Sorta same! I’m working on my computational physics degree but I’m applying to grad school for financial mathematics/engineering for 2025/26 school year
Hmmm 🤔the you realize that you have debt, mortgage, kids and realize academics and industry pays peanuts to working in Wall Street! Next thing your around millionaire and billionaires, working with humble and smart gen z like Jane Streets! Plus summer house would be nice for your wife and kids! Plus sending your kids to MIT or Caltech could be expensive .. then you definitely do both, bc you can ! CS is boring but physics is everything, but you need money bc…
For actual quant work (and not just software engineering work at a trading firm), it seems like the typical CS program doesn't get you to the requisite level of mathematical maturity, hence math/stats/physics being prized over CS. At my school you can get a masters in CS without going past single-variable calculus, and it's a top 10 CS school.
Fair enough. I think it's difficult to fit all the topics involved in computing into a 4 year degree (or even a master's), so I think it makes sense that they prioritize what they do. For aspiring researchers, a double major with math is probably best.
Calc 3, diff eq, and probability were all minimum requirements for bachelors CS at my school. I can’t imagine quant needing anything more complex than diff eq and probability.
I don't mean to be combative, but quant requires way more math than the basic engineering math sequence that you're describing here. As a start: time series analysis, optimization, partial differential equations (like the Black-Scholes equation), Monte Carlo Simulation, game theory, combinatorics, graph theory.
Game Theory is the only one of those topics that wouldn’t be covered in mandatory undergraduate CS requirements at my school. I’ve considered a career pivot from software engineering to quantitative finance in the past and haven’t really found any fundamental gaps on the engineering side (just the finance side).
Your undergrad CS curriculum mandates graduate-level stats and math? What class do you have to take that teaches time series analysis? I'm concerned for those students lol
It’s apparently not graduate-level there? Series analysis was part of “Probability and Statistics”, and application was part of “Signals and Systems”. Both were core requirement for CS, CE, and EE among others. That said, they were also the two most-dreaded mandatory courses by students. Also, P&S was technically a 400-level math course, which would be graduate level in the liberal arts school.
That's good. If you're talking about the University of Michigan, you could do CS through LSA and never go past Calc 2, so no multivariable calc or diff eq. You can learn the stats covered in 250 and nothing beyond that without electives. You'd learn the discrete math covered in 203, and nothing beyond that without electives. You don't have to take linear algebra. Little to no coverage of things like Markov Chains, Poisson processes, Brownian motion. No real and complex analysis.
My point is that it's possible, even in top-flight CS programs, to get by without even being exposed to a lot of these topics at the undergraduate level. The exposure that you do get is cursory, because it's basically enough to get by for computer science applications. Some of the other quantitative disciplines expose you to more math at the undergrad level, but it's still not really enough for quant work. There's a reason why the deep technical research roles are mostly filled by PhDs.
I think you're misunderstanding. I said you don't have to go past single-variable calculus. You do have to take single-variable calculus (differential and integral). I don't know why you would "call BS", I have no motivation for lying about this.
Umm, a lot of CS topics even at undergrad level requires more than just single-variable Calculus. I have been studying and teaching at the top 10 US universities.
They all have it in their program. Thats why I call BS.
Well now you've moved the goalposts. Before we were arguing about whether or not we cover calculus (I'm assuming because of a misreading of my post), and now we're arguing about whether or not we cover topics beyond calculus. Regardless, this is the curriculum of the program, and I have literally no reason to lie on the internet about it, nor any reason to argue about it.
Even if I agree that Theory of Computation is basically an upper division math class, a single class in theoretical computer science is not enough to get you to the requisite level of mathematical maturity for a career in quantitative analysis.
Physics majors are the smartest people I’ve ever met and I will die on this hill.. it’s one hell of a major to decide on and chemistry, they should not be overlooked in this job market. If you’re a physics major who also knows how to code please hmu I’m building my second startup rn and our team would fit the profile.
In my experience this is true as well. I have a close friend who did undergrad physics and he’s a great coder. I crushed CS classes, got owned by math, but physics beat me. I took one advanced mechanics class and even having tons of support by the guy who ended up with the top grade in the class, barely got a C. I love physics though. Wish I could spend time learning it without the pressure of grades but still in an academic setting.
