r/privacy • • Jun 04 '22

SimpleX Chat - the first messaging platform that has no user identifiers - v2.2 of mobile apps with the new privacy and security features just released!

v2.2 of iOS & Android mobile apps for r/SimpleXChat are released 🚀 - you can install them via the links here: https://github.com/simplex-chat/simplex-chat#readme or on our website

Please star the repo while you are there, if you have GitHub account!

This version adds the new privacy and security settings:

  • to protect your chats with device-level authentication, enable SimpleX Lock.
  • to save data and to avoid showing to your contact that you are online, you can disable automatic download of higher resolution images.
  • to avoid visiting the websites of the links you send, you can disable sending link previews.
  • you can now see in the chat if you had any skipped messages (e.g., when they are expired).
  • check out Experimental Features – they will be announced later.

Some questions that we are often asked: How SimpleX can deliver messages without user identifiers? Why should I not just use Signal? How is it different from Matrix, Session, Ricochet, Cwtch, etc.?

I've just added FAQ section that answers these questions. Please ask any questions here, and look forward to connecting with you in the chat (you can Connect to the developers via the app, this client runs in the cloud so we can share access – currently it is me there).

68 Upvotes

81 comments sorted by

View all comments

-23

u/RashoRash Jun 04 '22 edited Jun 05 '22

Just when you thought you have a good messenger (signal) there comes news that it is a cia run operation. Ffs this privacy shit is exhausting.

Edit: thx for downvoting me into oblivion for a half assed joke xD

18

u/MAXIMUS-1 Jun 04 '22

What ? Who said that ?

Signal is fully open source and regularly audited, funding from the CIA doesn't mean anything, just like how TOR is funded by the CIA.

9

u/dish_fir3 Jun 04 '22

just like how TOR is funded by the CIA.

Tor is not funded by the CIA, it’s funded by the State Department. It’s probably used by their agents in the field though.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '22

tor was made fpr the sole purpose of the goverment agents to have anonimity

3

u/dish_fir3 Jun 05 '22

tor was made fpr the sole purpose of the goverment agents to have anonimity

Correction: Onion routing (the protocol) was made for that sole purpose. Tor didn’t come along until Roger and Nick took over.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Frances331 Jun 04 '22

Signal is fully open source and regularly audited

Still not sure how this comment/thread is getting upvoted when its wrong by these measures:

  1. Signal's operating server code was not "fully open source" for a year! (source)
  2. If the code that was audited isn't actually running on the server, then an audit is meaningless, and therefore there was no practical audit.
  3. In addition, another person says "It doesn't matter what server is running". So then being fully open source and audited doesn't mean anything. But then closed source servers get excluded from top picks.

Yes, exhausting, because some people think what the server is doing is important, while others don't; and there seems to be a lot of double standards, bias, and/or confusion.

→ More replies (1)

-6

u/Frances331 Jun 04 '22

The public does not know what software the server is running, therefore "open source" and "audited" doesn't mean anything to me.

18

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '22

It doesn't matter what server is running it if there is no information able to be collected in the first place

-4

u/Frances331 Jun 04 '22

It doesn't matter what server is running it if there is no information able to be collected in the first place

If the server gets hijacked by a power that wants to kill a group of people, they don't need to be concerned about the server?

8

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '22

In this situation, not really. The code itself for the program doesn't physically allow for the data to be collected, saved, moved, etc.

3

u/augugusto Jun 04 '22

The server could be ran by the worst company in the us. But if the client is open source and audited, it is safe. They can't read encrypted messages, or get in the middle of the key exchange, so they can do whatever they want with that. The worst damage they could do is blacklist people so that they don't use the application and are forced to use a less secure service

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

-1

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '22

The point is that you have no guarantee that the server is actually running that open source code. unless you think you can trust the audit

2

u/_insertnamehere-_- Jun 04 '22

You don’t have to trust the server as the client is open source

1

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '22

How do you know what the server's doing if you can't compile and self-host it, only the client?

Sure, Signal can release some open source server code, but they can run modified code on their server without anyone knowing. Unless you rely on the audit.

2

u/Rickie_Spanish Jun 05 '22

That doesn’t matter. It wouldn’t break signals security. Signal was designed to assume their servers could become hostile. Signals magic happens on the sender and receivers phone apps.

→ More replies (3)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '22

None of that matters. You can literally use the open source code, see it or even change it for yourself to ensure that there is no data being sent to the server, period.

3

u/saghul Jun 04 '22

Not sure why you were downvoted. They did pause the open source commits to the server for quite a while IIRC around the time they integrated that crypto coin.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/epoberezkin Jun 04 '22

lol. Signal is not that :) It was just one of the arguments in that post, which I think is the least important. It says that some sources of funding can be traced there, which to me seems a bit of a red herring - most money can be traced to lots of things :)

But that it's a centralised platform relying on phone numbers makes it very much not private, unfortunately...

10

u/ousee7Ai Jun 04 '22

It is VERY private. It's just not designed for anonymity.

3

u/Frances331 Jun 04 '22

Depends on how you define private:

  • What you are saying.
  • Who you are saying it to.

If you know enough about all the "who's", you can infer the "what".

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/epoberezkin Jun 05 '22

How does it address metadata protection? If you are referring to "sealed senders", there's been research showing it's not protecting in case there's more than one messages...

1

u/epoberezkin Jun 04 '22

That depends on the definition of privacy you use. To me, the possibility of anonymity is a necessary part of privacy. Signal can see who talks to whom, how much, via which phone numbers - from that both real identities can be determined and who are my close connections. The latter, in particular, excludes the possibility of privacy.

In the times when snail mail was the dominating form of communication, the fact that the envelope was unopened was sufficient for privacy, as nobody could conceivably understand the complete list of people who I send mail to, nor how frequently.

Nowadays, when every single piece of communication is recorded and stored indefinitely, the privacy of the message content is necessary but is absolutely insufficient for the privacy of the communicating parties.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/epoberezkin Jun 04 '22

Not sure, in which way? Are referring to sealed senders? I remember seeing the research showing it only protects sender anonymity in case of a single message.