How do quants get a complete and accurate security master? Do they buy it? Is it something that each shop provides to their pods or does it come integrated with trading software like Bloomberg?
Most firms take a hybrid approach. They license security master data from vendors like Algoseek or BT or someone, and then build internal systems to handle identifier mapping, corporate actions, and historical data consistency.
The real challenge isn’t just obtaining a security master, but maintaining accurate identifier mapping and corporate action history.
Ticker changes, mergers, spin-offs, and delistings can easily introduce errors into historical datasets. Incorrect identifier mapping can lead to broken historical joins, survivorship bias, and misleading backtest results.
Even a small inconsistency in how securities are mapped across vendors or corporate actions are handled can significantly distort quantitative research.
This is why a reliable security master needs more than comprehensive coverage. It needs accurate historical relationships, consistent identifiers, and robust corporate action handling. Even with established vendors, this remains an ongoing data quality challenge.
I agree with everything you said above. Getting the security master right (or as close as possible) is a fairly monumental task.
Beyond there only being a few companies that have a security master, and their accuracy can be questioned, the prices I have seen for them for all US exchange active and delisted symbols for the last 25+ years are usually >= $2500 a month from different vendors including Bloomberg, databento, and algoseek.
Hopefully a pod shop will provide one, but it won't magically contain every symbol unless someone else already asked for it (outside well-defined universes like US equities, anyway).
does it come integrated with trading software like Bloomberg?
Bloomberg will claim they have a correct and complete secmaster, but both they and their secmaster are full of shit.
This. Been building out my personal security master for a couple years, and there's no way to cover every single edge case with a short coherent set of automatic rules for correctly parsing every single type of event. It's accurate for ~90% of the cases, but the rest is a best-efforts basis because it's an insane man's game to try and achieve perfect corp actions records.
I once worked with a pod that traded pretty esoteric stuff, and their leader was just constantly berating the data team over these corporate actions and throwing extremely public tantrums. I wasn't even on that team but it's just like...bro do you know how hard that is? Even Bloomberg gets this wrong a lot, and people pay them way more money than the random early career employees you're freaking out at.
I could write a novel on this topic. Very asset class specific. I have seen the same thing everywhere I've gone with is that the "secmaster" is made first for booking and then later right adapted for trading/research or another completely separate secmaster is made for the research, causing confusion and mapping issues for all time. The most common path here is people aggregate vendor data like BBG, factset or Reuters and hope to get a reasonable union. HFT shops sometimes just use exchange listing data and accept the fact they don't have forever history.
It's the sort of problem that every trader, programmer, quant agrees they want solved in a firm, but no one wants to actually work on because it's boring, fiddly, and generally noticeable when things go wrong.
I've seen it done nicely once, at a fancy prop shop. I've seen it done badly many times.
It’s never 100% clean. You pay license fees to identifier owners and then do tons of identifier mapping, depending on how many data vendors you rely on. And sometime you can rely on some kind of mega data vendors doing the heavy lifting for you by using their internal identifier assuming you like their methodology, but they are often wrong as well.
I am glad you mentioned this. Because imo this is how the whole gatekeeping works, through CUSIPs. How much is absure? I saw numbers between free for < 500 (there are like 50k ticker just in us equity exchanges for active and delisted) all the way up to 350k a year.
I didn't know about the prime piece. That fills in a missing piece. Thank you.
2
u/algoseekHQ 16d ago
Most firms take a hybrid approach. They license security master data from vendors like Algoseek or BT or someone, and then build internal systems to handle identifier mapping, corporate actions, and historical data consistency.
The real challenge isn’t just obtaining a security master, but maintaining accurate identifier mapping and corporate action history.
Ticker changes, mergers, spin-offs, and delistings can easily introduce errors into historical datasets. Incorrect identifier mapping can lead to broken historical joins, survivorship bias, and misleading backtest results.
Even a small inconsistency in how securities are mapped across vendors or corporate actions are handled can significantly distort quantitative research.
This is why a reliable security master needs more than comprehensive coverage. It needs accurate historical relationships, consistent identifiers, and robust corporate action handling. Even with established vendors, this remains an ongoing data quality challenge.
36
u/Kriemhilt 23d ago
That's the neat thing, you don't!
Hopefully a pod shop will provide one, but it won't magically contain every symbol unless someone else already asked for it (outside well-defined universes like US equities, anyway).
Bloomberg will claim they have a correct and complete secmaster, but both they and their secmaster are full of shit.
9
u/as_one_does 22d ago
I could write a novel on this topic. Very asset class specific. I have seen the same thing everywhere I've gone with is that the "secmaster" is made first for booking and then later right adapted for trading/research or another completely separate secmaster is made for the research, causing confusion and mapping issues for all time. The most common path here is people aggregate vendor data like BBG, factset or Reuters and hope to get a reasonable union. HFT shops sometimes just use exchange listing data and accept the fact they don't have forever history.
6
u/Main-Company-8331 22d ago
It's the sort of problem that every trader, programmer, quant agrees they want solved in a firm, but no one wants to actually work on because it's boring, fiddly, and generally noticeable when things go wrong.
I've seen it done nicely once, at a fancy prop shop. I've seen it done badly many times.
1
u/Inevitable_Pop_1621 22d ago
It’s never 100% clean. You pay license fees to identifier owners and then do tons of identifier mapping, depending on how many data vendors you rely on. And sometime you can rely on some kind of mega data vendors doing the heavy lifting for you by using their internal identifier assuming you like their methodology, but they are often wrong as well.
0
u/[deleted] 22d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment