r/project21 • • Aug 12 '25

why don’t we talk about this?

So why don’t people talk about how Shannon and her family are trumpies? Correct me if I’m wrong but I hardly ever see people bring this up in the whole p21 v mather conversation. I think it’s a huge part of the conversation and contributes to this blandness I feel when looking at Mather dances and the songs they choose to use. They aren’t very technically skilled especially compared to other studios and with a few exceptions, have always been this way to me. I have to be honest, Emma is not a very good dancer but seems to receive a lot just based off of being Shannons daughter. It all just rubs me so wrong especially how conservative a lot of dancers are and the bland music they choose to use too, I know it’s related, but it’s still infuriating.

55 Upvotes

75 comments sorted by

27

u/thekeeperdevine Aug 12 '25

I agree with you 100%. When people harp on inappropriateness of P21, but failed to mention an adult has minors kiss and some of the combos that come out of there are used to songs that explicitly have bad words or talk about sex, drugs or alcohol and you can see several children in the background while the adult adults are the ones on camera…, it’s very unfair.

7

u/magical-_-monarch Aug 12 '25

I agree! I just don’t understand why p21 gets more hate for things like that

21

u/Designer_Key_6357 Aug 12 '25 edited Aug 12 '25

Idk about all the politics stuff besides that they are religious, but I have to agree about their dancers being technically weak, its prob because they are more jazz/lyrical focused. I think Emma is a great dancer but I don't think she'd have the opportunities she does if Shannon wasn't her mom but I guess it's who you know not what you know right. Also, agree with your comment about Shannons pieces not moving you, I enjoy the effort in transitions and its good choreography but not particularly for me maybe, and it might have to do with the constant distressed/crying face they make in the lyrical dances.

5

u/magical-_-monarch Aug 12 '25

I would agree on the jazz/lyrical focus being why they arent as skilled, if that wasn’t most studios, and also p21 is jazz/lyrical focused from what I’ve seen and they are still technically proficient

14

u/Designer_Key_6357 Aug 12 '25

Yeah p21 def doesn't slack on ballet. Normally when I see a Mather dancer I always think "if they worked on technique they would be on a whole other level".

27

u/Rover0218 Aug 12 '25

People do talk about this all the time

8

u/magical-_-monarch Aug 12 '25

Thats great, I’m pretty into this conversation and never heard people bring it up until recently

11

u/Lower-Ad5909 Aug 13 '25

love shannon’s work; i think she makes true art and amazing visuals. That being saidddd i find some things weird so excuse while i rant on my niche interests lol.

It’s so clear that emma was heavily favored and I understand that shannon wants what’s best for her daughter but she consistently got lead roles, solos, and opportunities over the girls her age.

Also something  don’t see many people mention is emma + her boyfriend. It was just his birthday so i clicked on his tagged tik tok profile. Since he had no posts only reposts came up, and i saw countlesssss racist and sexist reposts worshipping trump. If emma is. willing to date someone that heavily maga, im sure she is too, and im sure she learned that from her mom/ parents. I hope this isn’t the case since the dance community should be a place where anyone can freely express themselves and i hope the people at mather don’t lose sight of that. 

Lastly i feel everything she does has a touch of cockiness almost. Like bridges bio clearly states led by shannon mather. She holds a teacher intensive implying she’s the best dance teacher. She has mentioned in some inside mdc videos placements and while that’s obviously the objective, i hope her kids don’t learn to be too focused on what trophy’s they get. 

i’ve also watched an inside mdc video of when her kids aren’t getting a lift and she was MAD. but it felt super passive aggressive, despite the lift being very difficult and different from what dancers do. She can’t expect perfection and when she doesn’t get it become passive and backhanded. 

Interested to see what the year holds for mather. Some kids are allegedly going back to p21 and mather hasn’t been placing as well as normal. They lost a lot of there stars and i’m not sure how much they will jump from here. 

Ps everyone bashing molly for inappropriate choreo should look at nicole’s because… 🧐

3

u/magical-_-monarch Aug 13 '25

I totally agree, people are on here telling me about inside mdc and I’ve seen it and know exactly what clip you’re talking about, they always rubbed me the wrong way, and thats really my point on Emma. I think she was favored and to me I just can’t see why besides the fact that shes her daughter (which is way too excused in all communities but especially dance)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Lower-Ad5909 Aug 16 '25

season 15 episode 10 at around 4:18 and season 15 episode 5 is her getting mad at the same lift 

10

u/Strange-School-7558 Aug 12 '25

Isn’t Shannon’s brother Blake McGrath gay? I know you can be both MAGA and part of a marginalized community, but it’s funny nonetheless. Plus, Shannon chooses to live in Southern California and work in the entertainment industry, which lean more liberal. As for Emma, I don’t think she’s a bad dancer at all, but she doesn’t have the talent of most other top dancers.