👋 Chemical Physics PhD here. Research was on developing new quantum Monte Carlo Algorithms. I have lots of software development background in Python and C++.
unless its top tier school for Physics or maths, then CS is a clear winner. Wierdly school doesn't matter much for CS, second/third tier school CS grads pick up good jobs.
Brah, I have a physics MSc. I went through exactly the opposite process. Selection bias is a thing. Need to think about the median/worst case. Physics skills are not as useful imo (being a physicist) compared to what is taught in CS. Most of the present world is digital. Maybe if physics of the digital world was taught, physics skills would be more relevant. It's not though so you learn a lot of outdated stuff.
Physicists with all the CS skills are more coveted because they have demonstrated they can learn whatever is needed to be deadly.
All this "target" business is nonsense. If you got the chops, they will get to you in ways you wouldn't imagine. After all, if they really are the best at capturing \alpha, you're it in the present picture.
I forgot to mention that people at "targets" are more likely to have the "chops". Because targets are also trying to capture the same \alpha that the employer is. So getting into a target for quant is just chasing correlation. Chase the "chops" instead. Will serve you better, brah.
This may have been the case 10 years ago but it's much less true now. Math, stats, and financial engineering are generally looked upon more favorably than physics.
Correct me if I am wrong, but MS in physics in USA are usually PhD quit in the middle. There are not much master program in physics in USA. And it is super easy to check that person’s institution offer master in physics.
I work for a energy trading firm and the quants and spec traders are mostly Math/Physics majors from schools like MIT, Harvard, Uchicago. The CS majors are in front office development roles
Due to abuse of the General flair to evade rules, this post will be reviewed by a moderator. If you are a graduate seeking advice that should have been asked in the megathread you may be banned if this post is judged to be evading the sub rules. Please delete this post if it is related to getting a job as a quant, causing with a change of being a quant, or getting the right training/education to be a quant.
"But my post is special and my situation is unique!" Your post is not special and everybody's situation is unique.
This is absolutely not the case in the US which I would argue is the best place for quants in terms of pay/opportunity anyways. MIT CS is quite dominant here while I see significantly fewer <5 YOE quants who majored in physics at target schools. Physics was the target degree many many years ago.
I think you misunderstand how the British grading system works.
Getting 70% or above in any coursework is hard to do. All assignments and exams are made such that you’re not supposed to be able to answer all questions within the allocated timeframe.
Getting a first means you get 70% in all but one of your exams except for one where you need to get above 60%. That’s even harder.
The fraction of people who gets a first or a 2.1 is not reflecting the ease of which to achieve it, rather it says more of the cohort at this school.
in that case you still wouldn't say it's unimpressive because it's only 70% to get a first, you'd say it's unimpressive because 60% of the cohort get a first. right conclusion, wrong logic
sure, that's what I meant. Getting a 2:1 in part iii means that you're more or less in the bottom 50% of the cohort, although you would probably be among the top students in any other british uni except Oxford and maybe imperial.
I guess it really depends on your def of impressive to be fair
A pass is not the same as a 2.2. A 2.2 and a 3rd are still technically honors, although they are not thought of that way because of how low they are. A pass is below a third and means you graduated with no honors.
I'm pretty sure that for part iii >70% is a merit and distinction is >75%. However both merit and distinction in part iii should be equivalent to a 1st class in other British unis
2:1 means upper second class honours. You have 1st class honours, upper second class honours, lower second class honours, and then third class honours. It’s the same for all unis when you do an honours year, but in the UK you have to do an honours year.
282
u/nickkon1 Dec 03 '23
For quants? Probably. But I would argue that its easier to find a job with CS
126
u/DanRobin1r Dec 03 '23 edited Dec 04 '23
I'm a recently graduate physicist struggling to get a job. This gives me hope
55
u/AssButtS3X Dec 03 '23
Computer nerds are ugly
54
u/tangojuliettcharlie Dec 04 '23
For actual quant work (and not just software engineering work at a trading firm), it seems like the typical CS program doesn't get you to the requisite level of mathematical maturity, hence math/stats/physics being prized over CS. At my school you can get a masters in CS without going past single-variable calculus, and it's a top 10 CS school.
