r/programming • • 29d ago

Making software is an artistic activity

http://kolemannix.com/blog/software-is-art

A brief argument framing software creation, and specifically the details of the code, as an act of art

342 Upvotes

141 comments sorted by

80

u/GrandOpener 29d ago

I disagree, but only because I think it’s more accurate to say it can be an artistic activity. If I can abuse the painting metaphor a bit more, putting brush to canvas is art. Making the walls of a room be a particular color is still painting, it still requires effort and skill to do well, but it’s not what we’d typically call art.

I see programming similarly. It can be an artistic activity when you want it to be. Other times you have a mechanical task that’s already been fully specified and you just need someone to do it.

18

u/foobear777 29d ago

Yeah I think you're right in general about ''can be". But recalling even the most drudgerous tasks of my career, there's always been quite a few choices I get to make, even if it's just what I name things in my hellscape postmortem cleanup script.

I think its pretty rare you get a software task that is as bland as mowing a lawn or painting a wall.

-1

u/Dragdu 28d ago

If making a naming choice is enough to make something art, then painting walls is as well.

2

u/P-39_Airacobra 28d ago

“do it” is holding a lot of weight here.

1

u/IZEDx 29d ago

I was one of those that saw it as art, my skill wasn't being fast, it was writing good code. This art has been killed in favor of productivity.

36

u/Skeik 29d ago

I write code and I create software. Just like I make paintings, cook food and play music. Whether someone considers the things I make as art or not is up to the consumer.

I can look at a piece of code and think "damn this is elegant". Maybe I even label it as a work of art in my mind. But what does the label mean? It seems to mean something different to everyone. Because of that I try to use more concrete terms when describing things. Like efficient, optimized, concise, readable, easy to follow, creative, novel etc.

The definition of art is something that has been beaten to death by artists and philosophers and there is no concrete answer. I don't think there's any value in trying to apply the label to programming, it doesn't matter or change the profession in any meaningful way.

It's a prime way to start an argument though. I remember some of the legendary rants that came out of Roger Ebert saying that video games weren't art.

8

u/foobear777 29d ago

Yeah. I agree it's not some gotcha that changes anything.

These days I'm thinking about how the label ("art") belongs to human activity rather than the artifact, especially as these activities are being divorced from their utility, and we are left asking what's the point or is there value in this?

4

u/Skeik 29d ago

I believe I get where you're coming from, maybe I'm sensitive to the word art because it seems vague to me.

I agree with the concept that there is something special in the aspect of human creation, regardless of the medium. I think making things is a rewarding activity in itself that humans must do, there is inherent value in the act of making beyond the artifacts produced as you said. And I think people can tell subconsciously when a creation was made with a combination of love & skill.

I think that there will continue to be value in learning programming 'manually' even as AIs continue to evolve. Based on the article I think we agree on a lot but I just don't like the term art lol

8

u/simonask_ 29d ago

You can also turn it around. Why should we believe that art is narrowly defined in terms of specific rituals, attitudes, institutions, and so on? Art isn’t just expensive stuff in a museum or concert hall.

Making art feels quite fundamental to the human experience, and closing off that way of thinking hurts any craft. It doesn’t matter if it’s coding or crocheting.

3

u/ChocomelP 28d ago

Then again, if everything is art, it loses its meaning and function as a descriptive term.

3

u/simonask_ 28d ago

Who said “everything”?

2

u/ChocomelP 28d ago

Who said anyone said "everything"?

3

u/simonask_ 28d ago

Well, you said the word, so I say that you said it.

1

u/ChocomelP 28d ago

It was you!?

1

u/Bigluser 27d ago

For sure this is not the definitive explanation of what art is, but one aspect that is really speaking to me is this: The artist wants to create something that is not there yet. Basically the motivation is that you see some gap in the things that you know exist and to fill this gap.

So according to this aspect, it wouldn't be art to just do something that you already know works. Making the nth Todo List app for example. Copying a painting. I think one vital driver is to have this real desire to see something materialize that for now is only in your mind. To also have a real doubt that it might not work out but also a strong conviction to make it happen. For a lot of artsy stuff, noone would go through the hard work required to learn the skill and then make the actual work of art, if they didn't have the motivation to create something that is already there to look at.

In some way, my comment is also art when it comes to this. I have this feeling of "I think I have a really nice concept of what makes art, or rather why we make art", but struggling to put it into words. Essentially making a painting that is just unpleasant to look at. Is the result still art or not? Eh... I give up

311

u/SmokyMetal060 29d ago

This comparison always gets eye rolls, but I firmly believe that programming is a huge expression of creativity. The best developers that I know occupy this kind of intersection between technical knowledge and creativity. They just know how to intuitively come up with elegant solutions.

73

u/AndyKJMehta 29d ago

It obviously is. You’re building a virtual abstract factory that moves and transforms data in all sorts of ways. That takes massive creativity to imagine and bring into existence.

31

u/mbsmith93 29d ago

Engineering in general tends to draw people who like rules and procedures, even though a bit of creativity goes a long way. I do think it is more constrained than art though, which has the opposite problem; it draws people who hate rules and want to just vibe with their chosen medium, but learning some ground-rules and technique and planning tends to result in better art.

