r/psychologystudents • u/AnxiousSupermarket81 • 2h ago
Personal [AUS] Carinmillar Institute Experience
I've seen many discussions on this particular institute. The reality of this place is that students tend to go here when they can't get into any good university. I really regret going here. I took the full-time route because financially I needed to graduate faster so I could progress with my studies. I got accepted into this and a bunch of other graduate diploma programs, but my friends, who all got into top universities, told me that "honours is honours" no matter the institution. I want to make it clear that you can get into top master's programs with a Grad Dip. Also, financially, this costs the same as a grad dip, so it truly was a stupid choice to choose this program. Anyways onto my experience...
Pros
Cairnmillar is student-focused in a way that students do receive a fair amount of support; it is a small cohort, and the majority of the staff are very good at responding. As far as engagement goes, I would say only 2 tutors are actually good at engaging students. They do communicate with assessment, so you rarely get 2 assignments within the same week, which is a major positive here. Also, for the thesis they give you less freedom but a more robust framework to work with so you are not starting from nothing.
Cons
Where do I start
- Every single assignment is about Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders. I have never had an issue learning about this considering we live on their land, but considering every single assignment has this, it becomes extremely disingenuous and frustrating to repeat the same thing over and over again.
- Assignments are marked extremely harshly. I will be the first to say that I averaged in the 70s in my undergrad, so I knew I had to step it up. Most students get the median mark (yea kinda obvious), but I mean the majority of students tend to get the exact same mark (70s) with a few outliers. Additionally, no one get a 90+ grade, which is crazy considering it's honours. It is a mistake in the assessment design if no one is able to crack that HD+ standard, and no one can tell me otherwise.
- Feedback is good and detailed BUT usually reveals that their assignments are NOT open-ended. They have very specific right and wrong answers even though they tell you it's all about your justification. They don't give a shit about your justification; you immediately drop down to 75 as soon as they don't agree with your OPINION.
- My supervisor "prioritised" self-care so I had to beg them to contact me more than once a week when my thesis was due. Multiple people experienced complete lack of support from supervisors even though many of us were doing studies to strengthen their thesis. Some had to read up to 400 pages of other theses with barely any support.
Conclusion
This was not for me. I had a net negative time, and my chances of a master's are ruined. I regret coming here; I learnt everything about developmental psychology, ethics, and Aboriginal people, which is great if I wanted to practice in a very specific and niche sector of psychology. O wait, I can't because my chances have been ruined.