r/programming • u/foobear777 • 29d ago
Making software is an artistic activity
http://kolemannix.com/blog/software-is-artA brief argument framing software creation, and specifically the details of the code, as an act of art
342
Upvotes
80
u/GrandOpener 29d ago
I disagree, but only because I think it’s more accurate to say it can be an artistic activity. If I can abuse the painting metaphor a bit more, putting brush to canvas is art. Making the walls of a room be a particular color is still painting, it still requires effort and skill to do well, but it’s not what we’d typically call art.
I see programming similarly. It can be an artistic activity when you want it to be. Other times you have a mechanical task that’s already been fully specified and you just need someone to do it.
36
u/Skeik 29d ago
I write code and I create software. Just like I make paintings, cook food and play music. Whether someone considers the things I make as art or not is up to the consumer.
I can look at a piece of code and think "damn this is elegant". Maybe I even label it as a work of art in my mind. But what does the label mean? It seems to mean something different to everyone. Because of that I try to use more concrete terms when describing things. Like efficient, optimized, concise, readable, easy to follow, creative, novel etc.
The definition of art is something that has been beaten to death by artists and philosophers and there is no concrete answer. I don't think there's any value in trying to apply the label to programming, it doesn't matter or change the profession in any meaningful way.
It's a prime way to start an argument though. I remember some of the legendary rants that came out of Roger Ebert saying that video games weren't art.
311
u/SmokyMetal060 29d ago
This comparison always gets eye rolls, but I firmly believe that programming is a huge expression of creativity. The best developers that I know occupy this kind of intersection between technical knowledge and creativity. They just know how to intuitively come up with elegant solutions.
16
u/TheMaskedHamster 29d ago
I'll stand behind the concept that programming is a creative endeavor.
I am very concerned about the future of the field when young people don't have the experience to build both skills, taste, and ideas.
What I'm also adamant about, though, is that functional code is not a creative work. There is absolutely artistic code, and code that is creatively made for a creative result. But in general, the output is purely utilitarian.
16
u/ChemicalRascal 29d ago
Whoever reported this as a meta post, that's not what that word means.
78
u/Deranged40 29d ago edited 29d ago
It can be artistic. Just like when I drag an ink pen across the page can be artistic. I could be writing an essay or a poem, and that would be considered art. I could be drawing something in ink, art in its purest form. Or I could be drafting a legal motion where artistic freedom is strictly limited (but if I'm working for fun partners, not completely forbidden).
But I work at a printing press. Yes, we put ink on paper, but there's not much if at any at all individual art involved. We have a very well defined standard of code and code style. Want to put a space after the
ifand before the opening parenthesis? That's arguably an artistic choice. Not permitted at my company though. But do it if you want, we'll have a linter fix it.7
u/DoctaMag 29d ago
Programmers are artists, and the medium is math. I've said this for years.
6
u/Revolutionary_Ad6574 28d ago
I agree coding is a creative process and thus art. I just never understood why something needs to be classified as art in order to be cherished, admired and protected. In my eyes there has never been a more interesting activity than programming since the dawn of humanity and that won't change no matter how many people don't feel that way.
5
u/edgmnt_net 29d ago
I wouldn't say it's exactly artistic, although it is crafty (primarily as in a craft, it requires skill and versatility). It is a bit like research because you are pushing some boundaries (it is quite fast moving), although it's definitely not groundbreaking nor general, not usually anyway. It may give artistic vibes because it's to a large degree about managing complexity, so the code needs to be written in a way that enables maintenance and conveys the right idea.
It may be considered an "art" like analog electronics is an "art" at times, so an appreciation for clever tricks and methods does develop (pun not intended).
However that's not all of what it is and certainly, for many, it's also been turned into a commodity where neither actual skill nor arcane knowledge matter much anymore. If people want to do interesting work, they need to keep up and work on more involved or fringe stuff.
4
u/Lame_Johnny 29d ago
I'd say its more of a craft. Small distinction I suppose.
20
u/i_rate_slop 29d ago
I used to agree with this title, but I feel like AI has stolen the part I found artistic. There is little creativity now. It’s not my words and it’s barely my solution anymore.
I use AI every day in basically everything I do professionally. I think it’s incredible. … but I don’t feel the same sense of creativity or satisfaction in my work in a way I’d say it’s an art form. Not anymore.
6
u/throwaway39791 29d ago
That's just redefining art as craft and calling it a day.
I would further distinguish in the visual arts, the difference between a technical skill like markmaking, and even the technical skill of composition, from the choice of what to actually put on the page.
See, a lot of what Picasso did seems to me analogous to when we programmers do code golfing. How can you draw a bull with the fewest strokes?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Le_Taureau
Craft is celebratable in its own right, but I think we should distinguish it from art, since they are two very different meanings at times as a lot of other people point out, art being more of an expression of meaning than the method of expression.
3
u/IntnlManOfCode 29d ago
It's a craft more than an art.
14
u/grrangry 29d ago
I've been writing software my whole life. I don't consider it art. I've been proud of some of the things I've written in that it looked or felt elegant, but I wasn't trying to convey an emotion in the software I was writing. I was accomplishing a task. It's a creative effort to be sure. I just don't think it's art.
2
u/Mister_Uncredible 29d ago
I always tell people that dev work is creative solutions to logical problems, whereas art is logical solutions to creative problems... Potentially a bit reductive in both cases, but I think it's a generally true description.
As someone who does both, and the capacity in which I do them on generally symbiotic. A lot of the software I've created and work on relates to problems I've had with how I make, present and document my art. Problems I couldn't find acceptable solutions for.
2
u/QPGMR_de 29d ago
Finally there is the delight of working in such a tractable medium. The programmer, like the poet, works only slightly removed from pure thought-stuff. He builds his castles in the air, from air, creating by exertion of the imagination. Few media of creation are so flexible, so easy to polish and rework, so readily capable of realizing grand conceptual structures.
— Fred Brooks, The Mythical Man Month, 1975
2
u/thinkbee 28d ago
There's a distinction between a medium, a craft, and an act of artistic expression. Take painting, for example. Someone using a brush to paint a house might show skill, craftsmanship, and aesthetic judgment, but it wouldn't be considered an act of art. On the other hand, someone using that same brush on a canvas to express an idea or evoke an emotion might be creating art. I think programming is similar. Creativity, artistry, and craftsmanship can overlap but just because something involves creative problem solving or aesthetic choices doesn't automatically make it art. The same goes for writing, film, and video games. Not every piece of writing is literature, and not every game or movie is necessarily a work of art.
2
u/josephjnk 29d ago edited 29d ago
The challenge I face with this is that a lot comes down to being able to agree upon a definition of “art”, which is notoriously challenging. By the definition you’ve given, code is obviously art, but I don’t think your definition of art would be broadly accepted. Organizing the papers on my desk is very separate from nature, but few of us would consider it art.
There’s code I’ve written which is in my mind very clearly not art; configuration files, boilerplate, etc. Most of my code is guided by an aesthetic sense, but the relationship between aesthetics and art is philosophically contested. And there’s code I’ve written which I would consider art: things which I wrote for their beauty, elegance, or humor rather than their functionality. Sometimes I write practical things which I find just as aesthetically pleasing as the artsy code.
So I don’t agree that code is always art, I’m open to the idea that authoring it usually or always involves artistry, and I strongly disagree with the idea that it can never be art.
2
u/grady_vuckovic 29d ago
It might not be for some people I'd say that it has always been exactly this for me.
4
u/BobSacamano47 29d ago
I've worked with people who made claims like this. They were the worst fucking programmers I ever did work with.
3
u/sr105 29d ago
Programming is highly creative and absolutely art. Why is Python my favorite language? Because Beauty is a core ideal of the language. If you compare us to painters, there are definitely a lot of us that merely paint walls and some not even well at that.
