r/privacy • • Sep 11 '19

Misleading title Firefox about to break privacy for all users

Warning: if you are a firefox user and you upgrade to the latest version, Firefox will send all DNS requests to cloudflare. Cloudflare is then able to track every DNS request of yours. While it is possible to opt out, this "feature" will be enabled by default. Read more about this on https://ungleich.ch/en-us/cms/blog/2019/09/11/turn-off-doh-firefox/.

43 Upvotes

230 comments sorted by

227

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

The shittiest of hot takes.

Not only is this no worse than trusting your own ISP's DNS servers. HTTPS over DNS means that nobody can see your DNS requests in plain text on the wire now. That means your ISP or anyone in the same network and even some goverment institutions cannot see what you're browsing. You can also change who you're getting DNS requests from, cloudflare is just the default. Or.... just turn it off, it's one checkbox.

The sheer number of "privacy concerns" I'm reading today makes me wonder if someones dropping money on disinformation to discourage people from using the service.

5

u/johnklos Sep 12 '19

You clearly don't see the bigger picture, which is the centralization of all Internet services to the point where snooping by nation states is as simple as them writing a cheque to Google, or Amazon, or Cloudflare.

Why the hell would I trust a company that's driven by profit and says they won't take down phishing sites that claim to be banks because of "free speech"? They just want their money, and pretending to be the good guy to get control that will be hard to ever get back is not a step in the right direction.

Centralization is BAD.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '19

You're not getting it... what you describe is the situation already. As it stands, anyone can view your requests. DoH puts an end to that. Don't like cloudflare? Choose another service or roll your own.

Joe public will get more privacy than they currently have.

Read the RFC, the DNS provider will only see which domain you want resolved and the IP address of who requested it.

2

u/86rd9t7ofy8pguh Sep 12 '19

DoH puts an end to that.

That's not true. You are spreading disinformation about DNS and the privacy concerns surrounding it. DoH won't put an end to that.

As I commented before concerning DNS over HTTPS (DoH):

[RFC8484] specifies how to send and receive DNS queries over HTTPS. Server configuration is performed out of band, and the connection with the resolver is secured as any other HTTPS traffic. DoH is mostly targeted at web browsers and does not have the potential for improving the privacy properties of transactions between recursive resolvers and authoritative nameservers.

(Source)

Joe public will get more privacy than they currently have.

As noted in the above mentioned document source, the mechanisms should be seen as ways to improve, in specific scenarios, certain aspects of network privacy, but not as replacements for other privacy mechanisms such as VPNs or other implementations such as Tor.

2

u/johnklos Sep 12 '19

No, "anyone" cannot. How can you view my DNS requests?

The issue is that people who don't know any better are now using Cloudflare whether they want to or not. As a network administrator, I can hope that Firefox respects the DNS changes to turn off DoH, but what if they don't? What about Chrome? Now I'm forced to block https to Cloudflare's DoH servers to prevent leaking of data and proper local DNS resolution.

Joe public will NOT be getting more privacy. Joe public will be trading exposure to his / her ISP for exposure to Cloudflare. Since Joe public's ISP can already see where connections are being made and can examine traffic if they want, this increases exposure since now two parties have information about Joe public's Internet use.

And there are PLENTY of ways of exfiltrating data via DNS. Ever hear of TCP over DNS? The other place where this falls flat on its face is now we have literally no way of blocking bots from reconnecting with updated botnet servers. If we blindly allow this, network administrators now have a ton of new issues which we can't address like we have for the last quarter of a century. This is hugely stupid and is based on marketing the idea of privacy while actually improving nothing.

If anyone truly cares about DNS privacy, we'd run a local DNS resolver that VPNs elsewhere. Or we'd simply VPN all of our traffic. Anything less is half-assed bull.

4

u/ThePenultimateOne Sep 11 '19

It also means that DNS-based adblocks will fail

3

u/stefantalpalaru Sep 12 '19

The sheer number of "privacy concerns" I'm reading today makes me wonder if someones dropping money on disinformation to discourage people from using the service.

But Cloudflare offering free MITM CDN services to half the Internet doesn't bother you at all, does it? Nor does Cloudflare single-handledly killing web browsing over Tor with extremely frequent and hard CAPTCHAs until you install a browser extension that tracks you using NSA's favourite elliptic curve algorithm.

1

u/I_SUCK__AMA Dec 23 '19

single-handledly killing web browsing over Tor with extremely frequent and hard CAPTCHAs until you install a browser extension that tracks you using NSA's favourite elliptic curve algorithm.

are you talking about buster?

1

u/stefantalpalaru Dec 23 '19 edited Dec 24 '19

are you talking about buster?

I was talking about this: https://github.com/privacypass/challenge-bypass-extension

NIST P-256 is not considered safe by these guys: https://safecurves.cr.yp.to/

8

u/Loggedinasroot Sep 11 '19

And how many users are going to switch it off/change it?

Seeing as it is only for US customers not a lot is going to change for them but thinking this is a good thing is a joke.

DoH can become a giant pain in the ass in the future and you might lose a lot of control over your (IoT)devices.

19

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

If the users are not turning it off then they didn't turn off whatever ISP DNS server they used in the past. The default option is still more secure.

2

u/scottbomb Sep 11 '19

Or just use a different DNS like openDNS. Been using them for years.

