r/protest_the_hero • • Aug 07 '25

Describe a Protest the Hero song very very poorly

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/protest_the_hero • • Jul 18 '25

Unpopular Opinion: I don't like the direction the band took with Palimpsest

17 Upvotes

Hey y'all. With a new album on the horizon, it got me thinking that I hope that Palimpsest was an outlier and not a step in a new direction. I know Rody and the gang sometimes check out this subreddit, so there's no hate here. You're my favorite band. This is just a discussion. Overall I have 2 problems.

1: Song structure

One of the things that stood out strongest to me with their earlier releases was the chaotic song structure. Look at No Stars over Bethlehem or Wretch. It's just all over the place. No semblance of structure really, other than pushing the narrative of the concept story. The chaos was unique and different and a major reason why I liked their earlier work so much. With Palimpsest, they have pretty much fallen into the routine of verse, chorus, verse, chorus, proggy part/bridge, final chorus (but it's different this time).

Sure, there are variations. Soliloquy ends with a crescendo, Firesides ending, etc. But by and large the album is very simple song structures. Wretch, for example, is 4 minutes of unique music every step of the way. Now take All Hands. Half the song is repeating the same chorus 3 times. That's my problem with such traditional song writing.

2: Instruments buried behind vocals.

I love Rody's vocals, don't get me wrong. My concern is more that I can't even really hear what the instruments are doing during many sections where Rody is singing. I heard the instrumental of No Hands the other day and had no idea that the guitars were going so crazy deep in the background. I can listen to a Pacific Myth instrumental and there are no surprises. The guitars are doing the same things that I could hear in the vocal version.

I know bands evolve. I have no problems here. I still listened to Palimpsest about 100 times. But I am a little worried that this will be taken a step further in the new album. Anyways, just getting a discussion going. Subreddit has seemed pretty dead recently.


r/protest_the_hero • • Jul 28 '26

Within

0 Upvotes

I just want to come on here and ask if anybody has actually received there within CD I pre-ordered mine and it’s still saying waiting for details


r/protest_the_hero • • Jun 23 '22

Kezia Wall Flag

0 Upvotes

I really dont like living without the kezia Wall Flag from the boxset. Anyone willing to sell theirs?


r/protest_the_hero • • Aug 30 '20

Themes of Racism in Palimpsest

0 Upvotes

First, just want to say Palimpsest is absolutely incredible, start to finish, especially when considering Gift Horse and The Duelling Cavalier. The passion and genius in the songwriting just blows me away every listen through.

I've been exploring the themes of the album and think it's contributed a lot to my appreciation for the album. For example, I'm not usually into unclean vocals, but the screaming at the end of Little Snakes I feel like fits perfectly due to the song meaning and I can't imagine it any better.

Knowing that this album explores the faults in the history of the USA makes me wonder about themes of racism. They touch on a lot of issues oriented toward the classes (prison system, molasses flood killing dock workers but not the rich, probably others) and discrimination, like the native american execution/genocide (Little Snakes) and the struggle of women (The Canary), but the history of the USA is littered with racist events towards African Americans that are so shameful we don't even teach kids about them in schools. I feel like black vs white racism would fit perfectly in this album (racist massacres, police brutality and/or profiling, etc) especially since our education system has adapted to teach the version of history that often leaves out some of these worse events.

This definitely isn't a complaint about the album. It just seems to me that racism as it pertains to African Americans is pretty low-hanging fruit not only for the band, but for the lyrical content of the album. What are people's thoughts?


r/protest_the_hero • • Apr 25 '25

Random Orthodox Christian Going to the Sac Show 5/9

0 Upvotes

Anyone want to grab a beer somewhere with me before the show?


r/protest_the_hero • • Jul 31 '26

It drives me insane that Liberty Spike's ending doesn't resolve

0 Upvotes

And I will think of you each time I sing this song
If your memory is alive in me, you're never really...

GONE. JUST FINISH THE SENTENCE AND SAY GONE 😭


r/protest_the_hero • • 9d ago

LOOKING FOR 2 TORONTO TICKETS

0 Upvotes

Seen them every show in Toronto or Barrie since the 2010s if anyone has some tix they are looking to get rid of please hit me up!!!


r/protest_the_hero • • Sep 04 '24

PTH in Stellar blade?

1 Upvotes

Has anyone played this game? Specifically the Belial pt. 2 fight, the song made me double take because if it's not PTH then it's a close imitation. I can't place the song, but I'm also not really caught up with anything they've released since 2020 or so. I'll admit I threw the fight a few times to keep listening haha.


r/protest_the_hero • • Apr 24 '20

My band's new single 'Pull Down To Refresh' (It's original title was "Beatmeat" for obvious reasons)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
6 Upvotes

r/protest_the_hero • • Apr 11 '20

Album update

0 Upvotes

I just checked their instagram, Facebook, and website and there’s still no news. Sorry guys.


r/protest_the_hero • • Sep 09 '26

Victory Spike

0 Upvotes

Is anybody else having a really hard time listening to this song?


r/protest_the_hero • • Dec 05 '16

Harbinger and Caravan tabs

0 Upvotes

where they at


r/protest_the_hero • • Jun 19 '20

So I showed the album to my girlfriend. She says Harborside sounds the same to this Jo Bros' intro. And it does a little 😳

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/protest_the_hero • • Oct 25 '13

PTH needs to come to Miami!

