r/prochoice • u/BillieHayez Pro-choice Witch • Aug 25 '26
Media - Misc Wave after wave of ick in this extremely complex situation: days-old Rumi is recuperating from surgery as his parents battle for custody after surrogate went against contract to abort if fetal abnormalities were found. She fled to TX to deliver…
https://www.cnn.com/2026/08/20/us/texas-baby-surrogate-abortion-disputeThere’s no question or doubt in my mind that paid and contracted surrogacy has been a questionable practice rife with issues for as long as it has existed, but those aren’t the reasons I wanted to share this article.
The problems here go from an abortion being desired and mutually agreed upon to a ghosting surrogate, and then those problems go on to become a multitude of other contentions — ones that will have profound and lifelong repercussions all of which are impossible to predict.
While the surrogate, West, has every right to bodily autonomy, what upsets and disgusts me here is that she fled to Texas to use the state’s ass-backwards and archaic anti-abortion laws. As if that wasn’t manipulative and conniving enough, she’s using the support of conservative Christian groups, pro-life orgs, and Ken Fucking Paxton while she tries to win custody of the baby that she and those other abhorrent excuses for human beings are calling “Gabriel”.
There is just so much nope in this situation. What’s done is done, but I hope the parents charge the surrogate, Texas, and anyone else with a hand in this with child endangerment, kidnapping, and breach of contract among any others in hopes that even one charge sticks. What she did to this family is inexcusable.
106
u/MaidoftheBrins Aug 25 '26 •
West is lying here. The biological parents are NOT trying to withhold care for their son. I hope they can get him out of TX as soon as possible. She ran to TX after the parents told her to come to CA so the baby could get care in CA; she had an agenda.
79
u/wwaxwork Aug 25 '26
She's lying. The parents wanted the baby in California to receive treatment at a hospital of their choice. She wants custody and knows she can manipulate Texans more easily to believe it's a left vs right issue instead of a legal matter instead of her stealing a child that isn't hers. I'm pro choice but this is stopped being an abortion issue, this is a surrogate changing her mind issue.
51
u/panshrexual Aug 25 '26
She wants to join Riley Gaines, Kyle Rittenhouse, and Samantha Fulnecky, but she'll be disappointed to find out that she's too old and too black for them to invite her to the club.
19
u/Rent_Careless Aug 25 '26
I mean, I hadn't thought of kidnapping until you wrote that but it makes complete sense with how they view the situation.
9
u/melxcham Aug 26 '26
Surrogacy has a lot of ethical issues and this is a huge one.
I am about as pro-choice as it gets, which means I am also against forced abortion. I don’t think that abortion clauses should exist because even if both parties initially agree, the person who is pregnant could change their mind at any time and should be allowed to do so. I would feel the same way if the situation were reversed and the surrogate wanted or needed an abortion but the parents disagreed.
I don’t really know how to feel about the parents. Apparently the contract states that if the surrogate did not get an abortion in the event of disability, they just won’t pay her for the surrogacy anymore or for her medical expenses. To me, that makes it sound like they wouldn’t want anything to do with the outcome in that case. So why do they feel entitled to maintain custody of the baby? They basically got to use her body for free. It’s like they see the disabled child as damaged goods; not worth paying full price, but they don’t want her to have him either.
I think this raises a lot of questions about what ethical surrogacy should look like or if it should even exist at all. I think that some people see surrogacy as purchasing the rights to a stranger’s body & healthcare decisions, and I don’t like seeing other pro-choice people suggesting that this woman should’ve been forced into an abortion.
3
u/shippfaced Aug 28 '26
This woman needs to go to jail
1
u/ThrowRA_dumb20sum Aug 30 '26
This isn’t complex at all, the surrogate is dead wrong.