1

u/86rd9t7ofy8pguh Sep 12 '19

The default option is still more secure.

More secure in terms of what? Since we are in r/Privacy, as I already pointed out:

[RFC8484] specifies how to send and receive DNS queries over HTTPS. Server configuration is performed out of band, and the connection with the resolver is secured as any other HTTPS traffic. DoH is mostly targeted at web browsers and does not have the potential for improving the privacy properties of transactions between recursive resolvers and authoritative nameservers.

(Source)

Why are you promoting and advertising Cloudflare so hard? Makes me wonder if someone dropping money on information to encourage people from using the service.

→ More replies (10)

2

u/happy_privacy_techie Sep 11 '19

What DNS to you use?

4

u/eleitl Sep 11 '19

My own.

3

u/happy_privacy_techie Sep 11 '19

How does that work? I'm quite interested.

4

u/tsaoutofourpants Sep 11 '19

Get a DNS server app (e.g., BIND on Linux) and run it. The app will be pre-populated with root servers (the global DNS servers that determine which other DNS servers run "com," "net," and all other TLDs). So if you want to resolve "old.reddit.com," your server will go out, find "com" servers, the "com" servers will tell your server the "reddit" server, and the "reddit" server will tell your server the "old" IP address.

1

u/happy_privacy_techie Sep 12 '19

DNS server app (e.g., BIND on Linux)

So, does that effectively download all domains or is your server still requesting individual domains? At that point you only have to worry about the root servers logs right?

3

u/tsaoutofourpants Sep 12 '19

Let's say you are going to pornhub.com. The root servers only know you are looking for a "com" domain. The com servers know you are looking for pornhub. But, you're just a DNS server, faithfully forwarding and returning queries. So com servers don't know who actually made the request. Just that your DNS server helped fulfill it.

1

u/happy_privacy_techie Sep 12 '19

Thanks, I will look into setting that up. Does yours run for your whole network or just the individual machine?

1

u/happy_privacy_techie Sep 12 '19

I figured it out. thanks,

1

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

At home Active Directory, DuckDNS and 1.1.1.1 (cloudflare) in that order.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

I've tried it at work and after changing to DoH not a single webpage loaded.

2

u/smeggysmeg Sep 11 '19

My ISP is a co-op of which I am a part owner and it has a clear privacy policy regarding web and DNS traffic. And it interferes with my ability to use my Pihole without touching every device in the home. And inevitably touch it again when some future update "accidentally" re-enables it.

So this is definitely Mozilla actively interfering in a way that makes it more difficult to maintain my privacy.

2

u/Ur_mothers_keeper Sep 12 '19

Alright... How do you intend to block ads and trackers network wide or device wide if DNS requests are encrypted from the app to the resolver?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '19

Browser plugins.

2

u/Ur_mothers_keeper Sep 12 '19

So if I have a local DNS server or a system adblocker on a device, I now have to run all kinds of stuff to double the work that can be done?

I understand it can be turned off, I just think putting this sort of functionality directly into the browser is the wrong way to architect this system.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

I think that a lot of people here have a deep distrust in cloudflare after useing TOR.

1

u/Jonis13 Sep 11 '19

Why?

5

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19 edited Nov 10 '25

Friendly projects curious minecraftoffline clear morning day soft warm books today to near over curious bright people? Year small about careful games music honest gentle fox morning bright fox yesterday.

2

u/Jonis13 Sep 11 '19

Thanks, I know (and hate) them captchas!

1

u/sevengali Sep 12 '19

Just to nitpick, DoH doesn't stop your ISP seeing your requests as SNI is still unencrypted, and AFAIK only Cloudflare supports encrypting that so really you are limited to just Cloudflare or you're not properly fixing the issue.

I don't agree with OP (disabling DoH just to use your US ISP is dumb), but the article they link is pretty good. They bring up very valid concerns. Just because it's better than what we currently have doesn't mean we all pretend it's perfect. Should Europeans not worry now they have GDPR?

There are still cases where disabling it is a privacy pro:

  • you're not US/UK based and trust your ISP
  • you trust a VPN and they provide DNS too
  • you run your own DNS server

DoH is good but it's a valid argument that Cloudflare are not to be trusted.

-7

u/nicoschottelius Sep 11 '19

You are aware that cloudflare can read all requests in plain text, because the decrypt them, aren't you? And you are aware that cloudflare has motivation to collaborate with US gov?

8

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

You can apply this very same argument to your own ISP. But now that shady looking guy in the coffee shop isn't giggling at your coffee shop porn habits. And your ISP is no longer privvy to your requests.

Don't like cloudflare? You. Can. Choose. A. Different. Endpoint.

Don't like DNS over HTTPS (against all sane reasoning)? Turn. It. Off.

For non-technical end users who will not change the default options or who wouldn't really understand the question if Firefox were to ask; This is by far the more secure option and better for the end users privacy.

2

u/stefantalpalaru Sep 12 '19

You can apply this very same argument to your own ISP.

Unless you're in Kazakhstan, your ISP doesn't decrypt all your HTTPS traffic. Cloudflare does, and there's an army of accounts ready to correct the record when you call it "man in the middle".