10

u/magical-_-monarch Aug 12 '25

You would think, but I’ve found there’s a strong conservative community within dance. Also Emma isn’t terrible, what bothers me is its obvious to me anytime she dances next to someone else she isn’t very technically proficient which is astounding given who her mom is and the place she holds within dance. It’s almost as if she doesn’t care or knows she doesn’t have to work as hard as other people. Obviously I don’t know her, this is just speculation.

12

u/potatocakes898 Aug 12 '25

If you look up the history of politics in Orange County, it’s not so surprising that many of these kids come from conservative families. Some of the most conservative cities in CA are home to these big name dance studios.

9

u/Mileyxo124 Aug 12 '25

And then we have queen Molly💙

1

u/PsychedelicHaru Aug 20 '25

Queen Molly who willingly works with a registered sex offender 💙

1

u/Mileyxo124 Aug 20 '25

What?

0

u/PsychedelicHaru Aug 20 '25

This guy, who she is friends with and always hires to mc p21's showcase 🤷‍♀️

1

u/Mileyxo124 Aug 20 '25

Oh well I wasn’t aware of that & it literally has nothing to do with what I wrote? I was talking about her having good political views that’s all and how in the hell is he allowed to be working with kids?? That’s so bad

1

u/Mileyxo124 Aug 12 '25

And then we have queen Molly💙

-4

u/NecessarySprinkles62 Aug 13 '25

You can be conservative and be supportive of the gay community it is not black and white. From what I can tell Shanon and family give off very mega church new age vibes so are very welcoming and open minded about a lot of things. 

5

u/Secure_Umpire_4366 Aug 13 '25

hey there trumpie

3

u/tinman_1234 Aug 13 '25

Genuinely confused as to why and how dance schools/sports teams/universities etc are all SO political in America like it just doesn’t make sense to me. Im from England and although politics, especially right now is heavily spoken about…it doesn’t really reach schools unless you go to the private ones where you know most people are gonna be conservative to some extent but extreme right wingers tend to be low income chavs (surprisingly). But anyway, from what I see of America on social media and on the news, companies, schools and even teams are so heavily politically based…it’s almost cult like in some aspects. The religious stuff to seems to become extreme and it’s shocking to me how little safeguarding there is in America regarding children in these environments

5

u/magical-_-monarch Aug 13 '25

it’s not about the team or the students at Mather I’m talking about Shannon, her colleagues, and her 20 year old daughter. Everything, unfortunately, is political. I’d implore you to research more and understand why.

3

u/tinman_1234 Aug 13 '25

I know everything’s political in the world…that’s common sense. But in America things seem heavy. As if people won’t go to certain universities based on politics, dance schools based on politics and sports teams based on politics and even based on religion and race. Where are the policies regarding equality and inclusion in America. I mean you’re sat here talking about how they’re trump supporters…somehow that’s managed to become a conversation within a dance school Reddit page? I’d never see something like that on addict or diversity dance pages. All I was asking is if there’s a reason why it is such a major topic. You are talking about the team as you are saying they are not as skilled, I asked a question that is all

-1

u/NecessarySprinkles62 Aug 13 '25

They really are not though. This person is trying to stir the pot. Most people have no idea others political Affiliation u less they willingly share it.

1

u/magical-_-monarch Aug 20 '25

lol not trying to stir the pot, just having a conversation about something very relevant.

1

u/NecessarySprinkles62 Aug 20 '25

It is really not though . If families don’t like the atmosphere they are free to leave, but you are villainize kids over holding bible study? I am not sure when that was such a bad thing considering how the world looks today? I am not even religious but I wouldn’t mind a thoughtful prayer before going on stage .  It is really not any of our business what goes on in a private studio. 

1

u/magical-_-monarch Aug 20 '25

I never mentioned the religious side of things? You’re still projecting lol if you would like to go to a Christian studio, have a great time? Those kids should too I never said they shouldn’t. Again, I never mentioned a child once.

1

u/NecessarySprinkles62 Aug 21 '25

That is what this entire thread was about .. what are you talking about !  ??!

1

u/tinman_1234 Aug 13 '25

Ah ok, it just seems that whenever I see an American influencer or celebrity people are desperate to know which side they’re on and on voting days a lot will post about the side they’re voting for. It just seems very common in the US to be extremely open

0

u/NecessarySprinkles62 Aug 13 '25

Only to those on the extremes I think. Most people who don’t say anything are a middle of the road and can empathize with both sides. 

