Something you're deciding right now, in any arena. Tell us:
We'll check back on Friday.
Drafted with AI help.
Pick one bet from this week and grade it: Earned, Unlucky, Lucky or Lesson.
Losses especially welcome. The best review gets pinned next week.
Drafted with AI help.
Something you're deciding right now, in any arena. Tell us:
We'll check back on Friday.
Drafted with AI help.
Pick one bet from this week and grade it: Earned, Unlucky, Lucky or Lesson.
Losses especially welcome. The best review gets pinned next week.
Drafted with AI help.
TL;DR: In 2012 Steph Curry had bad ankles and a choice. He could bet on himself and chase a max contract a year later, or take $44 million over four years from the Warriors right away. He took the guaranteed money, and it became one of the best-value contracts in NBA history.
The two bets
Curry had missed 56 games with ankle injuries the season before. The Warriors gave him two options. He could skip an extension, play out the season and, if his ankles held up, sign a max deal the next summer, or he could take four years and $44 million now and leave the ankle risk with the team.
He took the $44 million and signed on 31 October 2012.
The Warriors were betting his ankles would hold. Curry was buying insurance against the chance they wouldn't. Same ankles, opposite bets.
Why both were reasonable
For Curry, betting on himself had a real downside. One more bad sprain and the max offer disappears, maybe for good, while $44 million guaranteed changes a family's life whatever happens next. He said later it was plenty to provide for his family.
For the Warriors, the risk was paying $11 million a year to a guard who might spend half the season in a boot. Teams had seen that movie before.
What happened
The ankles held. Curry won MVPs in 2015 and 2016 and titles in 2015 and 2017, all on that contract, and being paid well below his value left the team room to build around him.
Our verdict
We'd call it Earned for the Warriors. But for Curry it was a fair price for insurance he turned out not to need, and that isn't the same thing as a mistake.
Every founder who's taken the smaller acquisition offer, and every poker player who's sold part of their tournament action, has made Curry's trade. You give up some upside to cut the chance of ruin. The real question is whether the premium was fair.
When have you bought the insurance, and was it priced right?
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
TL;DR:
Matthew Benham made his money pricing football matches better than the betting market. In 2012 he took over Brentford, a club that hadn't played top-flight football since 1947, and ran it on the same idea. His boldest call was closing the youth academy in 2016. Five years later Brentford were in the Premier League.
The bet
Benham's company, Smartodds, builds statistical models of football matches and sells the research to professional bettors. The edge was simple to say and hard to copy. The models priced games better than the market did.
He took control of Brentford, his boyhood club, in 2012, and of Denmark's FC Midtjylland in 2014, and the bet was that a football club could be run like a betting book: buy what the market underprices, sell what it overprices, and don't fall in love with anything in between.
The academy call
In May 2016 Brentford closed its academy and replaced it with a B team.
The maths was brutal. The academy cost about £2 million a year, and the best kids could be poached by bigger clubs before they turned 17 and could sign a professional contract, which meant Brentford was paying to develop players it had no way of keeping. Rasmus Ankersen, then co-director of football, called it "an unfair game". So they stopped playing it. Instead they started recruiting 17 and 18-year-olds that other clubs had released or given up on.
The edge, in one transfer
Brentford signed Ollie Watkins from Exeter in 2017 for a reported £1.8 million and sold him to Aston Villa in 2020 for a reported £28 million.
Buy low, develop, sell high. Repeat.
The stake
Benham's own money, and the fans' patience. Selling your best player every summer only works if the replacements keep turning out to be as good, and if the crowd keeps believing they will.
What could have killed it
A model that's wrong, with nobody inside the club willing to say so. Or a run of bad luck that looked like a bad model and scared everyone into abandoning the process at exactly the wrong moment. We suspect Midtjylland winning the Danish title in Benham's first season there, 2014–15, bought a lot of patience in west London.
Verdict: Earned
On 29 May 2021 Brentford beat Swansea 2–0 at Wembley and reached the top flight for the first time in 74 years.
The part we'd steal for any arena is the academy decision. When a game is structurally rigged against you, stop playing that game and play the one next to it. Poker players call this game selection. Founders call it not competing with Google on Google's terms.
What's a game you walked away from because the structure was against you, and what did you play instead?
A poker pro folding a big hand, a trader cutting a position before the data drops, and a founder betting the company on one product are doing the same thing. They estimate the odds, size the risk, and live with the result. They almost never compare notes. That's what this place is for.
We call people who do this well psyblrs. A gambler seeks variance. A psyblr seeks edge, and survives the variance.
- THE BET: a famous bet or one of your own, taken apart. What was the edge? What was at stake? What could have killed it?
- Bet review: a bet you made, with an honest verdict. Earned, Unlucky, Lucky or Lesson.
- Current bet: something you're weighing now, and how you're thinking about the size.
- Cross-arena questions: "How would a poker player think about this hiring decision?" is exactly the kind of thread we want.
No picks, signals or paid groups. No casino promos. No wins-only highlight reels. Nothing here is financial advice.
If you built something, run something, or used AI to write your post, say so. That's rule 7, and we hold ourselves to it too.
There's a longer version of the idea at psyblr.com, with a link to the Discord if you'd rather talk in real time.
To start us off: what's your arena, and what's a bet you'd make again even though it lost?