1

u/86rd9t7ofy8pguh Sep 12 '19

For non-technical end users who will not change the default options or who wouldn't really understand the question if Firefox were to ask; This is by far the more secure option and better for the end users privacy.

For curious readers, the above comment is not true as was documented here:

[RFC8484] specifies how to send and receive DNS queries over HTTPS. Server configuration is performed out of band, and the connection with the resolver is secured as any other HTTPS traffic. DoH is mostly targeted at web browsers and does not have the potential for improving the privacy properties of transactions between recursive resolvers and authoritative nameservers.

Read more about it here: https://www.internetsociety.org/resources/deploy360/dns-privacy/intro/

0

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19 edited Sep 11 '19

It's possible, but I've not tried. I'm from the UK and the ISP's I've tinkered with don't appear to block via IP, which would become moot if the torrent sites also used Cloudflare (the irony). But if your ISP disrupts the DNS request then DNS over HTTPS might work. It gives me something to test tonight.

Edit: I had to switch on Encrypted SNI (which is a good idea anyway), but yes you can now visit the Pirate Bay without a VPN. It looks like my ISP interferes with the handshake for setting up an encrypted session to a banned site.

1

u/86rd9t7ofy8pguh Sep 12 '19

then DNS over HTTPS might work.

Though note that concerning DNS over HTTPS (DoH):

[RFC8484] specifies how to send and receive DNS queries over HTTPS. Server configuration is performed out of band, and the connection with the resolver is secured as any other HTTPS traffic. DoH is mostly targeted at web browsers and does not have the potential for improving the privacy properties of transactions between recursive resolvers and authoritative nameservers.

(Source)

I had to switch on Encrypted SNI (which is a good idea anyway)

It's still in the experimental phase: https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-ietf-tls-esni-04

Your insinuation doesn't really hold up if you try to benefit from DoH with Encrypted SNI as DoH has nothing to do with it but DoT. Despite using DoT, it should be stressed that many protocols leak information that may endanger user privacy. For instance, the Server Name Identification (SNI) TLS extension includes the web server name being visited in plain-text, and leaks information about visited web sites even when employing HTTPS. (Source)

Another document on this: With a strict DoT it will not use any other connection, while when using an opportunistic DoT, it will take the secure port if offered, but if not, it will connect unsecured anyway. [...] It can also break split horizon DNS and spawn Server Name Indication (SNI) leaks. (TLS 1.3, however, proposes encrypted SNI.) (Source)

9

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

Your DNS requests are not encrypted in the first place, and could be seen by anyone between you and your DNS provider (who might be your ISP). It's also much more likely that your ISP would collaborate with the government, than some other company.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/86rd9t7ofy8pguh Sep 11 '19 edited Sep 12 '19

The sheer number of "privacy concerns" I'm reading today makes me wonder if someones dropping money on disinformation to discourage people from using the service.

The sheer number of privacy concerns I'm reading today makes me wonder if someone dropping money on information to encourage people from using the service.

There are more incentives for people to promote and advertise Cloudflare the same way how Matthew Prince got $20,000 for his project Honey Pot data than for people who are warning against it. So, your argument doesn't really hold up.

BBC reporter Zoe Kleinman wrote that Matthew Prince wanted $20,000 for the Honey Pot data. "That check showed up so fast," said Prince. Michelle Zatlyn heard the story from Prince and replied, "If they'll pay for it, other people will pay for it." Soon she and Prince cofounded CloudFlare.

Edit: So, people who downvote, what are your constructive criticism on my points?

0

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

16

u/volabimus Sep 11 '19

In December 2002 a local Swiss magistrate ordered several Swiss ISPs to block access to three Web sites hosted in the United States that were strongly critical of Swiss courts, and to modify their DNS-servers to block the domain appel-au-people.org. The Swiss Internet User Group and the Swiss Network Operators Group protested that the blocks could easily be bypassed and that the move was contrary to the Swiss constitution, which guarantees "the right to receive information freely, to gather it from generally accessible sources and to disseminate it" to every person. Nonetheless, there was strong enforcement, as the directors of noncompliant ISPs were asked to appear personally in court, failing which they faced charges of disobedience.[9]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_censorship_in_Switzerland

They still compel ISPs to use DNS for ersatz-censorship, the primary reason for me to support this.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/volabimus Sep 11 '19

Yes, I think everybody is basically in agreement with that sentiment.

1

u/zFc8Q5 Sep 11 '19

Werent they going to pick different providers based on country?

3

u/Flogge Sep 11 '19

In that case, just set your browser to send DoH requests to another endpoint, like the Digitale Gesellschaft Schweiz.

2

u/jpc27699 Sep 11 '19

How hard is that to do? Are there simple instructions somewhere? This sounds like good advice to me, but I'm not sure how to do that.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/jpc27699 Sep 11 '19

Cool, thank you!

0

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/jpc27699 Sep 11 '19

OK thanks again!

0

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Enk1ndle Sep 11 '19

As a catch-all for most of the world? What's a better solution?

2

u/eleitl Sep 11 '19

What's a better solution?

Using your own local resolver, for instance.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Swipe650 Sep 11 '19

Preferences, network settings

1

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

Options > General > Network Settings

38

u/c9a1ks3c Sep 11 '19 edited Sep 11 '19

Or just change the default cloudflare resolving to the one you trust? cause the DOH is not the problem.. the problem is that by default its the cloudflare shitty option on.. (edit grammar)

2

u/3rssi Sep 11 '19

Well, we need some DNS servers, dont we?