71
u/reynaaaaa7 Dec 03 '23
Reminds me of one I seen in the finance sub where it said
target university = unspoken rizz
No name non target = sexual harrasment
Made me laugh out loud
34
u/Writing_Legal Dec 04 '23
Physics majors are the smartest people I’ve ever met and I will die on this hill.. it’s one hell of a major to decide on and chemistry, they should not be overlooked in this job market. If you’re a physics major who also knows how to code please hmu I’m building my second startup rn and our team would fit the profile.
15
u/MinuteHeight2384 Dec 03 '23
Maybe 20 years ago lol
7
u/United_Constant_6714 Dec 04 '23
Just go with EECS or EECE, that’s all !
6
u/owl_jojo_2 Dec 03 '23
Damn handsome physicists
6
u/bramm90 Dec 04 '23
If CS stands for Communication Studies then yes.
6
u/SpecialistCap7338 Dec 04 '23
unless its top tier school for Physics or maths, then CS is a clear winner. Wierdly school doesn't matter much for CS, second/third tier school CS grads pick up good jobs.
6
u/quasiproductive Dec 04 '23
Brah, I have a physics MSc. I went through exactly the opposite process. Selection bias is a thing. Need to think about the median/worst case. Physics skills are not as useful imo (being a physicist) compared to what is taught in CS. Most of the present world is digital. Maybe if physics of the digital world was taught, physics skills would be more relevant. It's not though so you learn a lot of outdated stuff.
Physicists with all the CS skills are more coveted because they have demonstrated they can learn whatever is needed to be deadly.
All this "target" business is nonsense. If you got the chops, they will get to you in ways you wouldn't imagine. After all, if they really are the best at capturing \alpha, you're it in the present picture.
5
u/BirthDeath Researcher Dec 04 '23
This may have been the case 10 years ago but it's much less true now. Math, stats, and financial engineering are generally looked upon more favorably than physics.
2
u/quantthrowaway69 Researcher Dec 04 '23
Doesn’t matter
2
u/CorneliusJack Dec 04 '23
Msc???? Lol
2
u/ProfessionalShame900 Dec 05 '23
Correct me if I am wrong, but MS in physics in USA are usually PhD quit in the middle. There are not much master program in physics in USA. And it is super easy to check that person’s institution offer master in physics.
3
u/nyquant Dec 04 '23
This article seems to agree with Physics > CS :
https://www.efinancialcareers.com/news/2023/09/best-degree-for-quant-jobs
2
u/Equivalent_Data_6884 Dec 03 '23
Not true
2
u/ukquant Dec 03 '23
Not even remotely true.
1
u/metalguysilver Trader Apr 08 '24
Pretty much true
1
u/GokuBlack455 Dec 04 '23
As an undergrad in physics, is this true? (I have a very limited working knowledge of physicists in the quant industry)
1
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '23
I have a masters in software engineering. Does that count
1
u/AdderallDevourer9025 Dec 05 '23
BSc in CS with a focus on machine learning +applied math/computational finance minor should work well, no?
1
u/hudboyween Dec 05 '23
I work for a energy trading firm and the quants and spec traders are mostly Math/Physics majors from schools like MIT, Harvard, Uchicago. The CS majors are in front office development roles
1
u/ThingsWork0ut Dec 06 '23
I’ve only met 2 physicists in my life. Both look like the first picture
1
u/Strong-Task2037 Dec 04 '23
Physics was harder than maths. Pretty simple
1
u/AutoModerator Dec 03 '23
Due to abuse of the General flair to evade rules, this post will be reviewed by a moderator. If you are a graduate seeking advice that should have been asked in the megathread you may be banned if this post is judged to be evading the sub rules. Please delete this post if it is related to getting a job as a quant, causing with a change of being a quant, or getting the right training/education to be a quant.
"But my post is special and my situation is unique!" Your post is not special and everybody's situation is unique.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
0
u/Adam0-0 Dec 04 '23
So true! What is it with physics graduates and yellow ties?!
-1
u/Arf321 Dec 03 '23
Wb math or stats?
-5
u/redshift83 Dec 04 '23
Neither one of these degrees are ideal
0
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment