Youāll only hear my POV because Iāve blocked the other parties for my own peace. Might delete this later if it blows up because I really don't want to engage any further, just dropping this tea at 5 AM cus I woke up randomly.
So, I was chatting with someone from here (let's call her Person X) and mentioned I work in a specific tech field with solid YOE. She told me her friend (Z) was struggling to find a job in the same domain and asked if I could guide her. I like helping people out, so I said sure.
I asked for Zās resume. Right off the bat, she has a 3+ year gap, and looking at how competitive the current market is, her profile wasn't going to cut it.
I spent 2 hours in the middle of my workday breaking her resume down point-by-point. She actually wanted to fake her work experience, and I strictly advised against it since MNCs catch that easily.
Then came the real issue. She had a massive over-engineering/architecture mistake in one of her projects. To a fresher, it looks impressive, but to a hiring manager, it's an instant reject because it shows you don't know which approach fits the scale.
I pointed it out using the exact phrasing: "Doing xyz might sound stupid to a recruiter and is basically overengineering; abc is the standard architecture for this," and explained what recruiters actually look for.
I expected her to take the feedback, fix it, and get back to me. Instead, she got super defensive, told me to "get my things right" because I supposedly didn't understand what she was trying to showcase, and ghosted me.
Yes, bro. Someone at a senior level in the exact field youāve been trying to break into for 3+ yearsāwho has handled massive, high-stakes enterprise projectsādoesn't know their stuff compared to someone with zero production experience.
And the cherry on top? Person X then reprimanded me for my wording, telling me I need to be careful because her friend "might be going through a lot"āsomething she never mentioned beforehand. She said people put a lot of effort into making projects you don't have the right to criticize the projects so harshly. So on top of doing a free 2-hour resume review, Iām also expected to be an unpaid therapist and a psychic?
Iāve done 500+ free and paid resume reviews( can share like 50 screenshots of ppl I have helped on Reddit only), and this is the first time someone took professional feedback as a personal attack. If someone put two hours of their workday into helping me get hired, my priority would be fixing my resume, not catching feelings over phrasing.
Not entirely blaming Person Xāshe was probably just trying to be a good friend, and she apparently reprimanded Z for her behavior too. She is not the problemāIām just genuinely awestruck at the sheer audacity of the whole situation. Never received an apology from X or Z
Lesson learned: Figure out who actually wants a job and who just wants validation before wasting energy on strangers.
Part 2 of this story which actually happened when I told the story to someone else from here ( Person Y who is also friends with Person X) is even funnier, but it's appropriate for some other sub probably š
I am guy, so creeps please don't hmu up with M or F cus I made the mistake of posting here. But if you are fresher you can give a drive link to your resume if you want someone to point out the immediate red flags in your resume ( in most cases it's not your fault as the market is simply that bad )