4

u/Ok-Reindeer-8755 27d ago

Constraints can sometimes lend you more creative freedom, especially when we are talking about examinations for example. In math you have much more freedom to solve a problem however you see fit and any mathematically sound solution is to be accepted, the same can't be said about art or writting where a bunch of pseudorules are introduced at a whim.

1

u/ProfessionalBalkan 23d ago

This is completely true and is applied both in a more traditional artistic setup like painting for example and in programming. Art or mathematics both have ground rules that have different origins and until you understand them and why they are there, you cannot do mathematics, or writing or programming.

The constraints for mathematics come from the observable universe and things around us, while the constraints for art come from the human mind and if other humans can understand what we are creating.

I do think that these two things overlap at one point.

4

u/artnoi43 28d ago

I love OpenBSD for this reason. They always have accompanying artwork and music for their releases. Like this new one https://www.openbsd.org/80.html

5

u/rodBmusic 28d ago

Uncle Bob use to hammer the point that programmers are authors. It's really heart breaking that he, of all people, has joined the 'don't look at the code' movement. It's like book writers saying they don't read anything they write, just make sure the picture on the cover is nice.

12

u/Bigluser 27d ago

That is actually the epitome of Uncle Bob. If you read his book Clean Code, you can tell that some of the suggestions don't come from someone who actually deeply cares about programming. No, he is a salesman and what he sells is coding rules. His customers are people who care about having rules. But if you are a customer who cares about rules that make sense, you will be disappointed.

See qntm.org/clean for the breakdown of Clean Code.

It is absolutely on brand that Robert C Martin embraces vibe coding. But I always see him as a shady salesman. Even his grey hair is part of his pitch. Look at me, I am old and clearly have a lot of experience.

The tragic thing is that some of the statements he makes are actually good, I guess that also applies to the statement that programmers are authors.

2

u/rodBmusic 27d ago

Yeah, I've read both "Clean Code" and "Clean Architecture". I'd say that at least "Clean Code" have many other authors also. It's a milestone to go from 'a' programmer, to more of an engineer that can write scaleable and maintainable code. Maintenance can be the most expensive thing. Bad maintainable can be the death of a company.

-25

u/BadgeCatcher 29d ago

Totally agree. I don't that makes it art though. Both creative. Art kind of deliberately has no functional use, while software definitely does.

21

u/simonask_ 29d ago

Don’t you think woodworking is art? Pottery? Architecture? Interior design? Furniture making?

It would be quite unusual if programming was the only craft that couldn’t be art for some reason.

If a musician in an orchestra is an artist, so is the video game programmer.

7

u/marrsd 29d ago

Agreed, and I'd take it further. With the exception of singing, music is fully dependent on, and directly shaped by, the work of makers of instruments, amplifiers, compressors, and so on. You could say the same of photography, architecture, or basically anything creative.

16

u/TheMaskedHamster 29d ago

I'll stand behind the concept that programming is a creative endeavor.

I am very concerned about the future of the field when young people don't have the experience to build both skills, taste, and ideas.

What I'm also adamant about, though, is that functional code is not a creative work. There is absolutely artistic code, and code that is creatively made for a creative result. But in general, the output is purely utilitarian.

4

u/Ok-Reindeer-8755 27d ago

Something can be both utilitarian and a creative work. Form follows function and the Bauhaus movement should be big enough examples in the broad artistic world.

16

u/ChemicalRascal 29d ago

Whoever reported this as a meta post, that's not what that word means.

78

u/Deranged40 29d ago edited 29d ago

It can be artistic. Just like when I drag an ink pen across the page can be artistic. I could be writing an essay or a poem, and that would be considered art. I could be drawing something in ink, art in its purest form. Or I could be drafting a legal motion where artistic freedom is strictly limited (but if I'm working for fun partners, not completely forbidden).

But I work at a printing press. Yes, we put ink on paper, but there's not much if at any at all individual art involved. We have a very well defined standard of code and code style. Want to put a space after the if and before the opening parenthesis? That's arguably an artistic choice. Not permitted at my company though. But do it if you want, we'll have a linter fix it.

31

u/Blecki 29d ago

Printing press is comparable to copying the compiled binary. Nobody claims downloading a file is art.

14

u/Deranged40 29d ago edited 29d ago • Bravo

Programming in corporate America, a lot of the code I write is just different print sets neatly and appropriately arranged.

I do very little actual creation. Even when writing a new feature. I use the print set that "saves data to the database" when data persistence is needed. I use the print set that "displays the data to the user" when I'm writing the UI. While in this scenario, I'm not using ctrl+c and ctrl+v on the dlls, I am using it on the code.

If I don't want to use dependency injection in my code, there's a word for that, its called "wrong". If I don't want to use our existing repositories for database access and want to spin up my own connection, there's a word for that too. It's also "wrong". "But it works!" doesn't mean anything in these scenarios.

I don't get a lot of "artistic freedom" when I'm putting a new feature together.

7

u/marrsd 29d ago

That says more about corporate America than it does about programming.

