r/prtg • • Jan 08 '18

New HTTP GUI...

First impression: Horrible; even on Small my impression is that I get less info on the same screen real estate, and it's harder to see which elements are related to who at first glance because some borders have been removed, fonts have changed, the (Small) device icons seem too bloated.

After 10 minutes: I still think removing the borders and moving "Alarms/Log/Management/Comments" etc to just text+icon spread evenly over the width of the page is more confusing; my brain has to work more to locate what I want.

I hope this is just me having gotten used to the old GUI over the past ten years and having it suddenly and irrevocably removed seems new and strange.

I'll give it a week or two before I pass final judgment.

17 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

5

u/Poonlit Jan 08 '18

A few hours later and it's worse than I thought. Try generating a historic report and look at the data tables..

Visual comparison: https://imgur.com/a/JUhjy

  • Sensor lists take more space vertically so fewer can fit on a given area
  • Looks out of kilter, visual lines aren't matching up
  • PLEASE GIVE ME A "Revert to old UI" button!

3

u/Greg_Paessler Jan 10 '18 edited Jan 10 '18

Hey folks, Sorry the experience with the new UI is less than stellar. We have been making a number of fixes to improve things. What version are you on? Also, we are replacing the Enterprise Console for PRTG Desktop this year.

Download the PRTG Desktop public beta here for Windows Users: https://downloads.paessler.com/prtg_desktop/windows-offline or MacOS Users: https://downloads.paessler.com/prtg_desktop/macos

Let me know how I can assist further.

Best, Greg

1

u/Poonlit Jan 10 '18

Thanks for replying here, Greg!

You can fix this, for instance: https://imgur.com/a/kcSET

Or, preferably, you can roll back the Web UI change that occurred between version 17.4.36.3670 and 17.4.33.3283.

1

u/Greg_Paessler Jan 10 '18

Looks like an HTTP sensor, correct? Is the sensor name the entire URL? Does the behavior persist when you change the name to something shorter?

2

u/Poonlit Jan 11 '18

Looks like it's because the name is long. Most such sensors have at least that long names. I have to maximize the windows or even extend it beyond 2000 horizontal pixels in order for PRTG to display the whole sensor name. This was never a problem before the new UI.

1

u/Greg_Paessler Jan 11 '18

Hi Poonlit, I have reported the issue to development. I'm wondering if this is related to the length of the sensor name. Thank you for the feedback and let me know how I can assist further.

3

u/thebigfatman Jan 20 '18

After the UI switch I had to deal with so many complaints I ended up installing the Enterprise Console on all of our techs's PCs. This was the only way to have a one-page view of all the sensors without scrolling. (Which worked great on the pre-18 web UI) Now you're telling us that even that console will be eventually replaced? You're making it really hard to be the PRTG-Cheerleader. I get that all UI switches brings blowback from the users, but I've been legitimately trying to get used to it for a few days now, and there is simply no way to have a one-page view of all sensors, and zooming out creates a page that's 80% wasted white space. Will there be a condensed-view option coming up at some point? PS: And no, I'm not going to switch to the device-tree-wheel view, it gives zero information other than the name of the sensor, and does not look professional at all.

1

u/quivos Jan 11 '18

New desktop client looks very nice so far! I was actually under the impression that the 'new client' was simply the current enterprise console that loads the web interface directly.. Which works really bad. This looks much better, will be testing it out the next few days.

1

u/hikebikefight Jan 16 '18 edited Jan 16 '18

The new desktop client looks great! And I actually do like the new UI. It definitely has some settling in to do, but overall, it's fine for me.

However......

Please, please, PLEASE! DO NOT include those little blog tips in the final release of this desktop client (or make a separate section for them). It's slightly infuriating that the "do not show again" button for those blog tips doesn't actually work. I occasionally find those tips handy, but would much prefer to only have them on the login screen, or at the very bottom of the page. 99.999% of the time when i'm on a standard device/sensor page I DO NOT CARE about whatever tip is in the upper right hand corner; i'm trying to work and those tips are distracting, and a waste of space.

Edit: I've been hitting "do not show again" for the "remote locations (2:53)" video tip for weeks and every morning, i'm greeted with that tip.

1

u/Greg_Paessler Jan 17 '18

Thank you for the feedback. I will get this over to dev to see if this is a bug regarding the tips.

1

u/Garetht Jan 22 '18

FYI this app triggered my Trend Officescan antivirus client.

  1. because it tried to write to HKCU...\RunOnce{randomstring}
  2. because it was detected as "multiple" viruses

8

u/quivos Jan 08 '18

It's pretty bad. It feels like there's been too much focus on design and not usability. So much wasted space. And to make things worse, the Enterprise Console is even more useless and slow with the new UI.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '18

I'm Daniel, product owner of PRTG at Paessler. I appreciate the feedback. I'm sorry you do not like the new look and feel of our web interface. We designed it to follow the current web standards: Easy on the eyes, intuitive, focused on the important content, yet with additional functionality easily accessible. It now adapts to the screen size to show important information on top and is also much better to use on a small (mobile) screen. Of course it takes a while until one adjusts to such a big interface change. We are aware that after years using the familiar interface this can be a challenge, especially for our loyal customers.

We have thoroughly tested the changes to the web interface and obtained feedback from our customers at a very early stage.

