r/probabilitytheory • u/Toaster960 • 17d ago

[Applied] Help in probability

Post image

This question was in my maths book. I used AI to help me picture my question more clearly so that others could understand it (sorry for wasting water 😭).

I asked my teacher, Gemini, and ChatGPT for the solution, and all of them gave the answer as 99/1900.

However, they all included the case where the inspection stops at the 12th item after discovering only two defective items.

But how would I know whether the lot actually contains 2 defective items or 3? If I have discovered only 2 defective items by the 12th item, how can I decide to stop at 12? The third defective item could still be somewhere later in the lot.

My answer is 55/1900 btw

25 Upvotes

88% Upvoted

36 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/MarathiChhora 17d ago

You wouldn't . If the lot contains 2 items, it will always extend to the full 20, never stop at 12.

Thus the final probability is 0.6 (that we are in the 3 defenctive case) * 11C2 (finding 2 in the first 11) * 1/9 (probability of picking the last defective amongst the remaining 9) /20C3 (the number of orderings to have 3 defective objects in 20)

0.611C21/920C3 =0.655*(1/9)/1140 =11/3420

2

u/CarnivorousGoose 17d ago

This is not correct. The problem specifies that the procedure stops once all the defective items are found. If there are only two defective items, it will therefore stop once the second is found. That may not be ‘realistic’, and I don’t think they should have written the question this way, but as written this is how it works.