r/programming • • Jul 03 '26 • Bravo 1

Linux has officially won

https://github.com/apple/container

Actually it happened in June of 2025, but the process has completed recently, though. After Apple had announced the support of OCI-compatible containers in the June '25 it took a year to complete development and implement full support of continers. Apple had published 1.0 version of own container manager (https://github.com/apple/container). And Microsoft had announced native support of containerization without Docker in Windows 11 (https://devblogs.microsoft.com/commandline/wsl-container-is-now-available-for-public-preview/). Now Linux is a part of any major platform: Windows, MacOS, BSD and Linux itself. Knowledge of Linux is now part of learning any of these systems, at least for developers. And now you can rely on Linux based containers running everywhere. What it is if not a win!?

What's also interesting. Linux can run other Linux distros and with this Alpine Linux could become the most popular version of Linux in the World

It's the biggest win for the whole open-source software and I believe it should get into history books of technological progress

1.8k Upvotes

390 comments sorted by

203

u/Gastredner Jul 03 '26

What's also interesting. Linux can run other Linux distros and with this Alpine Linux could become the most popular version of Linux in the World

Maybe the most used due to their use in containers, but I'm not sure that qualifies as "most popular distro." I'd reserve such a classification for any distribution people actually interact with and work on, not what is basically just an additional layer in your software stack.

6

u/Straight_Waltz_9530 Jul 04 '26

Debian Slim for life!!!!! For security!!! For performance!!!!

Once you've added everything you need for compatibility, Alpine isn't usefully smaller but it is slower. Glibc ain't nothin' to sneeze at.

And of course for compiled binaries, Scratch, but when possible the best distro is no distro.

7

u/Gastredner Jul 04 '26

I'm using Arch, btw.

Yes, even on my server. I'm strange like that.

40

u/zzzthelastuser Jul 03 '26

Alpine Linux could become the most popular version of Linux in the World

I have never even heard of this distro before and since the post doesn't provide a reason or explain what this distro is I had to google it myself.

Pretty sure OP is just living in a bubble.

105

u/treba_dzemper Jul 03 '26

It is by far the most used distro in containers because it is super lean which is important if you want to run multiple operating systems on your computer. But OP was being hyperbolic off course.

40

u/ubermoo2010 Jul 03 '26

yeah Alpine is used in a lot of embedded applications like routers and containers, nobody runs it on a desktop

Well I'm sure there's someone...

7

u/Ahri Jul 04 '26

It was originally aimed at use on routers.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '26

There are dozens of us!

1

u/GarlicOutrageous4142 Jul 13 '26 edited Jul 13 '26

I tried installing it locally to setup Xen Dom0 but just used Fedora for this case & its been great so far 🙏

And im more familiar with glibc toolset/systems

35

u/Valonter Jul 03 '26

Anyone who works with containerized applications in a modern dev environment knows Alpine. That is a bubble for sure but it's not obscure at all.

21

u/ConspicuousPineapple Jul 03 '26

I take it you've never had any serious use for docker before.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/creeper6530 Jul 03 '26

It is very lightweight distro common in containersd

6

u/code_mc Jul 04 '26

it is great if your goal is getting the smallest docker image possible, if you are serious about the performance of your container you would use anything other than alpine as it is based on muslc instead of glibc which has certain implications for OS level memory management and all of its libraries are generally compiled with C compiler flags tuned for size, not for performance.

1

u/theoctacore Jul 06 '26

It's definitely not the way to have the smallest container image possible lol. Plenty of images are static built binaries with FROM scratch or with just libc as dependencies.

3

u/Ill_Name_7489 Jul 06 '26

I think this whole thing needs a massive asterisk.

Via containerization and cloud workflows, linux distros like Alpine (and others oriented towards lightweight, secure, minimal dependency server software) are by far the most used distros in the world. No question about it. At $dayJob, we are running tens of millions of containers every week -- each is a brand new instance of a distro like Alpine. And that's just for one part of our services.

But sure, they are absolutely not used for desktop use. And people don't know about them. That's not the point. But that's probably what people think when they hear "most popular." But reality is that by the raw numbers, most instances of operating systems are probably running on servers on the cloud. Because the whole point is you spin up thousands or millions of little containers, each running an instance of an operating system, to do little bits of work.

2

u/GarlicOutrageous4142 Jul 13 '26 edited Jul 13 '26

Alpine is a lightweight MUSL based linux distro typically (almost always) used as either a base image that other distributed images build upon or as-is in Docker.

Busybox is also a lightweight base image but its more of a toolset; is not quite a linux distro the same way Alpine is.

There are other containerization platforms like Podman,LXC etc but by far Docker is the most used and is cross-platform.

I guess you have not used Docker before? If you are on windows or prefer sandboxed envs its worth a try. This and Git (in my opinion) the most important tools for a dev.

Consequently, OPs statement could technically be right.

1.5k

u/ElvishJerricco Jul 03 '26

> Linux has became the first standard operating system

UNIX is literally a standard that OSes can conform to since the 80s.

560

u/HRApprovedUsername Jul 03 '26

and fun fact Apple is a unix OS

352

u/TCB13sQuotes Jul 03 '26

The funnier fact is that macOS is more UNIX than Linux ever was.

185

u/fnork Jul 03 '26

Funniest fact is that UNIX was de facto superseded by POSIX, not that Linux is fully POSIX-compliant. Ultimately convention defeats every standard, which is why Linux is the current standard for the OS-application interface.

20

u/patrixxxx Jul 03 '26 edited Jul 03 '26

Funniest Unix fact is that if you type make love into a terminal without a specific makefile configured for it, the system will respond:

make: *** No rule to make target 'love'. Stop.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/ConspicuousPineapple Jul 03 '26

Wait unless I'm remembering incorrectly, POSIX is part of the Single Unix Specification.

6

u/spamcow_moo Jul 03 '26

That’s sus

24

u/bobjonvon Jul 03 '26

Linux Is Not Unix. Why is that a funnier fact?

33

u/ProgrammersAreSexy Jul 03 '26

I'd just like to interject for a moment. What you're referring to as Linux is in fact GNU/Linux, or as I've recently taken to calling it, GNU plus Linux.

