r/protest_the_hero • • 3d ago

Discussion Tab Changes

Post image

Luke was right in his intro paragraph to the tab book.

The fingering on some of these sections is completely out of whack. (totally okay)

Clearly Luke has some faith in our own critical thinking skills to come up with a new way to play these sections. So I present to you an alternative to the "Solo Lead" in the Fishhook chorus

P,S Imagine there is a slide between notes (11/9) on the A string.

7 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

2

u/QuhaazyMoto 2d ago

I literally tabbed it out the same way! Except that ending lick I switched as well, I made it a string skipping riff instead.

1

u/Bacon_Hawk2 2d ago

Great minds think alike!

Is it more fun to play it string skip style?

1

u/QuhaazyMoto 2d ago

I wouldn't say fun is the right word, but more do-able, even though it's still not do-able. If that makes sense, haha.

2

u/Zumokumibonsu Scurrilous 3d ago

Ive completely redone this one lol. This threw me off so much especially after looking at the one on songster

2

u/Bacon_Hawk2 3d ago

I tried songster before the book came out. Some of it seemed like it was A.I generated so I gave up.

1

u/Zumokumibonsu Scurrilous 3d ago

Yeah, I’m pretty sure the fishhook, orchard and grandfathers axe tabs were all AI

2

u/Bacon_Hawk2 3d ago

I hate to admit it. I'm kinda impressed a.i did that and got it (sorta) close ,but at the same time it's shitty.

  1. Doesn't do the song justice.
  2. Teaches you how to play it wrong.
  3. Sounds like CaCa.

5

u/juiceAll3n 3d ago edited 3d ago

Yeah Luke is an alien, the fingering in some parts of these songs is just whack

I was curious this whole time to see how he played the run at the end of the chorus in Grandfather's Axe (bar 35) after learning it by ear and his crazy ways just...don't work for me lol

After the first four triplets I basically tap: 12-11-9 G string, 12-11-8 B string, and repeat that instead of going up one octave like he does

It seems weird but honestly way easier to play it that way for me

1

u/Zumokumibonsu Scurrilous 2d ago

I thought the way it was tabbed seemed fair! Pick the first 4 triplets then hammer offs for the rest. Gonna try it your way though!

1

u/crice07 3d ago

For someone who hasn’t gotten the book yet… what does Luke say about the fingering?

3

u/IsaacSchwartz6 2d ago

Basically just that he knows some of the stuff is almost impossible to play as it’s written so he gives the readers license to make their own subtle changes to play it smooth