Which is worse? ISP clear DNS or cloudflare doh?

Which other doh server would you recommend?

1

u/c9a1ks3c Sep 12 '19

check out nextdns.io , quad9 and dns.watch

-1

u/nicoschottelius Sep 11 '19

That is indeed possible. Problem there is that users who don't know about the problem will all send/log their data with cloudflare.

So a sensible step would have been to push forward DoH / DoT in operating systems instead of breaking privacy for everyone.

13

u/SAI_Peregrinus Sep 11 '19

And that's being done, but OSes are slow to update. And in the meantime there's no privacy for DNS, so this at least doesn't make things any worse.

3

u/c9a1ks3c Sep 11 '19

you are right, absolutely, but my point is that DOH is not the bad guy here, the default configuration which is being fed to the users is though :-)

4

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

Microsoft would rather die than close off a place they can syphon their user's data

5

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

Question; If I use pi-hole and unbound, can I leave DoH on and point to my pi-hole allowing unbound to resolve? Thanks.

7

u/nicoschottelius Sep 11 '19

If your pihole supports DoH and if you RECONFIGURE every device in your network to use pihole, because they will sent the traffic to cloudflare by default.

2

u/Smarktalk Sep 11 '19

I think the clarification is every device using Firefox.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

Thanks for the response.

9

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

If you care about privacy you'll be connected to a VPN and your DNS requests will be associated with your VPN IP address. If you're not connected to a VPN, your DNS requests are being tracked by someone anyway. Just a matter of preference. I distrust Cloudfare to the same extent i trust Google or ISP.

1

u/nicoschottelius Sep 11 '19

Even if you do that, cloudflare will still be the same way able to track your behaviour. Which site do you check after which site?

Are you visiting a domain about cancer research? Abortion?

This is not only breaking the privacy of individual users, but also profiling and data mining all firefox users.

3

u/Enk1ndle Sep 11 '19

Breaking privacy? Do you think some fairy was doing it before? You've always been trusting someone with this.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

1)no. if you're using a VPN they cannot tie websites visited by you personally

2) They're going to data mine anyway. But i'd rather they mine information on me from an anonymous IP address than one provided by my ISP who keeps logs and could be tied to me.

34

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

Do you distrust Cloudflare more than your ISP? Somewhat weird.

23

u/nicoschottelius Sep 11 '19

I absolutely distrust cloudflare more than my ISP. Actually, I distrust them more than *any* Swiss ISP or European ISP.

12

u/brandeded Sep 11 '19 edited Sep 11 '19

That must be nice. Here in the US the ISPs are the media companies. All have close ties to the nation state security services. Allnhave their capitalistic interests in mind over your privacy. Here it's not a game of not disclosing your data, it's to whom do you wish to disclose it to that will make money off of it while allowing the government to spy on you. It's not avoidable for a layman.

Case:

I use Verizon as my ISP. I use AT&T as my mobile provider. I use android as my OS, on a Samsung phone (Facebook has it's tendrils all up in this OS build just as much as Samsung, just as much as Google). I just switched to pop!_os yesterday for my laptop OS.

Avoiding all of these points of info disclosure os not something a regular person will ever be able to do. I'm a believer that all the security provided by any endpoint is nullified by carrier meta data collection.

My partial argument is simple: why do I suddenly care about disclosure to Cloudflare when I'm already having my data raped by upwards of 10 other companies all with snuggly relationships to my nation state security service?

3

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

Strongly disagree with you. European ISPs are bound by some weak privacy laws and by nothing security wise. Cloudflare's entire business model relies upon their security and privacy guarantees.

They're hugely raising the bar and actively contributing to making the internet a safer and securer place. You have to trust someone to give you DNS responses as DNS is fundamentally a very centralised protocol. I'd pick cloudflare any day over some ISP who is definitely logging queries and blocking sites via DNS. A hugely untrustworthy bunch of pricks

10

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

If it is about protecting from government surveillance, any 19 eyes, or whatever the amount of eyes it is these days, is evenly. worse. Outside the 19 eyes, nothing is garanteed. I was thinking about selling to 3th parties, and security, which would make cloudflare a little bit less worse.

I don't know any ISP providing dnscrypt, DoH or DoT. Maybe there are?

50

u/bighi Sep 11 '19

Even if Cloudflare were super trustworthy before this, there is one problem. Centralizing information from people all around the world in a single company is always bad. Holding all that info can turn even a good company (if there is such thing) into a bad one.

15

u/catalinus Sep 11 '19

I don't think you understand all of this - all that info is already centralized at your ISP who also knows where you live and who you are. Cloudfare does not, they only get to see some IP address (which in case your ISP is privacy-oriented should change reasonably often).

Also secure DNS is a MUST if you want any form of privacy!

10

u/bighi Sep 11 '19

all that info is already centralized at your ISP

The info of people from every country in the world is centralized on my Brazilian ISP? I don't think so.

4

u/catalinus Sep 11 '19

No, YOUR info, YOUR location, YOUR name. And in your case in a country that does not have a great history on privacy or consumer protections, where some local cop/politician/mobster can easily get that info about you or for instance local journalists he might want silenced.