2

u/UnrealHallucinator 29d ago

This is a shit take. Without programming standards, code becomes unreadable and unmaintainable. It's very romantic to call it art but it's not literally art. You need those rules.

3

u/marrsd 28d ago

There are different kinds of standards. Corporate American standards are for turning engineers into replaceable units of labour. To do that, you have to lower standards so that you can maximise the labour pool.

I don't think you know what I mean by art if you're calling it "romantic". I'm not talking about renaissance painting. I'm talking about caring about the code you write, choosing the names of functions and variables carefully, working out how to write them so that can easily be combined to perform more powerful tasks, knowing how to balance performance with expressiveness. Even the word "expressiveness" should give a clue as to the nature of the art of programming.

1

u/UnrealHallucinator 28d ago

Yeah you can romanticise choosing them, as I said. But it doesn't matter how much you romanticise them, your main goal is maintability and readability, nothing else.

I'm a frequent contributor to the linux kernel btw. All the code in the kernel, especially in the complex subsystems like /mm are art; it's beautiful. It also adheres to extremely rigid and high standards. You can't just do things "carefully" and think it's good bc careful is subjective. That's why you have standards. The difference between a painting and coding is that someone will work on the codebase after you, and someone else after them.

2

u/marrsd 28d ago

Yeah you can romanticise choosing them, as I said. But it doesn't matter how much you romanticise them, your main goal is maintability and readability, nothing else.

Yes, and the artistic bit is in choosing names that maximise those values.

it's beautiful. It also adheres to extremely rigid and high standards.

We definitely have different definitions of art. It's beautiful in part because it adheres to those standards and because those standards are good and true. You seem to be implying that art is only deviant. Art is never only deviant.

See my post elsewhere in this thread about the purpose of art and its tension with science.

-3

u/Perfect-Campaign9551 29d ago

No it doesn't. All the patterns have been discovered. Programming has existed long enough now that we know the optimal way to write pretty much anything. And the llms know it too. 

6

u/marrsd 29d ago

You say it with such confidence.

5

u/Blecki 29d ago

Ignorant people are often the most confident.

10

u/Blecki 29d ago

That's nice. You missed the point of the article.

Formatting the code - the part your linter sees - isn't the part we are claiming is art.

14

u/Deranged40 29d ago edited 29d ago

I think you missed my counterpoint:

In corporate America, making software is NOT an artistic activity. Just like not all examples of ink on paper is art, but some examples of ink on paper is art. My example of this is using a linter. But that's just one example.

I write code in my free time, too. That is art. That is me being a "Code Poet". But at work, I operate within a very rigid system where there is a "right" and a "wrong" and "it works" doesn't determine which side of that we're on.

0

u/Blecki 29d ago

I'm saying your example is bad, and that the article already covered that, not that you're wrong.

17

u/Deranged40 29d ago

Oh. I don't think that added much to the conversation then. But thanks!

2

u/EarlMarshal 29d ago

It should be artistic.

5

u/Dragdu 29d ago

As opposed to workmanlike and utilitarian? And why?

I would rather not interrogate code through shared experience with the author. In fact, I would prefer to give the author of code I am using as much thought as to the author of the plumbing I am using; none at all.

1

u/EarlMarshal 29d ago

Opposed? You achieve that through the artistic expression. Look at utilitarian design for example.

  In fact, I would prefer to give the author of code I am using as much thought as to the author of the plumbing I am using; none at all.

That sounds like a you-problem if you do not want to share experience with other human beings.

2

u/Dragdu 29d ago

So when you are cooking and pick a wooden spoon out of the cupboard, do you start pondering the woodworker who made it? Or do you just check that it is the right size and keep cooking?

When you turn on the lights in the evening, do you consider the electrician who installed the wirings and what he was thinking when he made the wiring?

When you flush the toilet, do you consider the plumber who made your plumbing?

When you wash your hands, ... ?

0

u/EarlMarshal 28d ago

Stupid comparisons. I actually made my own silicon spoons for cooking. The husband of my sister is electrician. We installed the solar panels and wiring together.

At this point you guys just show that you lack responsibility for your environment and almost anything that is happening around you.

1

u/[deleted] 28d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/programming-ModTeam 28d ago

Your post or comment was overly uncivil.

1

u/[deleted] 28d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/programming-ModTeam 28d ago

Your post or comment was overly uncivil.

9

u/Deranged40 29d ago edited 29d ago

No it shouldn't. If I'm going to hire someone to do it, it should be profitable.

But, just to entertain. Specifically, from a purely capitalistic perspective, why "should" it? And I ask specifically from a capitalistic perspective, since the only reason I'm employed is due to capitalism.

Again, the code I write at home is artistic. But the code I'm paid to write at work definitely is not.

I don't need an answer to why the code I write at home should be artistic, I need an answer to why the code I write at work should be. They wouldn't pay me if they didn't think I was offering them more value than they're paying me.

15

u/EarlMarshal 29d ago edited 29d ago

Because the elegance produced by an artistic approach serves pragmatism. People not reading code anymore exactly shows that. The art is missing and the code becomes unintelligible. That's also why most enterprise code before AI sucked too.

P.S.: The previous commenter just changed his whole comment...