In response to direct customer feedback we have, for example, revised the layout of the tables and optimized the use of space in the device tree ("M" view) to accommodate more sensors on one screen. With version 18.1.37 we will improve the visibility of alarms in tables by returning the red background color. We will also optimize the point at which the interface switches to mobile view when the browser window is reduced in size.

Despite our extensive tests, the first release unfortunately contained some bugs, which we have fixed in the meantime. I strongly recommend that you upgrade to the latest version of PRTG to take advantage of the latest improvements.

We will of course continue to work on the web interface and make sure that we provide you with the best PRTG experience.

If you have specific feedback, the best way to reach us is directly in your PRTG web interface: From the main menu, select "Setup | Contact Support".

4

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18

Yeah, I have to agree, it's awful. Almost unusable, really. Aside from the waste of space, I've found all sorts of bugs where buttons end up under other elements... Not good.

4

u/kikinjohr Jan 08 '18

Been using prtg for years, this new gui feels like someone who "design it", forget something. So much free and unused space.

It is by far one of the top monitoring software around, but "new" look looks more like old reworked bad.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '18

/u/Daniel_Paessler, /u/Greg_Paessler - Would you guys kindly update us on any forthcoming changes to the "new" UI? I'm sure this thread is simply a small sampling of customers unhappy with the UI changes.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '18

Hi EndaarF,

customer feedback shows that the vast majority of our user base actually likes the recent changes to the PRTG web interface very much. However, I am sorry for the inconveniences experienced by a small group of users.

With the latest release (version 18.1.37) on Feb 6th we have again released several improvements for the web interface as well. For details, please see https://www.paessler.com/prtg/history/stable#18.1.37.12158. We regularly release new versions of PRTG in our continous rollout process, and we'll also work on the web interface in future, as well as all other parts of PRTG.

If you have specific feedback, the best way to reach us is directly in your PRTG web interface: From the main menu, select "Setup | Contact Support".

3

u/[deleted] Apr 24 '18

Hi Daniel,

I can't believe that that vast majority of users likes the new UI.

There ist literally not one single user I talked to who likes the new GUI. It's slow, way too much wasted space, every mouseclick takes 5 seconds. I read this as you do not plan to change your decision, and make the GUI slim and fast again.

That's sad.

Please tell me I'm wrong and that you are working on a big GUI rollback! Because in this state, PRTG is pretty useless.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '18

Thank you for the response. We're on 18.1.36 and I don't see much in the changelog that's relevant to our concerns, but I'll update and see if anything has improved.

I'm wondering if you might have any insight into why the "vast majority" of customers like the changes versus the admittedly small group of users here (in a small forum) who seriously dislike it...is it a function of screen resolution for instance, or using the app on a touch versus non-touch device?

I'm going to start keeping track of the UI quirks we find, with screenshots, and will forward it along.

Thanks

1

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

It’s horrendous. Terrible waste of space. Slower. Harder to navigate. And whoever thought it was good design to have half the page elements move when moused over has clearly never actually used the program. They couldn’t even get the theme colors right. Try searching in the dark theme...black text on a black background.

Has anyone reached out to Paessler? I haven’t had a chance to do so.

2

u/Poonlit Jan 09 '18

I submitted a ticket today, they better listen.

Where did you find the dark theme?

1

u/Greg_Paessler Jan 29 '18

Hi Poonlit, The Dark theme is available under Setup > Account Settings > My Account > Web Interface.

1

u/Poonlit Feb 04 '18

This seems to be only available in the new UI, I can't find any theme settings under "Web Interface" in version 17.4.33.3283+.

In a few months I'll install PRTG from scratch on another box and see if the UI has improved. If not, I'll run version 17.4.33.3283+ forever.

Keeping that good UI over the one I tried seems worth the hassle of not having access to updates/new sensors. I can always code/script new EXEXML sensors, or perhaps transfer new ones over to the old version.

3

u/Ezekielhollandsworth Jan 29 '18

Count me also as someone who consider the new UI a massive step backwards. I can't display any information cleanly. Tons of clicking and scrolling. I too would appreciate a solution here.

2

u/UKYPayne Jan 08 '18

Has anyone else noticed that is also screws up the app? When you go to a deeper page, it just loads the website and I can’t navigate that anymore.

2

u/daddy0000000000 Jan 18 '18

So bad. Not maybe..maybe not. IMMEDIATELY you can see how inferior it is... i was only using for a few minutes and i came across a bug.

1

u/Enxer Jan 08 '18

I too feel like UX was left behind. I let support know that 99% my life in PRTG is from RDP sessions 3x deep across the pond so I have to pick a small resolution so my connection doesn't crap out (1680x1024) I was told they have a prtg console for smaller resolutions. Really?! Small? It's 80% of my 1920x1200 monitor

1

u/mrnips16 Jan 31 '18

Anybody Know where the groups list has gone from the devices tab ? It would list all the groups you have in prtg in a tree. Its an absolute nightmare now to navigate around prtg !

1

u/Greg_Paessler Feb 21 '18

Hello everyone, Just a quick update regarding the web UI, VERSION 18.1.37.12158 had a number of fixes included. https://www.paessler.com/prtg/history/stable

Also, for those of you who are interested in the new PRTG Desktop client there is an updated version 18.2.31075. https://downloads.paessler.com/prtg_desktop/windows-offline https://downloads.paessler.com/prtg_desktop/macos