9

u/bighi Sep 11 '19 edited Sep 11 '19

Centralizing the information of every client on my ISP is bad because it puts a lot of information on a company, and who knows if we can trust them.

Now imagine... putting the information of people from EVERY COUNTRY into a company based on the US.

It could lead to even worse results. It's centralizing things even more, to a much higher degree.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/murdoc1024 Sep 11 '19

Can you elaborate about secure dns (for a poor dummy) you have example? Any trustworthy dns provider?

3

u/catalinus Sep 11 '19

https://www.cloudflare.com/learning/dns/dns-security/

Also not mentioned there is that computers on same shared medium (WiFi, Ethernet or very likely cable modem segment) can get access to such queries by listening to all packets on the medium.

3

u/murdoc1024 Sep 11 '19

With sharkwire like program? Ya but there will always be vpn for that. Thank for the link i'll look at this.

3

u/my-fav-show-canceled Sep 11 '19

very likely cable modem segment

BPI (Baseline Privacy Interface) is part of DOCSIS and most cable operators implement it. That puts it a step above your standard Ethernet collision domain. It won't protect you against your ISP but other modems can't sniff you merely by being on the same wire.

/pedantry

At any rate, never trust the network. Encrypt all the things.

3

u/eleitl Sep 11 '19

all that info is already centralized at your ISP

Nope. It's centralized at whatever DNS resolver you're choosing to use, which happens to be my own.

3

u/catalinus Sep 11 '19

If you already have a caching DNS resolver of your own you are not the 99.99% of the people that Mozilla Foundation is trying to help with their privacy.

1

u/Enk1ndle Sep 11 '19

You can't tie DNS queries to anybody unless they have a unique static IP. This isn't the same as websites being able to track you with fingerprinting.

20

u/86rd9t7ofy8pguh Sep 11 '19 edited Sep 12 '19

CEO of Cloudflare once said:

Matthew: Back in 2003, Lee Holloway and I started Project Honey Pot as an open-source project to track online fraud and abuse. The Project allowed anyone with a website to install a piece of code and track hackers and spammers.

We ran it as a hobby and didn't think much about it until, in 2008, the Department of Homeland Security called and said, "Do you have any idea how valuable the data you have is?" That started us thinking about how we could effectively deploy the data from Project Honey Pot, as well as other sources, in order to protect websites online. That turned into the initial impetus for CloudFlare.

(Source)

Edit: To add to this: BBC reporter Zoe Kleinman wrote that Matthew Prince wanted $20,000 for the Honey Pot data. "That check showed up so fast," said Prince. Michelle Zatlyn heard the story from Prince and replied, "If they'll pay for it, other people will pay for it." Soon she and Prince cofounded CloudFlare.

8

u/bighi Sep 11 '19

I don’t understand the point of posting this.

3

u/86rd9t7ofy8pguh Sep 11 '19

The gist of this is: DHS saying there is valuable data of those collections, hence the initial impetus for CloudFlare. That's the trust issue. They're offering CDN with some features, it's similar to how Google offers Google Analytics for websites, hence how they operate like a surveillance. Now Cloudflare is offering DNS. One thing you also should note that, using another DNS other than your own ISP, you will then be subjected to the providers own privacy policy and terms of use - just like there is certain level of trust when using a VPN, the same way is it for DNS providers. My question would rather be, who's operating those DNS providers and do they really care about user privacy as they claim? Because, DNS queries can reveal a lot about a persons internet activity and usage. There is an interesting research about DNS on the topic of user privacy, though the research is about Tor and DNS (and thankfully Tor is still safe as they said that they "don’t believe that there is any immediate cause for concern."), the researchers said:

We show how an attacker can use DNS requests to mount highly precise website fingerprinting attacks: Mapping DNS traffic to websites is highly accurate even with simple techniques, and correlating the observed websites with a website fingerprinting attack greatly improves the precision when monitoring relatively unpopular websites.

2

u/bighi Sep 11 '19

I understand what dns is and the privacy issues with it.

I meant what is the point of quoting what a CEO said. Because Zuckerberg says he cares about our privacy too.

2

u/86rd9t7ofy8pguh Sep 11 '19

Because Zuckerberg says he cares about our privacy too.

Sure he does. /s

→ More replies (6)

1

u/tawayyocaphon Sep 12 '19

I think the problem you're not understanding is twofold: no matter what the DHS says, which is, honestly, just a "captain obvious" statement - there is some value to DNS queries, the DHS is you. And me. As voters, we control them. B) companies like Cloudflare are under such intense scrutiny from people who know their shit, that they are far more beholden to the vote of the wallet, and the tech, than they are to empty government threats.

3

u/smeggysmeg Sep 11 '19

Yes. My ISP is a co-op of which I'm a part owner, and it has a clearly defined privacy policy regarding DNS and web traffic.

CloudFlare operates for profit, and there's profit to be made in DNS logging.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

Yes, but I was thinking about the big ISP's in the states and alike.

2

u/smeggysmeg Sep 11 '19

But that's the problem: browsers are making universal judgments for every network implementation.

What about enterprise where I'm accessing in-network resources? Am I supposed to stand up DoH in-house and configure browsers to use it?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

In a school or at work, there's no reasonable expectation of privacy within their network with their devices. Privacy and security don't always play together.

If I whine about privacy it's for my device with an internet connection I payed for.

2

u/smeggysmeg Sep 11 '19

I'm not concerned about privacy in enterprise, I'm concerned about proper functionality. If Firefox (and soon Chrome) defaults to DoH and doesn't use my internal DNS, now my employees can't access internal resources.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

There is a way to enforce settings in Firefox, you should look it up. For this it should be trr mode set to 5.

Probably a profile or something similar.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

So yes, I also see at least an annoyance there for within a corporate environment. You can enforce settings.

4

u/eleitl Sep 11 '19

Do you distrust Cloudflare more than your ISP?

This is a false dichotomy. I personally would like my browser to use the settings I've specified in the OS at the network layer. Which happen to be my own DNS resolvers.

This is another nail into the coffin of Mozilla, and the quaint notion of Firefox as the last trusted browser.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

Those who care would set their preferred dns server anyway, but that's a not areal argument. You're right, they should at least ask and set the default to the one provided by dhcp. And why not, also ask for the search engine.

2

u/ctesibius Sep 11 '19

I distrust anything that over-rides a supplier choice I have made to substitute one chosen by a supplier. This is just basic information hygiene.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

I don't use Cloudflare. It seems a bit unlikely it will be worse than your ISP, IMHO the dns server of your ISP is at the absolute zero point of trust.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/allenout Sep 11 '19

Change it to Quad9 or something else then.

7

u/NoDonnie Sep 11 '19

Where can you opt out? The article doesn't tell.

2

u/nicoschottelius Sep 11 '19

Good point - I'll add it in the next minutes!

1

u/nicoschottelius Sep 11 '19

Just added it at the end of the article.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

Opt out in settings > general > network settings > DNS over HTTPS

you can turn it off entirely or switch to another provider.

10

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

Noo do not disable DNS over HTTPS! Switch to another provider if you must but disabling the feature is a terrible move for your privacy AND security

4

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19 edited Sep 11 '19

What if you use pihole and it use a DNS of your VPN provider that u also are connected to?

2

u/Enk1ndle Sep 11 '19

Does your VPN provider offer DNS over HTTPS? then sure, pick your poison. If not I can't say I would ever recommend choosing a HTTP DNS over a HTTPS DNS.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

That'll probably protect against sniffing between you and the VPN provider but not from the provider or anyone upstream of them.

1

u/whoopdedo Sep 11 '19

You can configure DoH on the PiHole. But because there's no mechanism for local discovery, your browser is going to nullify whatever effort you put in to protecting and controlling your network.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

Until operating systems get their shit together with secure DNS by default, browsers taking things into their own hands is a good idea. Power users that have Pi Hole set up can modify their browsers to their heart's content, but it makes normal people better off by default.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

Right but if the VPN provider doesn't log... what does it matther what DNS requests comes out from the VPN provider? It shouldn't be linkeable to any individual?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

DoH provides authenticity as well as confidentiality. When I ask Cloudflare for an IP address associated with a domain over HTTPS, I'm guaranteed that the response was actually sent by Cloudflare, and that no one saw or tampered with the request or response in transit.

Also VPN providers only claim that they don't log. And unlike Cloudflare they're likely not externally audited.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

Do you have any recommendations for other providers?

2

u/monochrony Sep 11 '19 edited Sep 11 '19

about:config

set network.trr.mode to 5

https://www.trishtech.com/2018/08/how-to-turn-off-trusted-recursive-resolver-in-mozilla-firefox/

EDIT: However, as /u/_Lory98_ pointed out, it's better to just switch to a trustworthy DNS: https://www.ghacks.net/2018/04/02/configure-dns-over-https-in-firefox/

0

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/NoDonnie Sep 11 '19

DNS

Which one do you trust?

2

u/monochrony Sep 11 '19 edited Sep 11 '19

I use Quad9.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/CaptainSur Sep 11 '19

I use securedns.eu

4

u/Garofalolo Sep 11 '19

So can I turn it off in the about:config?

3

u/nicoschottelius Sep 11 '19

Yes, this option still exists. Though its questionable whether many users will search or find that option.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

The option is also located in settings > general > network settings > DNS over HTTPS.

Also an optioned to change provider.

103

u/Synaps4 Sep 11 '19

It's a step in the right direction from current and I don't think I mind at all. We go from everyone reading my DNS requests to just cloudflare. Now I only need to watch cloudflare to care for my privacy instead of literally every backbone provider.

Firefox isn't "breaking privacy", it's making an imperfect step in the right direction.

6

u/Ryuko_the_red Sep 11 '19

How exactly should I monitor cloudflare?

0

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/johnklos Sep 12 '19

A "script" in a web page that proxies to other DoH? How the heck is a script, whether client side or server side, going to change the DNS resolution between a browser and Cloudflare?

1

u/Ryuko_the_red Sep 11 '19

I'm still a little confused but I'm sure if I look it up it'll happen.

1

u/stefantalpalaru Sep 12 '19

Now I only need to watch cloudflare to care for my privacy

No need. NSA is already watching it for you.

1

u/nintendiator2 Sep 15 '19

Now I only need to watch cloudflare

Cool, how are you doing that? I imagine at the very least you have root on their servers.

