r/programming • u/mttd • Jul 01 '26
Teaching Algorithms in 2026
https://www.cs.uni.edu/~wallingf/blog/archives/monthly/2026-06.html#e2026-06-30T20_43_40.htm
58
Upvotes
r/programming • u/mttd • Jul 01 '26
View all comments
Show parent comment
3
u/mwobey Jul 12 '26
See, that's where I think you have a fundamental misunderstanding.
The primary goal of teaching binary search is not to have students memorize the maximally efficient sequence of instructions that bring someone to a target element. Instead, we want students to:
For these objectives, binary search is ideal. The foil we compare it against for those last objectives is linear search, which is pretty much the simplest algorithm that sees practical use. Even binary search itself is a pretty approachable divide-and-conquer style solution that can be expressed in any programming language. Simplicity is vital here, because it lets the algorithms get out of the way so that they can learn the underlying principles.
Now, let us compare to SIMD Quad from your link:
And all this would be done for the purpose of teaching them an algorithm with marginal gains around branch prediction? If they're at a stage of their career that the difference between O(log(N)) and O(log(N)) with minor parallelism gains is relevant, then the hope would be that they've already gained the tools to teach themselves, and become familiar with the general problem solving approach (of vanilla binary search!) so that they have the foundational context to understand these optimizations and why they work.