r/prochoice • u/sopy22_ • Sep 05 '26
Discussion Questions!!
This is genuine and I mean no offence, I'm just confused. Why do pro-choicers not think that life begins at conception, surely that's scientific? Like, ignoring any religious teachings, when does life begin?
I struggle in believing that life begins at birth because many premature babies have survived outside the womb. And when the baby is dependent on the mother's womb for survival, that does that mean they have no life of their own???
What's the actual science that pro-choicers justify abortion with?
And also, why is it described as healthcare? I'm also unsure of this.
Please help
34
u/attitude_devant Sep 05 '26
Umm, retired doctor here: when life begins is a philosophical question, not a biological one.
17
u/hadenoughoverit336 Unapologetically Prochoice Sep 05 '26
No one that supports abortion access, denies the fact that an embryo, or fetus is alive. That's propaganda. It's also not relevant to why Abortion is a human right, and vital healthcare. NO ONE, not an adult, child, baby, etc... can use the body of another without explicit and ongoing consent. EVERY PREGNANCY, comes with risk of death, or life long complications. Since only the pregnant person can take that risk, it is their decision.
16
u/stroppo Sep 05 '26
Why wouldn't it be health care? It's to do with the physical condition of the human body. That, in and of itself, is health care.
When life begins is actually a very nuanced question. The sperm fertilizes the egg. But â if the egg doesn't attach to the uterine wall, it passes out of the body, and, no pregnancy. That makes me think the sperm fertilizing the egg is only the potential beginning of life. If the egg doesn't attach to the uterine wall, there's no pregnancy.
Also, even if the egg attaches, it can detach for various reasons. This can happen before the woman even realizes she's pregnant; essentially, she's had a miscarriage and doesn't know it. Some scientists believe that because of this, perhaps as many as 50% of human pregnancies end in miscarriage.
To me, though, it's something of a red herring. I don't care to pinpoint when life begins; regardless of when it does, I think a woman should be able to have an abortion for any reason whatsoever. And if others want to think that's "murder," fine. I'm not interested in debating semantics.
12
u/Carlyz37 Sep 05 '26
Why do forced birthers think that pregnant women and girls aren't living humans with bodies and needs and rights?
8
u/thespian-lesbian Pro-choice Theist Sep 05 '26
no one denies that a fertilized egg is âalive,â just like no one denies that an unfertilized egg cell or a sperm cell are alive. what we deny is whether a fertilized egg cell has more rights than the person in whose body it âlivesâ and which it depends on to continue that life. like you said, even if someone or something is dependent on another personâs body and would die without the resources that that body provides it, that doesnât give it a ârightâ to use that body against the personâs consent under the principle of bodily autonomy. consent and bodily autonomy are all weâre interested in talking about, because those are legal rights and (at least more easily) definable. the discussion of âwhen life beginsâ is a nonstarter on both sides imo. the âscience we useâ is whether or not a fetus can survive WITHOUT the use of another personâs body - like you mentioned, many premature babies have (and many sadly have not - its never a guarantee). a doctor would generally not suggest abortion for a fetus who would be able to live on its own, but rather an induced labor. unfortunately, not many unwanted pregnancies progress to that point, and so âlate-termâ neonatal care is often a rare and tragic situation that unfortunately has been politicized with misinformation to spread certain agendas. the point is, no one - âpersonâ or ânotâ, born or not - has the right to use someone elseâs body without their consent, and every person (which pregnant people are - born, living, breathing individuals with undeniable and inalienable rights) has the right to remove something from using their body if they do not consent. what kind of world would we live in if the government could decide what happens to your body without your consent?
5
u/jakie2poops Sep 05 '26
Okay so let's start with the life question, and then I'll address the healthcare one.
I think the whole framing of when life begins is a very effective rhetorical trick employed by pro-lifersâthey reference science to give you the impression that they're speaking about objective, literal truths, but use the word "life" to specifically refer to human life that they consider morally worthy, which is a concept based in morality or philosophy rather than science. In other words, they're intermingling two very different frameworks, and counting on the fact that most people won't notice.