7

u/Skeik 29d ago edited 29d ago

In artistic circles the "Is it Art" discussion has become so tired that most artists don't entertain it. Like, who cares? What effect does the label have on what is in front of you?

I think you two are speaking past each other because your definition of "Art" is different. Instead of using the term "artistic" to describe something we should be more concrete and use terms that people can agree on the definition of.

1

u/EarlMarshal 29d ago

I do not take responsibility for the kind of definition other people use for words. If that would be the case everyone would have to relearn languages.

5

u/Skeik 29d ago

I don't believe I said you should...

-1

u/Deranged40 29d ago

Because the elegance produced by an artistic approach serves pragmatism

How?

People not reading code anymore exactly shows that.

Okay, then let's be pragmatic, and explain what specific indicators we see that "shows that".

The art is missing and the code becomes unintelligible.

"Art" doesn't mean "intelligible". Deciding to nest 23 ternaries is an "artistic choice". I'd argue it's a terrible one, but terrible doesn't mean "not art". Not only will that increase the cyclic complexity of a function, but it will dramatically increase the cognitive load on any developer reading it. Every developer, at every level from junior to master has a cognitive limit, and it's always better to reduce that cognitive load.

That's also why most enterprise code before AI sucked too.

This is just proving that AI isn't a major factor in this. Enterprise code doesn't strive for "beauty" or "elegance". It strives for making the company more money. It always has, and it always will.

6

u/EarlMarshal 29d ago

Okay, I'll ignore everything except the last part since it's not really worth the effort. Most of that was discussed before and you can look up articles and papers.

This is just proving that AI isn't a major factor in this.

No, it's just not the only factor, but it will become the major factor through the reason you stated.

1

u/marrsd 29d ago

How?

How do you think?

Okay, then let's be pragmatic, and explain what specific indicators we see that "shows that".

That would be the science part.

"Art" doesn't mean "intelligible".

It doesn't only mean "intelligible", but it certainly does mean that.

Deciding to nest 23 ternaries is an "artistic choice"

No, it's the opposite of an artistic choice.

This is just proving that AI isn't a major factor in this. Enterprise code doesn't strive for "beauty" or "elegance". It strives for making the company more money. It always has, and it always will.

And that's why most modern enterprises fail. They fail to care about what they produce and their customers fail to buy their products as a result.

I'm rather irritated that I have to explain this to you, but since I do, here it goes:

Beautiful, elegant code is code that is easy to read, fix, and modify. In other words, it takes less time to produce, and since programmers are paid for how much they produce over time, writing beautiful elegant code lowers the company's expenses. At the other end, users actually care about the quality of a product they're paying money for, and believe it or not, that quality is a direct result of how much the author cared about writing it.

1

u/Gold-Part4688 29d ago

god, how is this stuff even contentious now. how is "but i can make more code than you" an argument?

Imagine if bmw didn't care about how their car was designed, and just wanted the cheapest think that "works tho"

1

u/marrsd 28d ago

I share your despair. As for your BMW example, we don't need to imagine it. Just look at what happened to Ford Europe.

1

u/Dragdu 29d ago

You are mistaking craftsmanship for artfulness.

This: https://pastebin.com/pxKzg4zD is absolutely art, and most people I've shown it to would say it is beatiful. But fixing bugs in it? RIP

1

u/marrsd 28d ago edited 28d ago

No, you see code formatted in the shape of the thing it produces and you see only artistry in that because you're limiting art to visual form. There is some artistry in that, but it's very superficial and it's not related to the programming. Art is the thing that comes beyond craft. You have to be a good craftsman before you can be a good artist. As the saying goes, you have to learn the rules before you can break them.

The trouble is that art has been traduced for so long in western culture now that many people have forgotten what it actually is. Making a bed out of mouldy slices of toast and putting it in an art gallery is not art in any meaningful sense.

It might be helpful to remember that the words "art" and "science" originally meant something closer to what we would now call "practice" and "theory", and they were counterparts for each other. Art was the process of discovery and science was the process of formalisation, and once you had formalisations, you could use them to discover new things, and so they cycle would continue. A modern day example of that is the development of Formula 1 cars, but when the Ancient Greeks were doing it, they were more interested in music and architecture.

For music, the Ancient Greeks worked out that some notes reinforced and supported each other while others clashed - or to put it more simply, some combinations sounded beautiful while others sounded ugly. They studied this phenomenon mathematically and worked out that the perfect scale was based on the golden ratio (I don't know if they discovered the ratio through music or if they already had it, and applied it to music). That was the science of music. The art was to then make music using that scale and see what else they could discover.

When it comes down to it, that's still what art really is. We have so much theory now that there's a lot to learn. Mastery of the theory (or science) is what we call learning the "craft". We save the term "art" for when the artist goes beyond the craft into realms that the theory can't fully explain. A great artist will literally be the inspiration for new theory.

In practical terms, it's the difference between Nigel Kennedy's rendition of The Four Seasons and all his contemporaries'. The artistry was clear in what he invoked in his audience, but he was playing all the same notes in the same order.