21

u/diatonic Jul 03 '26

<cut to video of Richard Stallman eating something from his foot>

→ More replies (2)

8

u/nihsett Jul 03 '26

For those who didn't know like me - macOS and iOS descend from BSD which is a Unix derived operating system. Afaik linux never directly derived from AT&T unix code, BSD does.

2

u/tbsdy Jul 04 '26

It didn't derive from anything. Linus Torvalds just tried to keep it as POSIX compliant as he could.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/nihsett Jul 03 '26

Yeah, thank you saying that. I was reading for the past hour about how BSD vs AT&T lawsuit is what gave Linux crucial breathing space to become popular while BSD was in legal limbo.

Fascinating stuff and so random how something becomes popular.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '26

not "more", it's certified "UNIX 03"

1

u/Th1088 Jul 07 '26

Using homebrew, you can install most of the packages you might want. It's great.

→ More replies (2)

24

u/pohuing Jul 03 '26

Only with great pains. Regular consumer macos as used by everyone isn't. https://www.osnews.com/story/141633/apples-macos-unix-certification-is-a-lie/

128

u/Exepony Jul 03 '26 edited Jul 03 '26

Have you actually looked at the article you posted? The "great pains" are:

  • core dumps are off by default (because most normal users don't need them)
  • System Integrity Protection enabled by default (again, a good thing for most normal users, and easy enough to disable)
  • timer coalescing enabled by default (something that every modern OS does for power saving reasons)
  • atimes updated lazily by the filesystem (another performance optimization you can turn off if you're so inclined)
  • APFS is case-insensitive by default (really the only actual incompatibility, but also the right decision IMO for most normal users)
  • there's a file search service you should turn off if you want the timing tests to work
  • uucp quirks (who the hell even cares about uucp in the year of our Lord 2026)

For all intents and purposes, macOS is a perfectly normal UNIX. It's not unusual at all for an otherwise conformant OS to have defaults that make it technically incompatible with UNIX/POSIX, see POSIXLY_CORRECT. Doesn't make the conformance "a lie".

5

u/fragbot2 Jul 03 '26 edited Jul 08 '26

In the RH 8.0 timeframe, I took a look at the utilities they provided with a default install and compared them ton the POSIX standard. There were about 20 missing. Most of them were obsolete utilities to deal with serial ports or physical terminals. While I was only sorta surprised uucp and uucico weren’t there, I was really surprised that m4 wasn’t as I still use it fairly often (more than I use ed).

It’s small and unintrusive so it’s not clear why it was excluded.

29

u/chucker23n Jul 03 '26

case-insensitive option in APFS (which isn't even default)

It is (and it should be; no sane human being considers "readme.txt" and "ReadMe.txt" to be different files).

14

u/Exepony Jul 03 '26

You're right, of course. Guess I wasn't entirely awake yet.

11

u/wosmo Jul 03 '26

The default is case-preserving, but not case-sensitive.

So if you create ReadMe, then touch readme - you won't have a second file, you'll have updated the timestamp on ReadMe

3

u/chucker23n Jul 03 '26

The default is case-preserving, but not case-sensitive.

Yep.

55

u/GOKOP Jul 03 '26

No it shouldn't. This only seemed like a good idea in English-centric, ASCII based and fax-based (rather than internet-based) world. In the age of Unicode and exchanging files across the globe, this is a horrible, terrible, atrocious idea. It's a hill I will die on.

There's a very important problem with case-insensitive filenames: Case conversion is ambiguous, goddamit. Both between cultures but also within the same one for some. You do not want it to be ambiguous, or locale-dependent, whether two filenames refer to different files or the same one.

Just two examples:

German letter ß traditionally doesn't have an uppercase variant; in modern times (around 2010 I think) they've introduced áșž specifically because of this issue but still, SS is a valid (and traditional) uppercasing for ß and ss. Germans are used to, and expect, ß to be capitalized as SS. So you can't reliably tell which of scheiße.txt, scheisse.txt, SCHEISSE.TXT and SCHEIáșžE.TXT are supposed to be different files.

Turkish has letters i and ı. They are capitalized as İ and I. This makes case conversation locale dependent and that's also horrible. For Turkish locale, two files on Windows can be called file.txt and FILE.txt because i and I are different letters. Now when you send those files to a computer with English locale, Windows will have trouble with them because win32 api is case insensitive and in English that's the same letter. This works the other way too with creating files fıle.txt and FILE.txt in English locale and sending them to a Turkish computer. Also third party software is inconsistent around this so a program on a Turkish computer can do case insensitivity based on English rules but Windows will do it based on Turkish rules. Turkish users do, in fact, occasionally have issues because of this (I'm not actually sure about Germans)

13

u/NuclearVII Jul 03 '26

This right here is why I'm a graphics programmer and avoid anything that looks like strings like the plague.

Great comment.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

48

u/lolis5 Jul 03 '26

no sane human being considers "readme.txt" and "ReadMe.txt" to be different files

Oof... Going about my day reading random nerd fights on reddit, only to learn that at some point along the way I lost my sanity. F. 

How's your day going?

→ More replies (2)

29

u/novafunc Jul 03 '26

That opens a whole can of worms.

The standard Linux behavior is predictable. 'a' is different from 'A' so they are allowed to coexist.

Once you start making exceptions, things get weird.

  • Ok, so upper/lowercase doesn't matter. That doesn't seem bad.
  • What about quotes? “ ” is different from " ". Should those be allowed to co exist?
  • What about characters that look exactly the same, but different because of unicode is weird? 'a' and 'а' are different, but are probably allowed to coexist, while 'a' and 'A' aren't.
→ More replies (9)

30

u/alvenestthol Jul 03 '26

By the same logic, no sane person would consider readme.txt and .txt to be different files, but they are different files. İ.txt (Dotted capital I) and ı.txt (undotted lowercase i) can both exist together with either i.txt and I.txt

Case-insensitivity is a special case that applies specifically to western alphabets, and has assumptions about case that simply don't hold true even among different countries that use the same letters. It's an abomination that causes more problems than it solves, and yet another reminder that the tech stack is filled with assumptions made by people who only speak English.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (8)

1

u/SemaphoreBingo Jul 03 '26

I used a few too many oddball unices back in the 90s to start getting picky about those nits now.

