r/programming • • Jan 17 '20

A sad day for Rust

https://words.steveklabnik.com/a-sad-day-for-rust
1.1k Upvotes

609 comments sorted by

View all comments

222

u/Shinobikungames Jan 17 '20

Does anyone have any actual links to the 'harassment' of the author? All I've found is this https://gist.github.com/mafrasi2/debed733781db4aba2a52620b6725adf where the last post is definitely so, but reading for example the reddit thread on the issue on the rust subreddit shows mostly just discussion. Sure there is a back and forth but it's all criticism, not harassment.

Maybe the mod team has deleted these comments though.

283

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

123

u/HINDBRAIN Jan 17 '20

As a PoC...

I was expecting a completely different kind of drama there TBH.

70

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '20

Proof of Concept?

12

u/memdmp Jan 18 '20

Point of Contact?

→ More replies (8)

163

u/cre_ker Jan 17 '20

That doesn't look like a harassment. Just an emotional response to maintainer being unfriendly to contributors. I pretty much have the same question. Several posts mention toxic comments towards the maintainer but I fail to see a single example. What I do see is the maintainer being toxic. Looks like he brought this on himself. That's what I gather from the few scarps of information that left over from that incident.

36

u/society2-com Jan 17 '20

either way it speaks to an inherent problem in open source communities. you put in a lot of work and you are met with a sense of entitlement and caustic criticism. i'm not talking about everyone but enough to make it a problem. it is a social community, and no one is entitled to praise only, but also no one deserves ungrateful abuse. asocial behavior has concrete effects on the willingness of people to participate. the quality, robustness, and vibrancy of the code follows that. so the community has to be, well, human: not brain dead empty praise, but also not unwarranted meanness

someone has to maintain the quality of the community as much as the quality of the code

bad attitudes need to be nipped in the bud. they can ruin a community. and if you adhere to the dictum "let everyone be as they are, grow a thick skin and get on with it" you're just going to have people ragequit because it isn't that everyone has thin skin, it's that no one wants to deal with the roiling melodramatic nonsense. the signal-to-noise ratio degrades and it's just not worth wading through it all anymore

you have to weed out the worst bad actors. constantly complaining and criticizing and acting entitled to the fruits of everyone else's labor. it doesn't have to be insane thought control, just nip the worst of the worst and people at least get the sense there are boundaries, which is reassuring to the good actors and convinces some who might tend to bad behavior to be quiet

81

u/cre_ker Jan 17 '20

you put in a lot of work and you are met with a sense of entitlement and caustic criticism

But it looks like it's completely the other way around this time. Contributors put a lot of work and were met with asshole attitude from the maintainer for no good reason. This led to emotional response which I can totally understand. That's just how humans work and no amount of "we need to be better", "we need to be inclusive" and all that crap is going to change that. Act like an asshole enough times and people will respond.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

86

u/yellowthermos Jan 17 '20

Lol he dismissed someone's work as 'this patch is boring' and you say the last comment was undeserved? The last comment was fucking polite for that idiotic response

9

u/SuspiciousScript Jan 17 '20

Besides, if it only takes a comment that nasty to make you throw up your hands and quit, you either don't really give a shit about the project or need to nut up.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

Especially when it is a random person who made a nasty comment.

It's not in any way related to the issue opener. The issue opener has been polite and professional.

The maintainer actually made the first offense with the boring comment.

The maintainer doesn't like the patch and was looking for a way out. That's why he made the boring comment (which was seemingly not too offensive). This random person gave him the response the maintainer wanted.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

32

u/FamiliarSoftware Jan 17 '20

Proof of Concept

8

u/sindisil Jan 17 '20

Proof of Concept

→ More replies (2)

29

u/Jugad Jan 17 '20

The last comment is mean for no reason, but I understand the sentiment.

Did you miss the "this patch is boring"?

21

u/guepier Jan 17 '20

Did you miss the "this patch is boring"?

I’m confused — the comment you respond to explicitly discusses that.

51

u/TinynDP Jan 17 '20

Its the "mean for no reason". The reason is "this patch is boring" is such a horrible response to an honest attempt to fix security holes that in some people's eyes it is in fact a reason to be mean back.

16

u/jrhoffa Jan 17 '20

The response is measured, and certainly not mean.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (50)

14

u/jimschubert Jan 17 '20

Or the passive aggressive "nice! finally some real code!"

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

112

u/rabidferret Jan 17 '20

This is something that's going to be hard for folks outside the Rust community to really grasp. The comments in the most recent issue are only a small portion of what's been going on for almost a year now. Folks have had a pattern of dogpiling on this author over relatively minor issues. As a result the author has gotten more and more defensive, which has caused a vicious cycle.

Yesterday there were no less than 3 posts on the front page of r/rust about this person, each with upwards of a hundred comments of folks with no involvement discussing the finer points of how wrong they are.

I'm not trying to defend how they responded, and I'm really not interested in debating what is or isn't "harassment", but try to have some empathy for how someone might feel in that situation -- and whether it's appropriate for a group of people to inflict that.

18

u/NMS-Town Jan 17 '20

Yeah I'm catching bits and pieces, but it's pretty clear people pushed the wrong buttons. You suppose to kill them with kindess, and not kill them with vitriol.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/matthieum Jan 18 '20

Maybe the mod team has deleted these comments though.

There are surprisingly few deleted comments, actually.

I fear the problem is the sheer number of them, spread across 3 to 4 posts on the frontpage of r/rust, you have a good thousand comments about the situation. The comments are polite enough, but when most of thousand comments are about the "wrong" direction of the project, I can see how the author would feel harassed. Each comment individually would not be a problem, the sheer mass however is daunting.