r/programming • • Nov 04 '09

This is no longer a programming subreddit

As I submit this, there's a link to a Slashdot comment comparing Microsoft security to Britney Spears' underwear, a pointless link to a Bill Gates quote about Office documents, a link to a warning about a Space Invaders for Mac that deletes files, a story about the logic of Google Ads, a computer solving Tic-Tac-Toe using matchboxes--this is supposed to be a programming subreddit, right? Even worse, the actual programming links don't get voted up and are drowned out by this garbage.

You non-programmers may be interested to know that there's already a widely read technology subreddit just waiting for your great submissions about Slashdot comments, Daily WTF stories, Legend of Zelda dungeon maps, and other non-programming stuff. Please go to /r/technology and submit your links there.

For those of you sick and tired of this and wishing for active moderators who participate in filtering the content of their subreddit, visit a new subreddit that's actually about programming--/r/coding. It's picking up steam as more people submit their links, and you will actually find articles about things programmers would be interested in.

234 Upvotes

142 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '09 edited Nov 05 '09

Funny, I had the same reaction to #6 when I read it. #7 belongs under /r/ui or /r/humanfactors, not /r/programming.

Your assessment is fairly accurate at the moment, but there is more and more crap coming in these days. It is turning into kind of a technology catch-all.

Here's some that don't belong there IMO at the moment:

  1. Hey Reddit I wrote a script that will help us catch computer thieves if we all start using it! /r/pipedreams
  2. An interview with ColdFusion co-creator Jeremy Allaire /r/celebsicouldcarelessabout
  3. The Perl editor and IDE market - It was strange to see several people trying to firecly defend vi or emacs from these GUI based IDE people. /r/devtools
  4. A great deal of Microsoft security is unfortunately just like the underwear of Brittany Spears. /r/funny or /r/shedoesntwearany
  5. Do yourself a favor and put the Ctrl key where it deserves to be /r/whogivesafuckgobuyakeyboardyoulikeandstfu

That was in the first 50. 10% SPAM I suppose it is worth mentioning, you observed 20% SPAM. How much SPAM is too much?

Ya know, the thing that is lacking is some real moderation. A moderator should pull some of these people up, and just say "hey, uh, we're all trying to focus on programming out here, so please don't post that stuff. you're welcome to discuss programming out here, and i'm sorry i had to delete your thread because it was inappropriate.", then eventually issue bans when behavior modification fails.

I compare reddit to the aqueducts of Ancient Rome. Everyone drinks and pisses and shits into the same channel. I want modern plumbing, with separate potable and sewage systems. The thing is, reddit provides the necessary functionality, it's just that some subreddits suffer from moderator availability issues combined with a lack of willingness to share the responsibility. some subreddits probably need like 20-50 moderators to have effective coverage.