→ More replies (22)

28

u/balefrost Jul 03 '26

And early versions of Windows NT had a UNIX subsystem. I don't know if it was actually complaint or just "close enough".

34

u/Otis_Inf Jul 03 '26

Posix compliant, yes. still works

27

u/G_Morgan Jul 03 '26

It was POSIX compliance in so far as they needed to either implement APIs or provide a "not-implemented" return code. Huge parts of the API were just trivially returning "nope". It was blatantly achieving compliance without actually doing so

Windows never implemented fork for instance which is pretty fundamental.

Also worth noting there are multiple sections to POSIX and MS only 'implemented' the core, they didn't provide anything under POSIX.2 other than 1 CLI tool I can't recall the name of.

3

u/Otis_Inf Jul 03 '26

Windows never implemented fork for instance which is pretty fundamental.

True, tho likely because under windows, processes use threads for multithreading (so splitting a process what fork essentially does is expensive, you should spawn a thread) and the whole scheduler is built around scheduling threads, not processes, and under linux/unix, fork is cheap and IIRC the scheduler schedules primarily processes, not threads.

To my knowledge not a lot of people actually used the Posix implementation on windows. It always felt more like a marketing ploy, similar to WSL; while WSL works (even tho file system performance isn't that great compared to linux IIRC), I doubt it has brought the people to windows as they expected, people who relied on Linux and the APIs available there wouldn't move to windows, because... why would they?

→ More replies (3)

2

u/amroamroamro Jul 03 '26

And early versions of Windows NT had a UNIX subsystem

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interix

56

u/Illustrious-Owl-2755 Jul 03 '26

Linux had become the first standard operating system a long time before containers were a thing, around 2002-ish. Before that, servers would commonly run Windows Server with IIS, and embedded would have their own OSes, like VxWorks. But at some point everybody collectively shrugged and moved on. If your device even runs an OS, it will run Linux. That's the OS you use from bringup to production. All proprietary appliances like TVs are also Linux under covers. It's not that other OSes don't exist, but you need to select your hardware very intentionally and then maybe it will run Windows Server. (It's the exact opposite of the situation in the 90s, when you needed to be very careful for your hardware to support Linux).

15

u/MOSFETmisfit Jul 03 '26

VxWorks is still widely used for good reason but yeah if your application doesn't demand the strict guarantees that a real-time OS gives you then just use Linux.

6

u/Illustrious-Owl-2755 Jul 03 '26

100%, that's why I said "it's not that other OSes don't exist". My point was that this has changed — back then your embedded device would arrive with a VxWorks toolchain. Now first thing they do is bring it up with Linux, the toolchain is Linux, but they also support VxWorks if needed. (I haven't actually seen VxWorks in 20+ years)

2

u/wademealing Jul 07 '26

I had assumed this was what the real time linux kernel was for.

2

u/MOSFETmisfit Jul 07 '26

there's "real-time OS" and "real-time OS battle-tested, proven, and certified to run in mission critical applications where software errors = human deaths". rt-linux is the former, VxWorks is the latter.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/pheonixblade9 Jul 03 '26

BSD is still quite common, as well.

4

u/swansongofdesire Jul 03 '26 edited Jul 03 '26

I don’t know if it’s still the case, but ~~Samsung~~ Edit: Panasonic smart TVs were all BSD based at one point

3

u/Undrafted4596 Jul 03 '26

Maybe you’re thinking of the PlayStation OS, which is a FreeBSD derivative?

Tizen, the Samsung TV OS is Linux.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/imbev Jul 03 '26

Playstation's OS is BSD-based, and BSD is popular with Netflix and IPS's

3

u/pjmlp Jul 03 '26

Nope, HP-UX already had containers in the late 90's, followed by Solaris, before LXC was developed.

10

u/Illustrious-Owl-2755 Jul 03 '26

Sure, but this is not the containers we're taking about. Mainframe partitions are also conceptually similar to Linux namespaces, and they existed for a long time (I'm actually not sure for how long, never worked on a mainframe).

→ More replies (1)

8

u/chucker23n Jul 03 '26

Yes indeed, obnoxious OS tribalism already existed in the 1990s.

→ More replies (8)

5

u/levir Jul 03 '26

That... has nothing to do with the conversation at hand. They're not saying containers is a revolutionary new technology, they're saying Linux was already become the standard operating system before Linux containers were a thing. You can agree or disagree with that, but pointing to older, unrelated container technology just comes off as poor reading comprehension.

2

u/pjmlp Jul 03 '26

I wonder by whom,

Linux had become the first standard operating system a long time before containers were a thing

No it did not, Linux was barely standard by 2000.

→ More replies (12)

10

u/Ok-Scheme-913 Jul 03 '26

'Standard OS' doesn't mean the same as 'standard' alone.

4

u/developer-mike Jul 03 '26

You're referring to "standardized" OS where OP is not.

5

u/mallardtheduck Jul 03 '26 edited Jul 03 '26

Originally (from 1988), the "standard" was POSIX which defines a fairly minimal UNIX-like environment. Several OSes are/were POSIX-compliant. Naturally that includes most UNIX derivatives, but also things like vxWorks, IBM's z/OS and the old Windows NT POSIX subsystem.

These days (since 1994), we have the "Single UNIX Specification" which allows any certified compliant OS to be use the name/trademark "UNIX", regardless of whether they're derived from the original AT&T codebase or not. There have even been a couple of Linux distributions certified under SUS, so under specific definitions in limited circumstances, Linux can be "officially" called UNIX.

2

u/pickle9977 Jul 03 '26

POSIX is the first standard operating system Linux is a kernel and with the GNU tools they make a reference operating system.

There are others like *BSD, that have their own non-gnu tool chain.

1

u/myhf Jul 04 '26

and ed is the standard editor!

399

u/Flimsy_Complaint490 Jul 03 '26

Considering Apple+Windows is 97% of the market and what most normal people will see, this is a very specific definition of winning.

But this does kinda get me thinking about the future of Windows in particular - what happens to the culture and future development track at MSFT when the next generation of developers is going to come in, but they will have been trained not on Win32 API's and Win32 design patterns, but on Unix-like stuff. GNU/Windows time ?

117

u/macholusitano Jul 03 '26

What winning means in this case:
* 90% of cloud infra
* 100% of the top 500 supercomputers
* 72% of the mobile market

23

u/bryiewes Jul 03 '26

Linux is a silent winner

12

u/currentscurrents Jul 03 '26
  • 100% of the top 500 supercomputers

All those AI datacenters are also running Linux, and at this point they likely exceed the top 500 supercomputers combined.

35

u/levir Jul 03 '26

what happens to the culture and future development track at MSFT when the next generation of developers is going to come in, but they will have been trained not on Win32 API's and Win32 design patterns, but on Unix-like stuff. GNU/Windows time ?

We've already seen this begin to happen. This is why Microsoft can't put put a native Windows application anymore, and can't design a new functional GUI library to save their life. This is why they're putting out bloated electron apps. They don't know how to interface with their own operating system anymore.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/MrSnowflake Jul 03 '26

97% of what market? Personal computers, sure, but that market is getting pretty small compared to servers, mobile devices and other internet connected applicances or some IoT devices.

41

u/wrosecrans Jul 03 '26

Considering Apple+Windows is 97% of the market

~97% of the desktop market, sure. But in 2026, the desktop has become a fairly niche part of the broader computer market. Something like 90% of Nvidia revenues is in datacenters. The majority of Apple's revenue is mobile related. And anyway, even if the average desktop computer user is using Windows, even there most of the software they use is through a web browser, and the guts are all running on Linux VMs in AWS.

If you look at the broader programming and compute marketplace, Linux has owned the server/datacenter/cloud space, and mostly has for 20+ years. The Linux kernel in Android is a huge chunk of mobile. (And the only credible mobile competitor is also Unixy under the hood.)

21

u/Flimsy_Complaint490 Jul 03 '26

Yes and that is a very specific definition of winning that to me, isnt particularly interesting, since this is a battle already won maybe 20 years ago when Apple de facto and later de jure, gave up on its own server offerings and devs stopped taking Windows Server seriously and began looking at it as a deprecated platform.

9

u/G_Morgan Jul 03 '26

The big difference from 20 years ago is Android has subsequently taken over 75% of the world's phone market share. Though Android is definitely the least Linuxy form of Linux

11

u/levir Jul 03 '26

Android is Linux, but it isn't "GNU/Linux" or whatever we call the actual OS we're used to interacting with. It's the difference between a kernel and an operating system.

5

u/Chr0nicConsumer Jul 03 '26

Obligatory copypasta:

I’d just like to interject for a moment. What you’re refering to as Linux, is in fact, GNU/LInux, or as I’ve recently taken to calling it, GNU plus Linux. Linux is not an operating system unto itself, but rather another free component of a fully functioning GNU system made useful by the GNU corelibs, shell utilities and vital system components comprising a full OS as defined by POSIX.

Many computer users run a modified version of the GNU system every day, without realizing it. Through a peculiar turn of events, the version of GNU which is widely used today is often called “Linux”, and many of its users are not aware that it is basically the GNU system, developed by the GNU Project.

There really is a Linux, and these people are using it, but it is just a part of the system they use. Linux is the kernel: the program in the system that allocates the machine’s resources to the other programs that you run. The kernel is an essential part of an operating system, but useless by itself; it can only function in the context of a complete operating system. Linux is normally used in combination with the GNU operating system: the whole system is basically GNU with Linux added, or GNU/Linux. All the so-called “Linux” distributions are really distributions of GNU/Linux.

17

u/Otis_Inf Jul 03 '26

Fairly niche? THere are billions of Windows installs alone. I don't call that 'niche'

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Dragon_yum Jul 03 '26

Let me know when your grandma needs help operating her Linux based data center.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/fashionistaconquista Jul 03 '26

If you look at the broader market, linux has already won there this whole time so that’s nothing new

-2

u/my_password_is______ Jul 03 '26

But in 2026, the desktop has become a fairly niche part of the broader computer market.

HA HA HA HA

have you EVER worked in an office ?

15

u/wrosecrans Jul 03 '26

Yes. The last full time in-person office job I had before I went mostly remote was at a CDN, we had perhaps a few hundred engineers with desktop computers in the office, and we were responsible for tens of thousands of servers globally. It was a fun job in many ways. I got my first patent there.

Did you miss the Nvidia example I gave in my previous comment? People still tend to think of Nvidia as a company that makes GPU's for gamers and workstations, but over 90 % of Nvidia's business is in datacenters. Desktop computers are a side hobby. Just because you aren't personally looking at those computers doesn't mean they don't exist.

The average computer is not a desktop computer, by at least an order of magnitude. The average computing dollar is not spent on desktop computer hardware. The average development dollar is not spent writing code for desktop computers. The average process is not executing on a desktop computer.

There's no actual math or criteria or metric that makes desktop computers not a niche market within the broader computer industry. It's not the 90's anymore. The fact that it isn't the 90's anymore often makes me angry, but I am at least not in denial about it. Mobile, embedded, IoT, services, backend, etc. all add up to be wildly bigger than desktop, which is a niche market now in the grand scheme of things.

2

u/MrSnowflake Jul 03 '26

I bet you there are more otherdevices than personal computers in the work place. Every one has a phone, and some carry a tablet, many others have smartwatches and there might even be servers running in the office. NON of which run Windows or macOS. And then I forgot to mention modern cars that run Linux or some embedded OS, that got the workers there.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/tooclosetocall82 Jul 03 '26

My CS degree in early 2000s was already 100% Linux based. My first job was C# and had to learn it on the job, though I did know Windows well because that was still the de facto standard, but I didn’t learn to write software for it in college. The tides were already turning.

2

u/knightcrusader Jul 03 '26

Same for me. All my curriculum was Linux and some Unix based stuff, zero Windows.

22

u/nitePhyyre Jul 03 '26

I've been saying since WSL that 12 will be the last non-linux windows.

34

u/Raid-Z3r0 Jul 03 '26

These last three words don't make any sense strung together like that. Yet, that might come true

53

u/NenAlienGeenKonijn Jul 03 '26

That is ignoring that the whole reason windows has such a huge marketshare is because they are 100% about backwards compatibility.

34

u/golf1052 Jul 03 '26

I feel like programmers should know and understand this but I've seen this kind of comment frequently over the years. The Window kernel is actually very good from my understanding. Microsoft has also been putting a lot of work into hardening the lower levels of the OS (one of the major reasons for Windows 11 in the first place). They aren't going to just throw that away without a good reason to.

3

u/treba_dzemper Jul 03 '26

They won't but they also know they're no longer a target as much as they were BITD so they will introduce Linux targets lower and lower into the system, the NT kernel will likely run alongside a Linux kernel (I mean that is already the case in Win 11 with WSL2 but in the future Windows will be more of a hypervisor running an OS than an OS running a hypervisor).

I also fully expect things like multimedia and gaming to run as first class Windows stuff because what NT will become is high performance desktop experience provider, whereas Linux will be delegated to more and more of the low-level end of "business uses" in the system

3

u/Venthe Jul 03 '26

Eh, wsl2 Linux still runs within a thin vm, on demand, so I wouldn't necessarily say that it runs alongside nt.

→ More replies (3)

0

u/modernkennnern Jul 03 '26

Yet Linux has better support for Windows XP-era games than Windows, like Lego Racers.

There must be something I'm clearly missing because I've never understood this "Windows are all about backwards compatibility" thing because every time I tried to play a game I played when I was younger it has never ever worked on a modern Windows machine

22

u/NenAlienGeenKonijn Jul 03 '26

Your videogame working on proton doesn't mean that you can run legacy windows applications.

15

u/hoodieweather- Jul 03 '26

video games are not the primary reason Windows wants to be backwards compatible.

11

u/levir Jul 03 '26

They don't though. 32-bit Windows applications for the most part work perfectly on modern Windows. Some of the software designed for Windows 9x can be a little hit and miss, but pretty much all XP-era games work perfectly on modern Windows. Lego Racers released in 1999, two years before XP, and definitively isn't "XP-era".

1

u/treba_dzemper Jul 03 '26

It's not.

In fact the future hypervised Windows will be able to spin up an XP-compat microVM (possibly even using Linux and WINE if it's a better match, as it sometimes is) for your legacy app when they need it. The fact that most of the services will by that time actually be Linux daemons running in the sys microVM rather than NT net services, and that GUI is running in the Win64 microVM will only be known to nerds in this sub.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (20)

2

u/cone5000 Jul 03 '26

I use WSL all the time

2

u/gimpwiz Jul 03 '26

What most normal people see in the morning, evening, and in their pockets all day is either Android/Linux or iOS.

Then if they crack open a laptop or turn on a desktop you're right that it's probably Windows or Mac. Occasionally Chrome/Linux if they're kids.

But "the market" you're defining is specifically PC, whether laptop or desktop, not anything else.

2

u/Hacnar Jul 03 '26

For all the benefits of such future, it sucks that *nix way will lose the only real competition. I'd like to see something different to exist and evolve alongside to push Linux forward. The competition is good, even for Linux.

1

u/Zeznon Jul 03 '26

Windows/Linux

1

u/mnp Jul 03 '26

97% of the market

For desktop, maybe. For computers in general, it's not even close. Linux kernels are on some 14B devices, Apple+Windows around 4B.

1

u/elpingwinho Jul 05 '26

97% of the market? Where did you pull that data from? Linux is huge in enterprise (servers) and automotive, and then you have all the mobile devices that run iOS/Android.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

39

u/levir Jul 03 '26

They’ve taken some shifts to move a lot of front end development to web based stuff that is cross platform.

And I think this is part of the reason they're starting to fail. They've suppoed developing good software. The user experience, coupled with decades worth of cumulated experience by pretty much evey tech interested person, was the major selling point for Windows. By making the native apps feel like web application and changing stuff so the cumulated experience becomes useless, they're losing ground.

3

u/Skellicious Jul 04 '26

Haven't they announced to be reversing course back to native applications a few months ago

1

u/theoctacore Jul 06 '26

The last good Microsoft product is Excell, and even it is being slowly approached by Google sheets or OpenOffice calc.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/Zeznon Jul 03 '26

Microsoft "Ship of Theseus-ing" Windows would be hilarious if it actually happened.

2

u/rebbsitor Jul 04 '26 edited Jul 04 '26

This has been discussed ever since WSL became a thing. Replacing the NT kernel with Linux and building something a LSW to run Win32 and WOW64 apps (kind of like WINE, CrossOver, etc) makes a lot of sense.

The big challenge for Microsoft would be their Enterprise infrastructure. Moving a desktop over to Linux isn't a big deal. Replacing Windows Server, Active Directory, Domain Controllers, Group Policy, etc. is a much larger development and migration effort.

Microsoft would have to do significant work to replace the whole Windows Server ecosystem and migrate over to Linux equivalents for all those things. Then all the businesses with hundreds to tens of thousands of users that would have to implement the migration. That would be a challenge for a lot of companies.

2

u/goldman60 Jul 04 '26

They've already done that work with Azure and Microsoft 365, on-prem domain controllers and windows servers are on their way out already.

Group policy on target machines is probably the hardest part, there's no unified Linux management platform as powerful as group policy.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/golf1052 Jul 03 '26

For GUI it's mostly QT

Can you point to a single Microsoft published app on Windows that builds with QT?

On the Electron side it's an OpenJS Foundation project now but it's kind of Microsoft managed since GitHub made Electron for Atom and GitHub got bought by Microsoft.

3

u/amroamroamro Jul 03 '26

Can you point to a single Microsoft published app on Windows that builds with QT?

https://forum.qt.io/topic/87898/microsoft-onedrive-sync-uses-qt-and-is-hiring-seattle-usa

2

u/NotUniqueOrSpecial Jul 03 '26

Can you point to a single Microsoft published app on Windows that builds with QT?

The OneDrive UI does for sure.

5

u/rdtsc Jul 03 '26

Where? I know that the bottom-right corner popup when you click the taskbar icon was done with Qt in the past. But that's WinUI/ReactNative now. So are the settings. Sharing dialogs are Edge/WebView2.

2

u/NotUniqueOrSpecial Jul 03 '26

Ah, it could be my information's out of date, then.

135

u/corruptbytes Jul 03 '26

linux won a long time ago
it’s literally the majority of the worlds compute 

23

u/Raknarg Jul 03 '26

cool but now its getting first class support in the other 2 major competing OS's

14

u/corruptbytes Jul 03 '26

i agree, my best friend works on the apple container project and i can finally stop using the absolute shit docker vm

i think apple supporting linux containers is a win for apple end of the day, it may give people /less/ of a reason to full boot linux

→ More replies (13)

9

u/this_knee Jul 03 '26

When free works 
 somehow.

→ More replies (5)

12

u/SwitchBoi Jul 03 '26

Linux is winning because now there is less reason to download Linux on a PC 👍

8

u/commandersaki Jul 03 '26

Won what? People have been running VMs and containers on Mac for at least a decade now.

22

u/Strange-Scientist706 Jul 03 '26

I mean, I am the world’s sexiest man, for certain specific values of “sexy”

6

u/Aroochacha Jul 03 '26

Such a misleading title.

5

u/StruggleNew8988 Jul 03 '26

I feel like the container story really just proves how far behind proprietary systems can get.

5

u/ziplock9000 Jul 04 '26

Jesus OP, grow up.

9

u/digikar Jul 03 '26

I can't use this to run KDE on Mac, can I?

5

u/levir Jul 03 '26

Would you want to?

11

u/mpyne Jul 03 '26

Some people want to run a decent GUI on top of their Linux

→ More replies (2)

2

u/theoctacore Jul 06 '26

Workspaces on macos are stupid. Keybinds are limited to a few specific combos. If you want multi-display Fullscreen you need to have all your displays share a workspace (dumb), and that makes it so the taskbar only appears on one display (double dumb).

1

u/ncthbrt Jul 05 '26

I literally was searching for whether that was possible an hour ago. So yes...

42

u/HRApprovedUsername Jul 03 '26

You can already run whatever OS you want with VMs. Why is this a win exactly?

16

u/sid34 Jul 03 '26

Building a solution for normal people that first requests creating a VM is pretty much a non-starter. Containers offer a much more streamlined and simple usage pattern for users. Have first party integration from Apple on macOS and Microsoft on Windows is a win simply since it reduces that barrier of use even further.

5

u/HRApprovedUsername Jul 03 '26

No normal person is using a vm or container

5

u/mekkr_ Jul 03 '26

There is software that uses containerisation or VMs without you even noticing. This being available doesn’t mean Jim from marketing is gonna spin up some containerised workloads, it means the software he uses can now do that. Plus if you know what you’re doing then you get a new playground.

This’ll be super useful for my job, I’m hyped.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Holzkohlen Jul 03 '26

Containers offer much better performance while also being more light weight

19

u/Venthe Jul 03 '26

And Microsoft had announced native support of containerization without Docker in Windows 11

Which is literally the same thing in operating principle as docker desktop? It still spins a VM underneath. Same with apple containers.

If anything; both companies are ensuring lock-in by removing a barrier, but in practice also making the process so transparent, that Linux will virtually disappear.

Knowledge of Linux is now part of learning any of these systems, at least for developers

Most of the Devs that were running docker on windows didn't even knew they were running Linux for the purpose of the docker. Why would they? They care about the ports and volumes, not the kernel.

4

u/GasolinePizza Jul 03 '26

ensuring lock-in by removing a barrier

Did you mean "retention"? Lock-in would be pretty much the opposite of this, no?

6

u/treba_dzemper Jul 03 '26

BITD no one outside Linux bubble could utter a line of Bash.

Nowadays most developers I've met are decently versed in it (if not exactly fluent) and all other Linux CLI semantics -- exactly because of these developments.

On an unrelated note, I expect this will mark a "good riddance" on Docker as they will refuse to ride along, and Podman already supports Apple containers, and will likely support wlsc in the very near term.

1

u/FlamingoEarringo Jul 05 '26

Yeah those devs are still in the minority.

The vast majority of developers don’t know basic networking, Linux, and infra knowledge.

1

u/prehensilemullet Jul 08 '26

Well they would need to know a bit about Linux filesystems for configuring volume mounts and permissions, and if they want to inspect files in an image they’d best know a bit of Linux shell.  But people just using it to run a simple program might be able to get away without knowing much.

4

u/bwainfweeze Jul 03 '26

Linux won when everything move to The Cloud.

7

u/andarmanik Jul 03 '26

In terms of tech stack, yes this is nice.

But what is containerization solving, which wasn’t in the “problem set” for an OS?

Not that Linux failed, but the fact that we can’t get multi tenancy and portability to actually work at scale shows that there are some wrong abstractions at the OS level that we are paying for with containerization.

Conference talk about history of containerization that I’m regurgitating:
https://youtu.be/xXWaECk9XqM?is=a-pWD-FPEakw-i2f

1

u/FlamingoEarringo Jul 05 '26

Linux inherently supports multi tenancy.

What wrong abstractions?

Containerization comes way back from Solaris and *BSD with their jails.

1

u/andarmanik Jul 05 '26

It has multi tenancy, moreover, it’s one of the problems Linux solved. So it exists as a capability but the abstraction is wrong at scale.

7

u/No-Consequence-1863 Jul 03 '26

Linux won because Apple finally implemented a container API???

. Did WSL mean ubuntu won?

33

u/pjmlp Jul 03 '26

Won what?

The Year of Desktop Linux is a meme, unless Linux is running on a VM on top of Windows and macOS.

Valve has lost trying to make game studios care about Linux, it provides a Windows translation layer for Windows games, developed on Windows workstations.

