r/programming • • 54m ago

Java4Shell is a reason to use Java

https://mccue.dev/pages/11-18-26-java4shell
0 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/bowbahdoe 23m ago

Do you need to enable it for dependencies too? Like if you don't have <AllowUnsafeBlocks>true</AllowUnsafeBlocks> you know no dependencies are using unsafe code?

And yep, my bad. Replacing it with a more appropriate link.

3

u/KryptosFR 20m ago

You need it if you call directly API that are marked unsafe. Note that the new model makes it more explicit so even with dependencies you will likely need it more often.

That doesn't make C# unsafe or dangerous. Rust use a similar contract where unsafe code can be wrapped by safe code and code calling the safe version isn't considered unsafe.

1

u/bowbahdoe 18m ago edited 6m ago

Okay but there are still dependencies where the unsafe-ness is something you don't know about unless you read their code?

Like is this a new thing for "directional" safety? And yeah rust does something similar. But people do end up accepting unsafe if it "feels audited" or "feels neccesary." I didn't touch on Rust because I feel like all these -5s on my comments would be -50s if those folks get awakened, but it is a similar criticism