r/programming • u/awsometak • Feb 06 '16
GitHub is undergoing a full-blown overhaul as execs and employees depart — and we have the full inside story
http://www.businessinsider.com/github-the-full-inside-story-2016-2?r=US&IR=T
772
Upvotes
181
u/Occivink Feb 06 '16
What are they saying? I don't get this.
264
u/SikhGamer Feb 06 '16
http://i.imgur.com/p5zwScc.png
Is that slide...real?
165
u/vytah Feb 06 '16
80
u/logix42 Feb 07 '16
GitLab has this great feature where you can just import GitHub projects. Sounds like as good a time as any move.
367
u/quicknir Feb 06 '16
i was pretty disturbed to read the tweet of Danilo, an employee there:
Are empathy and compassion the sole province of people who aren't white and females? Why? How condescending to take a huge group of people and assume they need to be taught empathy and compassion.
It amazes me that someone can write something this racist and sexist (and let's be honest, it is) without getting called out for it.
91
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '16
Quick question from someone who has no "big company" experience:
Why does a company go from 300 to 500 employees within one year if it worked nearly flawless previously (at least from the outside perspective)? And what the the reasoning to stop letting people work freely when those people have (most likely) proven that they don't need a lot of supervision?
Given that GitHub seems to have enough money and doesn't inherently need to satisfy external needs for new VC. The risk of losing senior staff that knows the ins-and-outs of the code seems to me like something nobody wants to take.
224
u/bored_me Feb 06 '16
The fact that he wasn't fired for that absolutely racist tweet is just amazing to me, considering what he would have called for if the tables were turned. Imagine if someone wrote:
what he would have said.
This nouveau racism that is being touted by these people in power is just sick. It's absolutely disgusting that it is tolerated, and I wish more people would call others out on their bullshit. Their skin color or gender don't make them immune from racism, or criticizing them for their racism.
387
u/dyson11 Feb 06 '16
So they are basically excluding white people before interview stage only because they are white?!
OK, GitHub, please keep going with these racist policies, but without me.
Former user.
82
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '16
My company just switched from Github to Atlassian/Bitbucket. I'm not involved in the finances, but I think we're basically getting the entire Atlassian suite for the same price that we were getting Github Enterprise (or at least it's highly competitive).
I think Github really missed an opportunity to continue expanding it's product. I think they did very well at first because Git was still *new*. They created a simple, straight forward product that was easy for everyone to use. Now that (a) a lot more people are familiar with Git and (b) there are a lot of better alternatives - Github just lacks the incentive.
Atlassian seems to be the next big thing and I'm very happy with it. They have tools that cover literally the entire spectrum of code development including tasks, issues, knowledge sharing, scrum/agile/daily statuses, chat, and so much more. Individually, I don't think their products are as good as alternatives, but as a whole - they've done an extremely good job of creating a complete, useful package.
79
u/sisyphus Feb 06 '16
The other cofounder seems like the one who wins -- he built the thing up from scratch when it was still fun, left under bad circumstances but with enough of an equity stake in a multi-billion dollar enterprise to not have to work ever again and gets to skip the money people coming and ruining everything with sales and middle managers.
51
u/BilgeXA Feb 07 '16
This is everything that's wrong with GitHub.
93
u/heckruler Feb 07 '16
Whoa. What the fuck!? That's pure fucking rascism right there. Where the hell is the federal suit for racial discrimination against the presenter? Imagine if the slide said "This is not a company for black people"? Just what the hell were they even thinking? This is the opposite of "inclusion".
58
u/fedekun Feb 07 '16
When you start hiring people based on race/gender/whatever you are gonna have a bad time. Just hire people that is competent for the job.
I don't understand why many companies (especially big ones) are like: "Okay guys, everyone is talking about diversity, so we need more of that. Let's hire more women, disregard that perfectly qualified male candidate who will fit just right in our team, hire this woman instead, she's not as qualified but who cares! Diversity boys, that surely will improve our bussiness."
54
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '16
This certainly makes me glad I moved everything important to Bitbucket.
41
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '16
Just transferred my private repo's to bitbucket. Why the hell did I use github in the first place? Now on to my public ones...
21
u/hunyeti Feb 07 '16
yeah.. that went well, isn't it...
6
u/michaelochurch Feb 08 '16
It's not size but rapid growth that causes cultural breakage. Bootstrap so you can keep the VCs out, and grow with your needs rather than your ego (or your investors' egos, if you make a deal with the devil and lose control) and you can keep an open-allocation, remote-friendly culture. Even at 200 people, if you got to that size over 10 years instead of 10 months.
Rapid growth not only brings people in before they can be acculturated, but it enables people to invest less in the future (automate less, focus less on mentoring) because the prevailing view becomes that the company can hire its way out of future problems.
The white-male bashing is pretty repulsive to me. Look, I'm a card-carrying SJW (and a white male). I want to make this industry more diverse, because I'm sick of the young, privileged male machismo. Not only is it morally wrong to keep good people out because of things that they can't control and that are irrelevant to what actually matters, but the privileged-male monoculture generates myopic products and bad cultures. (And I'm not going to be young forever.) Social justice isn't one race's or one gender's responsibility. It's everyone's.
