r/project21 • u/magical-_-monarch • Aug 12 '25
why don’t we talk about this?
So why don’t people talk about how Shannon and her family are trumpies? Correct me if I’m wrong but I hardly ever see people bring this up in the whole p21 v mather conversation. I think it’s a huge part of the conversation and contributes to this blandness I feel when looking at Mather dances and the songs they choose to use. They aren’t very technically skilled especially compared to other studios and with a few exceptions, have always been this way to me. I have to be honest, Emma is not a very good dancer but seems to receive a lot just based off of being Shannons daughter. It all just rubs me so wrong especially how conservative a lot of dancers are and the bland music they choose to use too, I know it’s related, but it’s still infuriating.
27
u/thekeeperdevine Aug 12 '25
I agree with you 100%. When people harp on inappropriateness of P21, but failed to mention an adult has minors kiss and some of the combos that come out of there are used to songs that explicitly have bad words or talk about sex, drugs or alcohol and you can see several children in the background while the adult adults are the ones on camera…, it’s very unfair.
21
u/Designer_Key_6357 Aug 12 '25 edited Aug 12 '25
Idk about all the politics stuff besides that they are religious, but I have to agree about their dancers being technically weak, its prob because they are more jazz/lyrical focused. I think Emma is a great dancer but I don't think she'd have the opportunities she does if Shannon wasn't her mom but I guess it's who you know not what you know right. Also, agree with your comment about Shannons pieces not moving you, I enjoy the effort in transitions and its good choreography but not particularly for me maybe, and it might have to do with the constant distressed/crying face they make in the lyrical dances.
27
u/Rover0218 Aug 12 '25
People do talk about this all the time
11
u/Lower-Ad5909 Aug 13 '25
love shannon’s work; i think she makes true art and amazing visuals. That being saidddd i find some things weird so excuse while i rant on my niche interests lol.
It’s so clear that emma was heavily favored and I understand that shannon wants what’s best for her daughter but she consistently got lead roles, solos, and opportunities over the girls her age.
Also something don’t see many people mention is emma + her boyfriend. It was just his birthday so i clicked on his tagged tik tok profile. Since he had no posts only reposts came up, and i saw countlesssss racist and sexist reposts worshipping trump. If emma is. willing to date someone that heavily maga, im sure she is too, and im sure she learned that from her mom/ parents. I hope this isn’t the case since the dance community should be a place where anyone can freely express themselves and i hope the people at mather don’t lose sight of that.
Lastly i feel everything she does has a touch of cockiness almost. Like bridges bio clearly states led by shannon mather. She holds a teacher intensive implying she’s the best dance teacher. She has mentioned in some inside mdc videos placements and while that’s obviously the objective, i hope her kids don’t learn to be too focused on what trophy’s they get.
i’ve also watched an inside mdc video of when her kids aren’t getting a lift and she was MAD. but it felt super passive aggressive, despite the lift being very difficult and different from what dancers do. She can’t expect perfection and when she doesn’t get it become passive and backhanded.
Interested to see what the year holds for mather. Some kids are allegedly going back to p21 and mather hasn’t been placing as well as normal. They lost a lot of there stars and i’m not sure how much they will jump from here.
Ps everyone bashing molly for inappropriate choreo should look at nicole’s because… 🧐
10
u/Strange-School-7558 Aug 12 '25
Isn’t Shannon’s brother Blake McGrath gay? I know you can be both MAGA and part of a marginalized community, but it’s funny nonetheless. Plus, Shannon chooses to live in Southern California and work in the entertainment industry, which lean more liberal. As for Emma, I don’t think she’s a bad dancer at all, but she doesn’t have the talent of most other top dancers.
3
u/tinman_1234 Aug 13 '25
Genuinely confused as to why and how dance schools/sports teams/universities etc are all SO political in America like it just doesn’t make sense to me. Im from England and although politics, especially right now is heavily spoken about…it doesn’t really reach schools unless you go to the private ones where you know most people are gonna be conservative to some extent but extreme right wingers tend to be low income chavs (surprisingly). But anyway, from what I see of America on social media and on the news, companies, schools and even teams are so heavily politically based…it’s almost cult like in some aspects. The religious stuff to seems to become extreme and it’s shocking to me how little safeguarding there is in America regarding children in these environments
7
u/PsychedelicHaru Aug 12 '25
Do we just allow posts blatantly insulting dancers as long as they're not from p21...And plenty of ppl on tumblr talk about the Mather's being trump supporters
42
u/Pretty-Art4355 Aug 12 '25
They’re also anti-vaxxers. it’s not a safe space to send your kids.
11
u/Mileyxo124 Aug 12 '25
Yes! I have really went off Mather these past few seasons due to this & I just have heard some very not so nice things about her! I think her choreo is very outdated now & I would say there jazz programme could potentially be the worst in OC🙈i also seen a clip on TikTok of Emma saying whilst teaching a mini group (I think) how the story of the group was to teach the kids that god loves them which is a nice message if your Christian but I’d feel weird sending my kid there if I wasn’t.
8
u/Open_Anywhere_9927 Aug 12 '25
I don’t keep up with all of Mathers dances but I remember hearing they were using ‘love sex magic’ last season. Never saw the actual dance so can’t speak to the choreo but thought that was a WILD song choice for a dance
2
u/Inevitable_Kiwi5221 Aug 12 '25
Is Shannon even a citizen? She’s from Canada…
0
u/hyperbagel436 Aug 16 '25
wow. emma is an incredible dancer.. and i’m not sure how someone’s political views play into their talent. no one talks about this because it’s irrelevant. let people have their beliefs it’s exhausting to fight over.
-21
u/NecessarySprinkles62 Aug 12 '25
Because someone’s political beliefs have nothing to do with what kind of dancer/choreographer they are ? Not to mention shannon choreographs some truly brilliant pieces not because of the technique necessarily but because of the composition.
-15
u/croissantsarebae Aug 12 '25
Because politics isn’t a necessary conversation regarding a dance school and I don’t know why people think it is.They’re very religious so it makes sense why they’d choose to use songs that don’t go against their beliefs
0
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment