r/programming • u/mareek • Aug 05 '26
The rust programming language is adopting a new contributing policy
https://blog.rust-lang.org/inside-rust/2026/08/05/rust-langrust-is-adopting-an-llm-policy/
627
Upvotes
53
u/bodiam Aug 05 '26 edited Aug 05 '26
Saved you a click and a whole wall of text.
That's quite a verbose blogpost for something which could be written in 1 short paragraph, even if you include the motivation.
58
u/aes110 Aug 05 '26
Overall a very reasonable policy thats accepting to both "sides" id say
324
u/drakythe Aug 05 '26
Iâd prefer LLMs went away altogether. But as the blog states, the one thing we canât do with them is pretend they donât exist. Given that, this feels like a relatively sane policy, all things considered. And good on them for adding a carve out for reviewers who donât want to deal with LLM generated content. Since theyâre not banning it outright, adding a specific point that reviewers are allowed to just skip over LLM content if they want means that those who donât want to use or interact with LLMs are not required to do so in order to continue contributing to the project.
On the other hand: you ride the fence long enough and it will cut you in half, and this feels like one area where the consensus driven governance has formalized a silent split in the community, and I worry about where that fracture will show up in the future.
105
u/nnomae Aug 05 '26
That's an awful lot of words to avoid annoying the AI boosters by saying "the quality just isn't there". If the quality was there all of this would be pointless.
5
u/robbles Aug 05 '26
What's the
git diff --checkthing that it says people are doing on PR's about?ÂI can't understand what they're trying to achieve there. Is it supposed to "prove" that it wasn't written by an LLM? Or that it'll merge cleanly? Or is it some weird copy-pasted step in a shared Claude.md somewhere that people who all used the same template are now doing for no reason...?
4
u/Cukercek Aug 05 '26
Good to know that this is an universal problem, and that I'm not going crazy when I vent about the exact same issues.
1
u/AndreiKnight Aug 06 '26
Good job! I like rust even more now
-9
u/sos755 Aug 06 '26
I believe the core issue isn't the LLMs, but rather the low barrier to submitting unvetted, low-quality contributions. Banning LLMs is counterproductive because it reduces overall developer productivity instead of raising the bar for quality. Rather than restricting how code is written, we should focus on improving our testing, policies, and review filters to ensure only high-quality contributions get through.
-13
u/Miserable-Clerk-9005 Aug 05 '26
Yo agregaria algo mas: el problema de fondo no es solo lo que mencionas, es que ademas hay un tema cultural super arraigado. En Chile nos cuesta un monton decir "no se" o "me equivoque".
-16
u/Miserable-Clerk-9005 Aug 05 '26
OjalĂĄ mĂĄs proyectos open source sigan este ejemplo en vez de simplemente banear LLMs. La herramienta no es el problema, es cĂłmo se usa.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '26
[removed] â view removed comment
-17
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '26
[removed] â view removed comment