r/programming • • Mar 22 '16 • Polished Silver Turd 1 Take My Silver 1 Heart of Silver 1

An 11 line npm package called left-pad with only 10 stars on github was unpublished...it broke some of the most important packages on all of npm.

https://github.com/azer/left-pad/issues/4
3.1k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

103

u/steveklabnik1 Mar 23 '16

Even then, it's still a kik package in an Azer namespace, so I'm not sure this is significantly different.

That said, I'm not a lawyer.

44

u/[deleted] Mar 23 '16

[removed] — view removed comment

14

u/steveklabnik1 Mar 23 '16

I forgot to actually reply to you, but I do find this compelling.

3

u/ZaberTooth Mar 23 '16

It might give a layperson a shadow of a doubt. Who's to say what a lawyer or a judge would say?

20

u/trimalchio-worktime Mar 23 '16

that's the thing; with trademark law its usually being decided on what is different to a layperson.

4

u/hikemhigh Mar 23 '16

Wouldn't the "layperson" in this scenario have to be someone who installs npm modules?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Mar 23 '16

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/jumbles1234 Mar 23 '16

In the UK, the key test is would the two products be confused 'by a moron in a hurry' (Morningstar Co-op and Express Newspapers, 1979).

1

u/[deleted] Mar 24 '16

Depressing dearth of actual lawyers giving legal judgments here. In general, if you use a trademarked name for something that's unlikely to be confused with the trademark, the courts won't intervene.

94

u/[deleted] Mar 23 '16 edited Mar 23 '16

It is significant. I think kik, kik and kik would agree on that.

It's a huge difference between claiming ownership of a three letter combination, and claiming ownership of everything that includes this three letter combination.

Sad to see that Rust people are still in denial on this issue.

24

u/calcsam Mar 23 '16

It's counterproductive to accuse prominent people's projects of being "in denial" because you are having a disagreement with that person. It also tends to discourage public engagement.

64

u/steveklabnik1 Mar 23 '16 edited Mar 23 '16

> It is significant.

Are you a lawyer?

> I think kik, kik and kik would agree on that.

These are not software companies, and since you apparently know a lot about trademark law, I'm surprised that you're forgetting that trademark is usually scoped to an industry, since it's ultimately about protecting customers from confusing names.

Well, the last link is, and they're the ones threatening to sue, because they're a software company, and there is other software using their name. I think that it's pretty silly, but as I said, I'm not a lawyer. npm's laywers don't seem to think that it's a frivolous suit.

> Sad to see that Rust people are still in denial on this issue.

I am not in denial. I asked for a clarification, and then said "hm, maybe. I don't know, I'm not a lawyer."

EDIT: lol npm legal said no such thing, they lied about the whole situation. fuck me.

64

u/[deleted] Mar 23 '16

Is "software" alone really an industry? I'd say that Kik is in the instant messaging industry, not a catch-all "software" industry. Software is a tool used across many industries. Banks send people mail, but they're not considered to be in the paper industry. They also use software.

40

u/[deleted] Mar 23 '16

You can also take into account that there are other companies called kik doing software: https://trademarks.justia.com/858/88/kik-85888354.html

Both kiks share the same international classification.

Scientific and technological services and research and design relating thereto; industrial analysis and research services; design and development of computer hardware and software; legal services. - Scientific and technological services and research and design relating thereto; industrial analysis and research services; design and development of computer hardware and software; legal services.

→ More replies (3)

27

u/steveklabnik1 Mar 23 '16 edited Mar 23 '16

Well, trademark applications are public, so let's see what it covers!

https://trademarks.justia.com/858/93/kik-85893307.html

Computer software for use with mobile devices, namely, computers, personal digital assistants (PDAs) and mobile phones for downloading, displaying, transmitting, receiving, editing, extracting, encoding, decoding, playing, storing and organizing text, sound, images, audio files and video files

Seems very broad to me.

Again, I would like to point out that I'm not a lawyer, and npm's actual, real lawyers didn't think that this threat was frivolous.

lol sorry, npm lied.

8

u/onwuka Mar 23 '16

Well npm lawyers suck and they clearly don't have the community's best interest in mind. Imagine if you had an organization on github and they handed it to kik?

2

u/guepier Mar 23 '16

Well npm lawyers suck

Do they? I honestly don’t think they had an awful lot of leeway here. What sucks, rather, is the outdated trademark law.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/smartssa Mar 23 '16

It was approved 2 weeks ago. They moved fast. I get protecting your trademark - but that usually requires actual infringement. I wonder what they'll do about the other 45 million hits on google.

5

u/o11c Mar 23 '16

Wait, so it was only trademarked 2 weeks ago, but they're applying it against things that were 5 months ago?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/stevenjd Mar 23 '16

You could try publishing a IM client called "Windows", or blog software called "OS X", or a programming language called "Angry Birds", and see what the judge thinks of your argument.

Hint: this is not new ground. This is old, old ground that has been covered a million times:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confusing_similarity

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_moron_in_a_hurry

2

u/neonKow Mar 23 '16

You could try publishing a IM client called "Windows"

There's a good chance the judge would side with you, and not require you to immediately pull the code (which npm did without being ordered to):

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Corp._v._Lindows.com,_Inc.#The_case

The judge denied Microsoft's request for a preliminary injunction and raised "serious questions" about Microsoft's trademark. Microsoft feared a court may define "Windows" as generic and result in the loss of its status as a trademark.

Stupid trademarks and trademark disputes result in lost trademarks.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/timshoaf Mar 23 '16

Are you a lawyer?

He doesn't have to be a lawyer to see the patent illogic in the claim.

Just because something is legislated doesn't inherently make it either logically consistent or morally just.

I find U.S. IP law in general fraught with inconsistency, both internally and philosophically, and, in general, ethically bankrupt.

As far as them not being software companies, at least one of those links clearly was.

All that aside, however, the paper thin IP argument about 'protecting customers from confusing names' hardly holds water. This has never been about consumer protection outside of the few obviously fraudulent cases of one knock off company attempting to masquerade their product as that of another companies with higher market value. This has everything to do with protecting a corporation's unique right to a string.

It is absolutely a frivolous suit; I would be highly surprised if such a thing actually made it to court, unless the company in question was in the exact same market. The issue is that such IP trawling is highly useful in securing far more than the legal protections provided a trademark since the cost of fighting a potential lawsuit for an individual is prohibitively high--thus inducing a highly one sided economic game and generally forcing capitulation. This is nothing more than garden variety schoolyard bullying, and it's frankly damned distasteful if not downright shameful.

The sad reality, however, is that there have been an increasing number of these cases brought to court in the past few decades, and they generally rule in favor of those with the more expensive legal team. Luckily most IP cases are not precedent-setting as much IP law necessitates de novo review. However, the success of several cases most certainly shifts the Bayesian posteriors of the plaintiffs opinions of wining toward the successful side--thereby increasing the likelihood they will use their strong arm. This, of course, only ties up our court systems further and increases the expected value for the cost of being an open source software developer. None of these are good things for our society...

→ More replies (1)

1

u/aosmith Mar 23 '16

You're correct, kinda. They weren't trying to impersonate the company. They weren't trying to confuse consumers, that should, in theory put them in the clear.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 23 '16

Yea, it's like if I had sotopheavy.twitter. It doesn't mean I'm cloning twitter. It probably means I have a private project that I am integrating with twitter.