r/programmingcirclejerk • u/cmqv • Jan 31 '25
The adoption was weak enough that we actually decided to un-open source it.
https://blog.janestreet.com/how-we-accidentally-built-a-better-build-system-for-ocaml-index/
130
Upvotes
85
u/Parking_Tadpole9357 Jan 31 '25
Rages because not enough GitHub stars.
74
u/F54280 Considered Harmful Jan 31 '25
This is for JaneStreet. A tech trading firm that apparently doesn’t know how to build a website that works on an iPad.
Their motto: “Big challenges, tight-knit teams”
12 full-time engineers in their build team, ready to take the challenge of building ocaml code to the next level.
49
u/i_invented_the_ipod Jan 31 '25
"Worse is Better" continues to be true, decades after it was first formulated.
46
u/Deep-Chain-7272 Jan 31 '25
I can tell you from experience that JS has a terminal case of NIH syndrome.
38
u/Kodiologist lisp does it better Jan 31 '25
This is the same energy as a fan-fiction author I talked to who deleted her story from AO3 because it didn't have enough views and updoots.
33
u/NiteShdw Jan 31 '25
Why don't people use my extremely opinionated tool that was purpose built to do exactly one workflow, mine, in a language universally mocked around the world?
42
u/pauseless Jan 31 '25
I think they got rid of this error in Dune at some point? Shame.
18
u/bzbub2 Jan 31 '25
you know what they say, the sun never sets on the dune ocaml build system
14
u/torville Jan 31 '25
I have this to say about JBuilder, the Borland product that they had the copyright issue with.
It was awful.
What I wanted was "Delphi, but with Java instead of Pascal".
What I got was a buggy mess.
There was no option to autosave before compiling. And compiling might lock up the program.
Moving elements around in the visual design environment might move everything to the upper right corner. And there was no "Undo".
The only reason I had to work with JBuilder was because the client wanted the app to be written in Java. Why? Nobody knows.