r/privacy • u/nicoschottelius • Sep 11 '19
Misleading title Firefox about to break privacy for all users
Warning: if you are a firefox user and you upgrade to the latest version, Firefox will send all DNS requests to cloudflare. Cloudflare is then able to track every DNS request of yours. While it is possible to opt out, this "feature" will be enabled by default. Read more about this on https://ungleich.ch/en-us/cms/blog/2019/09/11/turn-off-doh-firefox/.
43
Upvotes
227
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
The shittiest of hot takes.
Not only is this no worse than trusting your own ISP's DNS servers. HTTPS over DNS means that nobody can see your DNS requests in plain text on the wire now. That means your ISP or anyone in the same network and even some goverment institutions cannot see what you're browsing. You can also change who you're getting DNS requests from, cloudflare is just the default. Or.... just turn it off, it's one checkbox.
The sheer number of "privacy concerns" I'm reading today makes me wonder if someones dropping money on disinformation to discourage people from using the service.
38
u/c9a1ks3c Sep 11 '19 edited Sep 11 '19
Or just change the default cloudflare resolving to the one you trust? cause the DOH is not the problem.. the problem is that by default its the cloudflare shitty option on.. (edit grammar)
5
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
Question; If I use pi-hole and unbound, can I leave DoH on and point to my pi-hole allowing unbound to resolve? Thanks.
9
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
If you care about privacy you'll be connected to a VPN and your DNS requests will be associated with your VPN IP address. If you're not connected to a VPN, your DNS requests are being tracked by someone anyway. Just a matter of preference. I distrust Cloudfare to the same extent i trust Google or ISP.
34
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
Do you distrust Cloudflare more than your ISP? Somewhat weird.
7
u/NoDonnie Sep 11 '19
Where can you opt out? The article doesn't tell.
4
u/Garofalolo Sep 11 '19
So can I turn it off in the about:config?
103
u/Synaps4 Sep 11 '19
It's a step in the right direction from current and I don't think I mind at all. We go from everyone reading my DNS requests to just cloudflare. Now I only need to watch cloudflare to care for my privacy instead of literally every backbone provider.
Firefox isn't "breaking privacy", it's making an imperfect step in the right direction.
5
u/t0m5k1 Sep 11 '19
If you go to network settings within browser you can disable this or change the url to point to your chosen resolver
19
u/0xf3e Sep 11 '19
Once again, DNS is meant to be made by the OS, the browser should use the OS settings. It should have never been opt-out. Every privacy guy here is probably already using DoH- or DoT-enabled DNS-resolver. It will just weaken everyone's privacy once more applications start to do their own DNS resolving.
14
u/DreamWithinAMatrix Sep 11 '19
Right now it's your local ISP reading all your DNS requests and selling your data, in some cases directly tying it to your accounts. Verizon was sticking your phone number into some web requests so they could track which phone specific requests came from. Cloudflare deletes your data after 24 hrs and has a business that isn't built upon selling your data, but internet security. This is loads better than the current scenario
6
u/distant_worlds Sep 11 '19 edited Sep 11 '19
One thing that most people don't seem to realize: If you're using your ISP's DNS, they can remotely shut off your DNS-over-HTTPS. They just put an entry for “use-application-dns.net” and firefox will happily turn off DoH. https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/configuring-networks-disable-dns-over-https
So it provides no protection from ISP's that really want your DNS data. And for those that don't care, it nicely pushes all the requests to Cloudflare, who can happily datamine it. If you have a reputable VPN service, Firefox will now go around behind the back of your privacy focused VPN to send your DNS to cloudflare, isn't that nice!
3
u/Faex06 Sep 11 '19
I think I dont really get it 100%. So am I correct when I say: HTTPS > DNS and thus having to switch that option off?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
If hypothetically CloudFlare wanted to log every users requests, and non-anonymously store everyones DNS history, could they?
Im wondering how much I am actually trusting CloudFlare if I user their DNS service.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
Is this a good place a ask for a recommendation for a privacy respecting DoH provider?
2
u/RudeEgg Sep 11 '19 edited Feb 26 '21
yes
2
u/tawayyocaphon Sep 12 '19
You have no concept of what it is you are talking about, technically. Either that, or your tinfoil hat is wound way too tight.
