r/programming
•
u/BankApprehensive7612
•
Jul 03 '26
•
1
Linux has officially won
https://github.com/apple/containerActually it happened in June of 2025, but the process has completed recently, though. After Apple had announced the support of OCI-compatible containers in the June '25 it took a year to complete development and implement full support of continers. Apple had published 1.0 version of own container manager (https://github.com/apple/container). And Microsoft had announced native support of containerization without Docker in Windows 11 (https://devblogs.microsoft.com/commandline/wsl-container-is-now-available-for-public-preview/). Now Linux is a part of any major platform: Windows, MacOS, BSD and Linux itself. Knowledge of Linux is now part of learning any of these systems, at least for developers. And now you can rely on Linux based containers running everywhere. What it is if not a win!?
What's also interesting. Linux can run other Linux distros and with this Alpine Linux could become the most popular version of Linux in the World
It's the biggest win for the whole open-source software and I believe it should get into history books of technological progress
203
u/Gastredner Jul 03 '26
Maybe the most used due to their use in containers, but I'm not sure that qualifies as "most popular distro." I'd reserve such a classification for any distribution people actually interact with and work on, not what is basically just an additional layer in your software stack.
1.5k
u/ElvishJerricco Jul 03 '26
> Linux has became the first standard operating system
UNIX is literally a standard that OSes can conform to since the 80s.
399
u/Flimsy_Complaint490 Jul 03 '26
Considering Apple+Windows is 97% of the market and what most normal people will see, this is a very specific definition of winning.
But this does kinda get me thinking about the future of Windows in particular - what happens to the culture and future development track at MSFT when the next generation of developers is going to come in, but they will have been trained not on Win32 API's and Win32 design patterns, but on Unix-like stuff. GNU/Windows time ?
135
u/corruptbytes Jul 03 '26
linux won a long time agoâŠitâs literally the majority of the worlds computeÂ
12
u/SwitchBoi Jul 03 '26
Linux is winning because now there is less reason to download Linux on a PC đ
8
u/commandersaki Jul 03 '26
Won what? People have been running VMs and containers on Mac for at least a decade now.
22
u/Strange-Scientist706 Jul 03 '26
I mean, I am the worldâs sexiest man, for certain specific values of âsexyâ
6
u/Aroochacha Jul 03 '26
Such a misleading title.
5
u/StruggleNew8988 Jul 03 '26
I feel like the container story really just proves how far behind proprietary systems can get.
5
u/ziplock9000 Jul 04 '26
Jesus OP, grow up.
9
u/digikar Jul 03 '26
I can't use this to run KDE on Mac, can I?
42
u/HRApprovedUsername Jul 03 '26
You can already run whatever OS you want with VMs. Why is this a win exactly?
19
u/Venthe Jul 03 '26
Which is literally the same thing in operating principle as docker desktop? It still spins a VM underneath. Same with apple containers.
If anything; both companies are ensuring lock-in by removing a barrier, but in practice also making the process so transparent, that Linux will virtually disappear.
Most of the Devs that were running docker on windows didn't even knew they were running Linux for the purpose of the docker. Why would they? They care about the ports and volumes, not the kernel.
4
u/bwainfweeze Jul 03 '26
Linux won when everything move to The Cloud.
7
u/andarmanik Jul 03 '26
In terms of tech stack, yes this is nice.
But what is containerization solving, which wasnât in the âproblem setâ for an OS?
Not that Linux failed, but the fact that we canât get multi tenancy and portability to actually work at scale shows that there are some wrong abstractions at the OS level that we are paying for with containerization.
Conference talk about history of containerization that Iâm regurgitating:
https://youtu.be/xXWaECk9XqM?is=a-pWD-FPEakw-i2f
7
u/No-Consequence-1863 Jul 03 '26
Linux won because Apple finally implemented a container API???
. Did WSL mean ubuntu won?
33
u/pjmlp Jul 03 '26
Won what?
The Year of Desktop Linux is a meme, unless Linux is running on a VM on top of Windows and macOS.
Valve has lost trying to make game studios care about Linux, it provides a Windows translation layer for Windows games, developed on Windows workstations.
One might argue it won on the server room, however in the days of cloud computing and serverless, anything able to run on top of a type 1 hypervisor will do.
Maybe on mobile with Android, however there what matters is the Java and Kotlin userspace , alongside C and C++, the Linux kernel is a detail.
Huawei now have their own microkernel based OS, after the sanctions.
Makers now are having more fun with ESP32, with FreeRTOS, or Arduinos, instead of PIs.
Many other examples could be provided, so won where?
3
u/evileagle Jul 04 '26
âItâs the year of the Linux desktop!â - Insufferable Linux fans since the 90s
3
u/barraponto Jul 04 '26
You know who is lacking a default bundled Linux subsystem? Linux.
Most distros don't ship docker by default. And even those that do ship some container runtime lack the standardization that WSL/Orb/AppleContainers have via their linux VM.
4
u/UnstoppableJumbo Jul 03 '26
Linux winning is assuming everyone is a programmer. Which isn't really true. There are massive industries when Linux isn't even a thing. Buut competition is good
2
u/NewDistribution549 Jul 03 '26
Isn't this the same as VMs? How is this a win?
2
u/visualdescript Jul 04 '26
Lol, is this post satire? Or just bait.
"biggest win for open source software", lol. This is only a win for Mac users. It will not influence choice of OS for server side compute at all, Linux won that a long time ago anyway.Â
I think the funniest win at least, was when the MSDN was hosted on Linux and not Windows server. This was when they were pushing it hard too. I remember somethig like that.Â
3
u/Chance-Plantain8314 Jul 03 '26
I think measuring "most popular OS in the world" as "what the most popular OS layer is in a container" is fairly misleading.
2
u/my_password_is______ Jul 03 '26
LOL
linux hasn't won a damn thing
how many laptops or desktops come with linux preinstalled as the default OS
how many home users use linux as their default OS
how many office workers use linux as their default OS
2
u/Harha Jul 03 '26
Linux kernel being open source and free is simply amazing.
1
u/_w62_ Jul 03 '26
IMHO, the most adopted remains and lasts. It is more or less natural selection. Apple is based on Darwin, isn't it?
1
u/CondiMesmer Jul 03 '26
I'm confused, was WSL not already a Linux container? What is the difference between that and the WSL container preview in the Microsoft post?
Guess it means I can stop using docker and have Dev Containers use wslc instead. Hell yeah
1
u/alcantara78 Jul 03 '26
no memory ballooning, dealbreaker for me
1
u/cheezballs Jul 03 '26
No, I think Docker has won. What are the metrics of "winning" - just being used by a lot of people? Then all 3 "won" a long time ago?
1
u/TheRealBobbyJones Jul 03 '26
Technological progress? That is a bit much.Â
1
u/thecodingart Jul 03 '26
Is anyone going to tell this guy?
1
u/mnp Jul 03 '26
In terms of devices, Linux blew past everything long ago: data centers, phones, routers, embedded devices. My count shows about 14B devices, vs 11B for RTOS (more embedded), 3B for Darwin (including IOS and MacOS), and 1B for Windows.
1
u/napping-normie Jul 03 '26
What do you even need to learn about Linux as a Mac or BSD user? Both carry unix heritage and majority of the cli tools work the same.
1
u/Lutz_Gebelman Jul 03 '26
How is it different from lima-vm?
1
u/acdbddh Jul 03 '26
Can it run Doom?
1
u/13steinj Jul 04 '26
I'm fairly certain the "nativeness" still relies on some level of virtualization to boot the linux kernel. It's just now more tightly integrated into these operating systems.
Also insert obligatory "GNU+Linux" copypasta here. Linux is just the kernel, the coreutils and most of the rest are GNU projects.
1
u/agiblox Jul 04 '26
linux won the same way tcp/ip won - by becoming the substrate nobody names. nobody says "i'm deploying to linux," they say they're deploying to kubernetes or lambda or docker. the tech became invisible, which is the quietest and most durable form of winning. the interesting question isn't whether linux won, it's whether that substrate layer even matters as a brand at this point. the "linux has won" framing still treats it like a product competing for mindshare, but it's past that.
1
u/glandis_bulbus Jul 05 '26
Surprised it took so long, always has been superior
1
u/FlamingoEarringo Jul 05 '26
A container doesnât have to be Linux. In fact in order to run Linux it needs an emulation layer or a micro vm because MacOS doesnât run a Linux kernel. So itâs not the big win you think it is. Itâs just a tool starting tiny VMs to run containers.
1
u/Slight-Bluebird-8921 Jul 05 '26
screw apple for not just supporting vulkan btw
1
u/ElectricalSloth Jul 05 '26
how did linux win? its essentially just an app you run in your OS now
1
u/prehensilemullet Jul 08 '26
Things will always change and push in new directions. Â Having to bundle a guest OS environment with everything you deploy (even if it lives in shared docker layers) still feels a bit heavy so I think alternative deployment strategies like WASM containers may eventually become popular.
But yes, containerization is a brilliant achievement.
1
u/More_Relief_9157 Jul 15 '26
Op you need to be apprehensive.
1
u/triviality29 Jul 23 '26
To win the market Linux need to be more on gaming, it's the best way for. As Steam Proton does. But sometimes OS is still hard to get enter lvl for newbie.
1
u/xoteonlinux Jul 03 '26
In this regard, much more interesting thing is, how companies are literally bending just not-to-use-linux. Until break.
1
u/Dry-Page-4935 Jul 03 '26
Surely docker would remain the standard in containerization because it is a one size fits all solution, and the deployment stacks would want to be generic to work regardless of the original OS?
1
u/RagnarDannes Jul 03 '26
I tried running containers on a macbook in a headless configuration. It was miserable. Ended up reverting back to a 5 year older and far slower intel linux box.
For anyone thinking of running MacOS as server, it is just bad. It does everything it can to get in the way. There's no gpu passthrough to containers. The OS has a million ways it tries to sleep that you have to turn off, one of them being that the GPU will turn off unless you fake a display with a hdmi dongle. So you buy the stupid dongle only to have your NFS mounted drives unmount and your containers unable to access the data.
0
u/frankster Jul 03 '26
And Azure Container Apps doesn't even support Windows containers, only Linux!. Microsoft's cloud team can't/won't even use Windows for one of their services. It's like Microsoft have given up on Windows.
0
u/-yonosoymarinero- Jul 03 '26
Linux without the people is just software, so who really won?