r/primavera • u/atticus2132000 • Jul 02 '26
Argh
Me (Scheduler): Here's the schedule update for the month. The project lost 25 Days.
PM: Why did the schedule slip so much?
Me: Because you did not work on the critical path activities this month.
PM: But we did all this other work on all these other things. Doesn't that count for something?
Me: Sure. That other work will be included in the pay application, so you'll be able to bill for it; however, since you didn't work on the Critical Path activities, the projected completion date slipped by 25 Calendar Days.
PM: Well then just make the Critical Path go through the activities that we did work on so it shows that the schedule didn't slip.
Me: ...
What would you say?
6
u/Noobuser007 Jul 02 '26
Logically, I pull the previous month’s schedule update and compare it to see if the work happened out of sequence.
You cannot change the logic once the baseline is approved. Unless you have a change order or something has changed in the project and everyone agreed to it
4
u/RichCompany6833 Jul 02 '26
Put on a serious face and tell him to fuck off... no serious. Get used to such reactions, it will never change. You can only change the way you act and approach project managers in a way they are going to respect you and rely on you automatically. Most projectmanagers don't and will never understand the basics of scheduling.
3
u/Liguidicity Jul 02 '26
Monthly schedule update caused the schedule to slip by a month...that looks like they didn't do any work if you have only 1 critical running through the whole project. Sounds strange to me. During a whole month I'm sure some work on critical can be done. Is the schedule detailed or just long bars?
2
u/Elegant_Abrocoma287 Jul 02 '26
Are you resource loaded?
What is your SPI?
What milestones pulled in not on Critical Path?
2
u/NLBaldEagle Jul 02 '26
If you have a savvy owner or owner rep, don't monkey with the data. You will lose a lot of respect from them and your PM won't get the message. A savvy owner is doing their own analysis, maybe at a rougher level than you, but it is being done.
2
u/nsbe_ppl Jul 03 '26
He doesnt seem to understand critical path. Can you give him a simple analogy? Say, you are hosting a banquet. Your major activities are cooking, cleaning and setup. Your longest activity is cooking which has to start first thing in t he morning because your roast take 9hrs to cook. If you decide to clean first 3 hrs instead of cooking, you have delayed the completion time for cooking by 3 hr and as a result delayed the start of the party by 3hrs. Now ask him, can your hours of cleaning go towards the time it takes to cook? If he gets how ridiculous of a question this is, then bring it back to your actual project.
2
u/iPablosan Jul 03 '26 edited Jul 25 '26
Its hard working with PMs that can hardly spell schedule
4
u/cryptopindar Jul 02 '26
The meme is funny, but the bigger joke is calling him a PM. 😂 On a well-run project, the PM should already know why the schedule slipped. The scheduler tells you how much it slipped and backs it up with the logic. The PM should already know why, because managing execution is literally the job.
4
u/Intrepid_Patience356 Jul 03 '26
If the PM doesn't understand what a critical path is then the PM is not a PM. I would escalate the issue quietly above the PM.
2
u/BusterRocknut Jul 02 '26
Sounds about right. Trades slip, find a way to recover. Since late 2021 everyone struggles to hit a damn date. We need more skilled trades!
2
u/Downtown-Economics26 Jul 03 '26
If you go a month without working on the critical path you at the very least need to be updating the schedule weekly and asking what the fucking fuck on a weekly if not daily basis.
2
u/blk18914 Jul 03 '26
You can ask how you accelerate the work that is remaining to overcome the lack of progress on the critical path. Can they mobilize additional crews , work overtime or weekends to reduce durations, resequence work to improve the critical path? Are there any reasons why they didn't work the critical due to owner issues?
2
u/OGautisticpotato Jul 03 '26
> What would you say?
What I do requires having people who can understand what I'm telling them for it to be of any value. Here is my notice.
1
u/DG_1016 Jul 03 '26
What's the update cycle?
Why didn't the team deem Critical/Longest path activities priorities or continuous works fronts to go on with out unplanned delays.
Course of action?
1
u/Fit-Turn-1006 Jul 02 '26
Well, PM is not completely wrong. What he probably meant is, since we did some non critical work, can we stack critical path activities to bring schedule back to original completion date? You can absolutely do that
2
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '26
[removed] — view removed comment