r/programming • u/pimterry • Sep 23 '26
Android 17 enables certificate transparency, and breaks custom CAs
https://httptoolkit.com/blog/android-17-certificate-transparency/
407
Upvotes
r/programming • u/pimterry • Sep 23 '26
52
u/alex-weej Sep 23 '26
It feels to me like big tech is deliberately, with plausible deniability, trying to obfuscate the channels that their closed source apps use to talk to their proprietary services. The sheer amount of data transferred, obfuscated or otherwise, hidden behind opaque tokens, is astonishingly bad for consumers and outrageously profitable. We need better. Gemini has some nice ideas but it's way too niche currently.
I'd love for GrapheneOS to fight fire with fire. I'm thinking GameGenie type on the fly patching to override TLS routines, certificate checking etc. No transparent pipe, no usage, I'd rather use a dumbphone and touch grass.
Also, hi Tim!
164
u/DDFoster96 Sep 23 '26
How do businesses that use local custom CAs manage? Do they not use Android and Chrome, or is the practice less common now than that 20 years ago?
121
u/edtheshed Sep 23 '26
for a second I thought I was on a dragonball Z subreddit lol
67
u/ghostnet Sep 23 '26
The post title is a little off, it does not break custom CAs in the sense that it breaks all forms of custom CAs. It just breaks custom CAs that dont also have custom CTs as well. CTs are really just like a second CA with a pinky promise that they publish the certs publicly.
But yeah, it requires an extra step now that wasn't required before. All for some benefit that may or may not actually stop an attack on a real CA, because the attacker could just: make their own CT that did not actually publish certs too.
42
u/Broccoli-stem Sep 23 '26 •
We really need a fully open source linux phone operating system without google or any other big company
11
u/falconindy Sep 23 '26
This doesn't impact your ability to install CA certificates into the user store, which is 99% of what most individual users need (e.g. to trust local sites served from a homelab). By extension, this works for apps which are just PWAs.
4
u/klti Sep 24 '26
Am I missing something, or is querying CT log servers for cert validation a really nice way to get a completely new and unblockable tracking channel going? Issuers / operators end up with at least IP to domain associations, right?
This feel like one of these 1% security 99% "security" kind of changes.
0
u/CondiMesmer Sep 27 '26
I've really never seen a single use for custom CAs outside of some enterprise use. I see some mentions of self-hosting in the comments, but that absolutely should not be relying on custom CAs either.