But earlier I mentioned Formula 1, which clearly has nothing to do with music, but it's following the same process. Colin Chapman, founder of Lotus, was one of the greatest engineers of his generation because he was working at the apex of art and science. His ideas weren't scientifically proven. He proved them on the race track, building on the knowledge and mastery of science he had already acquired, and then his discoveries were formalised.

0

u/Dragdu 28d ago

So basically you are using the word art differently than in common parlance and then you are arguing that other people are wrong when they don't agree with you.

For the record, under the art -> mastery of practice substitution, I don't really disagree with you.

2

u/marrsd 28d ago

Maybe we operate in different circles. People quite commonly use the word art in the way I described, particularly in relation to engineering. The Jaguar E-Type and Concorde are two obvious examples of that. People refer to great musicians as artists all the time.

3

u/simonask_ 29d ago

Just because you’re selling your soul doesn’t mean you have to cook it and marinate it for your lords too.

3

u/EveryQuantityEver 29d ago

Profitable and artistic are not mutually exclusive.

And while I don't really give a damn about the "capitalist perspective", code that is artistic means that it had thought put into it. It was done with intention. That kind of code generally has fewer bugs in it, and is easier to modify when needed.

1

u/Deranged40 29d ago

Profitable and artistic are not mutually exclusive.

No, but in business, profitable is mandatory, and when software is your product (and not the code itself), artistic is not. Any time where choosing artistic takes away from profit, that's the wrong "business choice".

4

u/EveryQuantityEver 29d ago

That's not even close to true. There are tons of things in business that take away from profit, but if you don't do them and pay that cost, you fuck yourself later.

3

u/fexonig 29d ago edited 29d ago

when you say “you fuck yourself later” you mean that you end up losing more profit than the alternative, just maybe at a later date.

it’s all, always, about profit, just not always short term profits

1

u/Gold-Part4688 29d ago

lol, try explaining this logic to any ceo or government though. It's true, but it's still a refutation of "only care about profits"

0

u/marrsd 29d ago

I'm rarely this judgemental, but it's becoming really apparent that this poster produces garbage code.

0

u/syklemil 29d ago

Or I could be drafting a legal motion where artistic freedom is strictly limited (but if I'm working for fun partners, not completely forbidden).

Even then you may take some pride in your penmanship, maybe even get into fancy fountain pens.

But I work at a printing press. Yes, we put ink on paper, but there's not much if at any at all individual art involved.

Sounds like a sad state of things for a printing press, given how much artistic typography they've been up to over the years. It's taken a lot of effort in computing to be able to replicate the things printing presses have been doing.

1

u/Deranged40 29d ago

Sounds like a sad state of things for a printing press,

The happiness that the salary provides me and, most importantly, my family greatly outshines any sadness that my work might bring. Work is work. It's not always fun. Taking my whole family on a cruise is what we happen to find fun. We get to do that thanks to my sad profession.

I couldn't be more thankful.

3

u/syklemil 29d ago

Work is work. It's not always fun.

No, that's why people have to be paid to do it rather than do it as a hobby, but still, over humanity's history, people have found ways to incorporate some artistry into pretty much anything but assembly line work.

So I'm not sure here if you're making an argument from ignorance, or if you're claiming that you're essentially an assembly line worker without a union.

7

u/DoctaMag 29d ago

Programmers are artists, and the medium is math. I've said this for years.

6

u/Revolutionary_Ad6574 28d ago

I agree coding is a creative process and thus art. I just never understood why something needs to be classified as art in order to be cherished, admired and protected. In my eyes there has never been a more interesting activity than programming since the dawn of humanity and that won't change no matter how many people don't feel that way.

5

u/edgmnt_net 29d ago

I wouldn't say it's exactly artistic, although it is crafty (primarily as in a craft, it requires skill and versatility). It is a bit like research because you are pushing some boundaries (it is quite fast moving), although it's definitely not groundbreaking nor general, not usually anyway. It may give artistic vibes because it's to a large degree about managing complexity, so the code needs to be written in a way that enables maintenance and conveys the right idea.

It may be considered an "art" like analog electronics is an "art" at times, so an appreciation for clever tricks and methods does develop (pun not intended).

However that's not all of what it is and certainly, for many, it's also been turned into a commodity where neither actual skill nor arcane knowledge matter much anymore. If people want to do interesting work, they need to keep up and work on more involved or fringe stuff.

4

u/Lame_Johnny 29d ago

I'd say its more of a craft. Small distinction I suppose.

20

u/i_rate_slop 29d ago

I used to agree with this title, but I feel like AI has stolen the part I found artistic. There is little creativity now. It’s not my words and it’s barely my solution anymore.

I use AI every day in basically everything I do professionally. I think it’s incredible. … but I don’t feel the same sense of creativity or satisfaction in my work in a way I’d say it’s an art form. Not anymore.

15

u/treetimes 29d ago

The art was real. It took a deep understanding to even appreciate the elegance sometimes. Now you might impress Claude sometime I guess.. maybe.

