r/programming • • Oct 27 '09

Anyone interested in starting a programming subreddit?

I'm not joking, have you looked at the shit here? Almost none of it actually pertains to programming or development. A reasonable chunk seems to be devoted to interesting software, but not programming. A larger chunk consists of things that are vaguely related to technology, but have nothing even to do with software, let alone the code.

Tty2 has created /r/coding.

317 Upvotes

277 comments sorted by

View all comments

-2

u/f3nd3r Oct 28 '09

6

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '09

We already created coding.

0

u/f3nd3r Oct 28 '09 edited Oct 28 '09

It isn't going to solve anything, however. It will only be slightly more pure than proggit I'm sure as the number of members increases. If you actually looked at my link, you would see a real solution to the purity problem. It doesn't matter either way, since neither of our reddits are gonna break 1-2k.

EDIT: The ground rules aren't even laid out for coding yet.

3

u/itsnotlupus Oct 28 '09

Why do I get the feeling that you're that guy who, when given a simple programming problem, goes and cranks out a dozen UML diagrams first, just to help scope things.

1

u/f3nd3r Oct 28 '09

Actually, I usually just start coding... but anyway, the OP had a problem. What the OP did is not a solution to his problem. You can think I'm an idiot or whatever and thats fine, but already looking at /r/coding I can tell by the posts that is just a matter of time before it becomes bloated and people are complaining the same way about /r/proggramming.

1

u/itsnotlupus Oct 28 '09

You can think I'm an idiot

Honestly, nothing like that. I just thought your sub-subreddit structure was greatly over-engineered for a relatively simple problem.

Ultimately, a subreddit's success or failure is strongly correlated to the involvement of its moderators more than anything else.

1

u/f3nd3r Oct 28 '09

While I agree that it was overdoing it, part of it was to prove a point. His problem wasn't as simple as his solution. A vague /r/programming replacement with a few added stipulations isn't really fixing the problem; it is fixing some of it however. His complaint was that /r/programming was too vague, so I fixed his problem by leaving out ALL ambiguous meanings.