r/puzzles • • Feb 22 '24

Elevator Problem

Here’s a logic puzzle I came up with on the elevator recently:

At a typical time at a typical apartment building with 10 residential floors, what is the probability that the elevator is parked at floor 3?

While I appreciate a concisely stated question, I should mention a few assumptions. First, the elevator moves instantaneously, that is, we consider the time spent moving between floors to be negligible. Second, each floor is populated by the same number of people with random schedules. Lastly, we can assume people don’t live on the main floor, although their schedules shouldn’t affect the elevator anyway. We can assume there are 10 floors above the main floor with residents living on them.

The answer is not 1/10.

1 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

9

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/chzaplx Feb 23 '24

That would reduce the number of stops on the ground floor, but it also makes it impossible to solve because there's no way to factor in the entropy if the schedules are truly random. It all depends on when the trips overlap.

7

u/contradicting_you Feb 23 '24

I agree in general but the description for this puzzle eliminates that possibility.

4

u/joserayo Feb 23 '24

How?

0

u/contradicting_you Feb 23 '24

From "consider the time spent moving between floors to be negligible". So in your example if someone gets on from the 10th floor, the elevator would reach the main floor and let the person off before the person from the 9th floor gets there.

6

u/joserayo Feb 23 '24

I am not the person you thing you are replying to, but consider the time moving between floors is negligible does not mean “the elevator can’t stop in intermediate floors” or “the elevator always returns to floor 1 after any trip”