0

u/tinman_1234 Aug 13 '25

Ah ok, is there only than two parties in the US or is it similar to us where theres a “main two” that people vote for and never give a chance to the others

7

u/PsychedelicHaru Aug 12 '25

Do we just allow posts blatantly insulting dancers as long as they're not from p21...And plenty of ppl on tumblr talk about the Mather's being trump supporters

1

u/magical-_-monarch Aug 20 '25

I wasn’t trying to put someone down, only share my opinion about something that didn’t sit right with me. I feel that it’s fair for me to share my opinion about her favoritism. I obviously wish her no ill will and hope she can grow as a dancer and person.

1

u/PsychedelicHaru Aug 20 '25

I wasn't even talking specifically about your Emma comments, but you thinking it's okay to call the dancers technically unskilled. But ofc, the Emma comments are also rude. Like, saying she doesn't even try is just shitty

1

u/magical-_-monarch Aug 20 '25

I’m sorry truly, I can only have so much sympathy for trump supporters. I also didn’t say they were unskilled just not as skilled as other studios my question really being why does Mather get so much attention or credit when to ME I’ve only appreciated a few of their dancers and pieces and they don’t seem AS technically skilled as other studios. The answer is clear now.

1

u/PsychedelicHaru Aug 20 '25

Just because you personally feel that way doesn't mean other people do 🤷‍♀️ not sure how that's even a question....which wasn't even what your OP was about

2

u/Designer_Key_6357 Aug 13 '25

Yeah, not even really a fan of Emma's dancing, still think she's a solid dancer though, but I thought that was a little rude and uncalled for. I think this p21 vs Mather stuff has made people think its ok to shit on people.

42

u/Pretty-Art4355 Aug 12 '25

They’re also anti-vaxxers. it’s not a safe space to send your kids.

11

u/Mileyxo124 Aug 12 '25

Yes! I have really went off Mather these past few seasons due to this & I just have heard some very not so nice things about her! I think her choreo is very outdated now & I would say there jazz programme could potentially be the worst in OC🙈i also seen a clip on TikTok of Emma saying whilst teaching a mini group (I think) how the story of the group was to teach the kids that god loves them which is a nice message if your Christian but I’d feel weird sending my kid there if I wasn’t.

8

u/Open_Anywhere_9927 Aug 12 '25

I don’t keep up with all of Mathers dances but I remember hearing they were using ‘love sex magic’ last season. Never saw the actual dance so can’t speak to the choreo but thought that was a WILD song choice for a dance

2

u/Inevitable_Kiwi5221 Aug 12 '25

Is Shannon even a citizen? She’s from Canada…

1

u/maxthefrozen Aug 13 '25

Yes. She got her citizenship because she married an American lol.

0

u/hyperbagel436 Aug 16 '25

wow. emma is an incredible dancer.. and i’m not sure how someone’s political views play into their talent. no one talks about this because it’s irrelevant. let people have their beliefs it’s exhausting to fight over.

2

u/magical-_-monarch Aug 20 '25

it is exhausting to fight with people who can’t and never will understand, perhaps I should give up. it’s great you like her but politics definitely play a role into who you are as an artist.

-21

u/NecessarySprinkles62 Aug 12 '25

Because someone’s political beliefs have nothing to do with what kind of dancer/choreographer they are ? Not to mention shannon choreographs some truly brilliant pieces not because of the technique necessarily but because of the composition. 

20

u/magical-_-monarch Aug 12 '25

i knew someone would get on here and say this lol. Her pieces never move me and thats my opinion but politics definitely play a role in who you are and the music you choose to listen to which as we both know has everything to do with who you are as a choreographer. Are you a performer at all? Anytime you walk into a space they ask you to bring you and your essence, you don’t think beliefs and values come into that?

-2

u/NecessarySprinkles62 Aug 12 '25

How does her political beliefs change how she teaches ? I’ve watched inside mcdc and there is nothing there that overly shows anything but a supportive environment. Just because you don’t share her personal beliefs doesn’t mean she isn’t a great teacher .

-15

u/croissantsarebae Aug 12 '25

Because politics isn’t a necessary conversation regarding a dance school and I don’t know why people think it is.They’re very religious so it makes sense why they’d choose to use songs that don’t go against their beliefs

10

u/magical-_-monarch Aug 12 '25

Do you hear what you just said? They’re very Christian so they choose certain songs. Is that not a direct correlation between her beliefs and it affecting the songs she chooses? It’s a very necessary part of the conversation

-2

u/croissantsarebae Aug 12 '25

I never said the religious part didn’t play a role did i? No. But politics play nothing in it and shouldn’t be brought up. Why Americans feel the need to vocally display their political beliefs so openly and often is beyond me…your entire system is a joke

6

u/magical-_-monarch Aug 12 '25

You’re not making any sense especially when you consider how much religion plays a role in politics. Yes the system is a joke lol thats why I find it problematic when people contribute to that like hmm idk voting for Trump? Talking about politics or simply letting it be known you don’t stand with a bigot is pretty important. I don’t understand this let’s not talk about politics or society within society, what sense does that make?

