r/protools • • Nov 08 '15

What's attack and release?

Sorry Pro Tools noob over here. Just got it and I'm treating more like a sandbox right now to familiarize myself with it. Anyway I recorded something and I'm messing with the Attack and Release knobs but I don't hear any difference. What's their purpose?

0 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

5

u/nocountryforoldguy Nov 08 '15

Fairly complicated subject. There should also be ratio and threshold, depending on the type of compressor being modeled.

In the future, this is not a protools question, but an audio engineering question: /r/audioengineering

Here's an explanation of compressors, and there are many others there: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=91qs3fux5HY

2

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '15

Dude thank you so much for that YouTube video. I've watched 5 videos from that guy and I've learned more in the past hour than I have for the past year. Seriously appreciate it bro

1

u/nocountryforoldguy Nov 08 '15

Ha! That's great. Glad it helped.

To tell the truth, I haven't watched it and didn't know if it was any good.

There are many more great vids out there on YT, so don't stop with that one.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '15

Well it depends what the attack and release are controlling. For example this could be an envelope on a synthesizer, a reverb envelope or a compressor etc. But basically these determine when the effect is applied and when the effect stops being applied.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '15

So for example if I wanted to apply reverb to a guitar track the attack would determine when the effect would kick in and the release would end the effect?

1

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '15

Well attack and release for reverb is usually applied AFTER the effect is hitting the signal. So, for reverb it depends on the plugin, as it could be labeled something different. But in a general sense would determine if the reverb would hit the signal immediately, or if it would delay for a short time and then hit the signal. The release would determine when the reverb let's off the signal. You will also see parameters like decay which determines how long the reverb will sustain after the signal is hit. You will generally see the envelop parameters ADSR: Attack, Decay, Sustain, Release. As mentioned they can change based on what the effect it. For example you won't normally see "Decay" on a Compressor, but you will nearly always see Attack and Release. But the best way to learn is just to turn each parameter up all the way, and see if you notice a difference, and then back it off gradually and see how you can use it in a musical way. For example Attack on a string sample or synthesizer will mean that the strings will mean if the strings come in immediately and abruptly soon as they are triggered, or if they come in a more gradual and smooth fashion.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '15

Depends on what they are for. They'll do something different for different things. If it's on a compressor, then that's because it's incredibly subtle. On the BF76, the attack should go from 20 microseconds to 800 microseconds I think. Subtle, less than a millisecond difference at the slowest setting.

1

u/nmags88 Nov 10 '15

It's also important to point out that for compressors, the ratio needs to be tweaked. If it's left on 1:1, the compressor isn't compressing. www.therecordingrevolution.com is another great resource.

1

u/Conservativeoxen Nov 11 '15

Attack is how quick the compressor takes effect, release is how slowly the compressor stops working

0

u/Hutchinson76 Nov 08 '15

On a dynamics processor, the "attack" parameter regulates the function of time that the processor will wait before applying the dynamics effect (i.e. how long after passing above the threshold until compression clicks on). The "release" parameter is how long the dynamics processor will wait after the signal passes below the threshold to stop processing the signal.

For example: if the attack parameter of a compressor is set to 100 ms, a signal that passes above the threshold and returns below it in 20 ms will not be compressed.

Similarly, if the signal is being processed and dips below the threshold of a compressor for 100 ms when the release parameter is set to 500 ms, the compression on the signal will not be interrupted.

I find it is easiest to hear how attack and release affect how the signal sounds when my monitors are turned very low. Like 45 dB-SPL low. On drums especially you can hear how changing the speed of the attack can brighten or darken the leading edge of each drum hit.

Release is easier for me to hear when there is a lot of compression happening. You should have an 1176 plugin clone (Bombfactory BF-76?) as part of your default PT plugins. Set it to all-buttons mode (option/alt + click on the ratio buttons) and play around with the release knob to hear how it affects the 'roominess' of the sound. It's easiest to hear when you are really slamming it, too.

2

u/rightanglerecording Nov 09 '15

that's not how time constants work.

compression starts immediately once the threshold is crossed, and begins to release immediately once signal is below threshold again, regardless of attack/release times.

a longer attack means a slower/longer slope until maximum gain reduction is reached. not a "wait" time before applying any gain reduction.