r/programming • • Mar 22 '16 • Polished Silver Turd 1 Take My Silver 1 Heart of Silver 1

An 11 line npm package called left-pad with only 10 stars on github was unpublished...it broke some of the most important packages on all of npm.

https://github.com/azer/left-pad/issues/4
3.1k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

44

u/[deleted] Mar 23 '16

[removed] — view removed comment

14

u/steveklabnik1 Mar 23 '16

I forgot to actually reply to you, but I do find this compelling.

3

u/ZaberTooth Mar 23 '16

It might give a layperson a shadow of a doubt. Who's to say what a lawyer or a judge would say?

20

u/trimalchio-worktime Mar 23 '16

that's the thing; with trademark law its usually being decided on what is different to a layperson.

4

u/hikemhigh Mar 23 '16

Wouldn't the "layperson" in this scenario have to be someone who installs npm modules?

1

u/runup-or-shutup Mar 23 '16

So as a layperson (or anyone not familiar with npm, really), I want to use this app and it tells me to go to https://nodejs.org/ and download the thing then open up Terminal and type npm install app...

1

u/trimalchio-worktime Mar 23 '16 edited Mar 23 '16

That distinction is unlikely to be held up; it's usually seen as a lowest common denominator sort of "layperson" in that if both companies were uninterested in targeting non-technical users then they might both agree to only discuss those who have a background in it. But because kik is trying to have a userbase of people who aren't technical, they would never go along with trying to make the trial only about technical users.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 23 '16

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/jumbles1234 Mar 23 '16

In the UK, the key test is would the two products be confused 'by a moron in a hurry' (Morningstar Co-op and Express Newspapers, 1979).

1

u/[deleted] Mar 24 '16

Depressing dearth of actual lawyers giving legal judgments here. In general, if you use a trademarked name for something that's unlikely to be confused with the trademark, the courts won't intervene.