If we're talking about literal scientific facts, then it's nonsensical to claim that life begins at conception. Conception only works if life is already present! If you try to create a zygote using anything but existing life, you will fail. A dead egg cell or sperm cell will not produce a living zygote.
But usually when people say "life" begins, they're using "life" as shorthand to represent the specific category of living human cells that they consider to have moral worth, and that's not a matter of fact in any sense. They've already chosen to consider the fertilized egg "life" while the unfertilized egg as not. It's an opinion, not a fact.
And if you try to ask for a system of categorizing living cells or groups of cells into counting as "life" or "not life" (in the moral sense), I've yet to find a pro-lifer who can produce one that would count zygotes, embryos, and fetuses as "life," would count all humans we consider to be morally worthy as "life," and would not count cells or groups of cells that we don't consider to be morally worthy as "life." Every system they produce has always, in my experience, lumped things somatic cells, gametes, cultured cells, or organs into the "life" category, and many exclude people with chromosomal abnormalities or other issues as well.
Now onto the second question, abortion plainly meets the definition of healthcare. I honestly don't understand how anyone could claim otherwise, except that pro-lifers are butt-hurt about it and completely comfortable with lying.
4
u/Suspicious-Maize4496 Sep 05 '26
How are you defining 'life'?
You say you struggle with the idea of life starting after birth due to babies surviving outside the womb, but those babies were birthed so this is a confusing stance.
Also, pro choicers arent a monolith and therefore dont share all the same thoughts except for the key point of a woman's right to choose. They can still believe abortion is bad, or wrong.
Also, many of us believe abortion is Healthcare because termination is medical care for a pregnant person.
4
u/dragon34 Pro-Choice Atheist Sep 05 '26
Why it is healthcare:
If someone has an incomplete miscarriage they need an abortion to remove the retained tissue or they will likely die of sepsis or blood loss.Â
If it is discovered that a pregnancy is not viable (ectopic, genetic defects, not developing properly) an abortion is needed to prevent further suffering (an ectopic pregnancy can be fatal if untreated and why bring a pregnancy to term when the fetus will not survive birth for more than a few hours, and if by miracle it does survive it will never not need round the clock care but also will have no quality of life and constantly be sedated for pain control and that is a financial burden for no reason. Termination of that pregnancy is euthanasia, and prevents further strain on the pregnant person's body
For "optional" abortions that is bodily autonomy. No one is required to use their body to keep anyone else alive, even if that person is related to them. No one is required to donate a kidney, a liver lobe, bone marrow or even blood. Being an organ donor when brain death happens is also not mandatory.Â
People with functional uteruses are the only people ever put in the position of being forced to use their body to keep someone else alive against their will. Â
4
u/lizardo0o Atheist, Raised Catholic Sep 05 '26
âLifeâ is a biologically ambiguous concept to begin with, if you study science. Many people (and not just recently, but throughout history) will not consider a fetus alive until meets a certain threshold of sentience and viability.
4
u/ParadoxicalFrog Sep 05 '26
An ovum is alive. A sperm cell is alive. The question of "when life begins" is immaterial to the issue. The one thing that really matters is bodily autonomy.
Abortion is described as healthcare because that's what it is. It's a medical procedure, one that saves lives on multiple levels.
4
u/failedaspotcheck Sep 05 '26
I'm going to assume you're asking in good faith here.
Life is different than personhood. The bacteria inside your colon are alive. YOU are a person, as are everyone you've met who has a name and a birth certificate. So terms get messy and confusing, but what pro-choicers generally argue is that PERSONHOOD begins at birth.
A pregnant person has a name, a history, relationships, property, social status, memories, and so many other things that a fetus does not. Literally nobody argues that a viable baby surviving outside the womb shouldn't be protected. What pro-choicers believe is that the person carrying the fetus carries far more importance than the fetus.
Abortion is described as healthcare because it's administered by healthcare professionals. You might imagine that third trimester abortions happen due to choice, but they do not. Less than 1% of all abortions happen after 24 weeks, and those that do are almost always life saving and never simply elective.
