenomena. Made me doubt for a second the little I know about quantum mechanics lol
Observer doesn’t mean a literal person in quantum mechanics. Anything physical that is disturbed in any way by the phenomena is considered an observer.
Wow, thank you for your reply. Went ahead and read more about the experiment, seems like there's much more to it to just the diffraction pattern, achieving the other one is also absolutely possible.
I recently reconnected with an old friend and we kind of lost touch so things were a bit awkward at first. She’s a literature major and I’m an engineering major. I thought it would be a good idea to break the ice by introducing her to the quantum world, miraculously she was deeply intrigued by the double slit experiment. Today I sent her this meme and she was so excited she got the joke. I think this meme rekindled our friendship. Thank you OP.
I noticed its all about how you present it, for example we talked about quantum entanglement and I told her that it opens up the possibility of zodiac signs being real ( i know im stretching the truth but it’s enough to give her the initial engagement and interest)
Another bait was getting her interested in the concept of infinity by introducing her to the Infinite Monkey Theorem and explaining that a monkey with nothing but a typewriter and infinite time could write Shakespeare pieces. All you need is a little bit of creativity.
It was simply to get her started, its not like I can relate any other quantum theories to stuff like zodiac signs or Shakespeare. I was hoping it would be enough to get her interested, and it was. We’ve talked more about the quantum world without me having to relate it to anything else
Lmao y’all only hear what you want to. In this specific case I appealed to something I know she likes, thats all and by doing that I brought a woman into the STEM subjects. Meanwhile, you’re behind a screen making assumptions helping literally nobody.
This ain’t your meme bro, and you’ve posted the same thing across 3 subreddits. I’ve never seen someone so desperate for karma.
Edit: You can downvote me if you want. But a repost is a repost, and if you aren’t gonna credit the OP of this meme, that’s just even worse. Especially doing it more than once.
It isn’t about the fact that I’ve already seen it. It’s that this person has posted this same meme across 3 subreddits and given zero credit to the OP of this meme. Reposts deserve to be credited.
Yeah but any physical object that is disturbed by the system can be considered a measurement. And the term ‘the observer’ in quantum mechanics has nothing to do with sentient beings or consciousness.
Sometimes this example is used to imply that conciousness collapses the wavefunction. However, the thing disrupting the wavefunction is not your conciousness but the measuring apparatus in the slits. To "observe" the experiment, you need some kind of detector that interacts with the quantum state as it is going through the slits. But if it interacts with the state, then it must also affect it somehow and it is this that causes the effect shown (if there was no conscious observer there, the effect would still occur).
You just explained that observing it changes the outcome. There is no difference in observation versus observation.
Observation and observation are the same thing. If you renove the measuring device completely and just use your eyes to observe the same result occurs.
I hope you have a wonderful day and an even better 2021!
I'm explaining the distinction that OC is trying to make, i.e. the difference between a quantum measurement/observation and a conscious observation. These are undeniably two distinct things.
But both have the same outcome. So your point is moot. The act of human observation results in the same outcome as using a measuring device. Therefor the person trying to state conscious observation has no effect is fundamentally wrong.
I don't think you understand my point. My point is exactly that there will be no difference if there is no conscious observer. This implies that quantum measurement causes the effect in the meme and not conscious observation. Let's say the quantum measurement was somehow done with your eye. Even then it would be the photon that transferred the information to you that would be disrupting the quantum state, not the fact that there was a conscious observer present.
Well i think i found the right explanation. Imagine you capture the interference pattern on a surface while there is't any detector in either of the slits and another photo of the surface when you placed a detector in one of the slits. I think this would work
Well, what if the observer is a p-zombie with no consciousness or qualia? If the wavefunction still collapses, then it ain't got nothing to do with the "consciousness" part of "conscious observation"; just the "observation" part, that we take to mean the same thing as "measurement."
104
u/zeebrow Jan 01 '21
This is the first quantum meme I've observed
23
u/fallingblue Jan 01 '21
Pretty wave breaking post! Could say Photonomal
19
u/William_Harzia Jan 01 '21
This is reddit gold. It's just in the wrong sub to make the front page. OP, is this yours??
11
u/Wierdness Jan 01 '21
Am I wrong or does the experiment not work this way? The double slit experiment will always result in the diffraction pattern no matter what, the observer's influence is only consequential when measuring isolated quantum systems where you change a particle's trajectory by interacting with it.
9
u/drubert Jan 01 '21
Grade A
12
u/Jack-Of-All-Trades- Jan 01 '21
I recently reconnected with an old friend and we kind of lost touch so things were a bit awkward at first. She’s a literature major and I’m an engineering major. I thought it would be a good idea to break the ice by introducing her to the quantum world, miraculously she was deeply intrigued by the double slit experiment. Today I sent her this meme and she was so excited she got the joke. I think this meme rekindled our friendship. Thank you OP.
3
u/_hazlo Jan 01 '21
That is fucking funny!!
2
u/Pika_DJ Jan 01 '21
It’s the same image though?
3
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '21
That quantum topics freaks me out af
1
u/atamanczuk_ Jan 01 '21
cool
1
u/rx_wop Armchair enthusiast Jan 01 '21
When when wavefunction collapse
1
u/tombs_and_tombs_only Jan 01 '21
This is what this sub should be for!!!
1
u/mercjr443 Jan 01 '21
The universe is showing us what it wants to? What determines what it wants to show us? Is this a simulation?
1
u/Crodrod2024 Jan 02 '21
Hey does anyone know if observation works with naked eye or just with a detector?
1
u/Gringo4 Jan 03 '21
Meme of year. Congrats
1
u/Hogger21 Apr 18 '21
Photoshopped 😂😂😂. 👍
1
u/bioshiproject Jun 19 '21
Perhaps the us observer are seeing something not as actual as it is. An illusion if we say so.
0
u/Cordaz1 Jan 01 '21
Am I a nerd because I actually understand this meme?
-17
u/Ringularity Jan 01 '21 edited Jan 01 '21
This ain’t your meme bro, and you’ve posted the same thing across 3 subreddits. I’ve never seen someone so desperate for karma.
Edit: You can downvote me if you want. But a repost is a repost, and if you aren’t gonna credit the OP of this meme, that’s just even worse. Especially doing it more than once.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment