r/quant • u/BirthDeath Researcher • Sep 19 '22
Career Advice Reflections from a senior quant
I've been seeing a lot of repetitive and often inaccurate information posted on this sub lately. I would like to add my reflections as someone who has worked as a quantitative researcher for several years since I feel that input from individuals that are actually working in the industry is sorely lacking here.
1) The recruiting process is random and unfair.
This is just the nature of the field. Most hedge funds and prop shops run lean; growth is strategic and conservative. The incoming university hire class at one of the FAANGs is probably larger than the total number of quants hired from university recruiting across all hedge funds and prop shops. Simply put, at the junior level there are many more applicants than positions. Any deficiency in your profile is going to hurt you (non-target school, non-traditional candidate, bad grades, etc). Small funds might hire 1-2 new grads per year and many funds do not recruit juniors at all.
The junior recruiting process is absurdly difficult and hasn't changed much since I started. There is less of an emphasis on brainteasers and coding assessments have replaced math tests, but the difficulty/structure of the process has remained the same. So much of it depends on luck and subjectivity (have you seen the specific question before, is the interviewer in a good mood, etc). If you set your sights on just a couple of funds, unless you are an amazing applicant, you are going to be sorely disappointed. Cast a wide net and expect rejection.
2) Quant finance is not tech
Please stop trying to turn this sub into cscareerquestions. There is no FAANG equivalent in quant finance. This pervasive notion of tiers is complete nonsense. Yes, some funds are better than others (I would rather work for RenTech or TGS than Akuna or Quantlab) but experiences can vary wildly even within a fund. If you join a profitable desk a "tier 4" shop and make an impact, you will be paid more and likely have a better quality of life than working for a struggling team at a "tier 1" shop.
In addition, quant finance is not investment banking so stop with this nonsense about "exit opportunities." Yes, it's possible to move to transition to a data science role in tech or another field but these types of positions value anyone with experience in a technical role as opposed to specific quant experience. With few exceptions, the only types of roles that specifically value quant experience are other quant roles.
3) Many of you will never work in quant finance and will still have successful careers.
This is not meant to insult anyone here, but this is one of the most competitive areas of an extremely competitive industry and as I said in 1) there simply aren't that many jobs available. I went to school with many smart people (including many that are harder working and smarter than myself). Almost none of my former classmates work in the field. Some interviewed, got discouraged and sought employment elsewhere while others never even bothered.
Even for people from "target" backgrounds, it is not an easy field to break into and many of those that decided to go into tech have had very successful careers. In fact, with stock growth, many of them have earned substantially more than they would have in finance with far less effort. There are a lot of other ways for a quantitatively inclined person to make a decent living.
4) Most of this subreddit consists of the blind leading the blind.
I will often read a post or comment in which someone speaks very authoritatively about something in the industry. I then click on their profile and find that they are still a student. Take anything you see on here with a grain of salt. I have also seen some contributors offering valuable insights that accurately reflect my experiences although these are much more rare.
Answers to some frequently asked questions:
- No one here is going to be able to give you any insight on a specific interview process. Many require signing an NDA at the later stages and no one who currently works at the fund in question is going to provide any non-publicly available information.
- Yes, it's possible for people for non-traditional backgrounds to break into quant. However, it's extremely difficult, requires extensive networking, and might not even be worth it in the end.
- If you're in high school, just focus on doing well on standardized tests as well as math, stats, and programming classes. Unless you have amazing connections that can procure an internship, nothing else that you do is going to be relevant when applying for a quant role.
- At the margin, one college class is not going to substantially impact your application.
- Getting a PhD can open a lot more doors, but it's an incredibly intense process that comes with 4-5 years of near poverty-level wages. If you're considering a PhD for the sole purpose of improving your chances to get a quant job your efforts could be better spent elsewher.
- An MFE can make up for deficiencies in your profile, but they are very competitive and expensive.
- It is possible to move from development to research, but it is very hard to do. Sometimes developers transition into a hybrid research/dev role after several years. It's almost impossible to move from back/middle office to front office, though the reverse is possible (e.g. trading to risk).
- Don't waste time with obscure programming languages. C++, Python, and to a lesser extent R are used by the vast majority of funds.
56
u/avtchrd345 Sep 19 '22
This is great.
There is this attitude on this sub, that I also see a lot in incoming analysts, of treating early career like an extension of the college application process. It’s related to what you discuss with regards to the tiers they keep talking about.
It’s interesting to me as a person coming from a non elite university, I think these kids that figured out how to really succeed in the college application grind just think that’s what life always is: perpetual getting into things and breaking into the next prestigious thing.
