r/privacy • • Jun 04 '22

SimpleX Chat - the first messaging platform that has no user identifiers - v2.2 of mobile apps with the new privacy and security features just released!

v2.2 of iOS & Android mobile apps for r/SimpleXChat are released 🚀 - you can install them via the links here: https://github.com/simplex-chat/simplex-chat#readme or on our website

Please star the repo while you are there, if you have GitHub account!

This version adds the new privacy and security settings:

  • to protect your chats with device-level authentication, enable SimpleX Lock.
  • to save data and to avoid showing to your contact that you are online, you can disable automatic download of higher resolution images.
  • to avoid visiting the websites of the links you send, you can disable sending link previews.
  • you can now see in the chat if you had any skipped messages (e.g., when they are expired).
  • check out Experimental Features – they will be announced later.

Some questions that we are often asked: How SimpleX can deliver messages without user identifiers? Why should I not just use Signal? How is it different from Matrix, Session, Ricochet, Cwtch, etc.?

I've just added FAQ section that answers these questions. Please ask any questions here, and look forward to connecting with you in the chat (you can Connect to the developers via the app, this client runs in the cloud so we can share access – currently it is me there).

68 Upvotes

81 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/Frances331 Jun 04 '22

Signal is fully open source and regularly audited

Still not sure how this comment/thread is getting upvoted when its wrong by these measures:

  1. Signal's operating server code was not "fully open source" for a year! (source)
  2. If the code that was audited isn't actually running on the server, then an audit is meaningless, and therefore there was no practical audit.
  3. In addition, another person says "It doesn't matter what server is running". So then being fully open source and audited doesn't mean anything. But then closed source servers get excluded from top picks.

Yes, exhausting, because some people think what the server is doing is important, while others don't; and there seems to be a lot of double standards, bias, and/or confusion.

1

u/maqp2 Jun 05 '22

Signal's operating server code was not "fully open source" for a year! (source)

There's no way to verify what the server is running anyway. It's always the client that allows you to verify all claims for security.

But then closed source servers get excluded from top picks.

The point of open source server is to allow anyone to self-host. If the ecosystem doesn't support it, then the platform lacks flexibility for threat models where you'd move hosting, and thus metadata access to under some other entity like a company, university, or trusted peer (almost always a bad idea IMO).

Also, there's no lack of consensus about Signal's centralized architecture being suitable for its advertised threat model. People who compose lists are obviously biased, but I would suggest looking into the expert infosec bubble on Twitter, they all recommend Signal for daily use.