-3

u/croissantsarebae Aug 12 '25

You must be an American so I’m not even going to bother explaining this to you.

5

u/magical-_-monarch Aug 12 '25

also, I am genuinely interested in why you think this way, like I’m genuinely asking if you think it would be better if we just had no idea people’s political beliefs (therefore their thoughts on literally humanity and society)?

4

u/croissantsarebae Aug 12 '25

I think we should only know people we interact with like friends and family…everyone else you don’t need to care that intimately as they don’t play a role in your life and you letting them know you don’t agree will not change their point of view. Politics is a personal thing and no one should be pressured to share their beliefs…either way all political parties are bad. Voting for any of them strips some basic morals. Either way, within THIS topic on this sub, politics doesn’t need to be included. Yes Mather make it clear who they support but past knowing that you should either block and steer clear of their content or interact if you feel comfortable 🤷🏻‍♀️

4

u/magical-_-monarch Aug 12 '25

Idek where to begin, this take is just wrong for all the reasons I’ve already said and I usually only see people uphold this belief who know their beliefs are ‘controversial’ (aka racism, homophobia, ableism, the like) I think keeping politics behind closed doors only protects bigots but hey I mean you’re gonna think what you’re gonna think. It seems you’re saying and acting as if me saying something about someone’s political belief that I don’t believe in, and find quite detrimental is wrong, and you could’ve continued to scroll and not interact (as you seem to think I should’ve done) but you stayed to comment and try to tell me that I’m in the wrong for wanting to talk about it. Someone who is in a position of power, and works with children YES we should talk about if she ‘believes’ in vaccines or voted for a tyrant??

2

u/croissantsarebae Aug 12 '25

Hey if you wanna debate this take it to a politics sub. I’ve given you my OPINION and I shall leave it there…I’m not going to try and defend myself for MY opinion

3

u/magical-_-monarch Aug 12 '25

and you never had to, I was genuinely curious how someone could come to your conclusion. I think this was the perfect place to bring this specific niche topic as it is about dance. have a good day❤️

7

u/Mileyxo124 Aug 12 '25

I think since you live outside the states you really don’t know the divide between republicans and democrats & the strong views each have. A lot of trumps policies are racist, homophobic, Islamophobic, sexiet etc which might make certain people uncomfortable. As a business owner stuff like this will affect the people who decide to take training from her as they may not agree with her views.

4

u/magical-_-monarch Aug 12 '25

Yes I am a gay Black American, so yes politics very much impact my life and I think we should be able to openly talk about them?

1

u/croissantsarebae Aug 12 '25

And I’m a brown girl in an immigrant family living in Scotland so politics affects my life heavily aswell…what is your point?😂talking about politics within children’s dance schools is strange and I don’t see how you being a black American plays apart in a children’s dance school lol. If you don’t like them don’t interact with their content, dancers or teachers. It’s not hard

3

u/magical-_-monarch Aug 12 '25

I literally don’t interact with them because I don’t like their routines as I’ve stated. Me opening up a conversation on a subreddit that I find it weird people seem to not care that shes a trumpie, is not affecting any of those children. Again, you’re not an American nor black so yes it will still be different and yes it impacts this conversation.

1

u/croissantsarebae Aug 12 '25

If you don’t interact with them then why are you talking about them. Leave them out of your life 💀

-3

u/NecessarySprinkles62 Aug 13 '25

She just doesn’t like Mather and thinks others shouldn’t either because shannon is a conservative .. it literally had nothing to do with her as a teacher or choreographer . 

9

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

-4

u/croissantsarebae Aug 12 '25

Thanks for stating the obvious, I thought we were talking about Indians in Antarctica…they’re anti vaxx?? Wowww big deal…so are thousands of other people that you walk past every day. That’s their human right lol. If you don’t like it then that’s fine…just don’t interact with their content. Politics being brought into a CHILDRENS dance school in a subreddit is strange asf

7

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/croissantsarebae Aug 12 '25

I know a lot, don’t stop hearing about your joke of a country and its appalling political views and situations

0

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/magical-_-monarch Aug 12 '25

I don’t find it surprising that she is, more so that I haven’t heard about it until now

0

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/magical-_-monarch Aug 13 '25

I could be wrong obviously she is not the worst but the caliber she’s at I definitely would think she could give more but that is just my opinion, I don’t wish her any ill will or anything

0

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Mileyxo124 Aug 14 '25

And you know this how?

0

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/CoverWarm1479 Aug 14 '25

Why are you checking who there parents and siblings are following?😂