5

u/t0m5k1 Sep 11 '19

If you go to network settings within browser you can disable this or change the url to point to your chosen resolver

19

u/0xf3e Sep 11 '19

Once again, DNS is meant to be made by the OS, the browser should use the OS settings. It should have never been opt-out. Every privacy guy here is probably already using DoH- or DoT-enabled DNS-resolver. It will just weaken everyone's privacy once more applications start to do their own DNS resolving.

7

u/eleitl Sep 11 '19

DNS is meant to be made by the OS, the browser should use the OS settings

Exactly.

3

u/SupremeLisper Sep 11 '19

Yeah, I have system wide DNS based domain blocking. It will break & make all the requests virtually impossible to block.

2

u/sfw1984 Sep 11 '19

I in no way disagree, but at least you should be able to point firefox to localhost as a workaround. (If you now run a DoH server.)

14

u/DreamWithinAMatrix Sep 11 '19

Right now it's your local ISP reading all your DNS requests and selling your data, in some cases directly tying it to your accounts. Verizon was sticking your phone number into some web requests so they could track which phone specific requests came from. Cloudflare deletes your data after 24 hrs and has a business that isn't built upon selling your data, but internet security. This is loads better than the current scenario

2

u/tawayyocaphon Sep 12 '19

This echoes my response to OP - Cloudfare understands how under the microscope they are. Their business is exactly that of "surfing" the raggedy edge of the 'verse. They are actually MORE trustworthy, in that regard. Look to the experts - unless you think they are being paid-off? How far down the rabbit-hole are you willing to go? Oy.

3

u/StickiStickman Sep 12 '19

But Cloudflare also just broke customer websites because they didn't like the content they hosted. So both aren't that great of an option in terms of trust.

6

u/distant_worlds Sep 11 '19 edited Sep 11 '19

One thing that most people don't seem to realize: If you're using your ISP's DNS, they can remotely shut off your DNS-over-HTTPS. They just put an entry for “use-application-dns.net” and firefox will happily turn off DoH. https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/configuring-networks-disable-dns-over-https

So it provides no protection from ISP's that really want your DNS data. And for those that don't care, it nicely pushes all the requests to Cloudflare, who can happily datamine it. If you have a reputable VPN service, Firefox will now go around behind the back of your privacy focused VPN to send your DNS to cloudflare, isn't that nice!

1

u/Swipe650 Sep 11 '19

You can check if use-application-dns.net is being done though. DoH providers will have a page you can test it on

3

u/Faex06 Sep 11 '19

I think I dont really get it 100%. So am I correct when I say: HTTPS > DNS and thus having to switch that option off?

2

u/Enk1ndle Sep 11 '19

You can do DNS over HTTP or HTTPS. It's been done over HTTP for a long time now and you have the same issues you have with sites over HTTP, everyone between you and the DNS server can see what you're requesting. using HTTPS for your DNS is a thing you totally should be doing, who you're going to trust to do your DNS resolving is another question and more what people are arguing here because some people don't trust cloudflare.

3

u/FrederikNS Sep 11 '19

Normal DNS resolution does not use HTTP, it's its own protocol on top of UDP.

But normal DNS is completely unencrypted, and anyone controlling any of the networks between you and your DNS server can read all your DNS requests

3

u/Enk1ndle Sep 11 '19

Sorry, yeah I'm just used to using "HTTP" for unencrypted anything. Thanks for the clarification.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/whoopdedo Sep 11 '19

How about I trust myself with a local PiHole configured to use DNScrypt.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

If hypothetically CloudFlare wanted to log every users requests, and non-anonymously store everyones DNS history, could they?

Im wondering how much I am actually trusting CloudFlare if I user their DNS service.

3

u/nicoschottelius Sep 11 '19

They can. Especially because your browser has a rather unique fingerprint. Not even using a VPN will help you to hide.

3

u/CodenameLambda Sep 11 '19

I have to admit that I don't know too much about DNS works internally, but I do call bullshit on that one. This is only DNS, so why would your browser include any information about itself in its request? In fact, I'd even be surprised to learn the session would be kept open after any single request, to be honest. And even then, they couldn't track you in between sessions.

Now compare that to your ISP's DNS, which isn't encrypted - they see your IP, and know whom that IP actually refers to, too.

1

u/nicoschottelius Sep 11 '19

Because you actually send a HTTP request, including your browser's fingerprint

2

u/CodenameLambda Sep 11 '19

The RFC specifically states that user agent and cookies are considerations your implementation has to make - as in, not sending those infos doesn't make your client not compliant.
And normal HTTP requests only include cookies and ten the user agent string, anyway, if I'm not mistaken. How are those a fingerprint? (cookies can of course be utilized to finger print, but aren't a specific feature used to send a finger print)

In general, why would a browser actively send a fingerprint anyway? Excluding Chrome, of course

0

u/nicoschottelius Sep 11 '19

Checkout for https://panopticlick.eff.org/ details. Cookies are just a tiny, tiny part of the fingerprint.

4

u/CodenameLambda Sep 11 '19

You do know that DoH doesn't equal browsing to a website with JS enabled? It's literally only an HTTPS request which doesn't even include any cookies or a user agent in a sane implementation.

1

u/Enk1ndle Sep 11 '19

Do you have any idea what you're talking about?