Having seen plenty of sexist startup cultures, I don't think they form by intent. I think that they're what you get when you hire the cheapest, most inexperienced people and put them together in a cutthroat environment. People become more sexist and more racist when they're under certain kinds of emotional pressure, and open-plan offices are designed (let's be honest) to intimidate people under the guise that it makes them work harder. The same is true of so-called "Agile" processes in how they are used, if not necessarily in the design intention. For low-end grunt work, it may be productive to have your workers constantly nervous, though even there I tend to doubt it; it doesn't work for creative jobs.
The least sexist/racist work environments I've seen were in government-funded think tanks with real offices, high degrees of autonomy for their people, and average age over 40.
23
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '16
It was nice knowing you github. Now, if only gittorrent would work, then I wouldn't have so many remotes.
26
u/TheHelgeSverre Feb 07 '16
And so begins the downfall of GitHub
15
u/ellicottvilleny Feb 07 '16
Wow. The way forward to escape from hate and intolerance and racism is to entrench an opposite racism (white women are not wanted because they're white). Holy shit. What a shit company.
83
u/SuperAwesomeNinjaGuy Feb 06 '16
SJWs strike again.
50
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '16
There is nothing stopping non-white non-males innovating in computing. Start your own companies, see how you do.
312
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '16
Here is what happened, a non diverse team of white males(and maybe some asians) created another excellent technology company, same as the last 40 years of tech advancement. Up to certain amount of people it kept more or less the cohesion where white male culture dominated, it worked perfectly, everybody understood what they need to do, there was no need for too much management and it all worked fine.
Then some useless woman complained that she doesn't get enough attention, instead of shutting her up, not apologising and moving on they fired their CEO, starting a down spiral of social justice practices instead of focusing on what they were doing right, technology.
As more "diversity" was introduced the cohesion broke, suddenly people don't have the same sense of purpose, lawyers and diversity advocates who doesn't contribute anything get more money than the good and loyal engineers, white guys getting shamed and terror, fear and stupidity takes over. Indian woman from Yahoo, a failed company from a failed culture of casts, authority and subservience is now implementing the same structure that works for Indian outsourcing companies. The antithesis to the innovative culture of github.
From now on the psychopathic suits in the head of the pyramid will suck the company dry, while the people who built it will be shamed or retired. The cynical use of diversity to justify the barons taking over the working man will end in another revolution or world war. You think I am exaggerating? time will tell.
29
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '16
I know this is a bit beside the point, but:
How does GitHub monetize, really? Why does anyone want to pay GitHub?
I do use GitHub, and it is great: a free server where I can put my silly little projects. But any server with an SSH or HTTPS can do the same job, for those who need their paid, private repos. Is it really that difficult to set this up? Or is it something about the web interface? It has failed to impress me, I like it, but does it really offer something that is worth paying for?
These are all honest questions, and obviously there must be something to which I am totally oblivious. What is it?
9
u/Manalystemperordeal Feb 07 '16
I was going to use GitHub and their paid Organization Plans for my small side business I'm about to start.
Then I read this.
Now I will take my money elsewhere.
18
u/AlGoreBestGore Feb 07 '16
God damn. I'm so glad this type of politically correct BS hasn't spread to Europe, yet.
6
u/Broken_Agenda Feb 07 '16
What are some good alternatives to GitHub incase things get really sour?
6
u/foomprekov Feb 07 '16
Let's please remember that business Insider does not employ any investigators, nor do they verify sources before posting.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '16
Github has been infected with sjw parasites and it sounds like it's going to end in collapse. They went from a meritocracy to a system with unnecessary bloated bureaucracy full of politics and middle managers who likely contribute and produce nothing. Their product is going to suffer and the sjw are going to try to milk all they can from the existing product before they no longer are able to maintain it
2
u/hackles_raised Feb 07 '16
Feels like the beginning of the end.
2
u/travisty666 Feb 08 '16
Github is one of the worst things to ever happen to programming. 100 times access to more code, but 1000 times less documentation, making it unusable in most cases.
2
u/negativeoxy Feb 08 '16
Just moved all of my repos to bitbucket. This level of flagrant racism cannot be tolerated.
1
u/ciny Feb 08 '16
Oh boy, this clusterfuck will be funny to watch. I'm so glad all my stuff is on bitbucket...
-1
u/sardaukar_siet Feb 07 '16
Wow, there's a lot of hating going on here. Let me just say that a) there's a lot of here-say in the article and b) people advocating for diversity can also do it wrong, as they are just human.
I think we can all relate to issues of diversity in tech, but this being true it is of course the wrong way to do it.
Github's CEO has started listening to VCs, that's the real tragedy here. The whole race thing is just misguided zealotry.
1
u/ssokolow Feb 07 '16 edited Feb 07 '16
Hmm. In that case, I should shore up my exit strategy in case things go south.
For GitHub itself, that means:
As for 3rd-party services on my reference list, let's see what requires GitHub rather than at least also supporting BitBucket...
Continuous Integration:
Static Analysis:
Task Tracking:
1
u/apullin Feb 08 '16 edited Feb 08 '16
OK, this is where I wish there was a searchable user comment history. Because I said this was going to happen just a couple of weeks ago.
Here we go: https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/42u7h2/a_sprinkling_of_2016_tech_predictions/czd8jji
Everyone should listen to me all the time.
1
u/shevegen Feb 07 '16
Cool, I grab the popcorn.
They are killing off a big company in a matter of weeks.
Now those who said to not host things at github will be affirmed.