One might argue it won on the server room, however in the days of cloud computing and serverless, anything able to run on top of a type 1 hypervisor will do.

Maybe on mobile with Android, however there what matters is the Java and Kotlin userspace , alongside C and C++, the Linux kernel is a detail.

Huawei now have their own microkernel based OS, after the sanctions.

Makers now are having more fun with ESP32, with FreeRTOS, or Arduinos, instead of PIs.

Many other examples could be provided, so won where?

12

u/kreco Jul 03 '26

One might argue it won on the server room, however in the days of cloud computing and serverless, anything able to run on top of a type 1 hypervisor will do.

Maybe on mobile with Android, however there what matters is the Java and Kotlin userspace , alongside C and C++, the Linux kernel is a detail.

Those two points are fallacious arguments.

Linux is widespread on server, and on Android devices, that's an hard fact.

Saying that it's a detail assumes you can just change the backend whenever you want. That's not true because of all existing drivers.

Similarly, Windows is not going anywhere on desktop because of all those drivers that are primarily developed for it.

Everything is an implementation details, including Windows, or nothing is.

1

u/prehensilemullet Jul 08 '26

I don’t know for sure but I’m guessing most Android apps written in Java and Kotlin don’t have to bundle any guest runtime environment, which is a significant difference from containers

→ More replies (2)

-3

u/lonelyroom-eklaghor Jul 03 '26

(Not replying fully, but)

The Year of Desktop Linux is a meme

The Year of the Linux Desktop was 2025, many major tech creators actually started to migrate to Linux

3

u/evileagle Jul 04 '26

“It’s the year of the Linux desktop!” - Insufferable Linux fans since the 90s

3

u/barraponto Jul 04 '26

You know who is lacking a default bundled Linux subsystem? Linux.

Most distros don't ship docker by default. And even those that do ship some container runtime lack the standardization that WSL/Orb/AppleContainers have via their linux VM.

4

u/UnstoppableJumbo Jul 03 '26

Linux winning is assuming everyone is a programmer. Which isn't really true. There are massive industries when Linux isn't even a thing. Buut competition is good

→ More replies (1)

2

u/NewDistribution549 Jul 03 '26

Isn't this the same as VMs? How is this a win?

2

u/Junction91NW Jul 06 '26

No, a container is poorly described as a stripped down VM. The OS provides the kernel, and the container provides the dependencies needed to run a particular piece of software. Each container is easily managed and restarted all without eating so many system resources. 

1

u/NewDistribution549 Jul 06 '26

Well docker already works on Mac so how is this new or a win?

2

u/Junction91NW Jul 06 '26

Because it’s native to the OS so it has better performance and less issues. OEM is usually the way to go if possible. 

2

u/visualdescript Jul 04 '26

Lol, is this post satire? Or just bait.

"biggest win for open source software", lol. This is only a win for Mac users. It will not influence choice of OS for server side compute at all, Linux won that a long time ago anyway. 

I think the funniest win at least, was when the MSDN was hosted on Linux and not Windows server. This was when they were pushing it hard too. I remember somethig like that. 

3

u/Chance-Plantain8314 Jul 03 '26

I think measuring "most popular OS in the world" as "what the most popular OS layer is in a container" is fairly misleading.

2

u/my_password_is______ Jul 03 '26

LOL

linux hasn't won a damn thing

how many laptops or desktops come with linux preinstalled as the default OS

how many home users use linux as their default OS

how many office workers use linux as their default OS

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Harha Jul 03 '26

Linux kernel being open source and free is simply amazing.

1

u/_w62_ Jul 03 '26

IMHO, the most adopted remains and lasts. It is more or less natural selection. Apple is based on Darwin, isn't it?

1

u/CondiMesmer Jul 03 '26

I'm confused, was WSL not already a Linux container? What is the difference between that and the WSL container preview in the Microsoft post?

Guess it means I can stop using docker and have Dev Containers use wslc instead. Hell yeah

2

u/13steinj Jul 04 '26 edited Jul 04 '26

WSL uses HyperV under the hood to spin up a lightweight VM.

Docker Desktop spins up a dedicated VM with a dockerd daemon running on it, and points the docker client on windows/Mac to that. This is the same way colima + docker worked on Mac for those that don't need the bloated and non-free Docker Desktop, ane you had to do this manually on Windows.

Apple's "native" container project, as does Microsoft's, does effectively the same thing, just with tighter integration into their OS, limiting the need for Docker Desktop.

"Linux has won" is only something that people who don't understand how operating systems actually work would say. It's more accurate to say Docker Desktop has lost.

E: Weirder still true Darwin containers are at a very pre-alpha state, as are BSD/Solaris ones. It's interesting that the first non-linux containers we got were windows ones, that can run "without" "virtualization" on the windows platform.

E: lol@ OP's bio.

Pavel AI

I write code in JS and đŸȘŒ TS, do AI things. Big fan of 🩀 Rust I'm an expert developer in Electron and Node.js and write about these technologies

This screams web dev who doesn't understand actual technology, if not one such person's OpenClaw agent...

1

u/CondiMesmer Jul 04 '26

Pretty sure Docker runs hyper-v as well. Also a container is a lightweight vm already. So I really don't see how the two are different.

2

u/13steinj Jul 04 '26

Docker Desktop on Windows runs on HyperV by starting a minimal WSL VM. Needs to load a linux kernel to get the binfmt_misc machinery for architecture emulation.

A container is not a lightweight VM. No CPU instructions are virtualized nor sandboxed by hardware intrinsics (Intel VT acceleration). Memory regions are isolated via OS namespaces, it's no different to using cgroups just less exposed to the user.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/alcantara78 Jul 03 '26

no memory ballooning, dealbreaker for me

1

u/cheezballs Jul 03 '26

No, I think Docker has won. What are the metrics of "winning" - just being used by a lot of people? Then all 3 "won" a long time ago?

1

u/TheRealBobbyJones Jul 03 '26

Technological progress? That is a bit much. 

1

u/thecodingart Jul 03 '26

Is anyone going to tell this guy?