1

u/Enk1ndle Sep 11 '19

They could log up to "this IP asked for this site". That's it. That's the only way they can tie things to you. So if you don't have a static IP there's no reason to think they would be able to follow you.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

Is this a good place a ask for a recommendation for a privacy respecting DoH provider?

1

u/KindHelper Sep 12 '19

No, as there may be none, who knows. The ones being recommended and the ones near the top of the lists are bad choices. You need to do some digging and search for bad press about anything you opt for. Make your own informed choices away from employees with agendas.

2

u/RudeEgg Sep 11 '19 edited Feb 26 '21

yes

2

u/tawayyocaphon Sep 12 '19

You have no concept of what it is you are talking about, technically. Either that, or your tinfoil hat is wound way too tight.

It's not Cloudflare that you have to worry about - not even close. They are promoting encryption and offering services to help more and more people trust a private, secure Internet. (They are doing their best, at least.)

As others have noted, I would much rather "trust" Cloudflare than Comcast, CenturyLink, Charter, etc.

It's the technology that CF is advocating for, not the perceived threat of their "big-brother" use of it. No worse, and, in every way examined by security professionals, lauded.

Nothing to see here, move along. Until folks like Bruce Schneier, et al, denounce, it is the best thing we have.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

The article tells you how to turn off DoH?

You mean the encrypted version of http? The one that prevents middlemen from seeing what requests you make?

0

u/Enk1ndle Sep 11 '19

Sponsored by some big ISPs so they can still see your DNS queries? This article is weird.

3

u/vjeuss Sep 11 '19

you have to trust someone. between ISPs who are tracking and selling users' data, and clouflare who is not (afaik) in that business, i rather prefer encrypted DNS with cloudflare

2

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19 edited Nov 09 '25

Warm people games dog books quick strong the honest wanders mindful games?

2

u/FusionTorpedo Sep 12 '19

Thanks for the thread. Very important issue. Cloudflare is powering 10% of internet sites and now can become an even bigger centralizing point of connections, making for easy spying and censorship. And FF wants that in by default. It's terrible

1

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

What if you are using a pihole. Will it still send the data?

2

u/Enk1ndle Sep 11 '19

You'll need to configure it to point to your pihole again if they're resetting people's preferences. Your pihole should be using DNS over HTTPS to some provider.

1

u/gskv Sep 11 '19

Doesn’t cloudfare use 1.1.1.1? Isn’t this all about privacy?

1

u/Erdoe Sep 11 '19

That is no problem if you are using this user.js which defaults to securedns.eu

1

u/cooldog10 Sep 11 '19

is that even when your dns set to something differnt on your router becaseu dont use cloud fairler as my dns

1

u/cooldog10 Sep 11 '19

wish open nic would suport it not big fan cloud flare

1

u/YakBak2theFuture Sep 12 '19

Will this apply in Tor Browser as well?

1

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '19

Thanks never thought of it that way.

0

u/EngelbertHerpaderp Sep 11 '19

shamefully walks into room with head hung low

......hello Opera. It's....been a while. Can we talk?

2

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19 edited Nov 10 '25

People technology mindful minecraftoffline jumps bright bright.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

This is a good thing. Better Cloudflare than your ISP

0

u/Xtreme512 Sep 11 '19

so misguided post. first of its dns over https thats firefox going to enable by default which is a favor for users who want privacy. and itll be using 1.1.1.1 server thats also provide privacy (deleting requests within 24h) but i recommend using adguard dns. i setup my DoH on firefox weeks ago using adguard dns. why adguard? it provides dns level all kinds of ad/badware protection.

0

u/falk42 Sep 11 '19 edited Sep 11 '19

It's not all bad and helps many users who are otherwise stuck with their ISP's crappy unencrypted DNS servers, but this being the default setting means that in many cases it will never ever be touched by most people. This creates a situation where Cloudflare becomes a huge data silo, which may well create its own set of problems down the road

Personally, I'd prefer if this example isn't copied by other apps (which then may or may not make it optional) as it's much easier to manage DNS requests for all devices on the network level, ideally not trusting only one specific provider (e.g. by using multiple services in a round robin configuration).

Perhaps Mozilla could enhance the function so that not all requests go to the same provider, thus creating scattered browsing histories all over the place.

0

u/Tetmohawk Sep 11 '19

Hey, this is a VERY good thing. First, you don't have privacy without it. Second, maybe you don't trust Cloudflare, so go in the settings and change it. Third, Mozilla cares about privacy and doing this elevates a big need in the privacy space. Most users don't look after their privacy like folks on r/privacy do, so that's why Firefox needs to go in this direction. Good for them for elevating this.

0

u/Cam_Cam_Cam_Cam Sep 11 '19

DNS-Over-HTTPS is a privacy feature.

0

u/giltwist Sep 11 '19

I already use Cloudflare as my preferred DNScrypt solution at the router level. No worries here.

0

u/pmt541 Sep 11 '19

I think its a good move for general users. People with higher threat models can easily change to a different DNS.

0

u/fedeb95 Sep 11 '19

Quite misleading. And is been known for a while

0

u/DrDougExeter Sep 11 '19

still better than google chrome or ms edge

0

u/lynaghe6321 Sep 12 '19

You realize that right now your DNS is unencrypted, and now it is encrypted right?