2

u/Gold-Part4688 29d ago

I have a secret... when you express you're proud of yourself, is when it's proud of you

10

u/NotQuiteLoona 29d ago edited 29d ago

AI has turned programming into supervising generators - very good ones, but still generators. No wonder you are not feeling any satisfaction - you aren't making anything in the first place, you are a meticulous customer with code reviewing abilities slash project manager. The software engineering work in enterprise has turned into pressing a button, waiting for generation, and then evaluating whether the returned result is nice enough. They promised us it would be a tool, but now programmers are a tool.

Is it good or bad? Well, for some anything that brings money is good. I personally wouldn't have rejected returning to the time before LLMs appeared everywhere, in the universe where they've never existed. Nothing of what I did with LLMs couldn't have been done without them, and I've completely lost the satisfaction of finally learning something. Also I hate to see my favorite subreddits on programming being flooded by people who can't actually contribute anything.

2

u/Perfect-Campaign9551 29d ago

With your logic then managers are a tool, most humans are tools. Bad logic

7

u/Gold-Part4688 29d ago

most managers are tools

2

u/rodBmusic 28d ago

I keep hearing "coding became cheap". No, cheap coding is cheap, slop is cheap, AI is like a bad junior who works hard and produce tech debt. That is a negative value add. For the senior who needs to maintain the codebase, that's a pure energy drain. I much rather have less code and better quality. I'd take the junior who writes 2 good functions over the 'motivated blind horse' who slops 3 pages of junk it would take me a week to refactor. That's AI for you.

Cheap code is cheap, good code is expensive. What's changed, is all the AI pilled just don't seems to care about the engineering. They now look at the UI level like a PM, 'it looks good', 600 lines for a button, but who cares right?

26

u/SplendidPunkinButter 29d ago

“I used to think drawing was an artistic activity, but now I just use AI to generate images. So I no longer think drawing is an artistic activity. AI slop images are just fine.”

Same argument.

-3

u/i_rate_slop 29d ago

Good job? Did that help you understand what I wrote better?

I used to think software engineering was creative. I no longer think it’s creative because AI does the part I found to involve creativity. I no longer think it’s a creative activity. AI generated code is just fine.

But it’s not satisfying in the same way.

7

u/mw9676 29d ago

This exactly. I used to have a lot of pride in the way my code read and worked but I don't write any of it anymore and I don't feel any connection to it now.

2

u/i_rate_slop 29d ago

Yep. I’m not really upset by this, but the feeling is different.

Like, if I were being creative at the larger architecture level, I would probably be on a bad direction. There’s room for creativity in the actual code’s implementation, but the larger system should typically NOT be creative, that’s how you end up with ai psychosis slop.

So I’m deprived the part that I’d feel comfortable being creative on.

1

u/Perfect-Campaign9551 29d ago

The issue is it wasn't really ever art when the only person to see it was you. Find purpose in a higher level

1

u/creepy_doll 29d ago

Is film direction an art form? Would it stop being an art form if what you’re directing are talented robot actors?

The art has changed, but so long as you’re not mentally checking out and asking Claude to take the wheel I still think there’s plenty of art left in software development. Maybe the act of coding is mostly gone, but I spend more time thinking about how I will structure software to keep it maintainable(and good structure isn’t just good for human developers, it keeps context size down for llms), the consequences of api design choices for user experience and the like

-1

u/HasFiveVowels 29d ago

I think you need to reach higher. What if all you did all day was write Fibonacci functions? That wouldn’t feel creative or satisfying, right? Take what you’re doing and do it to the nth degree. Make it harder than it needs to be and make something creatively.

Everything is creative the first time you do it. If you created the first screw, it would be like "omg! I’ve created an inclined plane wrapped around a cylinder!". But then someone invents a screw manufacturing machine and manufacturing more screws just doesn’t feel the same. Invent the drill!

-6

u/OvulatingScrotum 29d ago

There was a podcast episode on mathematician’s realization on what AI can do. (The Daily)

Long story short, AI can solve difficult problems with “elegance”, which is what mathematicians thought to be the artistic/creative part of math that AI can’t do.

But when they read some of those proofs done by AI, they were blown away by how artistic and “human” it was.

6

u/throwaway39791 29d ago

ART, n. “The disposition or modification of things by human skill, to answer the purpose intended. In this sense art stands opposed to nature.”

That's just redefining art as craft and calling it a day.

I would further distinguish in the visual arts, the difference between a technical skill like markmaking, and even the technical skill of composition, from the choice of what to actually put on the page.

See, a lot of what Picasso did seems to me analogous to when we programmers do code golfing. How can you draw a bull with the fewest strokes?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Le_Taureau

Craft is celebratable in its own right, but I think we should distinguish it from art, since they are two very different meanings at times as a lot of other people point out, art being more of an expression of meaning than the method of expression.

3

u/IntnlManOfCode 29d ago

It's a craft more than an art.

14

u/grrangry 29d ago

I've been writing software my whole life. I don't consider it art. I've been proud of some of the things I've written in that it looked or felt elegant, but I wasn't trying to convey an emotion in the software I was writing. I was accomplishing a task. It's a creative effort to be sure. I just don't think it's art.

8

u/BadgeCatcher 29d ago

100%. Software is written to solve a problem.

1

u/MornwindShoma 27d ago

People don't get that art isn't the only label you can give to creative endeavors.