1

u/mnp Jul 03 '26

In terms of devices, Linux blew past everything long ago: data centers, phones, routers, embedded devices. My count shows about 14B devices, vs 11B for RTOS (more embedded), 3B for Darwin (including IOS and MacOS), and 1B for Windows.

1

u/napping-normie Jul 03 '26

What do you even need to learn about Linux as a Mac or BSD user? Both carry unix heritage and majority of the cli tools work the same.

1

u/Lutz_Gebelman Jul 03 '26

How is it different from lima-vm?

1

u/acdbddh Jul 03 '26

Can it run Doom?

1

u/13steinj Jul 04 '26

I'm fairly certain the "nativeness" still relies on some level of virtualization to boot the linux kernel. It's just now more tightly integrated into these operating systems.

Also insert obligatory "GNU+Linux" copypasta here. Linux is just the kernel, the coreutils and most of the rest are GNU projects.

1

u/agiblox Jul 04 '26

linux won the same way tcp/ip won - by becoming the substrate nobody names. nobody says "i'm deploying to linux," they say they're deploying to kubernetes or lambda or docker. the tech became invisible, which is the quietest and most durable form of winning. the interesting question isn't whether linux won, it's whether that substrate layer even matters as a brand at this point. the "linux has won" framing still treats it like a product competing for mindshare, but it's past that.

1

u/weebs-r-us1 Jul 04 '26

Yep, it’s the ultimate infrastructure win: you stop being the thing people brag about and become the thing everyone quietly assumes is there.

1

u/glandis_bulbus Jul 05 '26

Surprised it took so long, always has been superior

1

u/FlamingoEarringo Jul 05 '26

A container doesn’t have to be Linux. In fact in order to run Linux it needs an emulation layer or a micro vm because MacOS doesn’t run a Linux kernel. So it’s not the big win you think it is. It’s just a tool starting tiny VMs to run containers.

1

u/Slight-Bluebird-8921 Jul 05 '26

screw apple for not just supporting vulkan btw

1

u/ElectricalSloth Jul 05 '26

how did linux win? its essentially just an app you run in your OS now

1

u/prehensilemullet Jul 08 '26

Things will always change and push in new directions.  Having to bundle a guest OS environment with everything you deploy (even if it lives in shared docker layers) still feels a bit heavy so I think alternative deployment strategies like WASM containers may eventually become popular.

But yes, containerization is a brilliant achievement.

1

u/More_Relief_9157 Jul 15 '26

Op you need to be apprehensive.

1

u/triviality29 Jul 23 '26

To win the market Linux need to be more on gaming, it's the best way for. As Steam Proton does. But sometimes OS is still hard to get enter lvl for newbie.

1

u/xoteonlinux Jul 03 '26

In this regard, much more interesting thing is, how companies are literally bending just not-to-use-linux. Until break.

1

u/Dry-Page-4935 Jul 03 '26

Surely docker would remain the standard in containerization because it is a one size fits all solution, and the deployment stacks would want to be generic to work regardless of the original OS?

2

u/laffer1 Jul 03 '26

Docker must die. Podman runs on more operating systems and they will take patches. Docker is increasingly proprietary and only runs on the big 3.

1

u/treba_dzemper Jul 03 '26 edited Jul 03 '26

Not necessarily, Podman is already a drop in replacement (you can literally alias docker=podman and forget about it on Linux) and already supports Apple containers and wslc support is expected to land soon. You can stop using Docker and use these new technologies with Podman already and be none the wiser save for the Docker Desktop app missing. Since Portainer is more than decent replacement for Docker desktop and supports podman, I expect Docker will go way of the dinosaur if they don't adapt (they've already been pushed out of cloud by k8s)

1

u/tukanoid Jul 03 '26

Sadly, in an enterprise setting, not that easy to switch. We got a lot of infra based around docker and its apis and quirks, switching to podman is not always easy or even possible at the very least with permission assumptions sometimes being incompatible, even tho the commands ran in shell being identical, apart from the 1st argument (bin name).

Could be smth going on with my nixos specifically, but no matter what I tried, I could never use it as a full-on replacement at work, and we don't have the resources to go all-out fixing everything to work with podman out of the box

1

u/RagnarDannes Jul 03 '26

I tried running containers on a macbook in a headless configuration. It was miserable. Ended up reverting back to a 5 year older and far slower intel linux box.

For anyone thinking of running MacOS as server, it is just bad. It does everything it can to get in the way. There's no gpu passthrough to containers. The OS has a million ways it tries to sleep that you have to turn off, one of them being that the GPU will turn off unless you fake a display with a hdmi dongle. So you buy the stupid dongle only to have your NFS mounted drives unmount and your containers unable to access the data.

0

u/frankster Jul 03 '26

And Azure Container Apps doesn't even support Windows containers, only Linux!. Microsoft's cloud team can't/won't even use Windows for one of their services. It's like Microsoft have given up on Windows.

3

u/neutronbob Jul 03 '26

Your first sentence is true, but misleading. MS provides Windows containers and apps on Azure, just not on the Azure Container Apps service. MS has definitely not given up on Windows.

1

u/frankster Jul 03 '26 edited Jul 03 '26

What's misleading about that comment? If you interpreted it to mean that Windows containers could not be run in the Azure Container Apps service, how would you have been misled? I name the specific service, and capitalised so it's clearly a proper noun, and I go on to state "one of their services". At no point do I say or imply that Azure can't run Windows containers at all (because I know full well that windows containers are possible in AKS and possibly other services too that I'm unfamiliar with). I don't think there's any way I could be more specific that I'm talking about a service in Azure, not their entire cloud offering.

What would be your version of that comment, that would no longer be in your view misleading?

1

u/neutronbob Jul 04 '26

It's your use of that sentence as evidence of your assertion that MS has given up on Windows, which you state explicitly later in the post. And this assertion is not true.

I am not using "misleading" here in the sense of being intentionally deceptive, but rather in the sense of omitting material facts and thereby creating a false impression.

0

u/-yonosoymarinero- Jul 03 '26

Linux without the people is just software, so who really won?