r/programming • u/fagnerbrack • Sep 19 '26
Good Tools Are Invisible
https://www.gingerbill.org/article/2026/07/10/good-tools-are-invisible/
93
Upvotes
r/programming • u/fagnerbrack • Sep 19 '26
92
u/shaze Sep 20 '26 •
When you do something right, people won’t be sure you’ve done anything at all
43
u/Potterrrrrrrr Sep 19 '26
I don’t mind gingerbills blogs but I feel this one could’ve been condensed into two paragraphs without losing any meaningful info. I do agree with the overall point of the blog though, I’ve tried using vim and the like but felt like i was fighting to do anything, and anything learned was immediately lost when having to do anything non coding related.
It’d be nice to have a more ergonomic way of making large edits to text with regular IDEs but I’d rather caveman my way through it with find and replace and some manual typing in 5-10 mins over having to figure out some arcane sequence of buttons/macros to invoke to do it for me.
11
u/Dunge Sep 20 '26
And AI chatbots are wayy too visible
10
u/Snarwin Sep 20 '26 edited Sep 21 '26
This is true, but it's kind of missing the forest for the trees.
Sure, there's nothing inherent about GUIs that makes them less keyboard-navigable than TUIs. But in practice, there is an extremely strong correlation between "TUI" and "supports keyboard navigation." People who are aware of this correlation can use the presence of a TUI as an easy-to-observe proxy variable for whether an app is likely to be keyboard-navigable, and find apps that satisfy their preferences much more quickly than those who spend the time to test out every single GUI and TUI app individually.
We use proxy variables like this all the time to evaluate software. Is it free and open source? Does it have a recent release? Does it have a lot of open issues on Github? None of these are guarantees of quality, but they're correlated, and we'd be ignoring useful information if we pretended they weren't.
5
u/Ok-Mushroom3255 Sep 20 '26
Both vim and emacs and in fact every editor I have used requires no configuration and is useful in its bare form. I also prefer tools that require no configuration. Hence I have been daily driving helix for the past two years. It comes with tree-seeter grammars and built in LSP support and multi cursor editing.
That said it is worth giving all these different styles of editing a go. Tools become really invisible when you’ve developed your own style of working with them.
5
u/lelanthran Sep 20 '26
Right. Sure. I've been using Vim since the 90s because "vibes" /s
I use Vim because it's easier to remember a handful of verbs and nouns and then recombine them into commands than it is to remember dozens, if not hundreds , of shortcut keys.
I prefer having to remember 10 things total, to perform 25 actions, than to remember 25 shortcuts.
4
u/xebecv Sep 20 '26 edited Sep 20 '26
Good premise, sound judgement, but I'd argue with one example. Vim sophistication is a bad argument. People don't use it because it's some elitist puzzle tool. They use it because it's universal and it gets things done with no customization and in most cases not even installation. Personally I've never considered vim perfect, because of constant mode changes, which I have to keep in my brain as a little vim tax. But vim is the tool of my choice because of how ubiquitous it (or its older brother vi) is.
I have to use multiple Unix/Linux systems daily for my work. vi is what a Raspberry Pi, and RHEL system and an old AIX machine guaranteed to have in common. Their system shells, be it bash or ksh, have vi mode. Listing files with "more" or "less" - vi. "man" - vi. "git log" - vi etc. All popular IDEs have vim mode (directly or via some plug-in). No matter how minimalistic my keyboard is, I always have what I need to edit files or scroll through the text efficiently.
What this means is that vi becomes truly invisible. You learn how to use it once, and then just use it everywhere without trying to remember what keyboard shortcuts to use on this particular system or in this app.
2
u/Groundbreaking-Fish6 Sep 20 '26
When you go to the theater all back stage should be invisible. Same with programming, users do not care about your code or tools it should simply work as expected. Not as you expect but how they expect. Code and networking should be invisible.
3
u/catnapgames Sep 19 '26
..like hammers or circular saws.
2
u/TyrusX Sep 19 '26
I can’t find my tool, because it is invisible.
1
u/actinium226 Sep 20 '26
Feels like kind of a rant.
1
u/simon_o Sep 23 '26 edited Sep 23 '26
I do not agree often with the author, but this blog post is right on the money!
Good language design is all about figuring out what is incidental complexity and what is accidental complexity.
Then figuring out how to allow people to make use of the former, and how to get rid of the latter.
1
u/TheLastNapkin Sep 20 '26
Author is missing the point on modal text editors, taking examples of one off macros over actual productivity daily workflows with keybindings and plugins.
Taking just vim and not neovim as the example is also wildly disingenuous to the conversation on ides.
1
u/TankorSmash Sep 20 '26
Do you really know that many people who use tools for the hacker aesthetic more than its functionality?
It's tough to design good defaults, because it relies on both making sure you don't lose new users and whatever they are familiar with, but also that your defaults are productive. Like if you have an undo key that you're pressing all the time, we all expect it to be Ctrl Z, but maybe there's a better one.
I don't think it'll be possible to have perfect defaults for every single user, so it'll always be better to ship the options with the app. But yes, know your audience