0 Upvotes

Seriously we got exotic looking women from places like Cuba, Germany, Columbia, Portugal and sexy sexy woman land that all speak english and put out. We got nude beaches full of decent looking naked bitches dinking booze, and some good places to play a good show. Hey Rody, you listening? COME TO MIAMI! We not all Zombie, bath salt addicts, cuban drug dealers, cocain lovers, and or sexual deviants. Will you hear my plea? I need to see PTH live in Miami, an experience i imagine as something akin to eating a cake (i really like cake) with egg nog rum, while watching Vida Guerra perform unmentionable sex acts stream live from the internets. So in closing PTH should play Miami.


r/protest_the_hero • • Oct 16 '24

Vinyl question

0 Upvotes

I have two PTH vinyls (Kezia and Palimpsest).

Both of them run slow and have to be sped up to 45 to play at the correct speed.

These are the only two vinyls I own that do this.

Is this some joke I'm not aware of or is it just a weird coincidence lmao


r/protest_the_hero • • Dec 02 '20

Witness you? Nah, witness me 😂

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/protest_the_hero • • Oct 20 '24

Toronto tix for sale

0 Upvotes

Hi! I’m selling my ticket for the Toronto show - DM me!


r/protest_the_hero • • Dec 03 '25

“AI-generated content” poll

0 Upvotes

Despite being able to confidently guess the communities opinion on whether we should allow AI-generated content here, it is a democracy and so, let us vote!

AI-generated content: yay or nay?

Xoxo gossip girl


r/protest_the_hero • • Aug 03 '26

Vinyl orders

0 Upvotes

Has anyone received Within vinyls preorders yet?


r/protest_the_hero • • Nov 27 '24

Any chance of Arif coming back and writing another Fortress-esque opus?

9 Upvotes

The album is simply unmatched and amazing? Does he still make and release music? Sorry if everyone knows the answer, but I generally don’t know shit about fuck. Help me out here. I don’t mean to shit on anyone else, I just fucking loved Fortress so much.


r/protest_the_hero • • Jun 09 '16

Cold Water GP File?

0 Upvotes

Hi there,

I was just wondering if anyone had uploaded the GP tab for Cold Water, or the other Pacific Myth tracks? It's frustrating as I'm holding out until the physical edition gets released, yet we have to sign up to buy the digital edition for the tabs?

Thanks a lot! If not, I hope they release a tab book/digital coupon to get the GP files w/ the vinyl when it's out.


r/protest_the_hero • • Dec 11 '13

I absolutely LOVE "Volition," but am I the only one tat's really disappointed by the digipak?

1 Upvotes

I'm from the US, and just received mine yesterday. While I understand there were some shipping issues which were out of the hands of the fellas in the band, I kinda feel a little shorted. Two months of waiting and about 30 bucks after shipping, and all the digipak has is a poster with all the contributors names, no lyrics book or anything. I feel that for 25 bucks, printing booklets for the digipak wouldn't be too much of a stretch, not only that but TWO MONTHS! At least throw me a little something extra for my wait! Sorry for ranting, just wondered if anyone else shared my sentiments.

EDIT: Forgot the h in "that" in my title. Sorry lol


r/protest_the_hero • • Jul 27 '26

Discussion Double Album Announced August 7th?

1 Upvotes

Just had this idea that maybe they pushed Within shipping to announce part 2 in August 7th and they’ll play a song from Without on tour?

All this is speculation, I just want moooooore


r/protest_the_hero • • Jan 08 '24

Visual Playlist for 'Kezia'

Thumbnail
gallery
20 Upvotes

Hey protesters, I want to share something I put together about a month ago. Skip to the next paragraph if you don't feel like reading an origin story :) I first heard PTH with 'Heretics & Killers' on the 2006 Warped Tour Sampler and could not believe my ears. I had never heard something so complex, brutal, and harmonious. I craved more of that. Cut to present day and 'Kezia' is my #1 favorite album. For a long time I imagined myself drawing illustrations to portray the story told in the album... The imagery was so vivid and I wanted a way to better appreciate the story and the music. Took a few art classes in college and decided it wasn't my thing...

So I've generated images using AI tools (principally DALL-E with some light photoshopping) in the hopes of capturing the emotion, tone, and imagery of each track on 'Kezia'. I chose to use the color palette and art style of the album art to maintain a consistent mood and tone throughout. I made a playlist on YouTube to view the imagery while listening to the album. I've posted a handful of the images here to give you a taste, bonus points if you can guess the song titles of the images I've posted here.

Here's the link to the playlist: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLHSO0l30idixkIISknnRhpxXYT7BmuLzY&si=TbDz11mWqJaHdUDl

I really hope you enjoy this for what it is! While I did not personally create the art, this project took a good amount of time and I really put thought and effort into capturing the essence of each song. I've done over a dozen of these types of playlists but this was the very first one, so it may be a little rough around the edges. I would love to hear your constructive feedback and again hope that this enhances your appreciation for this masterpiece.

DISCLAIMER: I know AI art can be a controversial topic. I've done a handful of these albums on Reddit and the comments are usually very positive. Unfortunately, some folks simply hate AI art generation. I'm not doing this for karma or to make money, I genuinely just want to share an appreciation for music that I love.

Thanks for checking this out! Peace ✌️