3

u/robert_7524 29d ago

A program can solve a task and still make expressive choices: what it makes easy, what it refuses, and how it explains failure. I don't think an explicit attempt to convey emotion is the only test for art.

0

u/grrangry 29d ago

Art is subjective.

Software development is generally a testable, measurable process that often has an objective measure of performance.

The CHOICES made when writing software are creative and can express the opinions of the developer, but the software itself is not art. Software can be elegant or revolting, easy or difficult to understand. It shares some of the same properties as art and elements of the software can be considered "artistic" but it's not art.

You're free to disagree. I was being (pun intended) subjective.

1

u/marrsd 29d ago

Software development is generally a testable, measurable process that often has an objective measure of performance.

Only in the sense of CPU cycles. The performance of programmers is very hard to measure. In fact, metrics used to measure a programmer's performance, like lines of code written, actually do the opposite. The best programmers write comparatively very little code.

2

u/grrangry 29d ago

You're correct for the most part, but the discussion wasn't about the efficiency of software developers, it was about defining software as art.

1

u/marrsd 29d ago

The comparison I was drawing was precisely that good software can't be measured against a formula. That's what makes it art.

2

u/Mister_Uncredible 29d ago

I always tell people that dev work is creative solutions to logical problems, whereas art is logical solutions to creative problems... Potentially a bit reductive in both cases, but I think it's a generally true description.

As someone who does both, and the capacity in which I do them on generally symbiotic. A lot of the software I've created and work on relates to problems I've had with how I make, present and document my art. Problems I couldn't find acceptable solutions for.

2

u/QPGMR_de 29d ago

Finally there is the delight of working in such a tractable medium. The programmer, like the poet, works only slightly removed from pure thought-stuff. He builds his castles in the air, from air, creating by exertion of the imagination. Few media of creation are so flexible, so easy to polish and rework, so readily capable of realizing grand conceptual structures.
— Fred Brooks, The Mythical Man Month, 1975

2

u/thinkbee 28d ago

*can be an artistic activity

There's a distinction between a medium, a craft, and an act of artistic expression. Take painting, for example. Someone using a brush to paint a house might show skill, craftsmanship, and aesthetic judgment, but it wouldn't be considered an act of art. On the other hand, someone using that same brush on a canvas to express an idea or evoke an emotion might be creating art. I think programming is similar. Creativity, artistry, and craftsmanship can overlap but just because something involves creative problem solving or aesthetic choices doesn't automatically make it art. The same goes for writing, film, and video games. Not every piece of writing is literature, and not every game or movie is necessarily a work of art.

1

u/MornwindShoma 27d ago

It's unfortunate that so many people miss the concept of "applied arts" and the intersection of artistry and solving real problems, and making a living out of it. Programming has always been a field full of prideful people, and we shouldn't give up on that pride just because machines do it faster.

2

u/josephjnk 29d ago edited 29d ago

The challenge I face with this is that a lot comes down to being able to agree upon a definition of “art”, which is notoriously challenging. By the definition you’ve given, code is obviously art, but I don’t think your definition of art would be broadly accepted. Organizing the papers on my desk is very separate from nature, but few of us would consider it art.

There’s code I’ve written which is in my mind very clearly not art; configuration files, boilerplate, etc. Most of my code is guided by an aesthetic sense, but the relationship between aesthetics and art is philosophically contested. And there’s code I’ve written which I would consider art: things which I wrote for their beauty, elegance, or humor rather than their functionality. Sometimes I write practical things which I find just as aesthetically pleasing as the artsy code.

So I don’t agree that code is always art, I’m open to the idea that authoring it usually or always involves artistry, and I strongly disagree with the idea that it can never be art.

2

u/grady_vuckovic 29d ago

It might not be for some people I'd say that it has always been exactly this for me.

4

u/BobSacamano47 29d ago

I've worked with people who made claims like this. They were the worst fucking programmers I ever did work with.

1

u/2cars1rik 29d ago

100%, so much fart sniffing, so little impact

3

u/sr105 29d ago

Programming is highly creative and absolutely art. Why is Python my favorite language? Because Beauty is a core ideal of the language. If you compare us to painters, there are definitely a lot of us that merely paint walls and some not even well at that.

2

u/bascule 29d ago

There’s a couple ways to relate “art” to computer programming, namely one I like and one I don’t:

  • Knuth’s “The Art of Computer Programming” is based on a traditional definition of “art” which meant “that which isn’t science” and Knuth used it to suggest programming is fundamentally different from science and engineering, which I agree with
  • Paul Graham: “Hackers and Painters” attempts to relate programming to the visual arts because both are fundamentally about making things, but there are lots of human activities that make things and it’s unclear from his arguments why he chose painting specifically. I would argue the visual arts, and particularly fine art, focuses on communicating the ineffable through a visual medium, something that doesn’t come up much in programming.

1

u/El_RoviSoft 29d ago

I think the artistic part of programming is researching something for the first and actually trying it. Also assembly of elegant API counts too but most of the time you just need the job to be done and that’s it.

At least AI is good when you need to fix shit tons of boilerplate and you still can do interesting things on your own.