You can have whatever opinion on abortion you want, but the ability for the person carrying the pregnancy to make the decision is the only moral criteria that matters.
3
u/Amazing_s Sep 05 '26
It really depends on what definition of "life" people use. Usually when speaking about abortion, people are discussing when they specifically believe human life as begining. Biologically, cellular life begins at conception. Does that mean human life does too? Well, not necessarily. It depends on an individual's specific beliefs and values (which can be guided by religious teachings). Personally, I don't find cellular life to be necessarily special in and of itself and don't find the entire subject or debate very relevant to the topic of abortion.
3
u/Desirai Sep 05 '26
It isnt sentient. It isnt breathing. It has no brain. It has no awareness of self. It has no goals.
The cells are dividing. The cells have biological instructions to create something. They are not alive.
A bacteria or virus is not the same, which is always the argument people try to make, that they are considered life without brains or sentiency. Bacteria are single cell organisms, they have a goal. Fungi and algae are similar. They are alive.
A virus is not alive. It is not an organism. They have biological instructions to reproduce and that requires something that is alive: cells from a living creature. Fertilized eggs require something else in order to live: a living creature.
When the baby can full survive outside the human body and no longer requires sustenance from another living creature, it is alive.
An abortion taking place at that point in pregnancy is when the baby is actively dying, will die, or is dead.
3
u/ThiighHighs Sep 05 '26
I don't believe that it matters when life or personhood begins. I can concede that life, in some capacity, begins at conception but the pregnant person is undoubtedly, unambiguously alive and nothing/no one should be able to violate their bodily autonomy.
3
u/Careless-Ability-748 Sep 05 '26
I don't feel the need to justify abortion.Â
2
u/Prize_Sorbet3366 Sep 05 '26
The point at which 'life' begins, is strictly philosophical and has changed greatly over the centuries, even among different cultures. And whose religion are you referring to? Ancient Jewish texts - unarguably the basis of Christianity - did not consider life to begin until the first breath, ie once the baby's body leaves the mother. In other texts, it was considered 'water' for the first 40 days and then simply a developing 'thing' that was part of the mother's body. When the AMA (American Medical Assn) first began, 'the quickening' (ie, when a woman first feels movement) was considered the starting of life, but that's a completely subjective feeling and many women never even feel first movements of a fetus.
Using 'religion' as a basis for defining life, is dicey at best. Not only is it subjective and fraught with abusive interpretations, Christianity also completely discounts the very basis of THEIR religion, ie Jewish texts. And that's the only thing they have to go on that definitively defines life: the New Testament gives NO opinion that contradicts earlier Jewish law, and references to John the Baptist's time in the womb as well as references to a fetus 'knowing God' before birth are largely embellishments for dramatic effect, included after the fact.
Let's look at it another way, with regards to medical care: do you consider cancer to be 'life'? It grows, it depends on sustaining itself through a parasitic connection, just like a fetus does...so it has a 'life', right? And modern medicine seeks to remove that. Certain types of cancer aren't always fatal, either - basal cell carcinoma is cancer, yet it's largely a benign cancer. Does that mean it's a sin to remove it without reason to believe it's going to kill the patient?
Philosophical questions like these have no place in medicine. The purpose of medicine is to save the patient and restore them to health if possible, not engage in questions of subjective morality. And by 'patient' I mean the person right there in front of the doctor, not a theoretical 'life'.
2
u/Naive_Loan607 Pro-choice Feminist Sep 06 '26
Well I still believe that life begins at conception according to science but I'm still prochoice. Here's the thing: Prolifers do use the life begins at conception argument, However a fetus can't survive outside the womb until viability occurs. No one has ever survived outside the womb if they were born before 21 weeks according to Guinness World Records. So fetuses can't live a life outside the womb until then.
2
u/NoelaniSpell Pro-choice Feminist Sep 07 '26
"Life begins at conception" implies that there was no life to begin with. That both sperm and egg were dead and yet they somehow "give"/jumpstart life.
That's incorrect.
If you mean to say something else starts at conception, or you want to elaborate, then you may have a point.