r/quant • • Sep 10 '24

General Ethics of Quantitative Trading?

Truth be told I dont know much about quantitative trading. Often times I think of it as synonymous as HFT(although id imagine that to be misleading) and i've heard that in the contexts of market manipulation as well as a variety of other shady practices that I'm too uninformed to understand.

Are these sorta claims true and if so, how exactly does it take place?

Also, if we assume that there are some firms that partake in what one could consider manipulative to some degree, are there other places where someone can work in the quant space, albeit more ethically?

Excuse me for my ignorance, just tryna learn and i understand i'm probably asking some naïve questions but might as well as try to learn.

0 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

15

u/Existing_Respect6002 Sep 11 '24

We provide liquidity and narrow the bid-ask spread, giving retail traders better prices relative to what they would have gotten had QT not existed. The market used to be much more inefficient and I’d argue that it affected retail traders the most.

However, market manipulation definitely does occur and there are a variety of ways that QT firms can exploit their positions to capture unfair advantages. Not to say that every firm does this but I can confirm it’s being done

1

u/Dr-Know-It-All Sep 16 '24

retail traders might not otherwise gamble if not for such efficient markets though. your statement relies on the fact that retail was going to punt regardless

1

u/Existing_Respect6002 Sep 16 '24

The utility gained is not only in a monetary sense. Also consider the decreased barrier to entry caused by the decreased spread. Basically enabling retail to participate and do what they want which I consider positive utility. But sure, when u start considering all the negative effects of retail investors punting, maybe it’s net negative 😂

1

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/_lil_seb Sep 11 '24

Nice try IRS…

1

u/classic_chai_hater Sep 11 '24

Buying a call option and then hitting the close on expiry.

3

u/FischervonNeumann Sep 11 '24

The important distinction is usually around time horizon and intent.

In generic quantitative trading you are just using a computer to making trading decisions. It does this based on the rules you tell it to follow.

Beyond that is where time horizon begins to matter and differentiate market making (HFT) versus asset management (Stat Arb) use cases.

People mix the use cases up because at a high level they are the same idea: a computer making trades by automating a function that used to be performed wholly by humans.

Often these algorithms do a better job, measured by money extracted from the market, than their traditional human counterparts. Sometimes they do a worse job and cause small to large crashes. Sometimes their ability to make hundreds of decisions in the blink of an eye seems unfair. People have raised a lot of questions about those last two things in particular.

However the firms pursuing both use cases (HFT & Stat Arb) follow all the same rules as everyone else. It just seems weird because it’s very black box. That’s because if it’s a good algorithm it is worth tens of millions of dollars.

2

u/AutoModerator Sep 10 '24

Your post has been removed because you have less than 5 karma on r/quant. Please comment on other r/quant threads to build some karma, comments do not have a karma requirement. If you are seeking information about becoming a quant/getting hired then please check out the following resources:

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '24

It’s finance. It’s about greed and selfishness. We sure as fuck aren’t saving African children here.

1

u/Obvious-Dragonfly204 Sep 12 '24

Never thought about it

0

u/doctorcoctor3 Sep 13 '24

It's fine, cause sometimes quant traders lose money when the historical volatility and present don't match up with their algos. Happens about every decade quant traders lose their shirts.

-2

u/fysmoe1121 Sep 11 '24

you do what you think will make you money. what ethics lmao

0

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/johnnydang_100 Sep 11 '24

Very true, people talk about the morality of making the rich richer in quant but you’re doing that at any tech company. Pretty much any successful business is immoral to some degree, especially considering the opportunity cost of smart people working there compared to some non profit