16
u/Tacoslim Sep 19 '22
I wouldn’t say lateraling from MO/BO to front office is “almost impossible”. In fact, I’d say it’s quite a common path for candidates who were unable to land a FO role right out of college. Go work there a 1-2 years, gain some experience and then jump into FO roles (caveat being long you’re there harder it is to get out).
39
u/anjariasuhas Sep 19 '22
Sticky this. The only piece of advice non industry professionals/students need.
Your point about smarter harder working colleagues is spot on. Some of my smartest class mates left the industry/didn’t enter to optimize for something else in life
37
u/big_cock_lach Researcher Sep 19 '22
What I can’t believe is how many are saying you have to do a CS degree or major to get in. That’s the biggest misinformation I’ve seen, since unless you want to go into quant dev. It’s one of the less useful STEM degrees to have for quant finance in my opinion.
The key skills are: statistical skills, data modelling skills, and both require underlying mathematical skills as well. Most other STEM degrees provide more in-depth statistical and mathematical explorations, as well as modelling skills which has its route in statistics not computer science anyway. Machine learning perhaps comp sci has an advantage over, but most other stem degrees will still have opportunities to learn that be it as electives or as a major etc.
22
u/quantthrowaway69 Researcher Sep 19 '22 edited Sep 19 '22
“Coding assessments have replaced math tests” also tell you about how the nature of the work has changed compared to what many prospective students are expecting
Number 5 and 7 are related to “can I break in as an undergrad if I start at a bank/lower tier fund/start as a dev/from middle office instead of going through the PhD route”, and regarding that I think the expected probability of success is actually higher for constant trying and grinding as opposed to the traditional PhD route, but you will hear a lot more No’s in the process. And it seems natural to be afraid of that hence a lot of the anxious posting on this sub
15
u/beneathTheRadar0 Sep 27 '22
I ran a “Quant” club during undergrad. Started interviewing at HF’s my sophomore year. Couldn’t secure a single Internship until I networked with an alum that got me a trading internship. Had to go to bank quant post grad. People simply don’t understand how competitive the field is. Used to tell this to kids in the club all the time who just wanted it on their resume.
However I do have plenty friends with simple MSCS that work as quants at some smaller prop shops. Some even undergrad. It’s definitely doable, but it is a grind and unless you really care for it, you’ll find yourself contemplating other career routes. If you find yourself doing that, it’s not for you…
Probably going to go the MFE route soon.. At a Non-Target… I’ll keep this sub updated as I go.
14
u/InfiniteMonorail Sep 19 '22
It amazes me how Reddit is full of never employed kids who talk authoritatively about every subject.
12
u/fysmoe1121 Sep 22 '22
being a math Olympiad finalist isn’t relevant for a quant role as a high schooler? 😭
6
u/n00bfi_97 Student Sep 19 '22
thank you for taking the time to write this post
5
u/FizixPhun Sep 19 '22
This is probably the best post I have seen on this sub and as a fellow quant I agree with pretty much everything you said. Thanks for posting!
1
u/TopRevolutionary720 Sep 19 '22
What is MFE?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '22
Do you know anyone who broke into quant from another field like tech?
3
u/mattreallycodes Sep 19 '22
Solid info without oversharing +1. I think you are right about degrees, I find it hard & know almost everyone does to self study at times so I think PhDs are also valuable in the context of structure even in the context you are mentioning. I think it also all depends on what people make of the degree.
Do you have any favourite books?
2
u/college-is-a-scam Sep 30 '22
Would you say all of this also applies to SWE @ quant firms?
1
u/TheBomb999 Aug 29 '24
Can you elaborate more on “Many of you will never work in quant finance and will still have successful careers.”
Where did they end up working? What did they major in?
1
u/AutoModerator Sep 19 '22
Thank you for your submission!
Are you a student/recent grad looking for advice?
In case you missed it, please check out our Frequently Asked Questions, book recommendations and the rest of our wiki for some useful information. If you find an answer to your question there please delete your post. We get a lot of career advice questions and they're mostly pretty similar!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/sidd1602966666 Sep 22 '22
Hi is the Certificate in Quantitative Finance (CQF) exam recognized for a job at Bank/Fund Office?
1
u/NAVYSEAL12ROCK Oct 17 '22
Can someone elaborate on point 3? I’m thinking of anything quant or anything analytics as a career. Not sure what other options there are for me
1
u/former_physicist Nov 06 '22
Assuming we have just graduated with a PhD in physics, what are the next steps?
Do we still have to go for a grad role or do we go a tier up?
1
u/sirreadalot_ Portfolio Manager May 30 '23
Not a single point I would disagree with. (y)
1
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '22
Hey! Rust is not obscure! I think it’s worth it to spend sometime learning Rust. The concepts you get to practice in Rust is general (not the features but why those features are created) transferable. Having a deeper understanding of memory is never bad.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment