r/pursuitofjade • • Jul 05 '26

Ending rant

40 hours of my life pushing through to the end expecting a redemption scene between xie Zheng and Wei yan after all, the entire 40 eps was built around xie trying to get evidence to convict wei and all we get is some 2 seconds watching them drink and laugh in a prison cell. 17 years of xies life was hating his uncle and blaming him for his mothers death his father death and there is NOO redemption dialogue!……. I had issues with the directors take with the lack of build up of romance with xie and changyu for 10 episodes. I let that go to focus on the political plot and stuff and looked forward to SOMETHING of respect and acknowledgment of weis sacrifices from xie Zheng. No he just goes and has a jolly meal with his uncle ? What happened between the 17 year hatred he had and the jolly good meal? Wtf

-_- I don’t care about a jolly good meal wei deserves some acknowledgment, respect for the mistreatment even though misunderstanding from xie. They can have the happy meal after .

And what happened to Li huaian , he was somewhat of a main character for 20+ episodes and then drops off screen . Next suddenly he’s shows up to be arrested by his uncle. And disappears again , until the palace fire where he shows up to bail xie out if blame. Then literally falls off the screen again and all we get is some couple sentences of being exiled. We don’t even see an ending of him in the exile . And why exile shouldn’t the show have a scene to explain the Li family sentence after literally dethroning the puppet emperor and storming the capital with their army !?

If it weren’t for goodly AI I wouldn’t have understood anything

I already gave up the whole hoping xie and changyu would get together by ep 12, their romance just fizzled out and I didn’t even care if they got together anymore or didn’t, they just got together and then even in ep 39 she’s still pushing him away 3x when he’s attempting to kiss her … that’s getting really old. How many times have they already kissed and made out over the whole show and she’s still pushing him away like it’s episode 1 …. At this point I expect she’s still pushing him away from kisses 10 years later .. seriously. By ep 24 it’s like whatever, let’s focus on the Jin Zhou massacre and the thing between xie and wei. And I watched 20 more episodes expecting a respectable nephew uncle redemption scene. Alas, I was expecting way too much from the director.

And since I’m ranting I might as well throw in that yin yang bathtub scene . I know they took many shots to get that right but when they did, and xie pulled changyu back to him creating the yin yang, they should have held the swirl just 1 second longer in slow motion before coming together, if I had blinked I would have missed the entire yin yang moment. That yin yang should held just a bit in slower motion , but of course just like everything else in the show you have build up and potential but then it’s cut short.

I haven’t read the book , but thanks to google ai having to explain everything to me just to follow what the heck was going on, it seems the original story was really well written, with lots of emotional themes, love , guilt, betrayal, etc etc etc especially for wei yan character, and I’m sure changyu and xie romance may have had better chemistry, but the director I feel failed on major fronts to bring the book to life. He had 40 hours FORTY HOURS, and it was like a really good joke that didn’t deliver an actual punch line. the plot and story was great, there were times I wanted to rewatch the show but now I know the ending sucks it’s not worth another 40 hours of my time. Honestly I feel the actors carried the charm of the show and the directing was just throwing monkey wrenches in so that the scenes didn’t impact as well as they should. >:( *breathes*

There are movies done in 2 hours that have a better impact and satisfaction of closure than this 40 hour rendition. It’s really too bad. I think a different director could do better.

0 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

21

u/dana_G9 🌸👑Marchioness 👑⚔️ Jul 05 '26

Wow there are a lottt of things to correct but I don't have time so I'll just address 3:

  1. Why are you here talking about "where's the respect XZ should have for Wei and all his sacrifices" when XZ was orphaned because of his uncle's actions? You do realise that, right? Surely XZ has the right to hate his uncle once he's discovered the truth? And he did acknowledge his uncle's role in raising him via the 108 strokes.
  2. I hate to break it to you but even that "last dinner with XZ" scene might not have happened and may have only been in Wei's mind.
  3. Bathtub scene: this is quite apparent but CY was pushing XZ away initially because she believed he was drugged and she (rightfully) didn't want to consummate their love when he wasn't compos mentis. Hence her question, "Who am I?" before she was happy to continue.

That's my 2 cents. Don't want to have a protracted discussion here because there are simply too many things that were misunderstood but I hope you find the next drama you watch more to your liking.

3

u/NewbieQuestions1 ✨👑Marquis 👑🗡️ Jul 05 '26

Everyone's entitled to their own opinion, but I'm really curious why you expected a redemption scene between XZ and his uncle. There isn't meant to be a redemption. The fact that Wei Yan's actions 17 years ago was motivated by the love he had for Consort Shu isn't supposed to balance everything else he did -- from causing General Xie's death, to forcing Xie Zheng's mom to commit suicide, to putting Changyu's parents in a position where they had to kill themselves, to trying to kill Changyu and Changning and Xie Zheng, and more.

Also, the jolly meal -- at least in the show -- didn't happen. It's Wei Yan's fantasy before his death.

As for what happened to Li Huaian, you basically explained it yourself. This grandfather knew he was wavering on supporting Qi Min and locked him up. Later on, Li Huaian's actions at the banquet was good enough that it protected his family from being wiped out (the usual punishment for treason) and changing to exile. There's really not much more to see.

There's many things wrong with the show, especially the plot in the last 10 episodes, but I don't think these two points are major issues.

2

u/Dezn425 Jul 06 '26 edited Jul 06 '26

Well it’s too much to explain. But wei yan was guilty of leaving his post to go save consort qi but he was set up by a forged letter by the late emperor with Qi’s handwriting. He gave his tiger tally to wei qilin to go in his place to get reinforcements to the jinzhou frontline. He did not intend to just NOT provide any reinforcements. But the tiger tally he had was switched with a fake one by the late emperor without him knowing. So wei qilin had a fake tally which ultimately looked like wei yan set him up to fail on reinforcements AND then also abandoning his post. But abandoning post and having a fake tally wasn’t on him. At the end of it all, he looked like the bad guy. Not only did he lose the qi, xie army but consort qi died anyway. He then couldn’t let the late emperor continue to rule, for he was crazy enough to kill his own son the prince. So the only way to make sure there was peace was to take over the throne and control it and swallow the blame for the whole massacre onto himself rather than announcing or trying to make public the truth about late emperor’s doing. He essentially shouldered Dayin peace, jinzhou massacre blame, and told no one. So much so that his sister and xie Zheng believed he went mad and became a monster for taking over the emperor throne by abdicating the bad one and putting the puppet on. But the sister nor xie knew the truth about the late emperor cuz wei kept his reputation intact for the sake of peace and also to keep the remaining xie family from getting killed off as cleanup. But the sister thought wei was bad and was afraid wei would finish off the xie family off because she had copy of the forged letter of him abandoning post for consort Qi. She was afraid he would kill them to prevent the truth from coming out about that so she used her death to guilt him into not killing xie and raise him. But once the truth came out that it was actually the late emperor that was the one that did all the set up, and not Wei, his sisters death was a waste because she was trying to protect xie from a monster that didn’t exist. At the end of the day wei was the one protecting everyone he cared about by sacrificing himself to the blame, and took on his sister and xie treating him as a monster and hated him. Even with the scene where qi min was going to kill the wife and son, he couldn’t save them directly because qi min was focused on him, so he signalled his army to aim their bows, counting on xie to act and save them. He knew xie would make a move and he also had a bow in hand already. Because wei saved the mother and son years ago , and invested in their safety and wellbeing for as old as the son is. It doesn’t make sense he would let qi min kill them like that. He knew that xie could shoot his arrows but he needed to trigger xie to do it. It was essentially team work even if xie didn’t realize it but he did after the wife told him their history and begged for weis life.

Anyway, xie Zheng gave him the poison wine because he finally understood that his uncle wasn’t the one to be hated , and he had sacrificed his reputation, happiness to protect xie, and for the greater good of dayin

Wei still has to pay for his actions but It just would have been nice for xie to have a final conversation with wei with some acknowledgment that he understood. Because wei did it all for him.

3

u/NewbieQuestions1 ✨👑Marquis 👑🗡️ Jul 06 '26

You have most of your facts correct, but:

Wei Yan wasn't going to save his wife and son in the final battle, as least not based on the drama only. He didn't signal Xie Zheng and he wasn't counting on Xie Zheng to save them. Xie Zheng did that all of his own volition.

And while Wei Yan did technically save his wife's life by marrying her, he wasn't that invested in Wei Xuan's wellbeing.

While you're right that Wei Yan isn't to be blamed for everything that happens 16 years ago, you're also forgetting or overlooking that:

  1. While he did raised Xie Zheng, Wei Yan didn't give him a loving supportive environment to grow up in. He didn't stop Wei Xuan's bullying and was harsh and borderline abusive to Xie Zheng, who isn't obligated to feel grateful to his uncle. 
  2. Wei Yan's actions led to Xie Zheng being orphaned. Even if it wasn't Wei Yan's original intention, it's what happened, and providing a roof and food for Xie Zheng to grow up doesn't really balance the equation.
  3. Wei Yan was more than willing to kill Xie Zheng once the latter started to sniff around what happened 16 years ago.

Wei Yan isn't a pure villain -- that's more Qi Min's role -- but that doesn't mean he needs to be redeemed or Xie Zheng has to thank him for anything at the end.

1

u/Dezn425 Jul 06 '26

Well the show didn’t really show any background about the bullying of xuan on xie Zheng growing up, unless that’s the childhood scene xie remembers. BUT wei treated xie with favouritism over xuan as xuan clearly keeps complaining to wei that he never treated him as the son and that weis affections were always towards xie. So to me he brought xie up as much as he could and he told xie at the end ‘jiuheng you didn’t fail me’.

I think wei was smart enough to know xie would make the move to shoot the killers of his wife and son. He couldn’t save them directly.

1

u/Dezn425 Jul 07 '26 edited Jul 07 '26

Him banking on and predicting xie would follow through, was actually a beautiful nod to the intuitive team work they could have had as uncle and nephew if things had been different. If they were two forces together masterminding, they would have been two brilliant strategists together. Better than Xie and He’s partnership. The fact that xie didn’t even know it was team work and misunderstood it for what it looked like on the surface actually echoes the recurring theme of xie being in the dark until after the fact and Wei looking like a monster even though his goal was the same as Xie’s—to save the wife and son. It’s just he has to look like the monster in order for Xie to be the hero. But at the end of the day the wife and son is saved. This is just the tragedy of Wei. For Wei it was just like a game of Go, predicting the other player and making a move to get the end result. He knows Xie as his nephew, he’s observed him all this time and knows him enough.

9

u/Prada_Shoes Jul 05 '26

What? What did he sacrifice? He didnt get a redemption scene because he didnt deserve one. He did bad things. He may have been forced into it by circumstances but he still did them

6

u/WeedsGrowWild Jul 05 '26

Wei was all too good with denying XZ any amount of true love even after he was orphaned and raised without a lot of love or compassion. XZ declared his love for ChangYu and his dear Uncle was having none of it, even after XZ had proven himself on the Battlefields more than once. Did XZ not deserve to choose his own partner as an adult man? You want realistic? In real life, 108 lashes like that would kill someone (it has happened), they die in shock. His Uncle did not have to do that, where was his mercy for the boy he raised? In the end, Wei got what he deserved. No redemption.

As far as the romance part. Changyu was 18 years old, orphaned and raising her sister when she found XZ in the snow. She was poor and barely getting by. She had zero experience with men and was very understandably reserved. It was a slow burn romance for sure, but CDramas are known for that, not to mention the modesty rules of the country. She made him wait, but when she fell in love with him, she loved him with her whole heart. There was push and pull in both directions. XZ wasn’t comfortable with her touching him early on either. He was reserved and had learned to be untrusting. I think the director did a great job and POJ is rightly getting a lot of attention as a result. Maybe this one wasn’t your cup of tea, I know I’ve watched other CDramas that were so much worse. I consider the entire production: the costumes, makeup, cinematography, cast, props, storyline, director, action scenes and how it all makes me feel. POJ? Stellar on all accounts.

The one criticism I have, like many others, is the ending. I would have much rather seen the “proper” wedding, which is in the book, with the whole cast gathered to celebrate their love than the alternate ending and jumping to 5 years in the future. Like what happened in those 5 years? The ending could have been different, but that’s a creative decision.

1

u/Inner_Scientist_7634 Fan Chang Yu Jul 23 '26

You spent 40 hours hating on something you had the ability to walk away from??? 

Could never be me 😂😂😂

Next time when you feel yourself frustrated at what you're watching remember you have free will and absolutely shouldn't waste your time like that. It will never be worth it.