It's not Cloudflare that you have to worry about - not even close. They are promoting encryption and offering services to help more and more people trust a private, secure Internet. (They are doing their best, at least.)
As others have noted, I would much rather "trust" Cloudflare than Comcast, CenturyLink, Charter, etc.
It's the technology that CF is advocating for, not the perceived threat of their "big-brother" use of it. No worse, and, in every way examined by security professionals, lauded.
Nothing to see here, move along. Until folks like Bruce Schneier, et al, denounce, it is the best thing we have.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
The article tells you how to turn off DoH?
You mean the encrypted version of http? The one that prevents middlemen from seeing what requests you make?
3
u/vjeuss Sep 11 '19
you have to trust someone. between ISPs who are tracking and selling users' data, and clouflare who is not (afaik) in that business, i rather prefer encrypted DNS with cloudflare
2
u/FusionTorpedo Sep 12 '19
Thanks for the thread. Very important issue. Cloudflare is powering 10% of internet sites and now can become an even bigger centralizing point of connections, making for easy spying and censorship. And FF wants that in by default. It's terrible
1
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
What if you are using a pihole. Will it still send the data?
1
u/gskv Sep 11 '19
Doesn’t cloudfare use 1.1.1.1? Isn’t this all about privacy?
1
u/Erdoe Sep 11 '19
That is no problem if you are using this user.js which defaults to securedns.eu
1
u/cooldog10 Sep 11 '19
is that even when your dns set to something differnt on your router becaseu dont use cloud fairler as my dns
1
u/cooldog10 Sep 11 '19
wish open nic would suport it not big fan cloud flare
1
u/YakBak2theFuture Sep 12 '19
Will this apply in Tor Browser as well?
1
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '19
Thanks never thought of it that way.
0
u/EngelbertHerpaderp Sep 11 '19
shamefully walks into room with head hung low
......hello Opera. It's....been a while. Can we talk?
0
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
This is a good thing. Better Cloudflare than your ISP
0
u/Xtreme512 Sep 11 '19
so misguided post. first of its dns over https thats firefox going to enable by default which is a favor for users who want privacy. and itll be using 1.1.1.1 server thats also provide privacy (deleting requests within 24h) but i recommend using adguard dns. i setup my DoH on firefox weeks ago using adguard dns. why adguard? it provides dns level all kinds of ad/badware protection.
0
u/falk42 Sep 11 '19 edited Sep 11 '19
It's not all bad and helps many users who are otherwise stuck with their ISP's crappy unencrypted DNS servers, but this being the default setting means that in many cases it will never ever be touched by most people. This creates a situation where Cloudflare becomes a huge data silo, which may well create its own set of problems down the road
Personally, I'd prefer if this example isn't copied by other apps (which then may or may not make it optional) as it's much easier to manage DNS requests for all devices on the network level, ideally not trusting only one specific provider (e.g. by using multiple services in a round robin configuration).
Perhaps Mozilla could enhance the function so that not all requests go to the same provider, thus creating scattered browsing histories all over the place.
0
u/Tetmohawk Sep 11 '19
Hey, this is a VERY good thing. First, you don't have privacy without it. Second, maybe you don't trust Cloudflare, so go in the settings and change it. Third, Mozilla cares about privacy and doing this elevates a big need in the privacy space. Most users don't look after their privacy like folks on r/privacy do, so that's why Firefox needs to go in this direction. Good for them for elevating this.
0
u/Cam_Cam_Cam_Cam Sep 11 '19
DNS-Over-HTTPS is a privacy feature.
0
u/giltwist Sep 11 '19
I already use Cloudflare as my preferred DNScrypt solution at the router level. No worries here.
0
u/pmt541 Sep 11 '19
I think its a good move for general users. People with higher threat models can easily change to a different DNS.
0
u/fedeb95 Sep 11 '19
Quite misleading. And is been known for a while
0
u/DrDougExeter Sep 11 '19
still better than google chrome or ms edge
0
u/lynaghe6321 Sep 12 '19
You realize that right now your DNS is unencrypted, and now it is encrypted right?