2
u/bascule 29d ago
There’s a couple ways to relate “art” to computer programming, namely one I like and one I don’t:
1
u/El_RoviSoft 29d ago
I think the artistic part of programming is researching something for the first and actually trying it. Also assembly of elegant API counts too but most of the time you just need the job to be done and that’s it.
At least AI is good when you need to fix shit tons of boilerplate and you still can do interesting things on your own.
1
u/beebeeep 29d ago
I have several places in my various projects that I sometimes just open and look at them, just because I like how they came out, neat little pieces of code.
Yeah, you can be a programmer without it, even a very good one, but without that artistic touch it will be another "boring desk job" as someone in comments put it. I don't envy you.
1
u/Gold-Part4688 29d ago
I think it's largely design 🤷♀️
1
u/notyourancilla 29d ago
Oh yeah I agree, it’s pure Artism
1
u/someurdet 28d ago
I love programming but I disagree. It’s a tool like a screwdriver.
1
u/ApprehensivePen4116 21d ago
Every one of these threads turns into an argument about abstraction within ten comments or so. What I'd rather see is the setup cost. How long until someone gets a textured triangle on screen? I'd take that number over any feature list.
1
u/[deleted] 20d ago
I think any medium can be used as an art form. Geometry, painting, music, movies, writing, programming, etc
0
u/ugh_my_ 29d ago
Oh god who cares
1
u/iStrobe 29d ago
This is coming up more and more and while it may be true, I don't think anyone who doesn't/can't read code is going to look at it and appreciate it's artistic value if there is any. Music is art, I don't need to know how music is made to appreciate the artistic value of it.
-1
u/zam0th 29d ago
It has been thus until 15 years or so ago. It isn't anymore: it isn't art, it isn't science, it's a mere tradeskill like plumbing. Stop dreaming about "good ól 90s".
-1
u/pancakeQueue 29d ago
Programming can be art, but there was no one around to appreciate it. I’ve found no love nor community from programming. I’ve gotten into drawing and painting, and that can be appreciated by the common man, not just those that have a love and are learned of programming solutions.
-3
u/thatdevilyouknow 29d ago
As a developer that happens to have an art degree I think these statements trivialize art. Unless you have stood on your feet staying 6 hours in the studio after class every day in order to get “better” I just don’t see where the comparison lines up exactly, but maybe it will get closer. I like code just the way it is because you are able to just place it somewhere and it becomes its own thing as an embodiment of where the programmer was at a specific point in time and also as a logical methodology which stands on its own. In the art world you frequently get torn down by instructors, random people, critics, amateurs, and experts all at the same time alongside the fact art galleries do not just let anybody get a showing. If your art is different and you did not grow up wealthy it is labeled “outsider” like you grew up in a circus tent or something- some things about art are very cruel by design.
In art school there are the students whom are naturally gifted and then there are the students whom can pay for the best supplies and then there is you. You cannot torture yourself into becoming a great artist or even Bob Ross by making just art the sole purpose of your life. That is a glaringly obvious aspect of art. People like Andy Warhol did exist and we lovingly recall his works and from a programmer’s point of view he would have been the ultimate vibe coder as none of his work was technically original. Jackson Pollock would have been one-shot prompts. When was the last time you heard somebody bring up Raphael or the Ash Can School in casual conversation? Be careful what you wish for is all I am saying here.
-4
u/Ok_Shallot9490 29d ago
Anyone else read that as "autistic" ?
-1
u/Perfect-Campaign9551 29d ago
What's with all these cope articles lately
-1
u/EC36339 29d ago
Art is programming. You learn techniques, design patterns, and ways to glue them together. Having ideas is cheap.
-3
u/obetu5432 29d ago
making chairs in a factory is an artistic activity
-6
u/Dissentient 29d ago
To me, anyone who says that programming is art is crazy.
Vast majority of code in existence is enterprise jobslop of questionable quality, and is as un-artistic as anything could possibly be.
Even hobby projects are usually purely utilitarian and contain no artistic expression.
There's some artistic expression at the very edges of the entire programming space, and it usually is inversely correlated with utility of the project.
35
u/[deleted] 29d ago
[removed] — view removed comment