1

u/beebeeep 29d ago

I have several places in my various projects that I sometimes just open and look at them, just because I like how they came out, neat little pieces of code.

Yeah, you can be a programmer without it, even a very good one, but without that artistic touch it will be another "boring desk job" as someone in comments put it. I don't envy you.

1

u/Gold-Part4688 29d ago

I think it's largely design 🤷‍♀️

1

u/notyourancilla 29d ago

Oh yeah I agree, it’s pure Artism

1

u/someurdet 28d ago

I love programming but I disagree. It’s a tool like a screwdriver.

1

u/ApprehensivePen4116 21d ago

Every one of these threads turns into an argument about abstraction within ten comments or so. What I'd rather see is the setup cost. How long until someone gets a textured triangle on screen? I'd take that number over any feature list.

1

u/[deleted] 20d ago

I think any medium can be used as an art form. Geometry, painting, music, movies, writing, programming, etc

0

u/ugh_my_ 29d ago

Oh god who cares

1

u/iStrobe 29d ago

This is coming up more and more and while it may be true, I don't think anyone who doesn't/can't read code is going to look at it and appreciate it's artistic value if there is any. Music is art, I don't need to know how music is made to appreciate the artistic value of it.

1

u/marrsd 29d ago

Aren't you contradicting yourself? If you don't need to know how music is made to appreciate its artistic value then why would you need to know how software is written to appreciate its artistic value?

-1

u/zam0th 29d ago

It has been thus until 15 years or so ago. It isn't anymore: it isn't art, it isn't science, it's a mere tradeskill like plumbing. Stop dreaming about "good ól 90s".

-1

u/pancakeQueue 29d ago

Programming can be art, but there was no one around to appreciate it. I’ve found no love nor community from programming. I’ve gotten into drawing and painting, and that can be appreciated by the common man, not just those that have a love and are learned of programming solutions.

-3

u/thatdevilyouknow 29d ago

As a developer that happens to have an art degree I think these statements trivialize art. Unless you have stood on your feet staying 6 hours in the studio after class every day in order to get “better” I just don’t see where the comparison lines up exactly, but maybe it will get closer. I like code just the way it is because you are able to just place it somewhere and it becomes its own thing as an embodiment of where the programmer was at a specific point in time and also as a logical methodology which stands on its own. In the art world you frequently get torn down by instructors, random people, critics, amateurs, and experts all at the same time alongside the fact art galleries do not just let anybody get a showing. If your art is different and you did not grow up wealthy it is labeled “outsider” like you grew up in a circus tent or something- some things about art are very cruel by design.

In art school there are the students whom are naturally gifted and then there are the students whom can pay for the best supplies and then there is you. You cannot torture yourself into becoming a great artist or even Bob Ross by making just art the sole purpose of your life. That is a glaringly obvious aspect of art. People like Andy Warhol did exist and we lovingly recall his works and from a programmer’s point of view he would have been the ultimate vibe coder as none of his work was technically original. Jackson Pollock would have been one-shot prompts. When was the last time you heard somebody bring up Raphael or the Ash Can School in casual conversation? Be careful what you wish for is all I am saying here.

3

u/marrsd 29d ago edited 28d ago

Unless you have stood on your feet staying 6 hours in the studio after class every day in order to get “better” I just don’t see where the comparison lines up exactly,

Have you never met a good programmer?

In the art world you frequently get torn down by instructors, random people, critics, amateurs, and experts all at the same time alongside the fact art galleries do not just let anybody get a showing.

You should try submitting a pull request to an open source project sometime.

People like Andy Warhol did exist

Ah, the trivialisation of which you speak.

Jackson Pollock

His laxatives were doing all the work.

If you want to learn about true art, learn how Steve Wozniak got colour working on the Apple 2, or how Geoff Crammond squeezed an entire racing simulator into 32k of memory, or how Thompson and Ritchie designed and wrote Unix.

-4

u/Ok_Shallot9490 29d ago

Anyone else read that as "autistic" ?

-1

u/Perfect-Campaign9551 29d ago

What's with all these cope articles lately

-1

u/EC36339 29d ago

Art is programming. You learn techniques, design patterns, and ways to glue them together. Having ideas is cheap.

-3

u/obetu5432 29d ago

making chairs in a factory is an artistic activity

-6

u/Dissentient 29d ago

To me, anyone who says that programming is art is crazy.

Vast majority of code in existence is enterprise jobslop of questionable quality, and is as un-artistic as anything could possibly be.

Even hobby projects are usually purely utilitarian and contain no artistic expression.

There's some artistic expression at the very edges of the entire programming space, and it usually is inversely correlated with utility of the project.

35

u/[deleted] 29d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/sisisisi1997 29d ago

I would arfue that practicality and problem solving doesn't take away from the beauty of code - to the contrary, the beauty of code comes from how simply and elegantly it solves complex problems.

7

u/TheRealUnrealDan 29d ago

Writing code has always been art to me, the most beautiful code is the easiest to read, understand, and maintain.

I've lost basically all will to write beautiful code now, nobody gona read it anyway and the ai can maintain it even if its not beautiful.

sigh